How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Only anarchists and other Libertarians think that undermining the ability of the agreed civil society to regulate undesirable, dangerous, and harmful behavior is not a "negative effect".
I said crimes against the self.

You mean aside from the inherent effect of flouting lawful authority that you agree to obey by being a member of society?
Martin Luther King and Gandhi flouted lawful authority. So just the fact that you are disobeying a law does not mean that the effects will be negative. You have to look at whether the law is just and what the results were once it was no longer obeyed.

(Now, please pleasantly surprise me and DON'T respond by saying something like "You compared bitcoin users to GANDHI AND MLK!!!!!!!!")

You go ahead and stand there...sooner or later society will find you and you will pay the price for being a scofflaw and a criminal.
Appealing to consequences is a logical fallacy.
 
So, if I send you a Bitcoin payment and you claim to send that non-descript package you keep talking about, but don't actually send it...? Sucks to be me?

I see no benefit here.
You can just tell the seller to send the package first if that's your concern. Or you can deal only with sellers who have a good reputations, references or a lot of positive feedback. That's the way these deals are done now. What your bringing up is a non-issue, really.
 
*shrugs* The same way they do today when estimating for property taxes.
Not everyone's net worth is in real estate, and I would say the majority of people's isn't. It's in bank accounts (which would be encrypted bitcoin wallets) and business holdings (which would deal in encrypted transactions you can't access)

Sure, bitcoins wouldn't show up unless people declared them themselves (of course, the same is true for cash today), but people rarely have much of their net worth tied up in ready money anyway so that's not a problem.

You realise that taxes pre-dates the modern transactional banking system and paper-based currencies, right?
Yes...and the notion of tithes and such. But I'm still wondering how you plan to figure out what someone's net worth is when you can't access their bank accounts or business records without their permission. And not only can you not access their profits, you can't even know who their customers are or if they sold anything.
 
Unless the economy has broken down completely with the switch to bitcoins, mercenaries would still be able to buy weapons for themselves somewhere.
So the war potential of government would be reduced to sending in unpaid teams of mercenaries armed with stuff they bought themselves (meaning no missiles, no planes, no tanks, no warships, etc etc etc)...who's only pay or insurance of loyalty is a promise to be able to loot the victims if they aren't killed (which I'm not even sure would work)? I think you can see why I feel this would be the end of warfare as we know it.
 
So the war potential of government would be reduced to sending in unpaid teams of mercenaries armed with stuff they bought themselves (meaning no missiles, no planes, no tanks, no warships, etc etc etc)...who's only pay or insurance of loyalty is a promise to be able to loot the victims if they aren't killed (which I'm not even sure would work)? I think you can see why I feel this would be the end of warfare as we know it.

Really? I think you're just not very imaginative. Taxes existed long before electronic systems, and so has war. All they really need to do is just add a little entry on your tax statement every year about digital income and tax that. If they think you're lying, like you could do now if you had a large amount of under the table income, they can audit you, fine you, or throw you in jail.

Personally, I'm happy that I have roads, police and fire protection, and all those extra little things that make the civilized world civilized. When I see people complaining about having any taxes I wonder if they really want to go back to when life pretty much sucked for everyone who wasn't filthy rich.
 
You can just tell the seller to send the package first if that's your concern. Or you can deal only with sellers who have a good reputations, references or a lot of positive feedback. That's the way these deals are done now. What your bringing up is a non-issue, really.
Yes the problem of fraud, and a system which makes defrauding people laughably easy, is a total non-issue for a wanna-be currency.
Do you even think before you write?
 
EGarrett, thanks for referring me to the Bitcoin FAQ.

Do you really think it never occurred to me to look at that goofy document before reading the whitepaper that details the specific workings of the Bitcoin software suite, and examining the source code?

It's not an FAQ so much as an infomercial sales pitch, but thanks anyway.

I can see you're quite drunk off that kool-aid, so don't sweat it.


When we say that a currency is backed up by gold, we mean that there's a promise in place that you can exchange the currency for gold. In a sense, you could say that Bitcoin is "backed up" by the price tags of merchants – a price tag is a promise to exchange goods for a specified amount of currency.


You really don't see the circular reasoning in the above statement? Nice doubletalk they use to obfuscate the issue that Bitcoin is backed by absolutely nothing. No laws, no Fort Knox gold, no nation's GDP, absolutely no substance there at all.


Absolutely! Even before the creation of coins ends, the use of transaction fees will likely make creating new blocks more valuable from the fees than the new coins being created. When coin generation ends, what will sustain the ability to use bitcoins will be these fees entirely. There will be blocks generated after block #6,929,999, assuming that people are still using Bitcoins at that time."[/i][/url]


"the use of transaction fees will likely make creating new blocks more valuable from the fees than the new coins being created"

That doesn't even make sense. Again, a masterful job of flim-flamming the credulous dupes interested in investing their hard earned cash in worthless Internet funny money.


At this point, which is estimated to be over 130 years in the future, if Bitcoins replace conventionally taxed and inflated money, there would be hundreds of millions of computers verifying transactions so the amount of power available to process them would scale along with their use. Furthermore, the amount of money each person has access to would be dramatically different and probably increased so I doubt by then the transaction fee would be an issue.


There would be a bottleneck in transaction processing, because with no more coins to be "mined," there would be no more "miners" and therefore nobody to perform the work of verifying the transactions.


How did we ruin the world economy?


I dunno, man. You tell me. I was kind of wondering about that part myself.

You're the one who seems to be getting off on the idea that all the world's governments will go broke because of Bitcoin. Have you not even considered the disastrous effect that would have on the world economy?

Or is Bitcoin supposed to magically replace all liquid assets, life savings, financial regulations, etc. with a totally equitable Utopia based on mutual trust and brotherly love?

You tell me what you think would happen if Bitcoin displaced the economies of even a few major governments. Go ahead, give it a shot.


You think regulation and oversight are the only ways to assure honesty or regularity?

Which government official inspects the hamburger that McDonalds gives you? What government regulation insures that Ipod technology continues updating at an insane rate?

Market forces do that. Not the government.


The food McDonald's serves is inspected by the USDA. You didn't know that?

Yeah, we have this big, bloated government bureaucracy that's supposed to make sure the food supply is safe or some such boring crap. Go figure. Honestly, I don't know why they don't just let the market forces take care of it. After all, if you buy some bad food and get poisoned, at least your surviving family will know not to eat there any more. Caveat emptor, up, up and away!

I don't buy Ipods because I think they're overpriced and there are better products on the market for less money. I wouldn't even say their technology is "updating at an insane rate." They make products and sell them, just like any other company. BFD.

All the rest is just marketing hype, just like that Bitcoin FAQ that you seem to have lost your critical faculties over.

Oh yeah, I almost forgot. When it comes to financial stuff, yeah, you pretty much need some government and body of laws to regulate things. Otherwise, you get all kinds of scammers operating freely with total impunity and nobody has any security. The Bitcoin micro-economy is a perfect example of that dynamic right now.

How many people have lost their shirts by speculating in Bitcoin?

And on the other hand, how many of your everyday goods and services do you pay for in your precious bitcoins?

(You never answered that question before, so I'm giving you a second chance.)


To ExchangeBTC...Tradehill...Bitcoin7. There are a number of sites that offer processing and trading services.


So then tell me, which of those services is the most trustworthy?

Which is the most secure?

What recourse do I have if one of them goes out of business and reneges on whatever money I was transacting with them?

The fact that other Bitcoin money-changers exist doesn't address the fact that the Bitcoin model offers no security at all for the process of exchanging bitcoins with any other real currency, and it offers no protection at all if somebody steals your money or cheats you.


You can't be 100% certain of that with the U.S. dollar right now. The notion of needing 100% certainty is a red-herring. There's only reasonable certainty based on available evidence...and the Bitcoin creators appear to have done a very good job of giving evidence that transactions can't be hacked...combine that with market forces (the same ones that have given us basically all the comforts of modern first-world life) and you can have quite reasonable certainty that you can make safe Bitcoin transactions.


If my bank goes belly-up (which isn't likely; it's a very large and stable bank, unlike the Bitcoin exchanges) the government insures all my funds through FDIC, up to the sum of $250,000. Of course, you can also split your money up into $250,000 increments and store each of them in different banks so you'll still be reimbursed even if they all go under. This system worked to save a lot of people when lots of banks failed in the recent banking crisis.

My credit and debit cards also have insurance against fraud and theft. This works. I've personally used it on more than one occasion. If I were dealing in bitcoin at the time, I'd have been SOL. Thank goodness I was using real money instead!

Bitcoin offers zero protections in cases like that. If somebody swindles me out of my bitcoins, I can't even go to the police, because bitcoins are illegal tender. I might as well have gotten burned in a street drug deal. Imagine if the whole world economy were as volatile and insecure as the black market. That's what you get with Bitcoin. All the laws and protections of civilized modern life are stripped away, and you're left with the Law of the Jungle.
 
Last edited:
But I'm still wondering how you plan to figure out what someone's net worth is when you can't access their bank accounts or business records without their permission. And not only can you not access their profits, you can't even know who their customers are or if they sold anything.


security.png


^ This comic should be reposted at least once on every page in this thread, that's how awesome it is.
 
Mercenaries armed with what?

Now you´re being ridiculous... don´t you think that, given the prospect of free and unrestricted looting, these mercenaries will invest in the proper tools to get to that looting?

If you take the not-for-profits, i.e. regular armies, out of the picture - always assuming that your Bitcoin farce could do that -, then profit-oriented enterprises will step up to fill the void, just as you Libertarians always say will happen if government stops intervening.

And looting the population is always more profitable that protecting them, so guess on which side the profit-oriented mercenaries are going to be on?
 
So there are still no protections against keyloggers stealing your account info (either from your side, or just the side you trade on)?
Or hackers getting into the system and devalueing everything down to zero?
Or a botnet getting access and looting everything everyone has?
Or a disgruntled employee on any of the trading sides using his full level access to help himself to everything you have, free market style?

And for this privilege of creating an un-backed, un-controlled money, you'd like us to abolish government healthcare, infrastructre and wellfare, which the spirit of the free market will all make better and cheaper as long as your money exists, but the moment it vanishes, tough luck?

Yeah... I'll take the taxes thank you very much. It might be a chuck out of my salary, but at least its predictable and I know the chances of me being pennyless in the street are virtually nill.
 
Huh. This Bitcoin business sounds like a scheme, to me.

Create a black-market-friendly virtual money system in which the earliest subscribers (the creators of the system) make the most of it; sell the new subscribers expensive machines to "mine" more of said currency which is subject to transaction fees...

Gee, I wonder where all that real money is going, or what the first subscribers will convert their bitcoins into when the end is near.

What am I missing ?
 
Really? I think you're just not very imaginative. Taxes existed long before electronic systems, and so has war. All they really need to do is just add a little entry on your tax statement every year about digital income and tax that.

If they think you're lying, like you could do now if you had a large amount of under the table income, they can audit you
How?

Personally, I'm happy that I have roads, police and fire protection, and all those extra little things that make the civilized world civilized. When I see people complaining about having any taxes I wonder if they really want to go back to when life pretty much sucked for everyone who wasn't filthy rich.
EGarrett said:
By the way, just to clarify, I'm not an anarchist or an anarcho-capitalist. I believe the government is necessary to provide courts, police, and national defense. I also think that private charity is the best and most efficient method for providing for the needy, and it works quite fine in doing so.



LukeB said:
Yes the problem of fraud, and a system which makes defrauding people laughably easy, is a total non-issue for a wanna-be currency.
Do you even think before you write?
Please read what I actually said.

I was asked about what someone would if they sent Bitcoins and the person didn't actually send them a package. I replied saying, "you can just tell the seller to send the package first if that's your concern. Or you can deal only with sellers who have a good reputations, references or a lot of positive feedback. That's the way these deals are done now. What your bringing up is a non-issue, really."

You now reply asserting, with no argument, and an attempted insult, that fraud is a major problem.

How? How is fraud a problem when your amount of risk for fraud is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use sellers who have references and widespread reputations? Answer the question.
 
I was asked about what someone would if they sent Bitcoins and the person didn't actually send them a package. I replied saying, "you can just tell the seller to send the package first if that's your concern. Or you can deal only with sellers who have a good reputations, references or a lot of positive feedback. That's the way these deals are done now. What your bringing up is a non-issue, really."
That's not an answer to what you were asked.
 
EGarrett, how much real money did they dupe you out of?

It's best to admit to yourself that you've been conned and move on, rather than continuing to go back for seconds.
 
How? How is fraud a problem when your amount of risk for fraud is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use sellers who have references and widespread reputations? Answer the question.
Good point, people/companys need not be defrauded if their willing and able to sink vast amounts of time in checking references to make sure the people/company their dealing with is legit. So we have monstrous inefficency and another market barrier to any newcomers who havn't had a chance to build a reputation. Huzzah the free market!
Or people could stick with actual money and save themselves the trouble. OH GOD HOW DO I CHOOSE?!

Also I love this
you can just tell the seller to send the package first if that's your concern.
Do you really not see the problem with noone sending packages before they get paid, and noone paying until they get the package? Hell of an economy your silly little utopia must have.
 
If they think you're lying, like you could do now if you had a large amount of under the table income, they can audit you
How?

<snip>

How is fraud a problem when your amount of risk for fraud is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use sellers who have references and widespread reputations? Answer the question.

How would a seller get references and widespread reputations and at the same time be untraceable by a government that wanted to recover taxes owed or bust an illegal operation?

If they think you're running an illegal business, they can find out where your packages are being sent from, how many packages have been sent in the last year, and most importantly, who you are.
 

How do they run an audit? Basically, they get all relevant paperwork, figure out what property you own and estimate a value on it. Got a Porscishe 911 registered to your name? Guess what, the government knows about that: your name is on the bloody paperwork. (And if your name is not on the paperwork then it is, by legal definition, not your car and nobody will defend your property right to it. If there is no paperwork at all, then the cops will pull you over for driving an unregistered car and put you in jail.)

It's not magic -- governments has collected tax for centuries before there even was such a thing as a paper trail on payments. They still do it today on businesses that take all their income in cash.

How? How is fraud a problem when your amount of risk for fraud is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use sellers who have references and widespread reputations? Answer the question.

It's not entirely up to you. It's also up to the people who develop your operating system, bitcoins software, web browser, anti virus program and computer hardware. It's up to the people who run the bitcoin exchanges (you might trust Company X, but do you trust Company X's database administrator?) It's up to your ISP. It's up to the certificate authorities. It's up to the people who handle your money for you (which might not be much of a problem for you personally, but it's going to be a huge problem for any corporation or business.)

And anyway, your argument also falls flat on that it is similar to saying "How is traffic accidents a problem when your amount of risk of accident is ENTIRELY up to you, and you can use cars and mechanics who have references and widespread reputations?"

The fact that people could drive safely doesn't matter when we know that they won't.
 
EGarrett, thanks for referring me to the Bitcoin FAQ.

Do you really think it never occurred to me to look at that goofy document before reading the whitepaper that details the specific workings of the Bitcoin software suite, and examining the source code?

It's not an FAQ so much as an infomercial sales pitch, but thanks anyway.

I can see you're quite drunk off that kool-aid, so don't sweat it.
If you read the FAQ, then you wouldn't have had to ask many of these questions. Particularly the one about why people will process transactions after the 21 million coin limit is reached.

By the way, I'm going to tell you one more time, conduct yourself like an adult. That means less name-calling and childish attitude and more reasoned answers and honest discussion.

You really don't see the circular reasoning in the above statement? Nice doubletalk they use to obfuscate the issue that Bitcoin is backed by absolutely nothing. No laws, no Fort Knox gold, no nation's GDP, absolutely no substance there at all.
It could have been a better answer. There are many merchants that do currently trade in Bitcoin, but not "just because," or because Bitcoins don't represent anything.

Bitcoins represent a unit of computing time and work. They also are basically impossible to counterfeit or inflate (removing one of the major dangers of unbacked currency). I'd rather have my money backed by a period of uncounterfeitable processing-time than by a government that can inflate and counterfeit it at will and who threatens to harm me if I don't go along with it.

I also keep an eye on the Bitcoin ticker for fun (it's been floating between $14.5 and about $15.2 over the past few days), and if the Bitcoin does suddenly crash in value I will be aware of it and will follow every theory about how or why. However, I don't agree that there's a major threat of it crashing due to being "value-less," It's not.

"the use of transaction fees will likely make creating new blocks more valuable from the fees than the new coins being created"

That doesn't even make sense. Again, a masterful job of flim-flamming the credulous dupes interested in investing their hard earned cash in worthless Internet funny money.
The transaction fees go to the computer that processed the bit, in the same way that newly-created Bitcoins go to mining computers now. In this scenario, keep in mind also that Bitcoins are so widely accepted and distributed that no new Bitcoins are being created, meaning that the transaction fee Bitcoins WOULD be easily spendable.

I dunno, man. You tell me. I was kind of wondering about that part myself.

You're the one who seems to be getting off on the idea that all the world's governments will go broke because of Bitcoin. Have you not even considered the disastrous effect that would have on the world economy?
To quote myself earlier in the thread...

"By the way, just to clarify, I'm not an anarchist or an anarcho-capitalist. I believe the government is necessary to provide courts, police, and national defense. I also think that private charity is the best and most efficient method for providing for the needy, and it works quite fine in doing so."

I don't want anarchy nor do I "get off" on the idea of all the world's governments going broke. I am however, fascinated by the idea of government's being unable to suck hundreds of billions of dollars out of people's pockets and having to reconfigure themselves to provide actual results to people in exchange for their taxes (thus providing incentive for people to pay), instead of just a vague speech followed by forcefully taking the money and throwing it around like a toy.

Or is Bitcoin supposed to magically replace all liquid assets, life savings, financial regulations, etc. with a totally equitable Utopia based on mutual trust and brotherly love?
Why do you assume that liquid assets, life savings and so on could only be in dollars? If Bitcoins hold value (which it looks like they will), then they will be perfectly fine for holding someone's savings and liquid assets.

In terms of financial regulations, free-market-created protections (personally determined terms for sales, reputations and references, security programs and services) would do the same thing and I believe would do it better.

You tell me what you think would happen if Bitcoin displaced the economies of even a few major governments. Go ahead, give it a shot.
I don't want Bitcoins to displace the entire economy, since that would be destabilizing, but a gradual replacement or gradual rise as an alternative to the dollar could probably work well. But if Bitcoins did eventually replace the dollar, I think the government would probably have to attach their money-collection to actual services and results (like for example, the way they have tolls on the road now, or renting out land the government controls, or charging certain static amounts for areas with certain amounts of police and fire coverage), or they would have to rely on a simplified income reporting system that would be much easier to investigate or verify (Are you a business owner? Into which income bracket do you fall? etc etc) and would be more voluntary (which doesn't mean they wouldn't get anything. I voluntarily report income now even if I didn't think it could be verified).

Mainly though, the end effect of all of this is that the government would have to provide some tangible results for the money they receive. I think this would result in a dramatic shrinking of government to more of the bare essential services instead of social engineering and forced "charity." I think this would be a good thing. Proactive, aggressive war would be almost out of the question due to the cost and the fact that it would go outside of people's security fees. That could be a miraculously good thing.

The food McDonald's serves is inspected by the USDA. You didn't know that?
Incorrect, sir. I didn't ask who inspects the beef that McDonald's receives. I asked which government official inspects the actual hamburger. That's market forces pushing McDonald's to try to provide consistently cost-effective, safe food that the public enjoys.

This post is getting long so I will try to speed through or skip through the things that would require repetition.

I don't buy Ipods because I think they're overpriced and there are better products on the market for less money. I wouldn't even say their technology is "updating at an insane rate." They make products and sell them, just like any other company. BFD.
If you don't think Ipod/Iphone/Ipad/Smartphone/3G blahblahblah technology is updating at an insane rate, then you're just not reasonable. The Ipod I've owned for a few years is already almost totally obsolete. And your complaints about Apple are irrelevant. Market forces are pushing them to innovate. Not the government.

Oh yeah, I almost forgot. When it comes to financial stuff, yeah, you pretty much need some government and body of laws to regulate things. Otherwise, you get all kinds of scammers operating freely with total impunity and nobody has any security. The Bitcoin micro-economy is a perfect example of that dynamic right now.
Nope. You can be nearly 100% scam-proof if you so choose. See my other posts.

How many people have lost their shirts by speculating in Bitcoin?
See what I said before about Bitcoins not being tulips.

And on the other hand, how many of your everyday goods and services do you pay for in your precious bitcoins?

(You never answered that question before, so I'm giving you a second chance.)
1991 DUDE: This new internet is pretty impressive. It could potentially do amazing things on a global-scale.

1991 DUDE #2: How many people use your precious internet right now?

Hopefully you can see why that is a silly reply in a hypothetical discussion.

So then tell me, which of those services is the most trustworthy?

Which is the most secure?

What recourse do I have if one of them goes out of business and reneges on whatever money I was transacting with them?
See above about market forces.

The fact that other Bitcoin money-changers exist doesn't address the fact that the Bitcoin model offers no security at all for the process of exchanging bitcoins with any other real currency, and it offers no protection at all if somebody steals your money or cheats you.
See above about why Bitcoins have value and the issue of scamming.

If my bank goes belly-up (which isn't likely; it's a very large and stable bank, unlike the Bitcoin exchanges) the government insures all my funds through FDIC, up to the sum of $250,000. Of course, you can also split your money up into $250,000 increments and store each of them in different banks so you'll still be reimbursed even if they all go under. This system worked to save a lot of people when lots of banks failed in the recent banking crisis.
The crisis that economists say was CAUSED by the government in the first place. But that's for another thread.

My credit and debit cards also have insurance against fraud and theft. This works. I've personally used it on more than one occasion. If I were dealing in bitcoin at the time, I'd have been SOL. Thank goodness I was using real money instead!
Your credit and debit cards also ALLOW you to commit fraud and theft, through chargebacks. So let's not pretend that they reduce these things only.

Bitcoin offers zero protections in cases like that. If somebody swindles me out of my bitcoins, I can't even go to the police, because bitcoins are illegal tender. I might as well have gotten burned in a street drug deal. Imagine if the whole world economy were as volatile and insecure as the black market. That's what you get with Bitcoin. All the laws and protections of civilized modern life are stripped away, and you're left with the Law of the Jungle.
See above about scamming.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom