How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's one big thing I'm waiting for -- who's going to take the _real_ plunge and start listing prices only in BTC without pegging it to USD/JPY/RMB/EUR?

A sufficiently brave operation could do this right now: assume that BTC is currently worth $700 per, and set all their prices as BTC-only based on that... and not change them. It seems easy, right? If BTC is on an upswing, your price of .01 BTC for, say, a month of VPN is going to net you more and more in USD over time. Of course, your customers aren't going to like it much because your prices are automatically rising relative to the competition, so now what? Stick with your .01 BTC and watch your customers drift to your competition for ideological purity? Or back off and list prices in USD? I bet I know which way that pans out.

Of course, if BTC is on a downswing you'll rapidly get screwed; $7/mo for VPN isn't terrible (depending on service) but you probably don't want to charge $5/mo... and $3/mo is likely to have you hemorrhaging money.

Well, one way they could do it would be to have their prices change daily (or hourly) depending on what the average exchange value is, but that would be a waste of resources. I buy from Great Britain every now and then, and their prices stay in GBP, with the actual exchange taking place once I place my order. Granted, the GBP / USD exchange is rather steady, so I can expect to pay the same price regardless of when I buy it.

The Overstock.com experiment will be interesting to watch. It's important to note that Overstock doesn't have any particular risk involved with this - Coinbase handles everything.

Per the Coinbase Merchant Tool page:
Coinbase sends payouts to your local bank account once per day when you enable automatic payouts. You can also manually sell bitcoin at any time from the sells page.

As a merchant, you never need to hold bitcoin or expose yourself to any exchange rate risk if you don't want to.

Most merchant set prices in their local currency and get paid in their local currency. For this "instant exchange" service we charge 1% plus $0.15 to convert the bitcoin you receive into your local currency (the same price if you manually sell bitcoin).

If you wish to get paid in and keep bitcoin, this is completely free.

So Overstock gets their money regardless of the price, which is a good thing. It seems that Coinbase has a rather substantial amount of capital if they can afford to do instant exchanges with merchants. Should be neat to see if this changes with a (relatively) major retailer joining the service.
 
Well, one way they could do it would be to have their prices change daily (or hourly) depending on what the average exchange value is, but that would be a waste of resources. I buy from Great Britain every now and then, and their prices stay in GBP, with the actual exchange taking place once I place my order. Granted, the GBP / USD exchange is rather steady, so I can expect to pay the same price regardless of when I buy it.

Daily price changes based on the exchange price is just pegging BTC to a USD value with a different name, though. To be a currency, you have to have prices that can stand on their own... such as your GBP example, where someone who has GBP in England gets it from his paycheck, buys stuff with it, pays his rent.. all without ever moving out of GBP or having to care how many USD his pound will buy at any given moment.

Not so much BTC right now, since the only value BTC has is the expectation that it can be traded for another currency with actual value. Risky, that.

So Overstock gets their money regardless of the price, which is a good thing. It seems that Coinbase has a rather substantial amount of capital if they can afford to do instant exchanges with merchants. Should be neat to see if this changes with a (relatively) major retailer joining the service.
I'm intrigued as to where Coinbase will be getting the USD for this sort of thing. Will they need to play on the exchanges heavily in order to turn BTC into USD at the rate they'll need? Will those heavy 'sell' orders on such short notice depress the price of BTC? I'm sure they wouldn't tell someone like me, admittedly, so that all has to remain speculation for now.
 
We talking about the same Sheep Market? The current (AFAIK) belief is that the Sheep Market owner himself is the one who took off with all the coins -- ie. set up the site honorably and then fell to temptation, or just set it up scammily to begin with; I figure probably the former.

Since when did whatever “The current (AFAIK) belief is..” become some kind of useful evidence on the JREF site?
 
Since when did whatever “The current (AFAIK) belief is..” become some kind of useful evidence on the JREF site?

Well, since nobody KNOWS what happened yet, that's all we have to work with, but here:

http://www.businessinsider.com/shee...-to-44-million-in-bitcoins-disappears-2013-12

FTFA said:
Sheep users and other Bitcoin followers on reddit say that the administrators began blocking withdrawals of bitcoins from the site more than a week ago, and may have absconded with as much as $44 million from the site’s users, pointing to a movement of 39,900 bitcoins visible in the public record of Bitcoin transactions known as the blockchain.

That's all I got and AFAIK all anyone's got. You got something more? Link it up. In the meantime, spare me the Larsen-like cries of "evidence" which substitute for actually discussing the topic.
 
I'm intrigued as to where Coinbase will be getting the USD for this sort of thing. Will they need to play on the exchanges heavily in order to turn BTC into USD at the rate they'll need? Will those heavy 'sell' orders on such short notice depress the price of BTC? I'm sure they wouldn't tell someone like me, admittedly, so that all has to remain speculation for now.

That was the question I was trying to frame; you did it much more succinctly than I could have. If Coinbase is paying Overstock in USD, as seems likely, they'll need to get those USD from somewhere. The logical place (indeed, the only place AFAIK) for Coinbase to get USD is on the exchanges. This will have the effect of sucking even more liquidity out of a system that is already gasping for air liquidity-wise.
 
We're in a parallel dimension where devotees of Magic the Gathering grew up, studied cryptography, and invented a virtual commodity/medium of exchange/payment processing system they believe to be the most important creation in the history of man, and have sold the idea to millions of speculators and venture capitalists trying to make a buck off of it.
Meanwhile, back in the real world, michaelsuede didn't invent bitcoin and nobody "sold" the idea. It was all open source software. As a matter of fact, it would take more than a year before anybody seriously considered trading bitcoins for profit.
 
That was the question I was trying to frame; you did it much more succinctly than I could have. If Coinbase is paying Overstock in USD, as seems likely, they'll need to get those USD from somewhere. The logical place (indeed, the only place AFAIK) for Coinbase to get USD is on the exchanges. This will have the effect of sucking even more liquidity out of a system that is already gasping for air liquidity-wise.

Is there any way to verify that? As far as I have read, banks (particularly in the US) won't make loans to companies that deal with crypto-currency. So either there is a loophole for Coinbase to exploit in order to have the capital to deal with retailers, or they are using the exchanges anyway to get money (through selling the BTC that they receive from retailers). There could be a third option, but it escapes me at the moment.
 
Meanwhile, back in the real world, michaelsuede didn't invent bitcoin and nobody "sold" the idea. It was all open source software. As a matter of fact, it would take more than a year before anybody seriously considered trading bitcoins for profit.


 
Is there any way to verify that? As far as I have read, banks (particularly in the US) won't make loans to companies that deal with crypto-currency. So either there is a loophole for Coinbase to exploit in order to have the capital to deal with retailers, or they are using the exchanges anyway to get money (through selling the BTC that they receive from retailers). There could be a third option, but it escapes me at the moment.

Venture capital?

A steady stream of Silicon Valley investors has been building stakes in virtual currency start-ups. Last month, a Chinese Bitcoin exchange raised $5 million from Lightspeed Venture Partners. Google’s venture capital arm has put money into a couple of companies in the space, Buttercoin and Ripple Labs. Coinbase has also attracted money from Union Square Ventures and Ribbit Capital.

Link.
 
I have no dog in this fight but would anyone hazard any thoughts on what effect this might have given that China plays such a big part in all of this

I tend to agree with the author of the linked article, who wrote:

But it hasn't really mattered. The price has proved resilient, and as the FT noted yesterday, trading is springing back to life, as people find a way around the government ban. Given that circumventing government regulations is one of the main appeals of Bitcoin, it was probably naive to think that China's crackdown would have major ramifications.
 
Well, since nobody KNOWS what happened yet, that's all we have to work with, but here:<snip>.

My small point is exactly that, as you just said, nobody KNOWS what happened there yet.

In your previous statement you inferred that because the sheep market hack happened, it was somehow more plausible to you that the owners of Ghash.io could or might make a 51% attack on the bitcoin network.

My point is:
1. Completely different business models. One being an illegal secret drug dealing operation, the other a legitimate public business.
2. Nobody actually KNOWS who did sheep market. Allegations that it was the owners or administrators of sheep market are just that. Allegations and nothing more.

The only similarity between the two businesses is that they both use bitcoins, and they both use computers.

Now I realize that your comment was really just an off hand comment as a small point, but I think it shows a mental connection that I see several people throughout this thread and elsewhere on the internet keep making. That somehow because some bad person/illegal thing happened involving bitcoins that any other operation involving bitcoins is more likely to be operated by bad people or doing some illegal thing. And it's hogwash.

Do you know why US $100 bills make up 80% of all the US currency? It is because it is the preferred currency around the world for drug trafficking and other illegal operations.

And here's some actual evidence of a real life drug kingpin with a huge stack of Benjamins:

Largest Drug Cash Seizure in US History:
http://www.celebritynetworth.com/ar...money-meth-kingpin-largest-drug-cash-seizure/

Would it be logical to conclude that every business around the world that handles US $100 bills is somehow more likely to be dealing drugs?

Would it be logical to conclude that any person with a $100 bill in their wallet is either buying or selling drugs?

Everyone knows there is lots of porn on the internet. Would it be logical to infer that every legitimate business with an internet presence is more likely to be hosting porn?
 
In your previous statement you inferred that because the sheep market hack happened, it was somehow more plausible to you that the owners of Ghash.io could or might make a 51% attack on the bitcoin network.

Close, but you've missed it. It was already 'more plausible' that the owners of ghash.io might make a 51% attack on the bitcoin network because of many other factors -- not the least of which being that it's even possible to do in the first place, since no such equivalent exists for USD/GBP/etc. What the Sheep Marketplace (my bad, this is the right name) scam shows is that Bitcoin is fertile ground for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility -- and that even significant organizations can't necessarily be trusted if they stand to gain enough.

Do I think it's likely that they would? Nah, very low probability -- ghash would have to find a way to gain a stupidly huge amount in one swoop. But Bitcoin users should have done what they did and helped make sure that ghash wasn't even close to having the capability... just in case.

Now I realize that your comment was really just an off hand comment as a small point, but I think it shows a mental connection that I see several people throughout this thread and elsewhere on the internet keep making. That somehow because some bad person/illegal thing happened involving bitcoins that any other operation involving bitcoins is more likely to be operated by bad people or doing some illegal thing. And it's hogwash.
Again, close but not quite. The bad people/illegal things are brought up to serve as examples of the problems with Bitcoin right now -- no regulation, no reversibility. In such an environment, it is _always_ more likely that you're dealing with a scam than in a well-regulated environment, just because it's easier to get away with it.

The logic chain you describe _is_ hogwash, but it's not the logic chain I'm using. It points out that Bitcoin has no safeguards, and look at all the bad things happening because of that.
 
Would it be logical to conclude that every business around the world that handles US $100 bills is somehow more likely to be dealing drugs?
If $100 bills are used more in drug deals then, yes, more likely than businesses that deal in $1 bills. Sigificantly more.. probably not.
 
Close, but you've missed it. It was already 'more plausible' that the owners of ghash.io might make a 51% attack on the bitcoin network because of many other factors -- not the least of which being that it's even possible to do in the first place, since no such equivalent exists for USD/GBP/etc. What the Sheep Marketplace (my bad, this is the right name) scam shows is that Bitcoin is fertile ground for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility -- and that even significant organizations can't necessarily be trusted if they stand to gain enough.

Exactly how does someone stealing from drug dealers show that “Bitcoin is fertile ground for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility” ?

Just what regulations do you think might have protected those poor drug dealers from getting their bitcoins stolen? Drug dealers, by the nature of their business, tend to avoid and ignore regulations, in case you've never noticed that.

When drug dealers get their cash stolen, does that show that US currency is fertile grounds for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility?
 
Exactly how does someone stealing from drug dealers show that “Bitcoin is fertile ground for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility” ?

Just what regulations do you think might have protected those poor drug dealers from getting their bitcoins stolen? Drug dealers, by the nature of their business, tend to avoid and ignore regulations, in case you've never noticed that.

When drug dealers get their cash stolen, does that show that US currency is fertile grounds for harvesting suckers due to lack of regulation and lack of reversibility?

The point isn't whose cash is being stolen; the point is that these exchanges, which are supposed to be trusted and trustworthy intermediaries, are anything but, given the number of thefts that occur. The fact that it might be drug dealers and CP purveyors getting their BTC stolen is secondary to the concept that the operators of any given exchange might pack up at any given time and leave their depositors holding the virtual bag.
 
The point isn't whose cash is being stolen; the point is that these exchanges, which are supposed to be trusted and trustworthy intermediaries, are anything but, given the number of thefts that occur. The fact that it might be drug dealers and CP purveyors getting their BTC stolen is secondary to the concept that the operators of any given exchange might pack up at any given time and leave their depositors holding the virtual bag.

Well this is absolutely ridiculous. Anyone that thinks an "exchange" set up anonymously, with a secret address accessible only by Tor in order buy and sell illegal drugs or other contraband is somehow a trusted or trustworthy intermediary equal in all ways to say Ghash.io or maybe coinbase or another legal bitcoin business is an idiot.

It absolutely does matter WHOSE "exchange" it is. There are scammer websites all over the internet that dupe people into giving their cc# or account numbers then close up shop and disappear. This is not an indictment against the internet, nor does it say that anyone that ever buys anything on the internet is foolish.
 
-- not the least of which being that it's even possible to do in the first place, since no such equivalent exists for USD/GBP/etc. What the Sheep Marketplace (my bad, this is the right name) scam

Despite having been told just now that you have no reason to call it a scam rather than theft, and you admit no one really knows, you continue to do so anyway. :rolleyes: Just like wrs keeps insisting MTGox has no money despite it being just his pet hypothesis.

Would be super duper if we'd apply critical thinking and make conclusions based on evidence rather than speculation. I would expect that much from JREF forum. But seeing this thread, it almost seems like asking for evidence will get you shouted down. Apparently it's derailing and avoiding the issue or something something.

and that even significant organizations can't necessarily be trusted if they stand to gain enough.

So you're grouping Sheep Marketplace and Ghash.io under the umbrella "significant operations" in order to compare the two now?
 
Well this is absolutely ridiculous...

First off, I suggest you moderate your tone.

Secondly, you again missed the point; Bitcoin has a long and sorry history of exchanges being set up to dupe legitimate would-be users, not just the drug and CP industry. I feel no sympathy for the drug dealers; caveat emptor and all that. But I do feel sympathy for people who invested in things like Sheep Marketplace, which was supposed to be on the up-and-up, and then the owner absconded with something like $40 million in BTC. I think BTC is a wildly speculative investment, and anyone who would invest in it is a fool; but even fools don't deserve to be ripped off.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom