How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's not a fee. Fees and risks are two different things (for example, cliff diving is highly risky, but costs no money). The lack of fees in using Bitcoin is one of the major points in its favor, and is separate from the risk of theft (if the risk of theft were nearly eliminated, the lack of fees would still be a positive). Let's not change word definitions and mix categories because the conversation will become messy.

Funny, so far, Libertarians are the ones who change word definitions as it suits them and mix categories like a bartender mixes drinks.

But my point is this: no matter if I pay a fee or accept a risk of theft, I lose money over time - except that, when I buy something in a store using dollars, I know I´m going to pay sales tax (7%, isn´t it?), but when I use Bitcoins, I never know when the next disaster strikes that costs me a lot of Bitcoins. Bitcoins introduces an unnecessary element of risk.

Not to mention, when I buy something in a store, they never notify me afterwards, "Looks like a purse has been stolen in our store yesterday, we´re rolling back all transactions from that day, please repeat your shopping trip." - unlike Bitcoins.
 
But my point is this: no matter if I pay a fee or accept a risk of theft, I lose money over time - except that, when I buy something in a store using dollars, I know I´m going to pay sales tax (7%, isn´t it?), but when I use Bitcoins, I never know when the next disaster strikes that costs me a lot of Bitcoins. Bitcoins introduces an unnecessary element of risk.

Not to mention, when I buy something in a store, they never notify me afterwards, "Looks like a purse has been stolen in our store yesterday, we´re rolling back all transactions from that day, please repeat your shopping trip." - unlike Bitcoins.
Oh, that's not Bitcoins or the Bitcoin client itself. That was a specific Bitcoin processing site. I don't know all the details of how that site (Mt. Gox) does business so I'm not sure if that was a good idea, but it probably wasn't necessary because without Mt. Gox's interference the price of Bitcoins rebounded within minutes. Just by market force. Furthermore, if people don't like Mt. Gox, they can just take their Bitcoins elsewhere. Not so for the U.S. government's dollars.

If someone was running Bitcoin or there was some built-in program in the client that allowed for sales to be undone or rolled back, it wouldn't be nearly as advantageous over the dollar nor would free-market proponents and libertarians be creaming their pants in the way that they are.

The value of Bitcoin and the actual Bitcoin client is that there IS NO central authority threatening to mess with the currency or the transactions. They are entirely voluntarily, unrefundable, and up to the person sending. It is pure market forces that influence their value and their usefulness, and the free-market people believe this will allow for much more freedom and much more useful currency than government controlled money. Since we've already seen the Bitcoin skyrocket past the dollar in value in a matter of months, and "taboo" voluntary markets like drug trading (and apparently soon online poker) are being mass enabled, it appears already that the free-marketers and libertarians might actually be right.

Did I mention that Bitcoin or something like it could even END WAR? How could the government fund them if they can't take people's money? You're excited about that thought, aren't you?
 
Last edited:
Did I mention that Bitcoin or something like it could even END WAR? How could the government fund them if they can't take people's money? You're excited about that thought, aren't you?

No. The thought of abolishing government doesn't excite me. I wasn't an anarcho-libertarian yesterday, why would I have become one today?

You seem to be under the impression that most people yearn for anarcho-libertarianism, and the only thing stopping it has been a technical way to implement it.

But yours is a minority position. That doesn't make it wrong. It's just that most people, as much as they grumble about "the government," actually want a government. They want things like police and fire protection and a court system and health care and highways, and they don't share your conviction that "the market" will take care of all those things adequately in the absence of a government.
 
I didn't ask if the thought of abolishing government excited you. I asked if the thought of abolishing war excited you. Your entire post is directed at a strawman. Please re-read what I actually said and respond to it.
 
By the way, just to clarify, I'm not an anarchist or an anarcho-capitalist. I believe the government is necessary to provide courts, police, and national defense. I also think that private charity is the best and most efficient method for providing for the needy, and it works quite fine in doing so.
 
How could the government fund them if they can't take people's money?

Ignoring that even if the world were to switch entirely to bitcons, the government would still be able to levy taxes, wars didn't use to be funded by tax money, you know. Feudal obligations, letters of Marque and looting rights work well enough if your neighbour's military forces are likewise constrained money-wise.
 
Ignoring that even if the world were to switch entirely to bitcons, the government would still be able to levy taxes,
How?

wars didn't use to be funded by tax money, you know. Feudal obligations, letters of Marque and looting rights work well enough if your neighbour's military forces are likewise constrained money-wise.
If you want wars to consist of low-wage mercenaries on horseback with iron armor and swords, then okay. But I wouldn't consider that comparable to the billion-dollar doomsday devices and multi-million casualty modern world wars that we've had in the last century.
 

By estimating people's net worth and putting them in prison if they refuse to pay the calculated amount of money. Yes, it would be a vastly less efficient way to collect taxes, meaning that the government would have to spend more money raising taxes, requiring a greater total tax pressure on the populace.

If you want wars to consist of low-wage mercenaries on horseback with iron armor and swords, then okay. But I wouldn't consider that comparable to the billion-dollar doomsday devices and multi-million casualty modern world wars that we've had in the last century.

Look into the effects the hundred years war had on the peasant population. Then multiply by modern small-arms, high explosives and population densities.
 
I want to buy something the government doesn't like. You want to sell something the government doesn't like. I anonymously send you bitcoins. You send me a non-descript package. How does the government stop this?

How did you send the package? Any kind of sending is going to be subject from scrutiny, unless you now have a postal service esque place, with a " We refuse to check what is in the package." policy. Which i am going to assume is not going to fly with any of the governments.
 
How?

If you want wars to consist of low-wage mercenaries on horseback with iron armor and swords, then okay. But I wouldn't consider that comparable to the billion-dollar doomsday devices and multi-million casualty modern world wars that we've had in the last century.

Read up on the Thirty Years´ War. If you don´t want to pay for an army, hire mercenaries - they pay for themselves. There´s some REAL looting for you.
 
How?

If you want wars to consist of low-wage mercenaries on horseback with iron armor and swords, then okay. But I wouldn't consider that comparable to the billion-dollar doomsday devices and multi-million casualty modern world wars that we've had in the last century.

Let me show you how silly that statement is.

You could hold the same opinion during medieval times....

" If you want your ranks to consist of ploughmen with clubs and scyths , then okay. But i wouldn't consider that comparable to the tons of gold requiring siege weapons, plate armor, and fine weapons, that we have had in the last century."
 
That's like saying youtube is slightly more convenient for spreading videos than mailing VHS tapes is. The notion of instant, world-wide, fee-free connection and distribution is not minor.
Fee-free? The constant risk of loss through hacking is a substantial fee, I´d say, and one which is completely unpredictable, in contrast to regular fees.
That's not a fee. Fees and risks are two different things (for example, cliff diving is highly risky, but costs no money). The lack of fees in using Bitcoin is one of the major points in its favor, and is separate from the risk of theft (if the risk of theft were nearly eliminated, the lack of fees would still be a positive). Let's not change word definitions and mix categories because the conversation will become messy.


Sure, risk isn't the same thing as fees. I'll grant you that, but it's semantic nitpicking that sidesteps the point.

Do you even understand how the Bitcoin generation/transaction processing algorithm works?

It encourages user participation in the processing duties of performing transactions, by coupling that work with the rewards of Bitcoin generation, or "mining."

However, the incentive to "mine" Bitcoin drops off exponentially as the "difficulty" goes up, which happens as a direct function of time and global processing power applied to the "mining." Do you understand the implications of that?

As time goes on, the process of "mining" becomes less and less efficient as the "difficulty" level is ramped ever higher. The more people who engage in "mining," that makes the "difficulty" ramp upward even faster.

Remember, the "mining" operation is directly tied to transaction processing. Part of the duties of Bitcoin miners is to process the cryptographic functions that secure Bitcoin transactions.

But, as time goes on and the "difficulty" ramps higher, the rewards of mining diminish exponentially regardless of the number of transactions the miners are charged with processing.

At this point in time (less than 2 years into Bitcoin's functional existence), it's already prohibitively expensive to get started mining bitcoins. The energy costs alone make it a barely-viable enterprise. That's not to even mention the costs of equipment, which needs to be constantly maintained and even expanded for a "mining" operation to remain competitive in the environment of exponentially-increasing, artificial difficulty.

Now, one might think that because mining is related to transaction processing, the increasing "difficulty" is a direct function of rapid increases in Bitcoin trading. Not so.

"Difficulty" is a function of the "mining" application that creates a number of totally arbitrary logic problems for the miners' processor(s) to solve, in addition to any transaction processing duties that might arise. The logic problems have absolutely no practical function in the system other than to make the miners' machines work ever harder to produce fewer and fewer coins for the market. Think about that for a minute. The system is actually set up to waste more and more energy, and cause more and more equipment wear and tear, for no other purpose than to artificially limit the amount of monetary units and create overvaluation (a bad thing).

So what happens if Bitcoin miraculously becomes super-successful as an actual currency in the global marketplace, with the sheer unbridled financial power to bankrupt governments, like so many anarchist Libertarians wet dream?

(I'm quite certain it won't, but the hypothetical scenario illustrates yet another failing point of the system.)

If Bitcoin really takes off as a currency, the demand for transaction processing will skyrocket. Who will handle the enormous processing duties of a global marketplace, if the number of "miners" drops off due to lack of compensation? Mining is already a barely profitable waste of resources at this point in time.

So when people start going nuts trading in this awesome free currency, the transaction load will spike and create a huge bottleneck in the system.

Are people expected to keep their "mining rigs" running with no remuneration, out of charity to this bold new world economy? Unlikely. No self-respecting Libertarian would be caught dead contributing his own resources for the benefit of others if an external system mandates it.

So what will happen? Transactions will need to be handled by either one or both participants, and like any service, will likely incur processing charges.

So we're back where we started from, paying transaction fees. But we've lost the stability and security that the existing, established currencies already had.

Hooray! We just ruined the world economy for nothing!


Oh, that's not Bitcoins or the Bitcoin client itself. That was a specific Bitcoin processing site. I don't know all the details of how that site (Mt. Gox) does business


Nobody does.

That's a major part of the problem. Lacking any form of standardized regulation or oversight, there's no way of assuring honesty or regularity in that rat's nest of an economy.


Furthermore, if people don't like Mt. Gox, they can just take their Bitcoins elsewhere. Not so for the U.S. government's dollars.


Take them elsewhere? Where are you going to take them?!?

In the absence of external, legal controls over the exchanges, nobody can ever be certain that the exchange they're dealing with is totally on the up-and-up, or be 100% certain they won't wake up tomorrow morning to find all their money has vanished into thin air.

There's no FDIC protection for Bitcoin. I'll gladly pay a 7% sales tax for the security of ensuring my money doesn't go "poof" into thin air overnight (not to mention all the other nice civilized society-type things that taxes pay for, like parks, roads, laws, police, firemen, etc.).


If someone was running Bitcoin or there was some built-in program in the client that allowed for sales to be undone or rolled back, it wouldn't be nearly as advantageous over the dollar nor would free-market proponents and Libertarians be creaming their pants in the way that they are.


In the neighborhood where I grew up, there lived a 26-year-old mentally retarded neighbor who went absolutely bonkers over the prospect of dinner at McDonald's.

The Bitcoin economy is already a nightmare of instability, inequity and uselessness. I'm thinking this Bitcoin thing might be a fine object lesson to prove how misguided the Libertarian anarchist utopia really is.


The value of Bitcoin and the actual Bitcoin client is that there IS NO central authority threatening to mess with the currency or the transactions. They are entirely voluntarily, unrefundable, and up to the person sending. It is pure market forces that influence their value and their usefulness, and the free-market people believe this will allow for much more freedom and much more useful currency than government controlled money.


Bitcoin is one of the least stable, most useless currencies in the world. How many goods and services do you buy on a daily basis, with your wonderful, precious bitcoins?


Since we've already seen the Bitcoin skyrocket past the dollar in value in a matter of months...


Yeah, that's a function of the artificial scarcity imposed by the Bitcoin system itself, coupled with its novelty and its appeal to speculators looking to make a quick buck off the credulity of Libertarian anarchist currency cranks.


"taboo" voluntary markets like drug trading (and apparently soon online poker) are being mass enabled, it appears already that the free-marketers and Libertarians might actually be right.


Yeah, because people buying heroin and methamphetamine via the Internet is a wonderful thing, right?


Did I mention that Bitcoin or something like it could even END WAR? How could the government fund them if they can't take people's money? You're excited about that thought, aren't you?


Wow, man, are you really that far gone?
 
Last edited:
As far as I can tell the anonymity of the system offers security against the non-issue of the government's involvement, but opens the door for fraud and theft that legally binding contracts offer protections against. It's like closing all the curtains on your house so no one could see what you're doing, assuming they wanted to, but leaving the door wide open for anyone to just come in and take your stuff.
 
obviously this new spike in "evil" crimes against the self has had no apparent negative effect on society.

Only anarchists and other Libertarians think that undermining the ability of the agreed civil society to regulate undesirable, dangerous, and harmful behavior is not a "negative effect".

We shall see if one emerges, since many people love to claim that these sorts of things must be controlled by well-meaning overseers of people's personal freedoms...

You mean aside from the inherent effect of flouting lawful authority that you agree to obey by being a member of society?

but of course, regardless, it appears that the nanny-wand is being forcefully removed from big-government and big-government voter's hands...and individual freedom is going to take over whether they like it or not. We can only stand back and observe the results. I wouldn't have it any other way.

You go ahead and stand there...sooner or later society will find you and you will pay the price for being a scofflaw and a criminal.
 
The value of Bitcoin and the actual Bitcoin client is that there IS NO central authority threatening to mess with the currency or the transactions. They are entirely voluntarily, unrefundable, and up to the person sending.


So, if I send you a Bitcoin payment and you claim to send that non-descript package you keep talking about, but don't actually send it...? Sucks to be me?

I see no benefit here.
 
Last edited:
By estimating people's net worth and putting them in prison if they refuse to pay the calculated amount of money. Yes, it would be a vastly less efficient way to collect taxes, meaning that the government would have to spend more money raising taxes, requiring a greater total tax pressure on the populace.
How do you estimate people's net worth?

Look into the effects the hundred years war had on the peasant population. Then multiply by modern small-arms, high explosives and population densities.
Once we figure out how governments would be collecting money, then we'll figure out what type of combat they could afford.
 
How did you send the package? Any kind of sending is going to be subject from scrutiny, unless you now have a postal service esque place, with a " We refuse to check what is in the package." policy. Which i am going to assume is not going to fly with any of the governments.
Not snooping in people's packages is already the policy.

Read up on the Thirty Years´ War. If you don´t want to pay for an army, hire mercenaries - they pay for themselves. There´s some REAL looting for you.
Mercenaries armed with what?
 
How do you estimate people's net worth?

*shrugs* The same way they do today when estimating for property taxes. Sure, bitcoins wouldn't show up unless people declared them themselves (of course, the same is true for cash today), but people rarely have much of their net worth tied up in ready money anyway so that's not a problem.

You realise that taxes pre-dates the modern transactional banking system and paper-based currencies, right?

Once we figure out how governments would be collecting money, then we'll figure out what type of combat they could afford.

"Here's the IRS' bitcoins account ID. Here's the web-page where you can register a bitcoin account as yours. Now pay us X bitcoins from a bitcoint account registered to you before 2020-30-06, or go to jail. Have a nice day."
 
Sure, risk isn't the same thing as fees. I'll grant you that, but it's semantic nitpicking that sidesteps the point.

Do you even understand how the Bitcoin generation/transaction processing algorithm works?

It encourages user participation in the processing duties of performing transactions, by coupling that work with the rewards of Bitcoin generation, or "mining."

However, the incentive to "mine" Bitcoin drops off exponentially as the "difficulty" goes up, which happens as a direct function of time and global processing power applied to the "mining." Do you understand the implications of that?

As time goes on, the process of "mining" becomes less and less efficient as the "difficulty" level is ramped ever higher. The more people who engage in "mining," that makes the "difficulty" ramp upward even faster.

Remember, the "mining" operation is directly tied to transaction processing. Part of the duties of Bitcoin miners is to process the cryptographic functions that secure Bitcoin transactions.

But, as time goes on and the "difficulty" ramps higher, the rewards of mining diminish exponentially regardless of the number of transactions the miners are charged with processing.

At this point in time (less than 2 years into Bitcoin's functional existence), it's already prohibitively expensive to get started mining bitcoins. The energy costs alone make it a barely-viable enterprise. That's not to even mention the costs of equipment, which needs to be constantly maintained and even expanded for a "mining" operation to remain competitive in the environment of exponentially-increasing, artificial difficulty.

Now, one might think that because mining is related to transaction processing, the increasing "difficulty" is a direct function of rapid increases in Bitcoin trading. Not so.

"Difficulty" is a function of the "mining" application that creates a number of totally arbitrary logic problems for the miners' processor(s) to solve, in addition to any transaction processing duties that might arise. The logic problems have absolutely no practical function in the system other than to make the miners' machines work ever harder to produce fewer and fewer coins for the market. Think about that for a minute. The system is actually set up to waste more and more energy, and cause more and more equipment wear and tear, for no other purpose than to artificially limit the amount of monetary units and create overvaluation (a bad thing).
"Where does the value of Bitcoin stem from? What backs up Bitcoin?

Bitcoins have value because they are accepted as payment by many. See the list of Bitcoin-accepting sites.

When we say that a currency is backed up by gold, we mean that there's a promise in place that you can exchange the currency for gold. In a sense, you could say that Bitcoin is "backed up" by the price tags of merchants – a price tag is a promise to exchange goods for a specified amount of currency.

It's a common misconception that Bitcoins gain their value from the cost of electricity required to generate them. Cost doesn't equal value – hiring 1,000 men to shovel a big hole in the ground may be costly, but not valuable. Also, even though scarcity is a critical requirement for a useful currency, it alone doesn't make anything valuable. For example, your fingerprints are scarce, but that doesn't mean they have any exchange value."


So what happens if Bitcoin miraculously becomes super-successful as an actual currency in the global marketplace, with the sheer unbridled financial power to bankrupt governments, like so many anarchist Libertarians wet dream?

(I'm quite certain it won't, but the hypothetical scenario illustrates yet another failing point of the system.)

If Bitcoin really takes off as a currency, the demand for transaction processing will skyrocket. Who will handle the enormous processing duties of a global marketplace, if the number of "miners" drops off due to lack of compensation? Mining is already a barely profitable waste of resources at this point in time.

So when people start going nuts trading in this awesome free currency, the transaction load will spike and create a huge bottleneck in the system.

Are people expected to keep their "mining rigs" running with no remuneration, out of charity to this bold new world economy? Unlikely. No self-respecting Libertarian would be caught dead contributing his own resources for the benefit of others if an external system mandates it.
"If no more coins are going to be generated, will more blocks be created?

Absolutely! Even before the creation of coins ends, the use of transaction fees will likely make creating new blocks more valuable from the fees than the new coins being created. When coin generation ends, what will sustain the ability to use bitcoins will be these fees entirely. There will be blocks generated after block #6,929,999, assuming that people are still using Bitcoins at that time."


So what will happen? Transactions will need to be handled by either one or both participants, and like any service, will likely incur processing charges.

So we're back where we started from, paying transaction fees. But we've lost the stability and security that the existing, established currencies already had.
At this point, which is estimated to be over 130 years in the future, if Bitcoins replace conventionally taxed and inflated money, there would be hundreds of millions of computers verifying transactions so the amount of power available to process them would scale along with their use. Furthermore, the amount of money each person has access to would be dramatically different and probably increased so I doubt by then the transaction fee would be an issue.

Hooray! We just ruined the world economy for nothing!
How did we ruin the world economy?

Nobody does.

That's a major part of the problem. Lacking any form of standardized regulation or oversight, there's no way of assuring honesty or regularity in that rat's nest of an economy.
You think regulation and oversight are the only ways to assure honesty or regularity?

Which government official inspects the hamburger that McDonalds gives you? What government regulation insures that Ipod technology continues updating at an insane rate?

Market forces do that. Not the government.

Take them elsewhere? Where are you going to take them?!?
To ExchangeBTC...Tradehill...Bitcoin7. There are a number of sites that offer processing and trading services.

In the absence of external, legal controls over the exchanges, nobody can ever be certain that the exchange they're dealing with is totally on the up-and-up, or be 100% certain they won't wake up tomorrow morning to find all their money has vanished into thin air.
You can't be 100% certain of that with the U.S. dollar right now. The notion of needing 100% certainty is a red-herring. There's only reasonable certainty based on available evidence...and the Bitcoin creators appear to have done a very good job of giving evidence that transactions can't be hacked...combine that with market forces (the same ones that have given us basically all the comforts of modern first-world life) and you can have quite reasonable certainty that you can make safe Bitcoin transactions.

In the neighborhood where I grew up, there lived a 26-year-old mentally retarded neighbor who went absolutely bonkers over the prospect of dinner at McDonald's.

The Bitcoin economy is already a nightmare of instability, inequity and uselessness. I'm thinking this Bitcoin thing might be a fine object lesson to prove how misguided the Libertarian anarchist utopia really is.





Bitcoin is one of the least stable, most useless currencies in the world. How many goods and services do you buy on a daily basis, with your wonderful, precious bitcoins?





Yeah, that's a function of the artificial scarcity imposed by the Bitcoin system itself, coupled with its novelty and its appeal to speculators looking to make a quick buck off the credulity of Libertarian anarchist currency cranks.





Yeah, because people buying heroin and methamphetamine via the Internet is a wonderful thing, right?





Wow, man, are you really that far gone?
If you want to talk to me, conduct yourself like a mature adult. No strawmen, no name-calling, no wild assertions. I don't have the time or patience to repeat myself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom