How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
"Lack of cash" and "cash flow problem" are two different things. Neither conclusion can be drawn simply from a mathematical formula.

I don't see why not. If they could process requests faster by adding processors as a temporary measure, then why not do it? It's good for customer service and most businesses do just this during times of peak demand. Seems to me that the only other explanation is that they don't have the cash to give. Can you think of another one?
 
W is the time in the store, L is the number of people in the store. It's clear that the increase in W and L is due to the store not being able to process the number of requests.

Agreed.

That would be most likely due to a lack of cash and not a lack of processors, the latter are easy to add in order to meet higher arrival rates but cash is another matter. So MtGox's delays obviously stem from a cash flow problem and not any inability to process withdrawal requests.

This is simply speculation, and moreover, a false dichotomy. As mentioned, it could be cashflow problem due to banks/government regulations, or reason X, Y z.
 
This is simply speculation, and moreover, a false dichotomy. As mentioned, it could be cashflow problem due to banks/government regulations, or reason X, Y z.

What is a cashflow problem other than not having the cash to pay out? The other issues of govt regulations were present prior to the problems being experienced due to bitcoin prices skyrocketing.
 
What is a cashflow problem other than not having the cash to pay out?

Umm, being restricted by certain banks on how much cash you can move around? The delays were mostly specific to USD withdrawals to North-America. Didn't seem to be lack of cash, but some imposed regulations. Even if that's not true, you're using classical argument from incredulity - you can't imagine other alternatives, so your speculation must be true.

The other issues of govt regulations were present prior to the problems being experienced due to bitcoin prices skyrocketing.

Bitcoin prices skyrocketed as more people bought into the market - cashflow increased in magnitudes, and hit some legislative restrictions. I can speculate all kinds of scenarios. You, for some reason, are just interested in selling the 'no cash' scenario. I would really like to know if MTGox is running on money it doesn't have, but mere speculation doesn't convince me.
 
More intriguing than delays on MTGox is this news:

WARNING: GHASH.IO IS NEARING 51% – LEAVE THE POOL

Apparently a mining pool is nearing a mining hashrate percentage that would give them an advantage to manipulate bitcoin transaction, including choosing which ones get confirmed and which ones don't.

The 51% Attack

You know, I get where they're (ghash.io) coming from with the press release that effectively says "What, you think we're gonna pee in our own pool?"

Except that they only have to pee in the pool once and get out of the pool (with their gains) before anyone notices. I'd be disinclined to trust anything they themselves say.

The underlying problems surrounding requiring miners to confirm all blockchain transactions is sort of interesting, too, but I need to read more on the details of that design before I throw any opinions out on that.
 
What is a cashflow problem other than not having the cash to pay out? The other issues of govt regulations were present prior to the problems being experienced due to bitcoin prices skyrocketing.
If the demand for cash withdrawals increases (eg as a result of a bad news event) then even if the bitcoin exchange has the necessary cash, it could hit a glass ceiling imposed by the banks or government causing the withdrawal queue to bank up.

It's only speculation here but if MtGox customers are having unreasonable delays in withdrawing their cash then some may do the opposite; buy as many bitcoins as they can and withdraw the bitcoins instead (no limits there). This would account for the higher bitcoin price at MtGox compared with the others.
 
(...snip...)

It's only speculation here but if MtGox customers are having unreasonable delays in withdrawing their cash then some may do the opposite; buy as many bitcoins as they can and withdraw the bitcoins instead (no limits there). This would account for the higher bitcoin price at MtGox compared with the others.

Perhaps I misinterpreted the MtGox wiki, but it appears that there are limits on BTC withdrawals too:

MtGox imposes a $1,000 USD limit for withdrawals per 24 hours and a $10,000 USD limit for withdrawals per month with most non-verified accounts. Bitcoins withdrawn are counted toward this limit as well and the USD value is calculated at the market rate at the time of the attempted withdrawal.
...

Any account-to-account transfers made also count toward this limit as well.

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Withdrawing_Funds

ETA:

That applies to unverified customers only. Verified and Trusted customers have far higher limits.
 
Last edited:
Umm, being restricted by certain banks on how much cash you can move around? The delays were mostly specific to USD withdrawals to North-America. Didn't seem to be lack of cash, but some imposed regulations. Even if that's not true, you're using classical argument from incredulity - you can't imagine other alternatives, so your speculation must be true.
Can you be specific? Otherwise that is pretty weak speculation.


Bitcoin prices skyrocketed as more people bought into the market - cashflow increased in magnitudes, and hit some legislative restrictions. I can speculate all kinds of scenarios. You, for some reason, are just interested in selling the 'no cash' scenario. I would really like to know if MTGox is running on money it doesn't have, but mere speculation doesn't convince me.

Can you be specific about those legislative restrictions?

The no cash thing is the most likely issue since we can see that they haven't had as many problems in other currencies.
 
You know, I get where they're (ghash.io) coming from with the press release that effectively says "What, you think we're gonna pee in our own pool?"

Except that they only have to pee in the pool once and get out of the pool (with their gains) before anyone notices. I'd be disinclined to trust anything they themselves say.

The underlying problems surrounding requiring miners to confirm all blockchain transactions is sort of interesting, too, but I need to read more on the details of that design before I throw any opinions out on that.

I really don't understand your "pee in the pool" analogy. Perhaps because ghash.io actually IS a pool.

Regarding your comment that they could actually perform a 51% attack and then just "get out of the pool" (whatever that means) before anyone notices, well that would be impossible. As the miner ids are logged with each transaction confirmation, (which is how you can get up to the minute charts showing hashing power of the various pools), it would be possible to see exactly what they did. Whether it could be reversed.. I assume it could, but I really don't know that for sure.

Pulling such a stunt would ruin ghash.io's reputation. And likely ruin their business.

But it appears that the warnings are already working. GHash is already down to 40%. https://blockchain.info/pools?timespan=24hrs
 
Funny, I'd think that if people were getting their money out of Mt. Gox you'd be the first to wave it in our faces.

I think it's an entirely reasonable question; what are the current processing times and withdrawal limits at Mt. Gox? I suspect that your response above is an indication that a factual answer would not be helpful to your cause.

ETA: Here's some interesting reading from the Bitcoin forum:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.2720
Fascinating. It seems the scheme is in the later stage and unable to pay all claims.

Nobody seems to know; according to the links above somewhere between one and infinity.
Well a few days to weeks for small amounts and at least a few months for larger.
Damn I dumped gold in a couple of hours. :rolleyes:

Perhaps I misinterpreted the MtGox wiki, but it appears that there are limits on BTC withdrawals too:



https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Withdrawing_Funds

ETA:

That applies to unverified customers only. Verified and Trusted customers have far higher limits.
Ah but do they actually get paid?
 
I really don't understand your "pee in the pool" analogy. Perhaps because ghash.io actually IS a pool.

Yeah, there may be some word confusion there. Think swimming pool.

My point was that ghash.io is currently making plenty of money both from being a legitimate bitcoin mining operation _and_ from having bitcoins themselves. To perform a 51% attack would sacrifice their operation and possibly any long-term value of bitcoins they hold -- so it wouldn't seem to be in their best interest from many fronts, hence I'm not surprised at their press release.

Regarding your comment that they could actually perform a 51% attack and then just "get out of the pool" (whatever that means) before anyone notices, well that would be impossible. As the miner ids are logged with each transaction confirmation, (which is how you can get up to the minute charts showing hashing power of the various pools), it would be possible to see exactly what they did. Whether it could be reversed.. I assume it could, but I really don't know that for sure.
For impossible -- well, I prefer not to say things like that when using brand-new technology. If it actually _were_ possible, simply knowing that it wasn't impossible would be worth a significant amount all on its own. Beyond that, just seeing what they did isn't necessarily going to help you if it's already been done and they've found a way to launder the BTC. People are very clever, I find, so just because I don't see a way to launder the BTC from such an action doesn't mean there isn't one.

For reversed -- one of the major disadvantages of Bitcoin is that once your coins are transferred, they're gone and there isn't a way to force a reversal.

Pulling such a stunt would ruin ghash.io's reputation. And likely ruin their business.
Sheep Market's reputation and business is ruined, too, but that guy is running around with ~90k BTC right now, I believe? If the rewards for crime are high enough...
 
Ah but do they actually get paid?

I've no idea. It's clear that there are people who have become very frustrated with the length of time it takes to get USD out of MtGox - it seems to vary from days to months - but I've not seen the same level of complaints relating to other currencies (after a rather brief investigation). I have to say that on balance, I'd probably avoid that particular exchange if I were trading BTC.
 
Looks like Overstock.com is actually taking bitcoins now. I just bought a nice set of sheets for bitcents :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom