chipmunk stew
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2005
- Messages
- 7,448
It's absurd to think it possible that successful Bitcoin merchants would be able to run a business without an auditable trail.
If you think the government's recourse is going to be physically beating people until they confess to their income, then you've already conceded that mass taxation as we know it will break down.[qimg]http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/security.png[/qimg]
^ This comic should be reposted at least once on every page in this thread, that's how awesome it is.
Empty assertions and attempted insults are the last recourse of someone who doesn't like what you have to say but has no way to argue against it. You should be more mature than that.I do see why you feel that, but it wouldn't be polite of me to say it.
If you think the government's recourse is going to be physically beating people until they confess to their income, then you've already conceded that mass taxation as we know it will break down.
Empty assertions and attempted insults are the last recourse of someone who doesn't like what you have to say but has no way to argue against it. You should be more mature than that.
Oh, people can privately invest in it, but they won't have NEARLY enough money to participate in 21st century-level warfare. A single tank, with no special weapon-systems, costs 65 million dollars. A single modern fighter jet costs 150 million dollars. If you want to go cheap and get an F-16, those are 25 million apiece. A single aircraft carrier costs 9 billion dollars. And all of this is ignoring research and development, which also runs in the hundreds of millions (or in the case of the aircraft carrier, billions)...and training, feeding, clothing, and giving wages to your pilots and soldiers.Now you´re being ridiculous... don´t you think that, given the prospect of free and unrestricted looting, these mercenaries will invest in the proper tools to get to that looting?
If you take the not-for-profits, i.e. regular armies, out of the picture - always assuming that your Bitcoin farce could do that -, then profit-oriented enterprises will step up to fill the void, just as you Libertarians always say will happen if government stops intervening.
And looting the population is always more profitable that protecting them, so guess on which side the profit-oriented mercenaries are going to be on?
Oh, people can privately invest in it, but they won't have NEARLY enough money to participate in 21st century-level warfare. A single tank, with no special weapon-systems, costs 65 million dollars. A single modern fighter jet costs 150 million dollars. If you want to go cheap and get an F-16, those are 25 million apiece. A single aircraft carrier costs 9 billion dollars. And all of this is ignoring research and development, which also runs in the hundreds of millions (or in the case of the aircraft carrier, billions)...and training, feeding, clothing, and giving wages to your pilots and soldiers.
Modern warfare is not feasible for private companies and individuals. Even Bill Gates and Microsoft would struggle to put together a single equipped and manned aircraft carrier or small air-force. It's not remotely feasible, at all, unless you can forcefully take hundreds of billions of dollars from the public.
Yes it is. People get defrauded with very little recourse every day (online it happens most often through credit card chargebacks), the issue is not what you do when it happens, the issue is what your options are to protect yourself and whether they are workable. In the case of bitcoin you have many options and there will be more in the future as security programs emerge. (which, just to say pre-emptively, can be open-sourced to insure their aren't stealing your money)That's not an answer to what you were asked.
Nothing. I haven't done any Bitcoin business yet, just tried out the software and researched it. I'm also not even sure who 'they" are. You do know that it's decentralized, right? There's no "they" controlling it.EGarrett, how much real money did they dupe you out of?
That's not true at all. There are tons of online services that can help you do this if you want. Ebay keeps seller-feedback ratings and it works just fine. (Silk Road apparently does too, for the record)Good point, people/companys need not be defrauded if their willing and able to sink vast amounts of time in checking references to make sure the people/company their dealing with is legit. So we have monstrous inefficency and another market barrier to any newcomers who havn't had a chance to build a reputation. Huzzah the free market!
I said that you could demand that if you wanted to. If this type of fraud were somehow rampant, you could refuse to buy from a seller that won't send first, or a seller could offer to send first as a way to show that they are trustworthy. More commonly though, businesses use references and public reputations, and transaction services make it very easy to check feedback, so this sort-of personal negotiation won't really be necessary.Also I love this
Do you really not see the problem with noone sending packages before they get paid, and noone paying until they get the package? Hell of an economy your silly little utopia must have.
Oh, people can privately invest in it, but they won't have NEARLY enough money to participate in 21st century-level warfare.
Nothing. I haven't done any Bitcoin business yet, just tried out the software and researched it. I'm also not even sure who 'they" are. You do know that it's decentralized, right? There's no "they" controlling it.
Each transaction tends to have a unique payment address (which is a series of characters), and the Bitcoin client encourages this by providing a new payment address for you after each payment you receive. So you cannot trace previous transactions done by a seller even if you know one address they used or provided. I believe this is how Silk Road drug-sellers continue to operate.How would a seller get references and widespread reputations and at the same time be untraceable by a government that wanted to recover taxes owed or bust an illegal operation?
If they think you're running an illegal business, they can find out where your packages are being sent from, how many packages have been sent in the last year, and most importantly, who you are.
As I've said, not everyone's net worth or income is in assets. In fact, most people's net worth and income is in bank accounts, which would be inaccessible if replaced by Bitcoin wallets.How do they run an audit? Basically, they get all relevant paperwork, figure out what property you own and estimate a value on it. Got a Porscishe 911 registered to your name? Guess what, the government knows about that: your name is on the bloody paperwork. (And if your name is not on the paperwork then it is, by legal definition, not your car and nobody will defend your property right to it. If there is no paperwork at all, then the cops will pull you over for driving an unregistered car and put you in jail.)
A business's bitcoins transactions would only be as accessible as they would allow them to be. If you know a method from centuries ago that would actually be feasible for tracking a business or individual's bitcoin income, bitcoin wallet savings or bitcoin transactions, by all means tell me (and no, hitting them over the head with a wrench until they tell you their income is not it)It's not magic -- governments has collected tax for centuries before there even was such a thing as a paper trail on payments. They still do it today on businesses that take all their income in cash.
You're not forced to work with any of those people. It's up to you in the same way that which restaurant you go to for dinner is up to you. It's a choice among services offered, and in the case of Bitcoin, you can choose not to work with those processors at all and negotiate your Bitcoin transactions on your own...which is what the client allows you to do (and why it's so bare-boned).It's not entirely up to you. It's also up to the people who develop your operating system, bitcoins software, web browser, anti virus program and computer hardware. It's up to the people who run the bitcoin exchanges (you might trust Company X, but do you trust Company X's database administrator?) It's up to your ISP. It's up to the certificate authorities. It's up to the people who handle your money for you (which might not be much of a problem for you personally, but it's going to be a huge problem for any corporation or business.)
No, because there are other drivers who you don't know, don't choose and don't control who can kill you. You can choose who you do bitcoin business with and negotiate the terms of your own transactions.And anyway, your argument also falls flat on that it is similar to saying "How is traffic accidents a problem when your amount of risk of accident is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use cars and mechanics who have references and widespread reputations?"
The merchants on Silk Road seem to be quite successful...and since they're selling illegal drugs I would assume that their transactions aren't trace-able. Given the way the Bitcoin client works, this makes sense.It's absurd to think it possible that successful Bitcoin merchants would be able to run a business without an auditable trail.
Putting you in jail for a crime they can't prove or investigate is the same principle as hitting you with a wrench to make you confess your income.The government does have the ability to use force to make people pay taxes. That's the reality of the situation. They're not going to send people around to your house to bust your kneecaps, but they will send people to arrest your and put you in jail.
You haven't been able to explain to me how the government could do it, you've only asserted that people collected taxes in the past, without giving me a single viable method for doing it currently.You don't understand how a government can collect taxes without payments being traceable, despite the fact that governments have been doing that very thing for thousands of years and, for cash-based businesses, are doing it to this very day. You don't warrant more maturity than that.
In fact, most people's net worth and income is in bank accounts, which would be inaccessible if replaced by Bitcoin wallets.
A business's bitcoins transactions would only be as accessible as they would allow them to be. If you know a method from centuries ago that would actually be feasible for tracking a business or individual's bitcoin income, bitcoin wallet savings or bitcoin transactions, by all means tell me (and no, hitting them over the head with a wrench until they tell you their income is not it)
You haven't been able to explain to me how the government could do it,
As technology falls, so does potential destruction caused by the conflict. Furthermore, without vastly superior weaponry, aggressive war and invasions become strongly discouraged. Lastly, a government working with private mercenaries instead of soldiers trained to take orders would have to find pure sociopaths (all jokes aside, there aren't a lot of them) or convince their participants that the war was justified. The side which could justify their war when gathering private combatants would have far superior numbers.Why would they need a high-tech airforce or navy? Infantry, supported by machine guns, mortars, may a couple of armored vehicles, would be more than enough to disperse the kind of armed rabble that would oppose them.
The part of warfare that needs expensive toys is the expensive toys you expect to face. As long as the opposition doesn´t have tanks or aircraft, you won´t need to spend a lot of money on them. Just take a look at that AnCap paradise, Somalia, and the cheap means with which privately owned, profit-oriented navies make money off piracy.
No matter how low the demand is, an aircraft carrier is not going to cost less than several billion dollars to make. And if the demand falls below the minimum price, those heavy-war implements will stop being created. Many people would consider that a good thign.Except that if there are no government-funded armies demanding tanks and aircraft, the price of same will tumble until they are affordable to the only people who are in the market for them - unless you think all that pricey hardware will be just left to rust in a junkyard. What costs billions now won't cost even millions if there are sellers but no buyers.
The human misery created by a war fought with clubs would not be equivalent to the human misery caused by a war fought with thermonuclear weapons.There is no correlation between warfare methods used and the scale of human misery:
The human misery created by a war fought with clubs would not be equivalent to the human misery caused by a war fought with thermonuclear weapons.
Oh good, now we're in a Monty Python sketch. You haven't answered the question. Insisting that you have won't change that.Yes it is.
Feds: "EGarrett, you've clearly been able to buy food, shelter, and other things for the past year, yet you haven't declared any income."You haven't been able to explain to me how the government could do it, you've only asserted that people collected taxes in the past, without giving me a single viable method for doing it currently.
Yes, it is. Some people own real estate and other major assets, some people are paid with cash, but most people keep their savings in banks and deposit their paychecks in banks.No, it's not. That's horrendously incorrect.
And when you suspect him of reporting 10 employees when he actually has 20, what do you do? You have no objective record, only what is provided to you by the people involved. The key factor here is how you deal with what you believe is omitted information.You look through their books (which they are legally required to keep), you check their receipts (which they're legally required to make), you check their inventory status, you check their flow of goods, you check the standards of their accomodations, if they're an employee you check their employer's books and their employee contract, you check their timesheets, you check their stated net worth on their loan applications (modern businesses can't operate without loans, nor can most house buyers), you go into their garage and check what kind of car they have, you go to town hall and find out what land they own, you check if they're the registered owner of any bonds or stocks, you check what property they've taken out insurance on.
Actual transaction data is only a small, and not particularly important, part of the paperwork the IRS checks when auditing you.
No, you're not forced. You choose your service providers, and in the case of Bitcoin the client can handle things for you on its own, through secure, self-negotiated transactions, if you choose no provider at all.You're not forced to work with any of those people.
Of course you are. If you don't, they'll put you in jail.
You believe that Rwanda in 1994 was equally as bad as an all-out thermonuclear war between world-superpowers?1994. Rwanda.
Try quoting more than three words of my posts.Oh good, now we're in a Monty Python sketch. You haven't answered the question. Insisting that you have won't change that.
They wouldn't pretend to have 0 income when they're clearly a multi-millionaire. They'd omit large amounts of information which you could not verify with an objective financial record.Feds: "EGarrett, you've clearly been able to buy food, shelter, and other things for the past year, yet you haven't declared any income."
EGarrett: "I am paid in Bitcoin and only use Bitcoin."
Feds: "Okay, then tell us how much Bitcoin you've earned in the past year, with documentation, and give us X% of that figure."
EGarrett: "No."
Feds: "Cool, cool. You're under arrest."
It's not that hard.