How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.

You guys didn't KNOW about that stuff? But you acted like you knew so much.

What I don't get is how you can demonize an entire industry based on a song and dance about Mt Gox, which stems from a couple issues they had with the US bank they were doing Dwolla with.

If I had bitcoins in Mt Gox and I wanted to cash them, and Mt Gox had a temporary slowdown due to the Dwolla issue.... I'd just move the bitcoins to another exchange and cash them. Since Mt Gox is Japanese, one would just move them to the USA and do it. Why try to get US dollars from a Japanese bank?

I don't get the logic here. It takes one hit of the enter key to move bitcoin out of MtGox.
 
Last edited:
Thats a lie. What happens is you dismiss the outrageous and misleading statements through a fiat declaration (and no evidence) as totally being plausible. People don't care enough to argue with you over nit picking. But I'd wager given the PMs I get from this thread, that MOST people reading this thread see these claims that Bitcoins will be worth $50k or up for what they are.
I have no idea what you are on about here.

Possibly you are conflating a number of issues raised by other posters but in no way are you addressing the lack of evidence that bitcoin prices are being bolstered by false information.
 
That site points out that MtGox lost $5M when its Dwolla account was seized and has another $5M held by Coinlab which is not only refusing to hand it back but is suing MtGox for $70M.

How much this is affecting its ability to service its American customers is difficult to say but it is a long way from proving that MtGox acts as a ponzi scheme.
 
That site points out that MtGox lost $5M when its Dwolla account was seized and has another $5M held by Coinlab which is not only refusing to hand it back but is suing MtGox for $70M.

How much this is affecting its ability to service its American customers is difficult to say but it is a long way from proving that MtGox acts as a ponzi scheme.

It sure makes them look incompetent, at any rate.
 
You guys didn't KNOW about that stuff? But you acted like you knew so much.

What I don't get is how you can demonize an entire industry based on a song and dance about Mt Gox, which stems from a couple issues they had with the US bank they were doing Dwolla with.

If I had bitcoins in Mt Gox and I wanted to cash them, and Mt Gox had a temporary slowdown due to the Dwolla issue.... I'd just move the bitcoins to another exchange and cash them. Since Mt Gox is Japanese, one would just move them to the USA and do it. Why try to get US dollars from a Japanese bank?

I don't get the logic here. It takes one hit of the enter key to move bitcoin out of MtGox.


And how many hits of the enter key does it take to move those Bitcoins out of the other exchange and get them in USD in your regular bank account so that you can actually spend them?
 

That's an excellent question, should be directed at wrs, since it's his claim. How does he separate delays from flat out stealing/non-payment. It's well documented that MtGox has insane queues.

Your clueless Senator-speak aside, <snip>

Take a breather and address the issues. This emotional vitriol is not constructive at all.

Mt. Gox is the largest exchange by a lot. If it goes under, all the Bitbugs lose; that's why no one is suing them.

Well as it turns out there's one class action suit against MtGox " for failing to transfer funds when ordered". So I guess that proves it's buried under lawsuits. On a more serious note, I'm actually glad people bother to provide links to back up their claims.

In the thread, it looks like those who sink money into Bitcoin (or even just want their free money from being early adopters) can't get it out in a reasonable fashion.

Why on Earth would I want to get involved in this stuff again?

The reported lousy customer support and unreasonable queues are what keeps me away from MTGox. Lucky for me, this ain't the only exchange around.

Have you read those links?

http://buttcoin.org/easy
http://buttcoin.org/easy-like-sunday-morning
http://buttcoin.org/easy-come-easy-go

At one point, this guy got his real bank account frozen for dealing in crypto-currency.

I did read the first one, which is where I got the comment I quoted. Why does a site named buttcoin.org sound like it might be entirely anti-bitcoin? Call me crazy, but my skeptic senses are tingling.
 
Take a breather and address the issues. This emotional vitriol is not constructive at all.
I love it! You avoid addressing the issues by accusing people of avoiding addressing the issues. The snip of the rest of my post speaks volumes.

Also, there was no vitriol in that post. Plenty of amusement at your attempts to speak like the kids these days. No vitriol though. I am beginning to think you are simply rife with malapropisms.

Finally, one class action action suit means that potentially all your customers are suing you. Technically it means anyone with standing and knows of the suit is suing them.

But this more of the same from the true beleivers. They cry for evidence, and when you give it you dismiss it out of hand. Nary a discussion on the strength of the evidence presented. Then they falsely claim that since others have no evidence then Bitcoins have no issues. It's pretty transparent. Which is an illogical conclusion based on false premises.

I for one was at one point actually interested in discussing the drawbacks and benefits of Bitcoins. But quite frankly of the supporters I have found I do not trust their judgements. Which is dissapointing, as it is a fascinating technology. But unlike solid state drives or self driving cars, it seems one can not discuss how and when or if Bitcoins are useful without drawing out the wackadoodles.
 
Last edited:
I love it! You avoid addressing the issues by accusing people of avoiding addressing the issues. The snip of the rest of my post speaks volumes.

You were on an emotional rant, just like you are now, and made no points to be discussed. I don't know (nor even care) why you addressed me in the first place.

Finally, one class action action suit means that potentially all your customers are suing you. Technically it means anyone with standing and knows of the suit is suing them.

Great. You're potentially right.

But this more of the same from the true beleivers. They cry for evidence, and when you give it you dismiss it out of hand.

I'm not a 'true believer', whatever that means. And I haven't dismissed any evidence. Try to actually read my posts if you want to engage in a discussion.

Nary a discussion on the strength of the evidence presented. Then they falsely claim that since others have no evidence then Bitcoins have no issues. It's pretty transparent. Which is an illogical conclusion based on false premises.

Such straw and spin, wonderful!

Did you make a single point to be actually discussed in your post? Not that I can see.That's why I snipped your earlier post, might as well have done the same here.
 
Last edited:
That's an excellent question, should be directed at wrs, since it's his claim. How does he separate delays from flat out stealing/non-payment. It's well documented that MtGox has insane queues.

Are you familiar with Little's Law? Furthermore, I posted another set of links to remarks of the same nature at other forurms, upthread here. If you can't be bothered to look for them, why should I bother to re post them. It's you that has the burden of looking for what I posted, not me.
 
And how many hits of the enter key does it take to move those Bitcoins out of the other exchange and get them in USD in your regular bank account so that you can actually spend them?
Four. Gosh, I don't know. Do you you want to count mouse clicks or just enter keys? Anyway, do you even have a point?

It's easy to move bitcoins into cash.

The straw bit argument pushed by jhunter, wrs and remirol seems to revolve around the difficulty of 'cashing out of a large amount of bitcoin, into USD, using the mt. gox operation'.

As best as I can figure it. Of course they change things around quite a bit as it suits them.

If Mt. Gox falters or provides poor customer service, other exchanges pick up the customer demand. Who cares?

Reiterating: If you could not cash out of Mt. Gox, they have not cheated you or stolen your money unless you also could not move your bitcoins out of Mt. Gox. It is just totally weird to me to think that someone would consider it important for them to move bitcoins to a Japanese business to convert them to US dollars.
 
Last edited:
Four. Gosh, I don't know. Do you you want to count mouse clicks or just enter keys? Anyway, do you even have a point?

It's easy to move bitcoins into cash.

The straw bit argument pushed by jhunter, wrs and remirol seems to revolve around the difficulty of 'cashing out of a large amount of bitcoin, into USD, using the mt. gox operation'.

As best as I can figure it. Of course they change things around quite a bit as it suits them.

If Mt. Gox falters or provides poor customer service, other exchanges pick up the customer demand. Who cares?

Reiterating: If you could not cash out of Mt. Gox, they have not cheated you or stolen your money unless you also could not move your bitcoins out of Mt. Gox. It is just totally weird to me to think that someone would consider it important for them to move bitcoins to a Japanese business to convert them to US dollars.

So it's just a coinkydink that prices are 10-20% higher on MtGox and if you have cash you pay their prices and then move your bitcoins to sell them on other exchanges for a substantial haircut? Why would anyone put money into MtGox to pay those premiums if you couldn't get your cash back out?
 
Are you familiar with Little's Law?

No, I was not. Thanks for the link. Now I'm trying to figure out how to apply it to MTGox and current discussion.


Furthermore, I posted another set of links to remarks of the same nature at other forurms, upthread here. If you can't be bothered to look for them, why should I bother to re post them. It's you that has the burden of looking for what I posted, not me.

Remarks of the same nature? You mean delayed withdrawals? Why would I want to look them up, this is not something that is under dispute.
 
I for one was at one point actually interested in discussing the drawbacks and benefits of Bitcoins.
I find that hard to believe. Most of your recent posts have been about defending the notion that bitcoin or its exchanges are some form of ponzi scheme. That firmly puts you in the camp of the "wackadoodles".
 
Look up Little's Law, like I said.

I did, from wiki. I see now you didn't actually link it, my bad, that wasn't meant to be sarcastic, I just automatically googled it myself. :P

I'm not that great with formal logic, or maths for that matter. How would you apply it to MTGox to establish there's something fishy going on? Wouldn't we need an arrival rate to make the calculation? And what would we learn, that the system is unstable (and what would that mean)?
 
Little's Law illustrated:

bank-run1.jpg
 
How would you apply it to MTGox to establish there's something fishy going on?

W is the time in the store, L is the number of people in the store. It's clear that the increase in W and L is due to the store not being able to process the number of requests. That would be most likely due to a lack of cash and not a lack of processors, the latter are easy to add in order to meet higher arrival rates but cash is another matter. So MtGox's delays obviously stem from a cash flow problem and not any inability to process withdrawal requests.
 
W is the time in the store, L is the number of people in the store. It's clear that the increase in W and L is due to the store not being able to process the number of requests. That would be most likely due to a lack of cash and not a lack of processors, the latter are easy to add in order to meet higher arrival rates but cash is another matter. So MtGox's delays obviously stem from a cash flow problem and not any inability to process withdrawal requests.
"Lack of cash" and "cash flow problem" are two different things. Neither conclusion can be drawn simply from a mathematical formula.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom