<snip>
So again, I ask:
1) I understand what the benefits of using Bitcoins are, but most people can get those benefits from using any number of other payment systems, and that are more convenient and less risky. This is why I see Bitcoins as serving a niche. So I guess what I am asking is "What is Bitcoin's competitive advantage?" what does it do that I can't do faster, more cheaply, or with less risk using another currency or payment system?
For a individual person:
a. A bitcoin wallet is more secure than using a credit card, because when you pay with a bitcoin wallet, you only provide the public wallet address. Unlike a cc purchase where you provide all the information necessary for a hacker or other unscrupulous person to start shopping with your cc immediately. This, of course, is negated if you use an online wallet and have an easily hackable password.
b. You can buy something securely from someone anywhere from Azerbaijon to Zambia without having to figure out how to exchange your currency into theirs or send it to them.
c. You can sell something online without having to set up and pay for some kind of online payment processing system.
d. You can send money almost instantly to family or friends anywhere in the world far less expensively that western union.
e. If you are in a country in which the stability of your home currency is questionable, you can convert your funds to bitcoin, which is a whole lot easier than attempting to convert your funds into another currency and moving that currency into a secure place.
For a business.
a. You can securely transact business less expensively than with paypal, cc processors, or other third party payment processors.
b. You can securely transact business with customers not in your country, which is difficult to do (if not impossible) with most payment or cc processing services and far more expensive.
2) How can I mitigate the inherent risks of Bitcoins? Some of this has been answered in this thread. For example there is now insurance. (But this does increase the costs of Bitcoin, which erodes its supposed competitive advantage of being lower cost - see question 1). But there are still issues - with fraud, with customer's ability to address issues, with getting your money out of the exchanges, with theft, with hard drive loss, with USD bank accounts getting flagged for money laundering, etc. etc. At this point the risks outweigh the marginal benefits of using Bitcoins even for niche operations (for me YMMV, and obviously it does for a fair amount of people).
Well, I think first step in any risk management strategy is identifying the individual risks. Then tackling each one by one. I think you will find that none of the risks you listed above are “inherent” to bitcoins. They are risks inherent to online information storage, good customer management, exchanges, data management, etc.
3) If the goal of Bitcoins is to be a currency, why do I want to hold a deflationary currency? How would you ever be able to use leverage to build capitol if the currency is deflationary? If the future value of my Bitcoins is inherently designed to be higher, why would I ever spend them?
Why would you want to hold it? Because it grows in value. Why would you want to spend it? Because there's something for sale in bitcoins that you want or need.
A
government does not want a deflationary currency because it does not encourage economic growth. Our government manipulates our economy in order to maintain a steady low rate of inflation in order to stimulate people to invest. People must invest their inflationary currency because money stuffed into a mattress or buried in the garden just loses value over time.
What's good for the economy, however, is not necessarily what's best for
people, who need to do things like save for old age. What people need are assets that appreciate in value over time.
4) When will the volatility be gone from the system? Such volatility introduces a risk to using Bitcoins. Now I can push that risk to coin exchange companies (like Overstock did), but the risk is still there. And if I push all that risk onto these external companies, they are more vulnerable to volatility spike. And what happens to my cash flow then?
That's a good reason why you should thoroughly check out whatever company you may be considering for your risk management solution, to make sure they are well funded and well run and able to withstand such a volatile market.
5) Will there ever be a way to vet a bitcoin holder, or a company providing bitcoin services? If so, who would control that service? I tend to not trust "private" vetting companies. Organizations like the BBB and the Chamber of Commerce are wholly corrupted, and provide little to no value to the customer as opposed to their member companies.
Exactly what do you mean by vet? It is possible to know the identity of a bitcoin wallet holder, as most legitimate business publicly announce it. Vanity addresses are even the latest trend. So Geico can own an address that starts with 1GEICO1. Satoshi Dice addresses all start with 1dice1, for example.