How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Getting the money out of the exchange is rather the point of the sale, is it not?

Not necessarily.
Obviously, getting fiat out from your exchange account is prerequisite for a exchange to be legit and trusted.

Well, yes; my point above was that it's going to take a whole lot of individual buyers to pay for those 10,000 BTC when the exchange (according to my reading of the chart wrs posted, which may be flawed, and I retract the statement if so) appears to only have a few hundred BTC worth of buyers on any given day.

Sure, there's no guarantee someone will buy your bitcoins, let alone buy them right away or at the price you'd prefer. Is anyone leaving the impression that's the case?
 
Yes but I think the point is that individual buyers pay for the sale, not the exchange itself.

It still doesn't make much sense. If the cash is supplied by the buyer, why shouldn't the seller be able to get his cash (less whatever fees the brokerage charges, of course.)

In practice, it seems that cash is supplied by buyers, bitcoins are transferred, but the cash doesn't become available to the seller.
This is some usage of the word "facilitated" with which I was previously unfamiliar.
 
It still doesn't make much sense. If the cash is supplied by the buyer, why shouldn't the seller be able to get his cash (less whatever fees the brokerage charges, of course.)

Exactly, why wouldn't he?

In practice, it seems that cash is supplied by buyers, bitcoins are transferred, but the cash doesn't become available to the seller.
This is some usage of the word "facilitated" with which I was previously unfamiliar.

In practice? :eye-poppi
What kind of practice is that?
 
One block gets added to the chain every 10 minutes when a miner solves a problem. If there are 1,000 miners then a certain amount of "difficulty" is needed to solve the problem such that only one miner can get the solution in those 10 minutes. If there are 10,000 miners then the problem has to be 10 times harder to keep the mining rate constant.

If the price of bitcoin collapsed to (say) 0.01c and most of the big miners quit then to keep the block generation rate constant, the problem to be solved would have to be so simple that it could be done on an ordinary PC at minimal cost.

Eeeeeenteresting. Thanks for the clarification. :)

That does mean that those big expensive ASIC miners are useless once that threshold is reached, though. I'm sure there's some site that calculates the watts required per Bitcoin now. Hard to justify mining if you're doing it at such a huge loss.
 
Although I suspect you're right, I'm giving TjW the benefit of the doubt that he/she is not making a faulty generalization fallacy. Besides, the recent discussion was about Bitstamp.

From my admittedly cursory following of this thread, and some of the links in it, I was under the impression that there were upper limits on the amount of cash that you could get over a given time period on many of the exchanges.
If I let my mind drift back, ISTR that Bitstamp claimed to have no such limits if you had a double ultraplus super identified status or some such, but there were complaints that getting such status was virtually impossible, because whatever the people complaining gave them, trying to follow their rules, they asked for something else in addition to that. That was some time back, and maybe it was something temporary that has since been straightened out.
I don't have a dog in this fight, but are all the complaints about the inliquidity of bitcoins coming from the Mt Gox situation?
 
It still doesn't make much sense. If the cash is supplied by the buyer, why shouldn't the seller be able to get his cash (less whatever fees the brokerage charges, of course.)

In practice, it seems that cash is supplied by buyers, bitcoins are transferred, but the cash doesn't become available to the seller.
This is some usage of the word "facilitated" with which I was previously unfamiliar.
We know that MtGox lost a lot of money when its Dwolla account was seized and it also had a dispute with Coinbase. Those problems appear to be unique to MtGox. There are also limits imposed on cash payouts by banks and regulatory authorities.

Ultimately however, we have no idea if the bitcoin exchanges are making all of the cash deposited by buyers available to the sellers or if they might be siphoning off some of those funds. This is a major weakness in the entire bitcoin setup and the reason why bitcoin exchanges are likely to be phased out in favour of more decentralized exchanging mechanisms.
 
That does mean that those big expensive ASIC miners are useless once that threshold is reached, though.
Not really. For a given bitcoin price, it is profitable to spend a certain amount of money mining for them. The higher the price, the more money you can spend mining and therefore, the more entrants you get into mining. The reverse is true when the price drops.

It's been designed to mimic the theoretical laws of supply and demand.
 
And it's at $496 on Preeve.

I wonder how much earlier it would have hit under $500, had they not stopped working Gox into their price.
 
Yup. You need stable Bitcoins and gold to hedge against that wildly volatile fiat USD.
:D

This problem has existed all along; there simply isn't enough fiat in the exchanges to cash out even one whale. It's all well and good to trade your pretend money back and forth from wallet to wallet, and maybe buy something on Overstock, but as far as getting out of the game... you can't.
This. Lots of bitcoin, damn all to use them for.

Indeed.
 
Paper millionaires, indeed. The ones who had the sense to cash out on the bubble are going to be the only winners in this.
 
If they could get their cash out of the exchanges, that is...

The sale of those 10,000 on BitStamp yesterday morning was sure smart now in retrospect wasn't it? Plenty of people on the inside knew about this.

How stupid do all those people buying cheap goxcoins feel and what about BTC Builder? That guy just got his head chopped off.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom