How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I doubt Bitstamp has $5 million in fiat. Frankly, I doubt all the exchanges combined have $5 million in fiat. This could very well signal the start of the Goxification of Bitstamp.

I think that BitStamp ended up with a lot of Gox coins once people saw that they couldn't get cash out of Gox and decided they were better off just selling their existing coins on BitStamp. So a lot of the make-believe wealth in uncashed coins came over to BitStamp without any cash backing them. So if someone moved 10k coins from Gox back in November or December and now wants out of BTC altogether, the problem of no cash just moved to another exchange. This is exactly why I expect $150 or lower on all exchanges eventually. The liquidity to cash out those that are tired of the game doesn't exist at $500 or $200 and surely not up at $1000.
 
I think that BitStamp ended up with a lot of Gox coins once people saw that they couldn't get cash out of Gox and decided they were better off just selling their existing coins on BitStamp. So a lot of the make-believe wealth in uncashed coins came over to BitStamp without any cash backing them. So if someone moved 10k coins from Gox back in November or December and now wants out of BTC altogether, the problem of no cash just moved to another exchange. This is exactly why I expect $150 or lower on all exchanges eventually. The liquidity to cash out those that are tired of the game doesn't exist at $500 or $200 and surely not up at $1000.

This problem has existed all along; there simply isn't enough fiat in the exchanges to cash out even one whale. It's all well and good to trade your pretend money back and forth from wallet to wallet, and maybe buy something on Overstock, but as far as getting out of the game... you can't.
 
Another curious thing. The cost in power consumption per bitcoin must be going up, considering the specialty hardware that miners use for new bitcoins. With the price crash, it wouldn't surprise me at all if miners are hemorrhaging filthy fiat for their power bills with no actual gain in Coins. Eventually no one will want to mine because it's simply too expensive to sink that much energy into each coin, for such a small gain.
 
Why wouldn't they? The money comes from the buyers. They would have had to put the money into the exchange before they can bid or accept the bitcoin offer.

Why? Suppose a whale deposited 10,000 BTC, then asked to sell them for fiat. Where does the $5 million or so to cash the whale out come from? 10,000 BTC is a lot of little fish buying one or two at a time.
 
Another curious thing. The cost in power consumption per bitcoin must be going up, considering the specialty hardware that miners use for new bitcoins. With the price crash, it wouldn't surprise me at all if miners are hemorrhaging filthy fiat for their power bills with no actual gain in Coins. Eventually no one will want to mine because it's simply too expensive to sink that much energy into each coin, for such a small gain.
If people drop out of mining then mining gets cheaper for the remaining miners.
 
Why? Suppose a whale deposited 10,000 BTC, then asked to sell them for fiat. Where does the $5 million or so to cash the whale out come from? 10,000 BTC is a lot of little fish buying one or two at a time.
A "whale" can only get what is offered for the bitcoins. If only $2M total is deposited to buy the 10,000 BTC then the price is a lot lower. It's just a brokerage after all.
 
Why wouldn't they? The money comes from the buyers. They would have had to put the money into the exchange before they can bid or accept the bitcoin offer.

Why do you continue to repeat this when there is no proof for it? Bitcoin sales are not for cash, they are for account balances. There is no proof that the account balances that bought bitcoins ever existed as inbound bank transfers in the first place. The point you make about the FDIC and the banking system not having an equivalent in the bitcoin world means that there is no oversight. The accounts that "bought" the bitcoins on Bitstamp don't need to have "cash", just a cash balance and that is easily created at the touch of a key by a BitStamp employee or executive. If the price of Bitcoin is to be kept from crashing, I suspect there would be no problem with this happening.
 
If people drop out of mining then mining gets cheaper for the remaining miners.

Wouldn't it remain expensive? The arbitrary difficulty isn't changed by the amount of miners in action (if I'm wrong, please feel free to correct me), so it should require more work per miner if there are fewer active miners.
 
From other buyers, where else. So your claim that the exchange doesn't have the cash is misleading.



:i:

Does MtGox have the cash? Did they ever? Why don't they give people cash if they have it? Why would BitStamp be any different?
 
A "whale" can only get what is offered for the bitcoins. If only $2M total is deposited to buy the 10,000 BTC then the price is a lot lower. It's just a brokerage after all.

yet at MtGox where bitcoins trade hands and no money ever comes out and hasn't for months, whales have dumped tons of coins and there isn't a scintilla of evidence that money really buys those coins, it's just claimed balances but people can't get their money. So the exchange claims they have $XXXXXXX but they can't get it out. So is it there or is it fictitious? I would say the evidence points to the latter.
 
From other buyers, where else. So your claim that the exchange doesn't have the cash is misleading.

From the chart above, it appears that "buy" volume is on the order of a few hundred BTC a day. And we don't know how much of that "buy" volume is from Gox refugees who got a few coins out of BitBuilder and are trying to arbitrage the much higher prices on Bitstamp. My point is that it's going to take a long, long time to accumulate the fiat to cash out this one whale. Bitstamp doesn't have the cash, or they would have just executed the trade. They don't even have the cash to execute it at $200.
 
Wouldn't it remain expensive? The arbitrary difficulty isn't changed by the amount of miners in action (if I'm wrong, please feel free to correct me), so it should require more work per miner if there are fewer active miners.
One block gets added to the chain every 10 minutes when a miner solves a problem. If there are 1,000 miners then a certain amount of "difficulty" is needed to solve the problem such that only one miner can get the solution in those 10 minutes. If there are 10,000 miners then the problem has to be 10 times harder to keep the mining rate constant.

If the price of bitcoin collapsed to (say) 0.01c and most of the big miners quit then to keep the block generation rate constant, the problem to be solved would have to be so simple that it could be done on an ordinary PC at minimal cost.
 
My point is that it's going to take a long, long time to accumulate the fiat to cash out this one whale. Bitstamp doesn't have the cash, or they would have just executed the trade. They don't even have the cash to execute it at $200.
You apparently still believe that bitcoin exchanges buy and sell bitcoins rather than broker exchanges.

Getting your money out of the exchange after the sale might be a problem but I haven't heard of any MtGox style problems with Bitstamp.
 
Last edited:
My point is that it's going to take a long, long time to accumulate the fiat to cash out this one whale. Bitstamp doesn't have the cash, or they would have just executed the trade. They don't even have the cash to execute it at $200.
You apparently still believe that bitcoin exchanges buy and sell bitcoins rather than broker exchanges.

Getting your money out of the exchange after the sale might be a problem but I haven't heard of any MtGox style problems with Bitstamp.

+1

I don't know what else to add.
 
You apparently still believe that bitcoin exchanges buy and sell bitcoins rather than broker exchanges.

Getting your money out of the exchange after the sale might be a problem but I haven't heard of any MtGox style problems with Bitstamp.

Getting the money out of the exchange is rather the point of the sale, is it not?
 
Yes but I think the point is that individual buyers pay for the sale, not the exchange itself.

Well, yes; my point above was that it's going to take a whole lot of individual buyers to pay for those 10,000 BTC when the exchange (according to my reading of the chart wrs posted, which may be flawed, and I retract the statement if so) appears to only have a few hundred BTC worth of buyers on any given day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom