How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
A lot of them seem specifically designed for BTC use, however.

Yup. I mentioned before that I would gladly see more vendors accept bitcoin. It's a rocky road, but we're getting there.

Thousands will do, but I need some big names, too. Some obscure website selling hand-made dildos will probably not get my attention. WalMart accepting BTC would, of course, be at the opposite of the spectrum.

I agree. I just wasn't happy with the characterization of the number of bitcoin vendors as 'very few'. Naturally, it's a subjective estimation. But considering how recent it was that bitcoin hit mainstream media headlines, I think it's doing darn well.


I'm happy to retract it if you say that the claim is unfounded. However, in the interest of not being called wrong again, would you mind if I ask you to show large BTC transactions in 2013 ? Say, a million or more.

I'm not entirely sure how to go about doing it. Even if anecdotes would suffice, I don't have that wealthy friends. One of my acquaintance deals in the range of 1-2 BTC, haven't heard him complain about withdrawals or frauding.

Would some big shot publicly reveal how he transferred millions to his account? I guess it needs some google-fu magic if someone's up for it. Personally, I'm too lazy.

Can anyone show the biggest cash outs from mtgox lately? Would be interesting.

Wouldn't that mean having access to someone's private bank details?
 
That's because this is exactly what it is.
No, it isn't. I can testify as to my own state of mind on something better than you can. Feel free to call me a liar if it makes you feel better, but I believe there are serious ideological and practical problems with Bitcoin and that is why it's not for me, not because of some irrational dislike.
That's what you could have said when bitcoin was $15 - then $100 - then and unprecedented $260 at the height of the Cyprus crisis.

Anybody who thinks these sorts of gains are far from over will be happy to pay $1000 for bitcoins - even if the seller only paid 10c for them a few years ago.
People who are buying with the expectation that the value will go up are doing so because they expect someone else to think the same thing later. As long as someone is willing to believe the hype, there will be profit in it, just like with anything else.

What are we to make of people who won't acknowledge the problems, despite the wailing and gnashing of teeth from those people who are trying to extract their new fortunes?
 
Bitcoin Cost Benefit Analysis

I've just read what seems to be a pretty good opinion of the risks and benefits of Bitcoin by a Bank of America analyst. This came out about a month ago.

Link.

Money/currencies are generally thought to have three distinct roles: as a unit of account, medium of exchange, and store of value. To the extent that Bitcoin offers users many benefits and efficiencies as a medium of exchange, this means it possesses some fundamental value that may increase over time as it gains wider use. However, as a unit of account and store of a value, it has considerable shortcomings which we believe will ultimately hinder it from ascending to international currency status.

The article goes on to review the advantages and disadvantages in greater detail. IMO it was clearly written and reasonable in its analysis.
 
No, it isn't. I can testify as to my own state of mind on something better than you can. Feel free to call me a liar if it makes you feel better, but I believe there are serious ideological and practical problems with Bitcoin and that is why it's not for me, not because of some irrational dislike.
Bitcoin is just a tradeable commodity. It has been proven thousands of times in this thread that it has no characteristics in common with pyramid or ponzi schemes. Your insistence on continuing to associate the word "ponzi" with bitcoin is just a dishonest appeal to emotion based on a false analogy.

Let us have a look at your "rational" explanation:
Whether you think Bitcoin is intentionally a ponzi scheme or not, the behaviour of the people who exchange it for "real" money shares characteristics with one at the moment. (No description of how it resembles a ponzi scheme - just assertion).

It's not like it's unexpected because the way the Bitcoin economy is set up requires it to be like that. (Assuming what you have failed to describe - let alone prove - is known as "begging the question").

The vast majority of Bitcoin holders obtained theirs for much less than the current nominal price, and a sizable fraction were obtained for virtually nothing. (Even if there was something morally wrong about this making a profit on something has nothing to do with ponzi schemes)

It's like a run on the banks (:yikes:), except one where all the banks said they'll pay out ten times the value of your deposits. Even if the banks had all the deposits in cash, which they don't, they couldn't pay out the full value of the promise by a long way. The value of their liabilities would vastly outstrip the value of theirs assets, and it's the same with Bitcoin. (Pure fiction but since bank runs are bad, we will say that bitcoin is a bank run just to make it sound bad).

What are we to make of people who won't acknowledge the problems, despite the wailing and gnashing of teeth from those people who are trying to extract their new fortunes?
I have acknowledge many times that there are risks in buying and holding bitcoins and also in dealing with bitcoin exchanges.

What I won't acknowledge is that you can throw every bad sounding word under the sun at bitcoin in an attempt to gild the lily.
 
This thread started with bitcoin in the $2-30 range. People were advised of it's potential. They showed the same negativity, bias and prejudice that you have accurately called a racial hatred then as now. The huge number of irrational comments in this thread is in my opinion only the display of fear of change. Bitcoin is a highly disruptive technology and there is no way to modify that.
Mobile phones were a disruptive technology, as were the Internet, PCs, flash drives, LCD/TFT screens, CDs and digital media downloads. Ask all these people how many of them they feared and resisted.

Stop being a plonker. Nobody here stands to lose from adopting a quicker, cheaper and more convenient payment system if it actually works as described. At the moment Bitcoin isn't that technology.

So there is nothing wrong with my commenting that there is a serious potential for bitcoin to go to 10k, or 100k or 1M per coin. Consider for example if something like the 2008-2009 financial crisis occurred today. (yeah, it's likely to) Bitcoin will shoot through the roof as a result of EVENTS.
So it's what people resort to when they're at risk of losing everything anyway? That's reassuring.
But we would prefer to see it's valuation increase as a result of increased utilization and transaction volume. Ease the worthless fiat currencies out gradually, without any panics or crises or human suffering. Give the banksters time to find honest jobs.
"Valuation increase" is part of the problem. Why should a currency change in value a millionfold because of increased utilisation? Currency is meant to be a reliable store of value which allows us to easily exchange goods and services of like value. Changing the value radically means that trading partners can no longer be sure that they are exchanging things of like value, and so are disinclined to trade in that currency.

You still haven't told us who is going be able to exchange a million dollars out of their deposits for all those people who bought Bitcoins for $2 a little while back.
 
.....
What I won't acknowledge is that you can throw every bad sounding word under the sun at bitcoin in an attempt to gild the lily.

I don't think you mean what you said, but you got it right. Just like the trembling and fearful get it wronger than wrong.

What Shakespeare said:

''To gild refined gold, to paint the lily... Is wasteful and ridiculous excess."

Bitcoin stands quite nicely without further adornment....
 
I've just read what seems to be a pretty good opinion of the risks and benefits of Bitcoin by a Bank of America analyst. This came out about a month ago.

Link.

The article goes on to review the advantages and disadvantages in greater detail. IMO it was clearly written and reasonable in its analysis.


Advantages:
  • As a medium of exchange, Bitcoin is attractive as it offers low transaction costs.
  • Bitcoin offers an attractive alternative to cash in terms of security, transparency of transactions, and counterfeiting.
  • There is a finite supply of Bitcoins.
  • Bitcoin’s relative anonymity is advantageous to citizens of crisis countries.
  • “Winner Takes All” market ensures that increasing acceptance and popularity of Bitcoin increases likelihood of success.
  • Bitcoin offers large benefits (from an asset allocation perspective) given its negative correlation with risk sensitive assets, much like gold.
Disadvantages:
  • Bitcoin’s role as a store of value is seriously compromised by its elevated price volatility.
  • Regulators could try to impose controls that would increase the transaction costs for using Bitcoin despite its efficiency and the transparency relative to cash.
  • The quality of Bitcoin exchange security, where consumers exchange dollars for Bitcoins (and vice versa) is suspect.
  • Seigniorage is currently accruing to the “miners” of Bitcoins who have the fastest CPUs.
  • A 50 minute wait before payment receipt confirmation is received will prohibit wider use.
  • Bitcoin’s use as an international currency will likely be hindered by the fact that it is not a legal tender.
I would have to agree that this is a good discussion article. There are some points that might be debatable but overall, the article avoids silly emotional remarks.

It's a pity this thread doesn't have more of this kind of discussion.
 
Proven? Sorry, your standard of proof must be looser than mine.

Thousands of times? Come on. You are exaggerating.

No characteristics in common? How about:
1. Early, long term holders can't harvest gains unless new buyers buy in before the price collapses.
2. You buy it today, not because you think it is going to offer a stable value, but because you think you're going to make a bundle of money when more people come into the market.

That being said, I do not believe it is technically a Ponzi or pyramid scheme. I agree with wrs who said it is more like a "pump and dump" setup, and others who have described it as a speculative bubble.
 
Proven? Sorry, your standard of proof must be looser than mine.
Since investment scams all require false or misleading information to be put out about the product, all I have to do is ask what false information is being put out to entice people to buy bitcoins and the debate stops dead in its tracks. Then a few posts later, someone else makes a "brand new" claim that bitcoin is a ponzi or pyramid scheme.

1. Early, long term holders can't harvest gains unless new buyers buy in before the price collapses.
You can't sell a product unless you have a buyer? That is weak - especially since you are implying that all long term holders expect the price to collapse and are trying to get out before that happens.

2. You buy it today, not because you think it is going to offer a stable value, but because you think you're going to make a bundle of money when more people come into the market.
You buy something today because you think you will be able to sell it at a profit in the future? By that measure every single investment is a ponzi scheme.

That being said, I do not believe it is technically a Ponzi or pyramid scheme. I agree with wrs who said it is more like a "pump and dump" setup,
Once again, that requires false information to be put out that causes a temporary price rise so you can dump your stock before the truth gets out.

and others who have described it as a speculative bubble.
That's about the only thing you have posted that might be true but that doesn't make it a scam in any way and of course, it could just as easily not be a bubble (short term price variations not withstanding).
 
Last edited:
....that requires false information to be put out that causes a temporary price rise so you can dump your stock before the truth gets out..

...the false information in this thread is demonstrably from those against bitcoin. So are they running a reverse pump and dump?
 
psionl0 said:
(No description of how it resembles a ponzi scheme - just assertion).
I thought you'd read this thread, it's been mentioned repeatedly, and in the last few pages. Exchanges do not have the liquidity to pay out older investors because those older investors put less money in than they are being told they are due back and no new wealth is generated, so they need to use the money from new investors to pay out returns to old investors. That is certainly somewhat similar in execution to a ponzi scheme, whether it is intentionally so or not.

It's not like it's unexpected because the way the Bitcoin economy is set up requires it to be like that. (Assuming what you have failed to describe - let alone prove - is known as "begging the question").
At it's opening value (approx BTC 1 : USD 0.0007) the entire supply of Bitcoins that would ever exist would be worth $16,000 total. If it's going to both have an exchange rate against the dollar and be useful, it needs to be worth more than that... that much should be obvious. In the first year the creator and others are busy mining away generating BTC much more cheaply than today.

So in the beginning people knew that the price was going to have to rise massively and there were going to be literally millions of BTC that were obtained for less than market value leaving the exchanges to deal with the problem of the cash shortfall.

The vast majority of Bitcoin holders obtained theirs for much less than the current nominal price, and a sizable fraction were obtained for virtually nothing. (Even if there was something morally wrong about this making a profit on something has nothing to do with ponzi schemes)
Making a profit is the whole point of a ponzi scheme, but making a profit in itself is not an indication of one and I never said it was.

It's like a run on the banks (:yikes:), except one where all the banks said they'll pay out ten times the value of your deposits. Even if the banks had all the deposits in cash, which they don't, they couldn't pay out the full value of the promise by a long way. The value of their liabilities would vastly outstrip the value of theirs assets, and it's the same with Bitcoin. (Pure fiction but since bank runs are bad, we will say that bitcoin is a bank run just to make it sound bad).
If the current situation with the exchanges was more analogous to skiing or kissing a duck I would have said those things, but it's analogous to a bank run, so I said that.

Both situations involve a money handling institution facing more demand for withdrawals than they have liquid assets to fulfil.

Give me a better analogy if you're unsatisfied.
 
I thought you'd read this thread, it's been mentioned repeatedly, and in the last few pages. Exchanges do not have the liquidity to pay out older investors because those older investors put less money in than they are being told they are due back and no new wealth is generated, so they need to use the money from new investors to pay out returns to old investors. That is certainly somewhat similar in execution to a ponzi scheme, whether it is intentionally so or not.

[ ............... ]

Both situations involve a money handling institution facing more demand for withdrawals than they have liquid assets to fulfil.
What a load of rubbish! You clearly don't have the slightest clue how bitcoin exchanges work. They are not financial intermediaries like banks but brokerage firms. They match "asks" with "bids".

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/MtGox#Buying_and_selling
 
By design, bitcoin is a deflationary currency. Period. If you can't understand the implications of that even though they are evident, and view that as negative, stick with your fiat paper currency.
Yes, deflationary currencies are undesirable.

You may have noticed that the original bitcoin paper doesn't really suggest it's use as an independent currency, but as a payment system. That would go some way to explaining why it's so badly suited to that role and renders the fist-pumping "stick it to The Man" posturing as pretty pointless.
Fiat currency has lot of use, after all. Just think - you can't use bitcoin as firewood.
I also can't buy food with it at present either, which is one of my more pressing lifestyle issues.
Wait....they would just laugh at you unless you took up your collection in bitcoins....they wouldn't take your stupid paper dollars...

It's so UNFAIR (sayeth the banker politician and cronies) ....

....we didn't get part of THE LOOT!

BWHAHAHAHHAA!
Grow up. I probably live on less than the average banker spends on commuting, and I couldn't care less. I'm not gripped by jealousy that someone else somewhere is making money and I'm not. That you assume other people are bothered probably says more about you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom