How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alright I have to take a break for now. Remember that this is a mature, hypothetical discussion. Be back later.
 
Not snooping in people's packages is already the policy.

Mercenaries armed with what?

You order an illegal knife to your area, and then tell me that there is a " No look" policy. And those packages are purposely non descriptive and often disguised as something else.

Personally i simply avoid it as anyone i know who has tried has had the knife confiscated. Your claim that there is no checking is unfounded.
 
You believe that Rwanda in 1994 was equally as bad as an all-out thermonuclear war between world-superpowers?

I think it was bad enough that it puts a lie to your belief that bitcoins will hallmark the end of war as we know it.
 
I said crimes against the self.

Martin Luther King and Gandhi flouted lawful authority. So just the fact that you are disobeying a law does not mean that the effects will be negative. You have to look at whether the law is just and what the results were once it was no longer obeyed.

(Now, please pleasantly surprise me and DON'T respond by saying something like "You compared bitcoin users to GANDHI AND MLK!!!!!!!!")

Appealing to consequences is a logical fallacy.

Psst, comparing the bitcoins scam artists to Gandhi and king is just silly and insulting to both men ( king a bit more than ghandi).

They didn't do what they did to save money, or to sell illegal items, they did it for real major issues, social change. And to compare them to this wacky attempt at avoiding paying taxes is just completely unfair.
 
Now you´re being ridiculous... don´t you think that, given the prospect of free and unrestricted looting, these mercenaries will invest in the proper tools to get to that looting?

If you take the not-for-profits, i.e. regular armies, out of the picture - always assuming that your Bitcoin farce could do that -, then profit-oriented enterprises will step up to fill the void, just as you Libertarians always say will happen if government stops intervening.

And looting the population is always more profitable that protecting them, so guess on which side the profit-oriented mercenaries are going to be on?

The thing the person your replying to is missing is that the operative part of his phrase is " as we know it.". We go from having the government being able to control their forces , to a system in which anyone with enough coin can have an army, and not be restricted by the rules and regulations currently in place.

What a utopia.
 
If you think the government's recourse is going to be physically beating people until they confess to their income, then you've already conceded that mass taxation as we know it will break down.

Empty assertions and attempted insults are the last recourse of someone who doesn't like what you have to say but has no way to argue against it. You should be more mature than that.

Pssst, your missing the point.

The "wrench" in question can be any unpleasant thing , most likely jail time. And the government would implement it long before it got to the point where mass taxation has " broken down.".

Might doesn't make right, but it is a pretty big force in regards to governments getting what they want. If you think with all the power they wield they will not be able to find a way to track this, your living in a fantasy world.
 
Why would they need a high-tech airforce or navy? Infantry, supported by machine guns, mortars, may a couple of armored vehicles, would be more than enough to disperse the kind of armed rabble that would oppose them.

The part of warfare that needs expensive toys is the expensive toys you expect to face. As long as the opposition doesn´t have tanks or aircraft, you won´t need to spend a lot of money on them. Just take a look at that AnCap paradise, Somalia, and the cheap means with which privately owned, profit-oriented navies make money off piracy.

And if we really start thinking, the business would probably be broken up into different kinds. Some mercenary guilds would focus on having many people, and focus on infantry heavy tasks. While others would focus on owning the expensive toys and training people to use them, acting as " Ringers" when needed.

The lack of imagination some people experience when it would show their idea to be silly is amazing.
 
Yes, it is. Some people own real estate and other major assets, some people are paid with cash, but most people keep their savings in banks and deposit their paychecks in banks.

That's just rubbish. Very few people have most of their net worth tied up in savings. Most people have more money tied up in their cars than in their savings accounts.

And when you suspect him of reporting 10 employees when he actually has 20, what do you do?

Good lord -- do you think that's some brand new issue that the IRS or economics crime division has never encountered before? You raid the workplace, take down the personal details of everybody who were working there, and check them against the list of registered workers.
 
I think it was bad enough that it puts a lie to your belief that bitcoins will hallmark the end of war as we know it.

Not to mention that if the governments are not getting the big weapons, someone is going to be buying them. I don't think the governments are that awesome, but as we have not yet been turned into a pile of dust, i would rather it stay in their hands than anyone who can pony up enough dough.
 
Each transaction tends to have a unique payment address (which is a series of characters), and the Bitcoin client encourages this by providing a new payment address for you after each payment you receive. So you cannot trace previous transactions done by a seller even if you know one address they used or provided. I believe this is how Silk Road drug-sellers continue to operate.

They ship product. I'm not referring to payment addresses or the financial transactions. I'm talking about the physical inventorying and shipment of tangible stuff.

Drug dealers have incentive to spend a lot of resources on obfuscating their operation and using smuggling techniques to ship their product. The mitigated risk is worth the cost.

If all you're trying to do is avoid paying taxes on an otherwise legal product, OTOH, the costs associated with smuggling (and the risks it INTRODUCES) aren't worth it.
 
Not to mention that if the governments are not getting the big weapons, someone is going to be buying them.

What I want to know, is who's going to run the GPS system or the weather service? If the government doesn't have the money necessary for an army, clearly they won't have the money for pseudo-military stuff like that either.
 
As technology falls, so does potential destruction caused by the conflict. Furthermore, without vastly superior weaponry, aggressive war and invasions become strongly discouraged. Lastly, a government working with private mercenaries instead of soldiers trained to take orders would have to find pure sociopaths (all jokes aside, there aren't a lot of them) or convince their participants that the war was justified. The side which could justify their war when gathering private combatants would have far superior numbers.

You don´t need to find sociopaths - only people who might be willing to set aside their morality in favor of unrestricted profit. And you don´t need to be a pure sociopath to find the prospect of looting those savage subhumans on the far side of the border attractive... only a patriot who´s had an entire lifetime of believing his country is the greatest in the world, and there´s certainly no shortage of those.

The human misery created by a war fought with clubs would not be equivalent to the human misery caused by a war fought with thermonuclear weapons.

It would be bad enough, though. Seriously... read up on the Thirty Years´ War before you spout stuff like that, or on what the Mongols did at Baghdad, or the Siege of Jerusalem (either in 70 AD or in 1099 AD), or any number of other conflicts. The Vikings who terrorized northern Europe for centuries were nothing but profit-driven individuals not held back by a government.
 
Oh, people can privately invest in it, but they won't have NEARLY enough money to participate in 21st century-level warfare. A single tank, with no special weapon-systems, costs 65 million dollars. A single modern fighter jet costs 150 million dollars. If you want to go cheap and get an F-16, those are 25 million apiece. A single aircraft carrier costs 9 billion dollars. And all of this is ignoring research and development, which also runs in the hundreds of millions (or in the case of the aircraft carrier, billions)...and training, feeding, clothing, and giving wages to your pilots and soldiers.


The cost of things would scale with the available currency. Your $65 million tank would simply cost, say, 20 BTC. (Your average family would have total net worth of, say, 0.005 BTC.)

Modern warfare is not feasible for private companies and individuals. Even Bill Gates and Microsoft would struggle to put together a single equipped and manned aircraft carrier or small air-force. It's not remotely feasible, at all, unless you can forcefully take hundreds of billions of dollars from the public.


So instead of one large government engaging in large-scale warfare, you have a bunch of corporations engaging in small-scale warfare.
 

You do know that the anonymity of bitcoin is basically the same as the anonymity of paper (or coin) money, right? All it's fancy algorithms and distributed computing are to compensate for it being in a medium that makes tracking easy. Heck, you'd probably be safer from fraud or theft if you did all your purchases under the table in public areas, like in spy movies or something, and the government would still not know about it - unless they were actively watching you, then I'm not sure bitcoins would be all that helpful either.
 
Try quoting more than three words of my posts.
Why? It wasn't an answer to the question you were asked. It was, to be frank, pointless drivel. I see no point in repeating it. But maybe I'm being harsh. If the other people reading this thread think that what you've said was a reasonable answer to the question, I'd appreciate it if they'd post to say so.
 
Why? It wasn't an answer to the question you were asked. It was, to be frank, pointless drivel. I see no point in repeating it. But maybe I'm being harsh. If the other people reading this thread think that what you've said was a reasonable answer to the question, I'd appreciate it if they'd post to say so.


As the person who asked the question that he responded to, I don't consider his response an answer. It was a dream; a response from an idealist ignoring what is and evangelizing about what should be. The equivalent of, "Bitcoins would be awesome in a perfect world."
 
Last edited:
Putting you in jail for a crime they can't prove or investigate is the same principle as hitting you with a wrench to make you confess your income.


The crime is the evasion of taxes. They can prove you hid assets from the IRS without having to prove the sum total of those assets.
 
As the person who asked the question that he responded to, I don't consider his response an answer. It was a dream; a response from an idealist ignoring what is and evangelizing about what should be. The equivalent of, "Bitcoins would be awesome in a perfect world."

Exactly. It's blather that doesn't address the issue. Equivalent to me saying "I've just been hit by a car and I think my leg is broken, what should I do about my possibly broken leg?" and getting the reply "Look both ways before crossing the road." It's related, but doesn't address the actual problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom