How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know enough about Bitcoin to have a firm opinion. But here is some food for thought:

Today I cam across this article in Salon:

“Absurd on every single level”: How the feds may be crippling the legal pot industry"

The gist of the article is that in states where pot has become legal (at the state government level), retailers are stuck operating on a cash-only basis. Banks, being federally regulated, are unwilling to open accounts or offer credit to businesses that openly engage in something that is still illegal at the federal level.

This means no capital loans, no acceptance of credit or debit cards. The businesses accept payment in cash, and pay expenses (including taxes, rent, and other big-ticket costs) in cash. This has obvious drawbacks in terms of security and book-keeping, not to mention the limitations businesses of being unable to obtain loans.

Would this be a case where Bitcoin could step in and save the day? Or, is that just a pipe dream?
 
What a load of rubbish! You clearly don't have the slightest clue how bitcoin exchanges work. They are not financial intermediaries like banks but brokerage firms. They match "asks" with "bids".

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Buying_and_selling

Since when is a brokerage firm not a financial intermediary? Furthermore, now much different is a brokerage from a bank? I have one of my bank accounts connected to my brokerage and can move money into and out the same day. Too bad the bitcon exchanges aren't that liquid otherwise there might be some real money there.
 
Since when is a brokerage firm not a financial intermediary? Furthermore, now much different is a brokerage from a bank? I have one of my bank accounts connected to my brokerage and can move money into and out the same day. Too bad the bitcon exchanges aren't that liquid otherwise there might be some real money there.
Didn't you read the link?

You have to have an account at the exchange which has to have money in it before you can make a bid. Similarly, a seller has to put bitcoins into an exchange before he can make a sale. Once the sale is made, it's a case of transferring money from the buyers account at the exchange to the sellers account (and vice versa for the bitcoins).

Since the buyer has put in enough money to make the sale, nobody else has to make any deposits for the buyer to withdraw his bitcoins or the seller to withdraw his cash.
 
Didn't you read the link?

You have to have an account at the exchange which has to have money in it before you can make a bid. Similarly, a seller has to put bitcoins into an exchange before he can make a sale. Once the sale is made, it's a case of transferring money from the buyers account at the exchange to the sellers account (and vice versa for the bitcoins).

Since the buyer has put in enough money to make the sale, nobody else has to make any deposits for the buyer to withdraw his bitcoins or the seller to withdraw his cash.

I read the link and I know how the exchange works. What I also know is that people are not getting their money out after a sale. They are putting money in, being allowed to buy bitcoins and sell them but not get cash from their accounts. This has been well documented on this thread and in the bitcoin forums. MtGox is essentially saying if you have cash in your account, you can buy bitcoins 20% above the rest of the market and transfer those coins out for sale in another market that can give you cash. The cash in MtGox accounts isn't real, it's a bookkeeping entry.
 
What a load of rubbish! You clearly don't have the slightest clue how bitcoin exchanges work. They are not financial intermediaries like banks but brokerage firms. They match "asks" with "bids".

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Buying_and_selling

It's not strictly a peer to peer situation, if it was there wouldn't be a problem, certainly not a problem that involves weeks or months of backlogs of withdrawing money. You don't make a buy order and then some payment method gets debited at that point. You pre-fund MtGox's bank account and then make orders.

If it was simply a case of matching asks with bids there shouldn't be any problems, should there? But there are.
 
MtGox is essentially saying if you have cash in your account, you can buy bitcoins [.................] The cash in MtGox accounts isn't real, it's a bookkeeping entry.
You are essentially saying that MtGox is accepting cash deposits then stealing them and the people who use MtGox haven't caught on yet.

Surely you can make up a better story than that. :rolleyes:
 
You are essentially saying that MtGox is accepting cash deposits then stealing them and the people who use MtGox haven't caught on yet.

Surely you can make up a better story than that. :rolleyes:
Im not making a thing up. People most certainly have caught on, look at the posts on the bitcoin forums. I have linked several in this thread.

Tell me why anyone would put money into Mt Gox to pay a 20% premium for coins they can get elsewhere for less? That is the whole point of their higher prices.
 
Last edited:
Since investment scams all require false or misleading information to be put out about the product, all I have to do is ask what false information is being put out to entice people to buy bitcoins and the debate stops dead in its tracks.

Thats a lie. What happens is you dismiss the outrageous and misleading statements through a fiat declaration (and no evidence) as totally being plausible. People don't care enough to argue with you over nit picking. But I'd wager given the PMs I get from this thread, that MOST people reading this thread see these claims that Bitcoins will be worth $50k or up for what they are.

Here is a stunning exaple of this pefidity in action.

You are essentially saying that MtGox is accepting cash deposits then stealing them and the people who use MtGox haven't caught on yet.

Surely you can make up a better story than that. :rolleyes:

Most convincing! For someone who mistrusts fiat currency, you sure do rely upon it rhetorically.
 
Last edited:
I don't know enough about Bitcoin to have a firm opinion. But here is some food for thought:

Today I cam across this article in Salon:

“Absurd on every single level”: How the feds may be crippling the legal pot industry"

Would this be a case where Bitcoin could step in and save the day? Or, is that just a pipe dream?

That actually is the kind of niche I envision Bitcoins would fill very well. (BTW calling Bitcoin a niche player garnered me the Stalinesque label "Enemy of Bitcoins".) Except for the capital loans thing. Bitcoin is far too volatile and difficult to convert to USD to work well for that at this stage. Things would have to change pretty drastically for Bitcoins to be used to build capital.
 
What I also know is that people are not getting their money out after a sale. They are putting money in, being allowed to buy bitcoins and sell them but not get cash from their accounts.

Wow. Just when I thought we finally settled this nonsense claim, wrs manages to get us back to square 1. I'm not even gonna ask you for evidence because I know you have none.

This has been well documented on this thread and in the bitcoin forums.

:rolleyes:
I guess how this will go is you'll be claiming that it's been documented and we'll be asking you to back up your claim, ad infinitum.

With all the alleged stealing Mt Gox is doing, you'd think it would be buried under lawsuits and reddit hacker attacks.
 
Wow. Just when I thought we finally settled this nonsense claim, wrs manages to get us back to square 1. I'm not even gonna ask you for evidence because I know you have none.



:rolleyes:
I guess how this will go is you'll be claiming that it's been documented and we'll be asking you to back up your claim, ad infinitum.

With all the alleged stealing Mt Gox is doing, you'd think it would be buried under lawsuits and reddit hacker attacks.

Reddit hackers. Tee hee. Over the series of tubes I'll bet.

Your clueless Senator-speak aside, how are lawsuits and hackers a measure of if something is a scam? No one is suing the creation museum, but it is a total scam. The people who bought Bitcoins are adamant that it is the second coming. It's only a slight hyperbole that you could steal their pants in the name of bitcoin, and they would call swinging in the breeze the next great achievement of civilization. As I said before, if a collapse comes, the Bitcoiners will almost certainly blame the govt somehow while absolving the Bitwhales, Gox, etc.

The people who would sue probably never got into the things in the first place, and therefore have no standing.

In other words, if you are going to fleece someone, fleece a true beleiver. They are more likely to thank you for taking their money, and far less likely to sue.
 
Last edited:
TeapotCavalry said:

This comment sums it up:

Sampson2020 said:
This situation is more like: "Damn, it takes a whole week to open an account and cash all these penny stocks I inherited? I can't wait that long! Better just go meet the Mafia in a back alley instead."

Have you read those links?

http://buttcoin.org/easy
http://buttcoin.org/easy-like-sunday-morning
http://buttcoin.org/easy-come-easy-go

At one point, this guy got his real bank account frozen for dealing in crypto-currency.
 
Post 2751 of the linked Mt. Gox Thread:
Been waiting on roughly $8k in transfers from Gox to a US bank. Withdraw was "confirmed" on Gox's site on December 9th. Nearly a full month later, I'm guessing I should expect at least another 2 month delay?

There are more posts later on that report similar issues, including those who have been waiting since June to get funds. Seems like it's very spotty. Some customers get their money quickly, yet others can take months. Worse yet, there's no actual guarantee on Mt. Gox or clear guidelines on how funds will be handled. Currency of the future!

In the thread, it looks like those who sink money into Bitcoin (or even just want their free money from being early adopters) can't get it out in a reasonable fashion.

Why on Earth would I want to get involved in this stuff again? Dealing with shady companies online with no guarantees or regulations or rules stating that they must treat clients in a particular manner, with the extremely high risk of getting my real bank account frozen and potentially never receiving my "filthy" fiat? I am not an uneducated person. I cannot see any upside to this other than as a tool to scam people out of real money with imaginary Funbux.

The fact that Bitcoin is valued at ~$850 right now is wonderful. Good luck getting your money out of the system. I have have no regrets about skipping this fad.
 
That Buttcoin site is hilarious.

This Wikipedia article summarizes the "trading incidents" that have plagued MtGox.

For anyone who wonders, like I did, where the name originated, MtGox used to be a game card exchange site called Magic: the Gathering Online eXchange.
 
Mt. Gox is the largest exchange by a lot. If it goes under, all the Bitbugs lose; that's why no one is suing them.

Unless you count the $75million suit filed by CoinLab:

In May of this year, CoinLab filed a $75M lawsuit against Mt. Gox for failure to turn over all North American bitcoin exchange operations as obligated per an agreement dated November 2012. In the same suit, CoinLab asserted that Mt. Gox was also in breach of the agreement by not providing funds, records and technology necessary for CoinLab to take over operations.

Link.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom