How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have no dog in this fight but would anyone hazard any thoughts on what effect this might have given that China plays such a big part in all of this
Meh, more uncertainty but probably not the end.

The point isn't whose cash is being stolen; the point is that these exchanges, which are supposed to be trusted and trustworthy intermediaries, are anything but, given the number of thefts that occur. The fact that it might be drug dealers and CP purveyors getting their BTC stolen is secondary to the concept that the operators of any given exchange might pack up at any given time and leave their depositors holding the virtual bag.
I'm curious how you'd turn 44k of stolen Bitcoin into something actually useful, real money or goods.

Secondly, you again missed the point; Bitcoin has a long and sorry history of exchanges being set up to dupe legitimate would-be users, not just the drug and CP industry. I feel no sympathy for the drug dealers; caveat emptor and all that. But I do feel sympathy for people who invested in things like Sheep Marketplace, which was supposed to be on the up-and-up, and then the owner absconded with something like $40 million in BTC. I think BTC is a wildly speculative investment, and anyone who would invest in it is a fool; but even fools don't deserve to be ripped off.
Indeed. I suspect the VC interest is purely of the "it's a one-in-a-million chance to become the next internet cashcow" type.

Here's good news: you can now insure your Bitcoins against loss or theft!
Can you pay for the insurance in BC?

As I said in my previous post, the idea is good; this incarnation of the implementation is not something that will ultimately succeed, but a better iteration is likely on the horizon.
Many a tech startup has had a good idea and then utterly failed to implement it, BC might be one.
 
Last edited:
Catsmate1 asked "Can you pay for the insurance in BC?"

Yes.

The fee amount is variable, depending on how much “cover” someone might want, or how much they want each bitcoin to be insured for if the exchange rate reaches that level. For example, at £1,000 per bitcoin, Elliptic bills its users in bitcoins at two percent annually. So, insuring 50 bitcoins at that level could cost 0.169 bitcoins monthly.

Link.
 
Meg, I can see those as valid defenses for crypto-currency in general, but from what I know and have read of bitcoin, there's no mechanism built in to avoid widespread adoption (i.e. higher demand) from continually driving the price up.
 
Meg, I can see those as valid defenses for crypto-currency in general, but from what I know and have read of bitcoin, there's no mechanism built in to avoid widespread adoption (i.e. higher demand) from continually driving the price up.

Well, you're right in that there is no central governing organization capable of manipulating the value of the currency. Some people find that an attractive feature, though.

The market itself is what will stop a climb that goes on too long. Obviously, nothing can continually go up.

If the price of bitcoins continues to rapidly climb, many people would quit using them and just hang onto them, because why sell today if you're sure the price will be higher tomorrow? And if people quit using them, the value would start to go down.
 
If the price of bitcoins continues to rapidly climb, many people would quit using them and just hang onto them, because why sell today if you're sure the price will be higher tomorrow? And if people quit using them, the value would start to go down.

Wow, that's deep. :rolleyes:
 
But isn't that the case with all new technologies or investments? That the early adopters/investors have the potential to reap the highest rewards? My uncle invested in Xerox in the 1960s and made quite a bundle. I really don't see much difference. The early adopters also took the most risk, dedicating their own computers and network time and personal time to work the bugs out of the system and to create coins that might have turned out to be completely worthless.

Xerox was set up as a business... with a product and customers. Buying shares in it was investing in the corporation, which invested that money in operations, and returned dividends to its customers.

Bitcoin is not taking in money to invest in its ongoing business. The analogy fails.

I'm only pointing out the failure of the analogy here, not commenting on whether or not it's wrong to invest in bitcoin.
 
Well, you're right in that there is no central governing organization capable of manipulating the value of the currency. Some people find that an attractive feature, though.
Yeah, nutters.

Well, that's the whole GRAND EXPERIMENT that is bitcoin, innit?

Create a system of trade no government can manipulate, let it loose in the world and watch what happens.

It is the free market in action.

Now I am not a libertarian by any means, but I still find this a fascinating experiment. It's about as pure a test of the “free market” as one could create.
 
Well, that's the whole GRAND EXPERIMENT that is bitcoin, innit?

Create a system of trade no government can manipulate, let it loose in the world and watch what happens.

It is the free market in action.

Now I am not a libertarian by any means, but I still find this a fascinating experiment. It's about as pure a test of the “free market” as one could create.

One problem, however, is that governments have manipulated it. Governments have effectively banned it (such as China) and others make it extremely difficult to transfer funds back and forth between BTC and anything else.

That said, it is an interesting experiment in the "free market" without any kind of regulation.
 
One problem, however, is that governments have manipulated it. Governments have effectively banned it (such as China) and others make it extremely difficult to transfer funds back and forth between BTC and anything else.

Not exactly.

What the Chinese government proclaimed was that Chinese banks could not do business in bitcoin. Which makes perfect sense, in my opinion. The Chinese government licenses Chinese banks to hold, lend, transact business, and otherwise protect Chinese currency. Those banks that were transacting business in bitcoin were, in the government's opinion, opening up the bank and it's depositors and shareholders to a risk that the government was unwilling to insure. And why should they?

Likewise, afaik the FDIC will not allow American banks to start trading in bitcoins, either.

This does not mean that bitcoins are banned in China. Chinese people and other Chinese corporations can trade in bitcoin all they want. They just can't expect assistance from the government banking system to do so. While they used to be able to buy or sell bitcoins at some banks, now they have to go through an intermediary, just like Americans do.


http://www.zdnet.com/cn/china-forbids-banks-to-transact-in-bitcoin-7000023967/
 
Last edited:
Not exactly.

What the Chinese government proclaimed was that Chinese banks could not do business in bitcoin. Which makes perfect sense, in my opinion. The Chinese government licenses Chinese banks to hold, lend, transact business, and otherwise protect Chinese currency. Those banks that were transacting business in bitcoin were, in the government's opinion, opening up the bank and it's depositors and shareholders to a risk that the government was unwilling to insure. And why should they?

Likewise, afaik the FDIC will not allow American banks to start trading in bitcoins, either.

This does not mean that bitcoins are banned in China. Chinese people and other Chinese corporations can trade in bitcoin all they want. They just can't expect assistance from the government banking system to do so. While they used to be able to buy or sell bitcoins at some banks, now they have to go through an intermediary, just like Americans do.


http://www.zdnet.com/cn/china-forbids-banks-to-transact-in-bitcoin-7000023967/

Hmm. That's a great clarification, actually. Thanks for letting me know about that!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom