How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think bitcoin, if it has a future, is as a competitor to on line payment services like PayPal. I think the idea of it being a currency that is beyond government contorl is as dead as a doornail.
 
In states where marijuana is legal, all transactions are done in cash since federal regulation prevent Visa and MasterCard to process payment for such transactions. I wonder if bitcoin can fill that need

On the other hand, accepting Bitcoins seems to have made it easier for the feds to shut down Silk Road.
 
Interesting article in Wired asks the question: Who Owns the World's Biggest Bitcoin Wallet?

link

In September, the FBI shut down the Silk Road online drug marketplace, and it started seizing bitcoins belonging to the Dread Pirate Roberts — the operator of the illicit online marketplace, who they say is an American man named Ross Ulbricht.

The seizure sparked an ongoing public discussion about the future of Bitcoin, the world’s most popular digital currency, but it had an unforeseen side-effect: It made the FBI the holder of the world’s biggest Bitcoin wallet.
 
Yes, the VPL is clearly a clone of Bitcoin. I'd assume that Chase would take their cut upfront, perhaps 1% of deposits under $1,000 and a sliding scale from there. Since BTC is open source the tech is already out there; they'd just have to adapt it to their system.

I'm sure VPL deposits would be adequately secure against hacking, and no doubt there would be safeguards built in for Chase as well to protect them against accusations of facilitating money-laundering and such. I suppose the real question is demand; is there enough to justify the initial infrastructure build? I'm sure Chase has an eye on the ongoing BTC saga...


I would not assume that just because it's JPMorgan/Chase it will be secure, adequate, or even entirely legal.

Chase to pay $389 million over illegal identity theft monitoring on credit cards:
http://www.oregonlive.com/finance/index.ssf/2013/09/chase_to_pay_329_million_over.html

JPMorgan Pays $920 Million to Settle London Whale Probes:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...to-pay-920-million-for-london-whale-loss.html

JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s *record $13 billion deal to end U.S. probes of its mortgage-bond sales*
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-10-19/jpmorgan-said-to-have-reached-13-billion-u-s-accord.html

JPMorgan Chase will pay $2.6 billion to settle federal charges..
*http://www.toledoblade.com/Editorials/2014/01/12/JPMorgan-s-penalty.html#X61y6BR9EzOtbIy2.99

JPMorgan warns 465,000 card users on data loss after cyber attack:
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/05/us-jpmorgan-dataexposed-idUSBRE9B405R20131205

Security Flaw Could Expose Credit Card Data from BofA or Chase:
http://www.nbcnews.com/id/44231957/ns/business-consumer_news/#.UtbUb_RDvRA

.. know what I mean? :)
 
I would not assume that just because it's JPMorgan/Chase it will be secure, adequate, or even entirely legal.

Chase to pay $389 million over illegal identity theft monitoring on credit cards:
http://www.oregonlive.com/finance/index.ssf/2013/09/chase_to_pay_329_million_over.html

JPMorgan Pays $920 Million to Settle London Whale Probes:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...to-pay-920-million-for-london-whale-loss.html

JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s *record $13 billion deal to end U.S. probes of its mortgage-bond sales*
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-10-19/jpmorgan-said-to-have-reached-13-billion-u-s-accord.html

JPMorgan Chase will pay $2.6 billion to settle federal charges..
*http://www.toledoblade.com/Editorials/2014/01/12/JPMorgan-s-penalty.html#X61y6BR9EzOtbIy2.99

JPMorgan warns 465,000 card users on data loss after cyber attack:
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/05/us-jpmorgan-dataexposed-idUSBRE9B405R20131205

Security Flaw Could Expose Credit Card Data from BofA or Chase:
http://www.nbcnews.com/id/44231957/ns/business-consumer_news/#.UtbUb_RDvRA

.. know what I mean? :)

Well, to be fair, similar points could be made about BTC, with the added problem that BTC users don't have the feds to protect them from loss via hackers.

I thought the Wired article was interesting; it more or less confirms what we had speculated above, that the largest holders of BTC for the most part use multiple wallets. I was surprised that Satoshi apparently has no more than 50 BTC in most of his wallets. It also makes me wonder what would happen if the FBI decided to sell their BTC to get restitution from the Silk Road guy.
 
On the other hand, accepting Bitcoins seems to have made it easier for the feds to shut down Silk Road.
I always thought that seeking out a hit man was Ross Ulbricht's undoing.

Have you got any information on the actual role bitcoin played in the shutting down of Silk Road?
 
Just read this article from last week discussing Zynga's move to accept bitcoins for payment.

http://seekingalpha.com/article/192...tcoin-and-savings-may-be-material-to-earnings

Proforma Analysis Of Financial Effect From Bitcoin Acceptance

In 2012, Zynga had $1.2B of gross revenue. We do not know what percentage of revenue will have the Bitcoin payment method as an option so we will just assume all of it. The credit card or PayPal fee for a $5 sale would be about $0.445 or 8.9%. Assuming Zynga has the same payment method breakdown as Reddit then we can expect this effect.

Approximately $30m of annual revenue being processed by credit cards or PayPal would cost about $2.7m. Bitpay will process this amount for a flat fee of $300/month or $3,600 per year which is a cost savings of approximately 99.87%. Not bad for a few hours of a developer who is likely already on salary!

I hadn't really realized before how much more retailers that deal in primarily small transactions have to save by adopting bitcoin. Music, games, monthly subscriptions, etc. There are a lot of them.
 
Now they just have to convince Johnny Consumer that bitcoin is in his interest, otherwise the savings won't be that high.

Interesting as the theoretical aspect of the technology is, my personal feeling, and I suspect I'm not alone in this, is that as an end user the extra security granted me by using financial institutions far outweighs a few percentage points of profit for the businesses.
 
I always thought that seeking out a hit man was Ross Ulbricht's undoing.

Have you got any information on the actual role bitcoin played in the shutting down of Silk Road?

https://www.rossulbricht.org/wp-con...cht-Silk-Road-New-York-Criminal-Complaint.pdf

Describes how the undercover agent was able to track the flow of funds through the site, as well as movement in and out of specific user accounts, using the Bitcoin transaction histories. Very interesting reading.
 
https://www.rossulbricht.org/wp-con...cht-Silk-Road-New-York-Criminal-Complaint.pdf

Describes how the undercover agent was able to track the flow of funds through the site, as well as movement in and out of specific user accounts, using the Bitcoin the Silk Road website forum and transaction histories. Very interesting reading.
ftfy.

In the link that you provided, Chris Tarbell details how he got a Silk Road account and examined the forum and messaging histories on that site. He also found posts on a "shroomery" website as well as a bitcoin forum which he interpreted as advertisements for Silk Road.

The Silk Road web site even had an accounts section which detailed payments to Ross Ulbricht and associates. This web site alone provided the "probable cause" for the complaint.

As for the role that bitcoin played in tracking down Ulbricht, Tarbell notes:
"However, the blockchain only reflects the movement of funds between anonymous Bitcoin addresses and therefore cannot by itself be used to determine the identities of the persons involved in the transactions. Only if one knows the identities associated with each Bitcoin address involved in a set of transactions is it possibile to meaningfully trace funds through the system".​

Tarbell further notes that Silk Road used a "tumbler" to scramble bitcoin transactions making the block chain even more useless as a tracking tool:
" ........In other words, if a buyer makes a payment on Silk Road, the tumbler obscures any link between the buyer's Bitcoin address and the vendor's Bitcoin address where the Bitcoins end up - making it fruitless to use the Blockchain to follow the money trail involved in the transaction, even if the buyer's and vendor's Bitcoin address are both known".​
So, while bitcoin didn't stop the closure of Silk Road and the arrest of Ross Ulbricht, it was of no assistance in the investigations by the FBI either.
 
Last edited:
ftfy.

In the link that you provided, Chris Tarbell details how he got a Silk Road account and examined the forum and messaging histories on that site. He also found posts on a "shroomery" website as well as a bitcoin forum which he interpreted as advertisements for Silk Road.

The Silk Road web site even had an accounts section which detailed payments to Ross Ulbricht and associates. This web site alone provided the "probable cause" for the complaint.

As for the role that bitcoin played in tracking down Ulbricht, Tarbell notes:
"However, the blockchain only reflects the movement of funds between anonymous Bitcoin addresses and therefore cannot by itself be used to determine the identities of the persons involved in the transactions. Only if one knows the identities associated with each Bitcoin address involved in a set of transactions is it possibile to meaningfully trace funds through the system".​

Yes, and Tarbell did in fact identify Bitcoin deposits made to the accounts of Ulbricht and two administrators, as detailed in the complaint.

Tarbell further notes that Silk Road used a "tumbler" to scramble bitcoin transactions making the block chain even more useless as a tracking tool:
" ........In other words, if a buyer makes a payment on Silk Road, the tumbler obscures any link between the buyer's Bitcoin address and the vendor's Bitcoin address where the Bitcoins end up - making it fruitless to use the Blockchain to follow the money trail involved in the transaction, even if the buyer's and vendor's Bitcoin address are both known".​
So, while bitcoin didn't stop the closure of Silk Road and the arrest of Ross Ulbricht, it was of no assistance in the investigations by the FBI either.

The complaint also notes, "The only function served by such 'tumblers' is to assist with the laundering of criminal proceeds." So, red flag to the feds there.

My point is that by relying on Bitcoin as the sole payment method, Ulbricht was able to conduct a high volume of illegal business, attracting the attention of the authorities, who built a case against him for years. Ulbricht seems to have believed he was safely hidden behind the cryptographic features of the Bitcoin/Tor system. Maybe this overconfidence and hubris led to his downfall.

I agree with you that hiring hit men was not a good move on Ulbricht's part.
 
Now they just have to convince Johnny Consumer that bitcoin is in his interest, otherwise the savings won't be that high.

Well, this is the company that convinced millions of people not only that playing a farming game would be fun, but that every time they so much as fed their pigs or watered their corn it deserved its own facebook update.

I have no doubt that they could likewise convince people to start paying for their virtual farms with virtual money.

Interesting as the theoretical aspect of the technology is, my personal feeling, and I suspect I'm not alone in this, is that as an end user the extra security granted me by using financial institutions far outweighs a few percentage points of profit for the businesses.

My personal feeling is that once people understand the superior security of a digital wallet, they will wonder how they ever thought that giving their credit card, debit card or bank account number over the internet was ever safe at all.
 
My personal feeling is that once people understand the superior security of a digital wallet, they will wonder how they ever thought that giving their credit card, debit card or bank account number over the internet was ever safe at all.

And once the VPL is rolled out, people will wonder why they ever needed Bitcoin. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom