How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The important thing when considering the accumulation of stock isn't necessarily the number of shares outstanding but the size of the float (that is, the size of the pool of shares that are actively trading). Typically, the float is far smaller than the number of shares outstanding (perhaps 1% or 2% of outstanding shares trade on any given day). Obviously, given this, 5% of the outstanding shares of a company hitting the market in a single day would have drastic negative consequences for the shares' price.
 
The important thing when considering the accumulation of stock isn't necessarily the number of shares outstanding but the size of the float (that is, the size of the pool of shares that are actively trading). Typically, the float is far smaller than the number of shares outstanding (perhaps 1% or 2% of outstanding shares trade on any given day). Obviously, given this, 5% of the outstanding shares of a company hitting the market in a single day would have drastic negative consequences for the shares' price.


Interesting. Where can I go to learn more about "float". It seems to make sense, but I want to know more / make sure before I run with it.
 
Ah! I really don't have much bias in this debate, but it's harder and harder to tell it apart from beanie babies circa 1996 or whenever. It seems like bitcoins are absolutely useless as a currency, and are only good as some sort of temporary commodity investment that you better well get out of at exactly the right moment, or else your $1,000, er $450, er $1100, er, whatever investment will be imaginary cyber junk sold at a virtual yard sale.


Ok, that was way harsh. But as an outside observer, that has been the impression I've had throughout the whole conversation.

The whole point was that it was supposed to replace fiat currency. But, now, you're a dummy if yo don't realize it's just a commodity. It's like the whole arguement reversed itself. And in the end, it just seems people will indeed, realize they're trading imaginary commodities, et voila, gone.
 
I wonder if Overstock sells gift cards. It'd be a good way to get out of a large Bitcoin position. assuming you live in a state that treats gift cards the same as cash.
 
Suppose that a venture capitalist starts up an exchange with $20 million in capital. Now, suppose that our friend above sees this and decides "Well, $20 million in the hand now is better than $400 million coming in $3,000 at a time over the next 60 years." So he dumps his BTC. The market tanks, but that isn't our friend's problem; he's walked away with his $20 million.
What a silly fantasy! You have seen enough of this thread to know that bitcoin exchanges don't buy bitcoins with their own capital so I don't know why you make such a dishonest argument like this.
 
No they always figured that there was a chance at a profit. If bitcoin got used they always stood to make huge profits on their trivial investment.
Obviously anybody who downloaded the software in those earliest of days would have been dreaming of these huge profits but a number of people would have gotten involved purely for the technical novelty.

When I first heard about bitcoin back in 2010 I installed a miner on my PC just out of curiosity. Unfortunately, by then, the hashing rate was too great for my stock standard PC.
 
What I do see is (with a few exceptions) an unwillingness to discuss any potential issues that are brought up with regards to Bitcoins. This is the hallmark of a true believer. When their faith gets challenged, one tends to double down, rather than discuss rationally the issue at hand.
Actually, it is the UNbelievers who refuse to discuss the real issues. They insist on equating bitcoin with "scam", "fraud", "<nefarious scheme>" or even "doesn't exist".

You appear to know the technological aspects of it and probably know its strengths and weaknesses as well as anybody. We don't know what the future holds for bitcoin nor how bitcoin will impact the future.

Bitcoin just is.
 
No one here ever accused you of committing fraud, so nice try. What we did do is say that you need to consider that you are buying stolen goods. I'm not a lawyer, but in my understanding, if, in fact, you are really buying a $100 gift card (which in many jurisdictions the company is legally obligated to give you $100 for it) for $39 then the extreme price discrepancy is enough of an indication to the buyer that the goods were stolen.

I'm going to go so far as to say that pretty much any gift card being sold for significant discount was purchased via credit card fraud. When you buy a gift card, you have to load it up with the prerequisite funds. Some companies may give you a bonus (say, 10%), but I don't believe they do discounts.

The fact that one could buy a $96 Hulu+ subscription gift card for $12 (It may have been less, I don't feel like combing through the thread to find the exact number) seems incredibly fishy. Considering the dodgy source (forum auction offering activation codes) and all...yeah.
 
http://eprint.iacr.org/2012/584.pdf

Here you go. It's interesting reading, if a little dry. Page 6 is where they show the various transaction and wallet sizes and such.

Thank you for this. You are right. It is interesting. And dry.

And I apologize ahead of time. I realize it's probably because I've been quite busy today and just haven't had time to really study this paper. But I've read it quickly twice, and I just can't see where it says one wallet holds 500,000 coins.

Could you please point out to me where it says that?
 
<snip>
So again, I ask:

1) I understand what the benefits of using Bitcoins are, but most people can get those benefits from using any number of other payment systems, and that are more convenient and less risky. This is why I see Bitcoins as serving a niche. So I guess what I am asking is "What is Bitcoin's competitive advantage?" what does it do that I can't do faster, more cheaply, or with less risk using another currency or payment system?

For a individual person:
a. A bitcoin wallet is more secure than using a credit card, because when you pay with a bitcoin wallet, you only provide the public wallet address. Unlike a cc purchase where you provide all the information necessary for a hacker or other unscrupulous person to start shopping with your cc immediately. This, of course, is negated if you use an online wallet and have an easily hackable password.

b. You can buy something securely from someone anywhere from Azerbaijon to Zambia without having to figure out how to exchange your currency into theirs or send it to them.

c. You can sell something online without having to set up and pay for some kind of online payment processing system.

d. You can send money almost instantly to family or friends anywhere in the world far less expensively that western union.

e. If you are in a country in which the stability of your home currency is questionable, you can convert your funds to bitcoin, which is a whole lot easier than attempting to convert your funds into another currency and moving that currency into a secure place.

For a business.
a. You can securely transact business less expensively than with paypal, cc processors, or other third party payment processors.

b. You can securely transact business with customers not in your country, which is difficult to do (if not impossible) with most payment or cc processing services and far more expensive.

2) How can I mitigate the inherent risks of Bitcoins? Some of this has been answered in this thread. For example there is now insurance. (But this does increase the costs of Bitcoin, which erodes its supposed competitive advantage of being lower cost - see question 1). But there are still issues - with fraud, with customer's ability to address issues, with getting your money out of the exchanges, with theft, with hard drive loss, with USD bank accounts getting flagged for money laundering, etc. etc. At this point the risks outweigh the marginal benefits of using Bitcoins even for niche operations (for me YMMV, and obviously it does for a fair amount of people).

Well, I think first step in any risk management strategy is identifying the individual risks. Then tackling each one by one. I think you will find that none of the risks you listed above are “inherent” to bitcoins. They are risks inherent to online information storage, good customer management, exchanges, data management, etc.

3) If the goal of Bitcoins is to be a currency, why do I want to hold a deflationary currency? How would you ever be able to use leverage to build capitol if the currency is deflationary? If the future value of my Bitcoins is inherently designed to be higher, why would I ever spend them?

Why would you want to hold it? Because it grows in value. Why would you want to spend it? Because there's something for sale in bitcoins that you want or need.

A government does not want a deflationary currency because it does not encourage economic growth. Our government manipulates our economy in order to maintain a steady low rate of inflation in order to stimulate people to invest. People must invest their inflationary currency because money stuffed into a mattress or buried in the garden just loses value over time.

What's good for the economy, however, is not necessarily what's best for people, who need to do things like save for old age. What people need are assets that appreciate in value over time.

4) When will the volatility be gone from the system? Such volatility introduces a risk to using Bitcoins. Now I can push that risk to coin exchange companies (like Overstock did), but the risk is still there. And if I push all that risk onto these external companies, they are more vulnerable to volatility spike. And what happens to my cash flow then?

That's a good reason why you should thoroughly check out whatever company you may be considering for your risk management solution, to make sure they are well funded and well run and able to withstand such a volatile market.

5) Will there ever be a way to vet a bitcoin holder, or a company providing bitcoin services? If so, who would control that service? I tend to not trust "private" vetting companies. Organizations like the BBB and the Chamber of Commerce are wholly corrupted, and provide little to no value to the customer as opposed to their member companies.

Exactly what do you mean by vet? It is possible to know the identity of a bitcoin wallet holder, as most legitimate business publicly announce it. Vanity addresses are even the latest trend. So Geico can own an address that starts with 1GEICO1. Satoshi Dice addresses all start with 1dice1, for example.
 
d. You can send money almost instantly to family or friends anywhere in the world far less expensively that western union.

Instantly being defined as spending a month or so in the payout que and and less expensively of course depending on the volitility of the market then.

Paypal seems a more effective choice.
 
What a silly fantasy! You have seen enough of this thread to know that bitcoin exchanges don't buy bitcoins with their own capital so I don't know why you make such a dishonest argument like this.

Well, the other option is that they use USD incoming from investors, and use that money to pay out to other investors. I seem to remember a scheme like that, by some fellow named Fonzie or something similar.
 
Thank you for this. You are right. It is interesting. And dry.

And I apologize ahead of time. I realize it's probably because I've been quite busy today and just haven't had time to really study this paper. But I've read it quickly twice, and I just can't see where it says one wallet holds 500,000 coins.

Could you please point out to me where it says that?

In Table 7, "Entity A" is shown to have accumulated 2.8 million BTC (as of mid-2012). At the top of Page 12, the authors state that Entity A had never sent out any large transactions. The authors were able to identify the exchanges among the entities with large numbers of transactions, but Entity A was not identified with an exchange.

To be fair, it is possible that Entity A sent out transactions smaller than those studied by the authors, but we don't know this from the data given. We know from your data that there is presently no wallet with more than about 140K BTC, but we don't know how many wallets Entity A might control.

So in conclusion, while there is not now a single wallet with 500,000 BTC, there is at least one entity which has had the opportunity to accumulate control of that many (or more) BTC (obviously, across multiple wallets).

This is all very interesting, and a diversion from the usual stuff in this thread. Thank you for that.
 
Well, the other option is that they use USD incoming from investors, and use that money to pay out to other investors. I seem to remember a scheme like that, by some fellow named Fonzie or something similar.
A third option is that you could stop making up lies and tell the truth. :yikes:
 
Are you frikking kidding? Major Silicon Valley investment from venture capital firms is going into bitcoin exchanges.

1.1M is nothing.

Psion, I'm afraid that you'll have to explain what this "major Silicon Valley investment" is, as mhaze is no longer with us to explain it for himself. It certainly seems, from what he's saying here, that major Silicon Valley venture capitalists are going to be investing in bitcoin exchanges. I was never able to get him to tell me what would keep the large BTC holders from simply withdrawing the capital investment as fast as it was put in, but maybe you could take a shot at explaining that to me.

And, just as a side note, I suggest you moderate your tone. I'm not allowed to moderate posts in this thread, but I am allowed to report them.
 
Psion, I'm afraid that you'll have to explain what this "major Silicon Valley investment" is, as mhaze is no longer with us to explain it for himself.
I'm afraid I can't help you. I don't know what mhaze was referring to.

It certainly seems, from what he's saying here, that major Silicon Valley venture capitalists are going to be investing in bitcoin exchanges. I was never able to get him to tell me what would keep the large BTC holders from simply withdrawing the capital investment as fast as it was put in, but maybe you could take a shot at explaining that to me.
It has been repeatedly pointed out that bitcoin exchanges operate on the same principle as stock exchanges where bitcoins are auctioned out. The money one receives from selling bitcoins at an exchange comes from the highest bidder - not the exchange.

Post #3980 is one example. See also https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Buying_and_selling.

And, just as a side note, I suggest you moderate your tone. I'm not allowed to moderate posts in this thread, but I am allowed to report them.
Others have legitimately questioned why a bitcoin exchange couldn't pay out on a withdrawal if it was already deposited by bidders. OTOH You appear to ignore this side of the debate entirely and repeatedly make ponzi references or other made-up theories.

In order to avoid being reported, I won't make references to trolling.
 
Others have legitimately questioned why a bitcoin exchange couldn't pay out on a withdrawal if it was already deposited by bidders. OTOH You appear to ignore this side of the debate entirely and repeatedly make ponzi references or other made-up theories.

Certainly they could, if the money was already on hand; but that's not what we see. If the exchanges had the capital on hand, there wouldn't be these lengthy delays at the exchanges when trying to withdraw USD. Withdrawals would happen immediately, or at least far more quickly than they appear to in practice. From this, we can conclude that the exchanges are undercapitalized as far as USD are concerned.

And that's where the Ponzi references are coming from; if you have to wait for new people to buy before you can pay those who've already sold, that's pretty much the definition of a Ponzi scheme, is it not?
 
Certainly they could, if the money was already on hand; but that's not what we see. If the exchanges had the capital on hand, there wouldn't be these lengthy delays at the exchanges when trying to withdraw USD. Withdrawals would happen immediately, or at least far more quickly than they appear to in practice. From this, we can conclude that the exchanges are undercapitalized as far as USD are concerned.
There was more debate on this than just post #3980.

There may be other problems (especially when interacting with the banking sector) which prevents bitcoin exchanges from making timely payouts or the exchanges might just not be operating honestly. That's one of the risks of a deregulated environment.

Either way, bitcoin exchanges do not make payouts from their own capital.
 
In Table 7, "Entity A" is shown to have accumulated 2.8 million BTC (as of mid-2012). At the top of Page 12, the authors state that Entity A had never sent out any large transactions. The authors were able to identify the exchanges among the entities with large numbers of transactions, but Entity A was not identified with an exchange.

To be fair, it is possible that Entity A sent out transactions smaller than those studied by the authors, but we don't know this from the data given. We know from your data that there is presently no wallet with more than about 140K BTC, but we don't know how many wallets Entity A might control.

So in conclusion, while there is not now a single wallet with 500,000 BTC, there is at least one entity which has had the opportunity to accumulate control of that many (or more) BTC (obviously, across multiple wallets).

This is all very interesting, and a diversion from the usual stuff in this thread. Thank you for that.

Ok. Whew! Glad I wasn't just being blind :)

I agree with your conclusion that while there is now no single wallet with more than 144k Bitcoins, there are entities out there with multiple addresses that have had the opportunity to collect millions of bitcoins. Whether they actually hold that many bitcoins is unknown.

In table 7, out of the 19 entities that made the most transactions, only 3 were identified. Two exchanges and 1 mining pool. As we know there were several different exchanges in existence in 2012, and several other large mining pools, I think it is safe to say that at least some of the the 19 were probably more of the same. There were also several large gambling sites and at least one large black market site (Silk Road) in action at the time, too, so more could be explained by those, also.

It is too bad that they didn't list the addresses in question, because we could just look them up now and see how many outgoing transactions there were, and whether the owners of those addresses are now known.

I don't know if you're aware that those same authors published another paper late last year that alleged a connection between an early bitcoin account (assumed to belong to Satoshi Nakamoto) and Silk Road. They have since retracted that conclusion, when the owner of the account showed that it was in fact his Mt Gox account.

http://www.businessinsider.com/silk-road-satoshi-paper-retraction-2013-11

I am not saying that the earlier paper is therefore rubbish; I think there is a lot of very interesting information in there. I am saying, though, that this later development does bring up questions as to whether their earlier methods of connecting multiple addresses to certain entities might be similarly flawed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom