How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, there may be some word confusion there. Think swimming pool.

My point was that ghash.io is currently making plenty of money both from being a legitimate bitcoin mining operation _and_ from having bitcoins themselves. To perform a 51% attack would sacrifice their operation and possibly any long-term value of bitcoins they hold -- so it wouldn't seem to be in their best interest from many fronts, hence I'm not surprised at their press release.

For impossible -- well, I prefer not to say things like that when using brand-new technology. If it actually _were_ possible, simply knowing that it wasn't impossible would be worth a significant amount all on its own. Beyond that, just seeing what they did isn't necessarily going to help you if it's already been done and they've found a way to launder the BTC. People are very clever, I find, so just because I don't see a way to launder the BTC from such an action doesn't mean there isn't one.

Well, I do agree with you that there are clever people doing amazingly devious things, so I guess you are right that it is not impossible. I find it highly improbable, though. Ghash has invested millions into their own data facility. They actually own 45% of their hashing power, and are making a real chunk of change leasing that equipment to miners. I find it unlikely that they would risk ruining their own legitimate successful business and bringing all the various legal problems that broken leases, unpaid loans, etc in order to perform a bitcoin heist.

For reversed -- one of the major disadvantages of Bitcoin is that once your coins are transferred, they're gone and there isn't a way to force a reversal.

Yeah. You probably are right. When I wrote that before I was thinking that they maybe could treat such an event like orphaned blocks, and basically go back to the beginning of the heist and start calculating the transactions all again. But after thinking about it, I think you are right, and it probably couldn't be reversed.

Sheep Market's reputation and business is ruined, too, but that guy is running around with ~90k BTC right now, I believe? If the rewards for crime are high enough...

Well, I think comparing an unknown person who hacked bitcoins from an illegal drug buying business to a legitimate bitcoin mining business is comparing apples to oranges. Just because they both dealt with bitcoins doesn't mean they are related in any way or similarly motivated.
 
I've no idea. It's clear that there are people who have become very frustrated with the length of time it takes to get USD out of MtGox - it seems to vary from days to months - but I've not seen the same level of complaints relating to other currencies (after a rather brief investigation). I have to say that on balance, I'd probably avoid that particular exchange if I were trading BTC.

Yeah, well maybe if you were working with BTC/USD. I do recall reading an article that stated their problem with withdrawals was just USD.

Of course it'd be better to be able to work with multiple fiat currencies anyway ( I do ). But a lot of people wouldn't have those accounts set up or want to do that.
 
Last edited:
So it's just a coinkydink that prices are 10-20% higher on MtGox and if you have cash you pay their prices and then move your bitcoins to sell them on other exchanges for a substantial haircut? Why would anyone put money into MtGox to pay those premiums if you couldn't get your cash back out?
What exactly is your hangup or thing about turning every conversation into one about MtGox? That's about as interesting as talking about little packages of sugar in restaurants.

One more time: It's not - as you allege - difficult to cash out of bitcoins. It is like a routine thing. Boring. Easy. So what. Big deal. Yawn.
 
And how many hits of the enter key does it take to move those Bitcoins out of the other exchange and get them in USD in your regular bank account so that you can actually spend them?
I am going to answer this a second time. It may interest you that because there are a lot of things that can be bought one way or another in the bitcoin ecosystem, it isn't as terribly important to "get them in USD so you can actually spend them".

Maybe it's that I don't particularly want USD. I like Amazon gift cards and Walmart cards and buy and use those routinely. Of course, Walmart has a grocery and gas pumps.....
 
Does anyone know where I can find the bitcoin/USD rate on a given day in the past (going back through 2009)?
 
According to wrs, just ask the bit whales that set all those prices....lol.....
 
.....I think comparing an unknown person who hacked bitcoins from an illegal drug buying business to a legitimate bitcoin mining business is comparing apples to oranges. Just because they both dealt with bitcoins doesn't mean they are related in any way or similarly motivated.
fits the narrative attempting to be constructed though....
 
Does anyone know where I can find the bitcoin/USD rate on a given day in the past (going back through 2009)?
2009 might be difficult since MtGox didn't start trading bitcoins until 2010 (I don't know if there were any exchanges before MtGox).

According to Wikipedia:
The first bitcoin trade for goods or services took place in 2010 after Laszlo Hanyecz posted on the BitcoinTalk forums offering to pay 10,000 bitcoins for two pizzas,[37][38] on May 22, 2010 Laszlo announced a successful purchase, becoming the first real world use of bitcoins at a valuation of US$0.003 per coin
 
Well, I think comparing an unknown person who hacked bitcoins from an illegal drug buying business to a legitimate bitcoin mining business is comparing apples to oranges. Just because they both dealt with bitcoins doesn't mean they are related in any way or similarly motivated.

We talking about the same Sheep Market? The current (AFAIK) belief is that the Sheep Market owner himself is the one who took off with all the coins -- ie. set up the site honorably and then fell to temptation, or just set it up scammily to begin with; I figure probably the former.
 
Looks like Overstock.com is actually taking bitcoins now. I just bought a nice set of sheets for bitcents :)

What? This can not be. There is no way. JREF posters have repeated lectured on the impossiblity of merchants transacting with bitcoin. Of course they were politely told they were wrong, that they didn't understand bitcoin, merchant transaction, the block chain, the way exchanges work, but they didn't change their mind so they must have been right.

The JREF posters said the owners of Overstock must be idiots. They must be stupid. JREF posters have said so. That means it must be true. Because bitcoin is bad and it's only used for drugs or illegal transactions. JREF posters said so. Over and over.



Back in the real world Overstock is using the Coinbase merchant API.

Laughter is totally appropriate.

BWHAHAHAHAHAHA!

(I can hear the responses now. "Secretly the Overstock owners are bitwhales.")
 
Last edited:
Looks like Overstock.com is actually taking bitcoins now. I just bought a nice set of sheets for bitcents :)

But still listing prices in USD, so even they aren't brave enough to take the plunge, regardless of their owner's brash chatter. :D
 
But still listing prices in USD, so even they aren't brave enough to take the plunge, regardless of their owner's brash chatter. :D

I'm imagining the conversation in the Overstock executive suite.

CEO: "Wilson, how are the Bitcoin sales going?"

VP: "Great, sir! We've got 500 Bitcoins in our wallet!"

CEO: "Good job, Wilson. How much is that worth in real money?"

VP: "$400,000... *checks smartphone* $395,000.. um, $390,000...."
 
I'm imagining the conversation in the Overstock executive suite.

CEO: "Wilson, how are the Bitcoin sales going?"

VP: "Great, sir! We've got 500 Bitcoins in our wallet!"

CEO: "Good job, Wilson. How much is that worth in real money?"

VP: "$400,000... *checks smartphone* $395,000.. um, $390,000...."

I don't think they even took that much risk.

As I understand how coinbase works, the Bitcoiner pays coinbase from his wallet, and then coinbase transfers USD over to Overstock at the going rate for BTC conversions. Overstock never sees any BTC, which isn't surprising because they don't want to. This is just another case of BTC competing with Paypal -- which might turn out to be a good thing, but the further down that road it goes, the less chance it'll ever become a currency.

The other way for them to do it would be to establish an account at Coinbase to hold paid-in BTC (again at the USD prices, of course), and then find a way on their own to turn the BTC into useful money. This doesn't strike me as very likely since Coinbase's entire purpose is to do that sort of thing for you -- and it would set up the risk factor that you mentioned in your post, where now _they_ are on the hook with the BTC.

Either way, though, these are USD transactions. I have more and more doubts whether BTC will ever become anything other than a Paypal alternative for part-time speculators; it doesn't look like the volatility will ever calm down, and the Bitcoin intermediaries that are springing up aren't creating business models that would help that.
 
So Overstock took the plunge? Cool. Let's see how they do. I'm curious to see how long this lasts. Who knows, maybe it'll become a long-term thing. Will they ever show prices in Bitcoin, or just USD?
 
So Overstock took the plunge? Cool. Let's see how they do. I'm curious to see how long this lasts. Who knows, maybe it'll become a long-term thing. Will they ever show prices in Bitcoin, or just USD?

It'll last as long as it takes them to suck all the USD out of the BTC economy. I gave it six months, above. Whenever they stop getting money from Coinbase, it'll come to an abrupt end.
 
It'll last as long as it takes them to suck all the USD out of the BTC economy. I gave it six months, above.....

Well!

So assuming no BTC price increases, Overstock is going to suck the 10B market cap right out of bitcoin.

Well, any attempt to do that in the real world would cause the price of a bitcoin to shoot through the roof. But we are not in the real world here.
 
So Overstock took the plunge? Cool. Let's see how they do. I'm curious to see how long this lasts. Who knows, maybe it'll become a long-term thing. Will they ever show prices in Bitcoin, or just USD?

That's one big thing I'm waiting for -- who's going to take the _real_ plunge and start listing prices only in BTC without pegging it to USD/JPY/RMB/EUR?

A sufficiently brave operation could do this right now: assume that BTC is currently worth $700 per, and set all their prices as BTC-only based on that... and not change them. It seems easy, right? If BTC is on an upswing, your price of .01 BTC for, say, a month of VPN is going to net you more and more in USD over time. Of course, your customers aren't going to like it much because your prices are automatically rising relative to the competition, so now what? Stick with your .01 BTC and watch your customers drift to your competition for ideological purity? Or back off and list prices in USD? I bet I know which way that pans out.

Of course, if BTC is on a downswing you'll rapidly get screwed; $7/mo for VPN isn't terrible (depending on service) but you probably don't want to charge $5/mo... and $3/mo is likely to have you hemorrhaging money.
 
But we are not in the real world here.

Agreed.

We're in a parallel dimension where devotees of Magic the Gathering grew up, studied cryptography, and invented a virtual commodity/medium of exchange/payment processing system they believe to be the most important creation in the history of man, and have sold the idea to millions of speculators and venture capitalists trying to make a buck off of it.

I keep thinking of that quote attributed to Einstein, about how reality is an illusion, just a very persistent one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom