OK. I normally don't do the line by line quote thing. I don't think it is (generally) good for a discussion. I did it here though because of the bullet point nature of your discussion, so please forgive the structure.
In a general sense, I feel like I need to clarify something. I spoke earlier of competitive advantage. This is a very specific term, but what it boils down to is this: When a potential customer asks "Why do I buy your product over your competitor's" what answer do we have that is compelling enough to convince them to actually buy your product.
If you do not have a compelling answer to this question, then there is little hoe that you will survive in the marketplace. If you have an answer that s compelling to a subset of potential users,then you are competing a niche market. This is where Bitcoins is operating now. My opinion of course, but I have evidence to that. While there is NOTHING wrong with being a niche player, it does mean that you are not a game changer.
I also want to add that for me "We are not PayPal" is probably enough of a competitive advantage.
For a individual person:
a. A bitcoin wallet is more secure than using a credit card, because when you pay with a bitcoin wallet, you only provide the public wallet address. Unlike a cc purchase where you provide all the information necessary for a hacker or other unscrupulous person to start shopping with your cc immediately. This, of course, is negated if you use an online wallet and have an easily hackable password.
Conversely, if my BTC wallet is compromised, that money is gone. Not true for a fraudulent CC purchase. I can get that money back. If I lose my CC it is not the end of the world; unlike if I lose my wallet. There is a hassle factor with sorting out fraudulent CC purchases, but its not too onerous. I can certainly envision the same scams to get CC # being used to get private wallet keys. Also, we have seen that a lack of a trail / 3rd part approval can be exploited. This is probably a wash - both have benefits, both have drawbacks. In either world, bad security practices are bad security practices, and neither has found a way to defeat social engineering.
http://onbitcoin.com/2013/10/25/bitcoin-cloud-wallets-comparison-security-and-liquidity/
b. You can buy something securely from someone anywhere from Azerbaijon to Zambia without having to figure out how to exchange your currency into theirs or send it to them.
OK - BUT Bitcoins require 2 steps: my local currency to BTC; BTC to their local currency. In almost every case where I want to buy something overseas, I give them my CC # and I am done. Even when buying from small vendors or individuals, payment can be handled through paypal or Amazon. I do not see this as an advantage of BTC at all. It does show that BTC meets the requirements of being a workable 3rd party payment system. But I have many options here.
Can you show me some examples of international sales that could not be done via PayPal, Amazon, or CC?
Can you estimate from those examples what is the size of the market of purchases that can only be done via BTC?
c. You can sell something online without having to set up and pay for some kind of online payment processing system.
Isn't using Bitcoins setting up some kind of online payment processing system? Especially for large businesses. Have we not established that they use Coinbase (or something similar)? And for individuals, you have to set up a wallet and deal with an exchange. From what I can see it is not quite the same hassle, but it may be more of a hassle, at least for individuals - I can't speak to businesses.
d. You can send money almost instantly to family or friends anywhere in the world far less expensively that western union.
Again, I do this about every month (on average) without fees via paypal and increasingly more via Amazon. So its not a competitive advantage for BTC, it is just them meeting the minimum requirements of the market.
e. If you are in a country in which the stability of your home currency is questionable, you can convert your funds to bitcoin, which is a whole lot easier than attempting to convert your funds into another currency and moving that currency into a secure place.
OK - now this may be an advantage. If the currency is more volatile than BTC
then you have a problem. But if BTC settles down, I can see where this might be a good thing. I do think the highlighted section is unsubstantiated however. I will wager getting BTC back into Litas in time to pay the rent may be a nail-biting experience, given how hard it is to get it into USD for individuals. Still rainy day money in BTC may be a good thing. Its still a niche market.
For a business.
a. You can securely transact business less expensively than with paypal, cc processors, or other third party payment processors.
Can you? I really can not find any hard info on things like who eats the float (the consumer, I think)? or if the consumer pays extra fees / or is charged a liquidity discount. It is hard to tell, but I think there is some of this going on. Pushing fees from the business to the consumer is not a good business model. But it is likely the bitcoin processors will take some heat.
b. You can securely transact business with customers not in your country, which is difficult to do (if not impossible) with most payment or cc processing services and far more expensive.
Again, I do not think international payments are that much of a hassle, and not much is gained by using bitcoins. Still, on the whole it looks like there is more upside to retailers than there are drawbacks. So long as it gets immediately converted to USD, I probably would go for that.
Well, I think first step in any risk management strategy is identifying the individual risks. Then tackling each one by one. I think you will find that none of the risks you listed above are “inherent” to bitcoins. They are risks inherent to online information storage, good customer management, exchanges, data management, etc.
Yeah - I disagree with your definition of inherent here. You can shuffle the blame for the risks to whatever subsystem you want. But if BTC uses that subsystem, then its a risk of BTC. It may not be fair that Mt. Gox's ****-ups reflect on BTC, but if I can't get my money with Mt. Gox or without M. Gox, then I have a problem with using BTC. Thats just how it is.
Why would you want to hold it? Because it grows in value. Why would you want to spend it? Because there's something for sale in bitcoins that you want or need.
The highlighted part is wrong, in that it is not nearly enough reason to spend Bitcoins (unless it is only available for sale as Bitcoins). Again, if I am given a spread of options you have to give me an incentive to not use my credit card. It is not trivial to set up a BTC wallet and get money into it. If you don't give people the incentive to clear that hump, you will have trouble growing your market.
A government does not want a deflationary currency because it does not encourage economic growth. Our government manipulates our economy in order to maintain a steady low rate of inflation in order to stimulate people to invest. People must invest their inflationary currency because money stuffed into a mattress or buried in the garden just loses value over time.
That is just one side of the picture. One that is very relevant right now in the recession, but not applicable to all situations. In fact, the current recession was made worse by too much focus on spending and not enough on saving.
What's good for the economy, however, is not necessarily what's best for people, who need to do things like save for old age. What people need are assets that appreciate in value over time.
This is the fallacy of composition. What is good for one is not always good for many.
That's a good reason why you should thoroughly check out whatever company you may be considering for your risk management solution, to make sure they are well funded and well run and able to withstand such a volatile market.
So there are many kinds of risks. Some can be mitigated through diversification. Something like a shallow cartel of service providers can not. Nor can you mitigate a risk if it is endemic to an industry.
Exactly what do you mean by vet? It is possible to know the identity of a bitcoin wallet holder, as most legitimate business publicly announce it. Vanity addresses are even the latest trend. So Geico can own an address that starts with 1GEICO1. Satoshi Dice addresses all start with 1dice1, for example.
Branding tells me nothing about a company's stability, liquidity, leverage percentage, financial health, or a whole host of other things I might want to know before I get into bed with them. I can ask for that info, but there is no guarantee it will be useful or true. Traditionally when done privately we end up with things like S&P rating agency, which was more corrupt and dispensed useless or misleading info. Basically there is an imbalance of information out there. Which means unmanageable risks for companies entering this market.