How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
All you're saying is that it's desirable for someone to develop convenient security software or security sites to accompany the Bitcoin client. That's inevitable...and is probably so easy to implement that I wouldn't even be surprised if they're free and open-sourced.

Not so fast. If nobody other than the current adopters take up Bitcoin because of the scams, viruses and security issues, then nobody will have an incentive to provide security tools.
 
Last edited:
Not so fast. If nobody other than the current adopters take up Bitcoin because of the scams, viruses an security issues, then nobody will have an incentive to provide security tools.

I'm suspecting any security software programmers wouldn't want to be paid in Bitcoins, being aware of the flaws in the security.
 
Seems to me that if enough taxable revenue were being handled via untraceable Bitcoin transactions, it would be simple enough for the government to pass laws to the effect that henceforth Bitcoin transactions must be traceable, auditable, and taxable.

And, obviously, that any attempt to avoid taxation through the use of untraceable, non-auditable electronic transaction systems would be a crime. Anybody who paid less in taxes than the government expected them to, and who was using UntraceableCoin, would promptly find themselves in jail for tax evasion.

Of course, UntraceableCoin would never catch on, except amongst the criminal underground, just like every other black-market money-laundering scheme. Which is exactly that it would be. And which is exactly what the Bitcoin evangelists want Bitcoin to be.

What's that you say? Bitcoin isn't a black-market money-laundering scheme? Then why are you promoting it as a way to avoid taxation?
 
How?
How? How is fraud a problem when your amount of risk for fraud is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use sellers who have references and widespread reputations? Answer the question.

How do you keep a reputation system in a global anonymised untraceable currency?

HINT: The answer does not lie in those cute coins in the BTC forums, or in IRC chat rating systems.
 
Nothing. I haven't done any Bitcoin business yet, just tried out the software and researched it. I'm also not even sure who 'they" are. You do know that it's decentralized, right? There's no "they" controlling it.

You poor naive fool. The people controlling Bitcoin are the early adopters who are sitting on hundreds of thousands of Bitcoins and are currently manipulating the small speculative market to fleece money off people with absolutely no financial clue whatsoever.

Nobody is spending any BTCs, it's all speculation at the moment.
 
If you read the FAQ, then you wouldn't have had to ask many of these questions. Particularly the one about why people will process transactions after the 21 million coin limit is reached.


As I said before: not only have I read that silly FAQ, but I've also read Satoshi's whitepaper, a large percentage of the Bitcoin Wiki, and have even perused portions of the source code. So quit insinuating that I don't understand how Bitcoin operates, OK?

That FAQ is little more than a protracted sales pitch. It's pandering and promotional, akin to an infomercial. It provides confusing and illogical rationales in support of the currency, it's evasive about many important operational details, and it neglects to mention even the most obvious shortcomings of the system.

My entire point of explaining the mining/transaction processing subsystem is to point out a theoretical design flaw that could cause some serious workflow issues if it were ever to really catch on as a common currency, and also to disprove the notion that fees are not part of the Bitcoin business model.


They also are basically impossible to counterfeit or inflate (removing one of the major dangers of unbacked currency).


But a steady, low level of inflation is actually beneficial to an economy, because it keeps the money flowing by encouraging spending and investment.

Deflation, on the other hand, is worse because even a low level of deflation restricts spending and discourages investment. High levels of deflation (like the extreme overvaluation we're seeing in the Bitcoin market right now) promotes hoarding, and causes extreme volatility which makes the currency too risky for trade. About the only thing Bitcoin is really good for at this point in time is as a crazy, high-risk speculative investment, and I don't see that changing any time soon.

In fact, looking at the way the system functions, it appears that a purely speculative market around a completely valueless commodity is precisely what the creators were going for, with the lure of "free money" being the "hook" that draws in suckers. The economics of this system really do look a lot like a pyramid scam.

The system is designed to reward the initial investors with a huge opportunity to stockpile the lion's share of monetary units for free, and then it restricts the availability exponentially as time goes on and interest builds. As artificial scarcity drives up the price, the value of the initial investors' holdings skyrocket. At the same time, the system punishes new investors, creates dangerous levels of volatility, and the extreme deflation discourages trade. Unless you got in on the ground floor when mining was profitable, Bitcoin is far too dangerous to bother with, even for routine online purchases.

I find it quite telling that even the most vocal proponents of Bitcoin do not use it themselves for daily purchases. I personally know a guy who got into mining last summer, and despite his tireless pimping and proselytizing on behalf of Bitcoin, he's been sitting on his stack without spending a single BTC. How anyone can argue that this is a useful, viable currency is beyond me.


I'd rather have my money backed by a period of uncounterfeitable processing-time than by a government that can inflate and counterfeit it at will and who threatens to harm me if I don't go along with it.


I can tell you're one of those "hate the Gubmint" types and I don't begrudge you that. But believe it or not, external control over the money supply and interest rates is an essential stabilizing factor in any modern economy. Lacking those controls, market volatility would be far more extreme than it is now.

Stability is what is needed in a currency, not insane overvaluation. As has already been pointed out many times before in this thread, a currency is useless if it can't be relied on to hold a steady value.


I don't agree that there's a major threat of it crashing due to being "value-less," It's not.


You can click your heels like Dorothy and repeat to yourself "Bitcoin is not valueless... Bitcoin is not valueless..." but it's all a matter of faith and nothing else. All the value it has is artificial, derived entirely from the whims of the speculative market with no stabilizing factors. Beyond that, there's nothing. Bitcoin is not backed by any legal system, GDP, physical commodity, stores of precious metal, contractual obligations, or anything else.

Remember Alan Greenspan's famous quote about "irrational exuberance?" He was describing an overvalued market driven by the tech industry bubble, but Bitcoin doesn't even contain a slight fraction of the intrinsic value that all those now defunct Internet "dot-coms" once did, with their physical assets and patent portfolios and whatnot.


Bitcoins represent a unit of computing time and work.


Computing time and work that has already occurred in the past tense. It's not like a bitcoin is backed by the promise of some future processing task to be delivered later.

Wear-and-tear on some random dude's video card is not a valuable, exchangeable commodity.


Nope. You can be nearly 100% scam-proof if you so choose.


Considering people seldom have a deliberate choice about getting victimized by crime, I don't see how you can possibly make such a bold claim.


I didn't ask who inspects the beef that McDonald's receives. I asked which government official inspects the actual hamburger. That's market forces pushing McDonald's to try to provide consistently cost-effective, safe food that the public enjoys.


Your laissez-faire capitalist approach is glassy-eyed and unrealistic. Just because something makes somebody money, that doesn't necessarily mean it's always good. How about an another analogy?

How about Bernie Madoff. In a Bitcoin economy, a swindler like him would be able to get away scot-free with all those peoples' money, because they paid him willingly and there are absolutely no laws or regulations governing financial transactions in Bitcoin.


The crisis that economists say was CAUSED by the government in the first place. But that's for another thread.


That's an appeal to misleading authority. "Economists" say a lot of things. There was plenty of blame to go round.

You do realize that the Gubmint's entire role in the economic crisis was the widespread deregulation of the financial markets throughout the 1980s and '90s, which allowed such irresponsible behavior on the part of the financial industry in the first place?

Now let me ask you this: How would Bitcoin, with its complete and total absence of any financial regulations, restrictions or controls whatsoever, protect its economy and consumers against similar or even far more egregious scams?


Your credit and debit cards also ALLOW you to commit fraud and theft, through chargebacks. So let's not pretend that they reduce these things only.


There is also a system of LAWS to protect against credit card fraud. If I scam somebody by reneging on my credit card, they can go to the authorities and demand payment. If I'm found guilty of fraud, I can be arrested and go to jail. Not so with Bitcoin fraud.

In the absence of governmental authority (a.k.a. laws and banking regulations) there's nothing stopping a Bitcoin exchange from ripping off its clients, and there's no insurance to protect its clients if it goes under. You never even addressed that major concern in your last snarky post.


See what I said before about Bitcoins not being tulips.


You're absolutely correct. They're not tulips. Tulips are useful for planting in your garden, looking pretty, and maybe even increasing the "curb-appeal" of your house. Bitcoin, on the other hand, is pretty useless unless you want to buy some online hashish, obsolete videogame consoles, hippy-dippy bead necklaces, or amateur webdesign work.

I looked over that entire list of Bitcoin merchants and there wasn't a single thing on there that's valuable enough to warrant switching to fake Internet funny money for.
 
Last edited:
How about Bernie Madoff. In a Bitcoin economy, a swindler like him would be able to get away scot-free with all those peoples' money, because they paid him willingly and there are absolutely no laws or regulations governing financial transactions in Bitcoin.


Even if there were laws or regulations, they'd be useless. Bitcoin's anonymous transactions mean never being able to prove you actually gave anyone any BTC.

How can any company with a decent client-base ensure that any individual client has made their monthly payment? At best, their end-of-the-month accounting shows them to be short of their expected revenue, but who failed to pay?

Any serious business needs payment records, whether those payments are in USD or BTC. There goes your anonymity.
 
Last edited:
And any scammer worth his chops could just fake a positive rating, how are they going to verify when all transactions are securely anonymous? Then either scam as many high value targets as possible before moving on, or do the xkcd bobcat strategy and balance your negative rating scams with positive rating real sales or fake reviews.

It is seriously a flawed idea.

And as for that strange no more war idea, if the government can't afford a military through lack of taxes what makes you think they can afford all the important services they provide?
 
Actually, all transactions are not anonymous by default, but the idea is that they can be, if both parties agree to it. The practicality of making the transaction anonymous only involves creating a new wallet account specifically for that transaction, exchanging public keys, and using an anonymous, encrypted proxy such as Tor to make the transaction.

However, each bitcoin itself contains a running record of all its previous owners, so one could conceivably trace back transactions if they can get their hands on the original bitcoins. On the other hand, a scammer, drug dealer or whatever could always "launder" his bitcoins by immediately circulating them among a number of other customers, or by cashing them in for real money.
 
Actually, all transactions are not anonymous by default, but the idea is that they can be, if both parties agree to it. The practicality of making the transaction anonymous only involves creating a new wallet account specifically for that transaction, exchanging public keys, and using an anonymous, encrypted proxy such as Tor to make the transaction.

Really, bitcoins transactions are only pseudonymous -- not anonymous in the strict sense. When the police is able to identify the holder of a bitcoin account (by computer forensics, traffic analysis, package tracking, getting hold of a seller's little black book or any of the other methods the police is already using to investigate drug trafficing and money laundering), every single transaction ever made to or from that account is immediately and unarguably linked to the identified person. Apparently, that will never happen as only smart people use bitcoins and smart people are never busted by the police.
 
Well, yeah of course. Once the police gain physical access to your computer, all bets are off.

That's why I have my burglar alarm rigged up to dump my machine into a vat of sulfuric acid if anyone enters my house without entering the proper passcode. ;)
 
That's why I have my burglar alarm rigged up to dump my machine into a vat of sulfuric acid if anyone enters my house without entering the proper passcode. ;)

Yeah, I used to have a setup like that, but then the vulcano erupted.
 
Another possible option would be to hide your wallet.dat using steganography, or better yet place all your "sensitive" (read: "incriminating") files inside a stegano-cryptographic filesystem like TrueCrypt or Rubberhose.
 
Actually, all transactions are not anonymous by default, but the idea is that they can be, if both parties agree to it. The practicality of making the transaction anonymous only involves creating a new wallet account specifically for that transaction, exchanging public keys, and using an anonymous, encrypted proxy such as Tor to make the transaction.

However, each bitcoin itself contains a running record of all its previous owners, so one could conceivably trace back transactions if they can get their hands on the original bitcoins. On the other hand, a scammer, drug dealer or whatever could always "launder" his bitcoins by immediately circulating them among a number of other customers, or by cashing them in for real money.


Ahh. You know, I vaguely remember reading the highlighted part now that you mention it. Thanks for setting me straight. I guess that means any given bitcoin is potentially more traceable than any given dollar bill.
 
Last edited:
This all seems to be a tremendous amount of hassle all to use a system trying to replace pre-existing options, with no benefit unless you're trying to break the law in some way. Let's consider the existing systems when buying online. Last year, I bought an item through ebay, paying with my credit card via Paypal, that was broken when it arrived. After receiving no response from the seller to repeated emails, I opened a dispute through ebay and eventually recieved a full refund. Had ebay not been helpful, I could also have taken the issue up with my credit card provider. This seems to be a reasonable system with reasonable safeguards for shopping online.

Now, had I bought from someone using Bitcoins, what would my options have been? Apparently, I would have to suck it up and try to be more careful in future. Never mind that the seller had excellent feedback at the time of purchase. So how exactly is this a superior system?
 
However, each bitcoin itself contains a running record of all its previous owners, so one could conceivably trace back transactions if they can get their hands on the original bitcoins. On the other hand, a scammer, drug dealer or whatever could always "launder" his bitcoins by immediately circulating them among a number of other customers, or by cashing them in for real money.
Ahh. You know, I vaguely remember reading the highlighted part now that you mention it. Thanks for setting me straight. I guess that means any given bitcoin is potentially more traceable than any given dollar bill.


I should really clarify this. Each bitcoin contains a record of the "mining" computer that generated it (and a number of other data regarding its generation) plus a running record of all previous addresses (GUIDs, basically) of the wallets it has been stored in.

A user can generate multiple wallets and transfer funds among them, and even create a new wallet for the purpose of a single transaction. That wallet can then be deleted after the transaction is complete.
 
...by repealing laws passed by state governments. That's a bit like telling me I shouldn't worry about a dog ******* on the carpet because every now and then they eat their own feces.

(I apologize if that's too strong an analogy, but when it came to me I had to say it)

The state governments were passing legislation wanted by their constituents. You seem to have the notion that evil states passed racist laws against the will of the people. This is not the case.
 
That's like saying youtube is slightly more convenient for spreading videos than mailing VHS tapes is. The notion of instant, world-wide, fee-free connection and distribution is not minor.

They're not instant, they're not fee-free, and they depreciate. PayPal is way better for many reasons.
 
They're not instant, they're not fee-free, and they depreciate. PayPal is way better for many reasons.


They don't "depreciate" as such. The system is engineered to create and maintain a situation of extreme scarcity, causing overvaluation. There's even a hard-coded ceiling on the number of Bitcoins that can ever be created, specifically 21 million BTC. The more people who take an interest in Bitcoin, the more artificial valuation they will acquire.

Furthermore, if a wallet file is deleted, your computer gets lost, stolen or destroyed, or the hard drive containing the wallet file goes bad, those bitcoins are irrevocably gone forever.

Lots of people have already lost their wallet files, so it is now impossible for Bitcoin to ever even reach the theoretical maximum of 21 million BTC.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom