How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Xerox was set up as a business... with a product and customers. Buying shares in it was investing in the corporation, which invested that money in operations, and returned dividends to its customers.

Bitcoin is not taking in money to invest in its ongoing business. The analogy fails.

I'm only pointing out the failure of the analogy here, not commenting on whether or not it's wrong to invest in bitcoin.

Argh! I meant, "returned dividends to its investors". I assume everyone knew I meant that.
 
Xerox was set up as a business... with a product and customers. Buying shares in it was investing in the corporation, which invested that money in operations, and returned dividends to its customers.

Bitcoin is not taking in money to invest in its ongoing business. The analogy fails.
There are some differences between buying shares in a company and buying bitcoins but that doesn't necessarily mean that you can't draw an analogy between them.

The main differences are that:
1. Companies usually pay dividends to their shareholders (although you can structure your investment such that these dividends are reinvested into buying more shares in the company which increases the value of your share holdings).
2. A company can influence its own share price by the way it operates so buying shares is not necessarily a purely speculative investment.

However, the similarities are more striking.
In spite of the romantic notion that you are investing in a company, this is not true unless you buy the shares directly from the company when they are first issued. The money you pay for shares goes to the previous owner of those shares (not the company).

Ultimately, you buy shares for the same reason that you buy bitcoins; you hope to be able to make a profit out of them by trading them sometime in the future. You might be hoping to derive an income from company shares but you can also derive an income from bitcoins by selling a small portion of them at periodic intervals. As long as the increase in the value of your bitcoin holdings is greater than the what you get from the sale of some of them, the effect is similar to pocketing company dividends and not reinvesting them.
 
Last edited:
You know, it's late at night, I'm tried, and I have to say it. You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't use reason to get into. Just keep defending bitcoin man, if it makes you happy.
 
Xerox was set up as a business... with a product and customers. Buying shares in it was investing in the corporation, which invested that money in operations, and returned dividends to its customers.

Bitcoin is not taking in money to invest in its ongoing business. The analogy fails.

I'm only pointing out the failure of the analogy here, not commenting on whether or not it's wrong to invest in bitcoin.

If you are unable to see the similarities between buying stock in a young corporation so that they can pay for their own operations, and people investing their time and money (in the form of hardware) to perform the “operations” of a young bitcoin network, then I think you are in the minority. But it doesn't really matter because the active part of the analogy is the “early investors” part.

The early investors in any technology, business, stock, or project are always the ones that stand to gain the most from its success. That is the point I was trying to make.
 
Some other differences:Investing in shares in a company gives you a vote in how to run the company, who will be chairman and who will be in the board etc. The companys responsibility is to make the investors a profit. The early investors are also taking the greatest risk.

With bitcoin it seems to be the other way around. Early miners invested little to nothing, probably control the whole shebang, and the stakes keep getting higher for newcomers.
 
Some other differences:Investing in shares in a company gives you a vote in how to run the company, who will be chairman and who will be in the board etc.
That is a difference that I had not considered. However, the influence that a shareholder has in the running of a company is generally limited. If they don't like how a company is being run then the usual recourse is to sell the shares.

It goes back to the second point I made earlier: "A company can influence its own share price by the way it operates so buying shares is not necessarily a purely speculative investment".

The early investors are also taking the greatest risk.
That is not necessarily the case. Buying shares in a startup company can be one of the most profitable investments you can make - especially if the year is 1986 and the company is Microsoft.
 
Last edited:
That is a difference that I had not considered. However, the influence that a shareholder has in the running of a company is generally limited. If they don't like how a company is being run then the usual recourse is to sell the shares.

It goes back to the second point I made earlier: "A company can influence its own share price by the way it operates so buying shares is not necessarily a purely speculative investment".

That is not necessarily the case. Buying shares in a startup company can be one of the most profitable investments you can make - especially if the year is 1986 and the company is Microsoft.

He said risk not profit. Given the percent of companies that go belly up and you lose all your investment. Those profits are the reason people expose thenselves to the risk.
 
He said risk not profit. Given the percent of companies that go belly up and you lose all your investment. Those profits are the reason people expose thenselves to the risk.
At the very best, the first miners were risking nothing to get nothing in return. Nobody could have predicted that within 18 months, bitcoin might be worth something.
 
With bitcoin it seems to be the other way around. Early miners invested little to nothing, probably control the whole shebang, and the stakes keep getting higher for newcomers.

Altcoin mining, whether by cpu, gpu, fpga, or asic miner is actually quite heat intensive. Many a miner has burned up their computer or mining rack mining for something that was worth absolutelty nothing at the time.

Even now, 5 years after mining started, mining is still not some kind of "set it up and walk away and just rake in the bucks" kind of operation. If you peruse the bitcoin mining forums you will see that miners are not that easy to set up or to maintain for long periods. Ours are a bit flaky and require stops and starts and reboots regularly throughout the day or they run hotter and hotter while their hashing power just gets lower and lower. It is a good thing I work at home, and it's a good thing that it's winter, so I've got the time to futz with them all them time, or we just wouldn't be able to do it.

While you put "little to nothing" as the value of these people's time and hardware, I imagine they would differ with you quite vigorously.

Really, you are just whining, here. Steve Jobs' early partners risked little to nothing to help put computers together in his dad's garage, but the stakes 5 years later were so much higher! Warren Buffet bought out Berkshire Hathaway at $11/share in 1964, but the stakes are so much higher for investors now!

I'm pretty sure in the history of all investments, there are no successful ventures in which the price to invest in the project did not climb with the venture's success.

But I suspect actually your whole negative argument really centers on the "control the whole shebang" part. Exactly what do you think the early miners now control other than their own wallets of coins? As others have so dutifully pointed out here, bitcoin is not a company. There is no CEO, no chairman of the board, no controlling entity whatsoever.

What do you mean by “control the whole shebang”, eirik?
 
There are some differences between buying shares in a company and buying bitcoins but that doesn't necessarily mean that you can't draw an analogy between them.

You CAN draw an analogy, but I prefer analogies that are useful. In this case your analogy is less than useful, and may in fact obscure relevant details.

The main differences are that:
1. Companies usually pay dividends to their shareholders (although you can structure your investment such that these dividends are reinvested into buying more shares in the company which increases the value of your share holdings).
2. A company can influence its own share price by the way it operates so buying shares is not necessarily a purely speculative investment.

Some other - more relevant to draw a distinction IMHO.

3. A company has assets, that they publish an accounting of, and that give that company value.
4. A company has a product that (hopefully) sells. There is data on those sales that is available


However, the similarities are more striking.
In spite of the romantic notion that you are investing in a company, this is not true unless you buy the shares directly from the company when they are first issued. The money you pay for shares goes to the previous owner of those shares (not the company).

OK, you are flat out wrong about buying shares and investing in a company. The fact that you are buying the share on the secondary market does not make it any less of an investment. True, one is not raising capital, like the original purchase did, but it is still an investment, one that comes with a share of control over the company.

Ultimately, you buy shares for the same reason that you buy bitcoins; you hope to be able to make a profit out of them by trading them sometime in the future. You might be hoping to derive an income from company shares but you can also derive an income from bitcoins by selling a small portion of them at periodic intervals. As long as the increase in the value of your bitcoin holdings is greater than the what you get from the sale of some of them, the effect is similar to pocketing company dividends and not reinvesting them.

Those are not striking similarities between Bitcoins and stock purchases, as they do not narrow the analogy at all. Instead you list characteristics that are shared by many different things - from art, to hummel figurines, to coal, to comic books, to your house. I think commodity buying is a much better description of Bitcoins. Still flawed (If the market goes away, I can still make a fork with the steel I buy - NSM with a bitcoin), but it certainly is a much more descriptive and useful analogy.

Again I say, that I honestly think Bitcoin will be a niche player in the "currency" market. I reserve the right to change that opinion as things change. :D But I do not see any real path to usurping any notion currency, let alone the USD.

What I do see is (with a few exceptions) an unwillingness to discuss any potential issues that are brought up with regards to Bitcoins. This is the hallmark of a true believer. When their faith gets challenged, one tends to double down, rather than discuss rationally the issue at hand.

So again, I ask:

1) I understand what the benefits of using Bitcoins are, but most people can get those benefits from using any number of other payment systems, and that are more convenient and less risky. This is why I see Bitcoins as serving a niche. So I guess what I am asking is "What is Bitcoin's competitive advantage?" what does it do that I can't do faster, more cheaply, or with less risk using another currency or payment system?

2) How can I mitigate the inherent risks of Bitcoins? Some of this has been answered in this thread. For example there is now insurance. (But this does increase the costs of Bitcoin, which erodes its supposed competitive advantage of being lower cost - see question 1). But there are still issues - with fraud, with customer's ability to address issues, with getting your money out of the exchanges, with theft, with hard drive loss, with USD bank accounts getting flagged for money laundering, etc. etc. At this point the risks outweigh the marginal benefits of using Bitcoins even for niche operations (for me YMMV, and obviously it does for a fair amount of people).

3) If the goal of Bitcoins is to be a currency, why do I want to hold a deflationary currency? How would you ever be able to use leverage to build capitol if the currency is deflationary? If the future value of my Bitcoins is inherently designed to be higher, why would I ever spend them?

4) When will the volatility be gone from the system? Such volatility introduces a risk to using Bitcoins. Now I can push that risk to coin exchange companies (like Overstock did), but the risk is still there. And if I push all that risk onto these external companies, they are more vulnerable to volatility spike. And what happens to my cash flow then?

5) Will there ever be a way to vet a bitcoin holder, or a company providing bitcoin services? If so, who would control that service? I tend to not trust "private" vetting companies. Organizations like the BBB and the Chamber of Commerce are wholly corrupted, and provide little to no value to the customer as opposed to their member companies.
 
Last edited:
What do you mean by “control the whole shebang”, eirik?

I'm not eirik, but what I mean by "control the whole shebang" is that there appear to be a few early adopters who control enough Bitcoins to by themselves manipulate the market for their own ends. Someone posted a chart upthread showing that there is at least one BTC wallet which contains over 500,000 BTC. That person or people, whoever they are, could at any given time dump, say, 250,000 BTC on the market for whatever they could get. Of course, it's not in their financial interest to do so, as such a move would probably cut the price of BTC by 90%, but stay with me here for a minute.

Suppose that a venture capitalist starts up an exchange with $20 million in capital. Now, suppose that our friend above sees this and decides "Well, $20 million in the hand now is better than $400 million coming in $3,000 at a time over the next 60 years." So he dumps his BTC. The market tanks, but that isn't our friend's problem; he's walked away with his $20 million.

The problem is that there are likely several people or groups in the position of our friend above; holding huge paper fortunes in BTC and having no way to get the money out in any reasonable period of time. Each of them are watching the others, waiting for one to make the first move to sell out.

Not a recipe for a long-term stable market.
 
What do you mean by “control the whole shebang”, eirik?

I can't speak for erik, but just because there is no Bitcoin CEO that does not preclude a small set of people controlling an asset.

Ever heard of De Beers? They do not have (one controlling) CEO, but they do control that entire commodity. Or wield such clout as to render those with an insignificant share obsolete.

I don't know that this is happening with Bitcoins, but there is some indication that there is cartel like market manipulations occurring.
 
Yeah, you know there are some problems with your post here. First, you are asserting that I own and sell illegal products, without any factual basis whatsoever. Second, you don't know anything about me. Third, you don't know anything about the Starbucks cards of which you speak ignorantly about, their origin, etc.

Hell of a way to go, JRAT! The forum admins should be proud of you!

No one here ever accused you of committing fraud, so nice try. What we did do is say that you need to consider that you are buying stolen goods. I'm not a lawyer, but in my understanding, if, in fact, you are really buying a $100 gift card (which in many jurisdictions the company is legally obligated to give you $100 for it) for $39 then the extreme price discrepancy is enough of an indication to the buyer that the goods were stolen. Same goes for counterfeit items, or items used for laundering money. But don't take my word for it - look it up or consult a criminal lawyer to see if your state uses the resonable person test.

I mean I doubt you will ever get punished, but don't try and turn this around on the people who are pointing out that you are probably buying sketchy goods, and most courts will probably see the price difference as reasonable evidence that you knew that to be true. You may be OK with paying cash for a cheap Blu-Ray player off the back of a truck, but lets not kid ourselves that it is a legitimate transaction.

What makes it even worse is that fact that you have been told this several times, and yet you doubled down. So now there is even less cause for plausible deniability if it turns out that you were dealing with stolen, laundered, or counterfeit goods.
 
Last edited:
At the very best, the first miners were risking nothing to get nothing in return. Nobody could have predicted that within 18 months, bitcoin might be worth something.

No they always figured that there was a chance at a profit. If bitcoin got used they always stood to make huge profits on their trivial investment. And they would if they could cash out.
 
I'm not eirik, but what I mean by "control the whole shebang" is that there appear to be a few early adopters who control enough Bitcoins to by themselves manipulate the market for their own ends. Someone posted a chart upthread showing that there is at least one BTC wallet which contains over 500,000 BTC. That person or people, whoever they are, could at any given time dump, say, 250,000 BTC on the market for whatever they could get. Of course, it's not in their financial interest to do so, as such a move would probably cut the price of BTC by 90%, but stay with me here for a minute.

Suppose that a venture capitalist starts up an exchange with $20 million in capital. Now, suppose that our friend above sees this and decides "Well, $20 million in the hand now is better than $400 million coming in $3,000 at a time over the next 60 years." So he dumps his BTC. The market tanks, but that isn't our friend's problem; he's walked away with his $20 million.

The problem is that there are likely several people or groups in the position of our friend above; holding huge paper fortunes in BTC and having no way to get the money out in any reasonable period of time. Each of them are watching the others, waiting for one to make the first move to sell out.

Not a recipe for a long-term stable market.

Ok. Let's do the math.

A 500,000 coin wallet is 4% of the 12,000,000 bitcoins in circulation now. 250,000 is 2%.

I honest do not know this. Do investors in a stock worry when individual investors hold 4% of the company's stock, for fear that the investor will do something not in their own financial interest and dump all the stock at once? Is a 4% dump of one stock enough to cause irrecoverable damage to the stock price? Could you show me a real world example?
------------

But wait.. hold the phone..

A look at here: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_Ladder#Top_addresses or here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0AgdyTvSh6bUkdDc2QVlvQk9DZlhMVzBWbFBUT09CU1E&output=html says the largest wallet holds approximate 144k bitcoins.

Could you please show your evidence of bitcoin wallets holding 250-500,000 bitcoins?
 
Ok. Let's do the math.

A 500,000 coin wallet is 4% of the 12,000,000 bitcoins in circulation now. 250,000 is 2%.

I honest do not know this. Do investors in a stock worry when individual investors hold 4% of the company's stock, for fear that the investor will do something not in their own financial interest and dump all the stock at once? Is a 4% dump of one stock enough to cause irrecoverable damage to the stock price? Could you show me a real world example?
------------

But wait.. hold the phone..

A look at here: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_Ladder#Top_addresses or here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0AgdyTvSh6bUkdDc2QVlvQk9DZlhMVzBWbFBUT09CU1E&output=html says the largest wallet holds approximate 144k bitcoins.

Could you please show your evidence of bitcoin wallets holding 250-500,000 bitcoins?

There is a more robust market in stock. There does not seem to be people with $50million to buy 4% of bitcoin. Getting that much cash for say Google stock wouldn't be hard.
 
Ok. Let's do the math.

A 500,000 coin wallet is 4% of the 12,000,000 bitcoins in circulation now. 250,000 is 2%.

I honest do not know this. Do investors in a stock worry when individual investors hold 4% of the company's stock, for fear that the investor will do something not in their own financial interest and dump all the stock at once? Is a 4% dump of one stock enough to cause irrecoverable damage to the stock price? Could you show me a real world example?

Without a doubt they do. And still I think stockholders should worry even more about it - but thats a whole nother discussion.

Such dumps do affect the market adversely, and it has, in some cases, been made illegal - Insider Trading. Even when it is not illegal, it certainly is morally very sketchy, and there are many ways / reasons you might want to cover up a CEO divesting large amounts of stocks. While not a specific instance, here are 1400 examples of such market manipulating shenanigans.

But again, you are using the the wrong analogy, and its leading you to the wrong places. Buying stock gives you partial ownership in an ongoing entity that has (potential) future earnings AND assets that can be accounted for, and liquidated for some value. Buying Bitcoins gets you total ownership of a specific quantity of a thing. A very abstract thing in this case, although that doesn't necessarily mean its bad. (See buying a patent, or movie-rights, etc.)

The better analogy is commodity trading or perhaps of less value currency trading. What OPEC decides to produce has a huge effect on oil prices. When a gov't makes a large move on their currency in the fiat world there are often very drastic consequences for their currency's standing and potentially their domestic economy. Look at the De Beers example I mentioned earlier, or OPEC. Look at the Sherman Antitrust Act.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom