How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
....mhaze, what do you suppose would happen if one of your putative Silicon Valley venture capitalists opened a Bitcoin exchange with, say, $20 million in capital? What makes you think there wouldn't be $20 million of immediate liquidation?

The venture capitalists would expect the Bitcoin exchange to make them a large multiple of the 20M investment?

Now where would I place my bets...
  • Your negativity???
  • Their vision???

Hmmm.....
 
Last edited:
Ah! So it's lack of government regulation and not fraud that defines a pump and dump or ponzi scheme.

That's an interesting dictionary you have. :rolleyes:

Huh? Lack of regulations don't define ponzi schemes. Please don't reply to my posts if all you have is straw.
 
And the Ponzi scheme using bitcoins, which of course Google reports (unlike JREF posts, which Google has stopped reporting) is not of bitcoin or bitcoin exchanges being a Ponzi scheme, but of a Ponzi scheme using bitcoins.

Nope. The bitcoin price is most likely manipulated by big holders and big exchanges by a classic ponzi scheme.


Thus your logical fallacy, the argument from popular opinion, fails to meet the standard for a logical fallacy.

Lol whut?
 
All that proves is that there are a lot of ignorant people around. Bitcoin itself is not a ponzi scheme.

Whether incompetence, fraud or banking difficulties make the exchanges unresponsive or slow is a matter of speculation. However, the principle on which they are supposed to run is similar to any stock exchange and has no ponzi aspect to it.
Banks and stock exchanges are regulated, bitcoin exchanges are not That's the difference. Pump and dump and Ponzi schemes are flourishing in such an environment.
Huh? Lack of regulations don't define ponzi schemes. Please don't reply to my posts if all you have is straw.
Who needs straw when you are so quick to contradict yourself?
 
Last edited:
I didn't contradict myself, my post wasn't about definitions.

I was commenting on your claim that bitcoin is not a ponzi:

However, the principle on which they are supposed to run is similar to any stock exchange and has no ponzi aspect to it.

Fraudsters don't care about principles on how it's "supposed" to work. They care about easy money. They weigh their actions on how easy it is to be caught, what punishment they risk, and what the potential reward is.

That's why banks/stock markets are strictly regulated - for example they have to report all sorts of information to the government and its law enforcement agencies, that makes it easier to uncover fraud, white washing, negligence, etc.

A market without these safeguards is an easy target for all kinds of fraud, ponzies included, and is very unsafe for the general public.
 
Transaction delays have nothing to do with the definition of "ponzi scheme". That is just a word you pulled out of your backside simply because you disapprove of bitcoin.
You keep telling yourself that people only say mean things about Bitcoin out of a deep-seated racial hatred of alternative currencies. :covereyes

Whether you think Bitcoin is intentionally a ponzi scheme or not, the behaviour of the people who exchange it for "real" money shares characteristics with one at the moment. It's not like it's unexpected because the way the Bitcoin economy is set up requires it to be like that. The vast majority of Bitcoin holders obtained theirs for much less than the current nominal price, and a sizable fraction were obtained for virtually nothing.

It's like a run on the banks, except one where all the banks said they'll pay out ten times the value of your deposits. Even if the banks had all the deposits in cash, which they don't, they couldn't pay out the full value of the promise by a long way. The value of their liabilities would vastly outstrip the value of theirs assets, and it's the same with Bitcoin.

It's obvious, and I'm sure most people are aware of it, but Bitcoin proponents seem to dance around it like it's not a big deal. Who in their right mind is going to give you $1000 today because you deposited $15 with them a year ago, and pretend they can run a sustainable business on that basis?
 
my post wasn't about definitions.

Fraudsters don't care about principles on how it's "supposed" to work. They care about easy money. They weigh their actions on how easy it is to be caught, what punishment they risk, and what the potential reward is.
Ponzi schemes are all frauds but not all frauds are ponzi schemes. The word "ponzi" is just thrown into the mix to make bitcoin or its exchanges appear worse than they really are. So you are right - your post isn't about definitions but about emotional appeals.

Any fraud that might be perpetuated by the bitcoin exchanges is simply a figment of your imagination. They might be committing frauds but you have no idea if that is the case or there are other reasons why there might be limits or delays on cashing out of these exchanges. If bitcoin exchanges were really ripping everybody off to the extent that is claimed (without evidence) in this forum then they wouldn't exist for long.

Your reasoning is about as logical as saying that just because there are anecdotes about lengthy delays some people experience in getting a tax refund that the tax office is just a ponzi scheme.
 
You keep telling yourself that people only say mean things about Bitcoin out of a deep-seated racial hatred of alternative currencies. :covereyes
That's because this is exactly what it is.

[.... irrelevant imaginings snipped ....]
Who in their right mind is going to give you $1000 today because you deposited $15 with them a year ago, and pretend they can run a sustainable business on that basis?
That's what you could have said when bitcoin was $15 - then $100 - then and unprecedented $260 at the height of the Cyprus crisis.

Anybody who thinks these sorts of gains are far from over will be happy to pay $1000 for bitcoins - even if the seller only paid 10c for them a few years ago.
 
You keep telling yourself that people only say mean things about Bitcoin out of a deep-seated racial hatred of alternative currencies. :covereyes

.... Who in their right mind is going to give you $1000 today because you deposited $15 with the...., and pretend they can run a sustainable business on that basis?

This thread started with bitcoin in the $2-30 range. People were advised of it's potential. They showed the same negativity, bias and prejudice that you have accurately called a racial hatred then as now. The huge number of irrational comments in this thread is in my opinion only the display of fear of change. Bitcoin is a highly disruptive technology and there is no way to modify that.

So I don't think you can use the $1000 number as a basis for argument. You have to use $2 as well as $1000 and all the numbers in between. It's all in black and white in this thread, you see.

The position of those explaining bitcoin in this thread has been remarkably consistent and unchanged in these two years regardless of the then current price.

So there is nothing wrong with my commenting that there is a serious potential for bitcoin to go to 10k, or 100k or 1M per coin. Consider for example if something like the 2008-2009 financial crisis occurred today. (yeah, it's likely to) Bitcoin will shoot through the roof as a result of EVENTS.

But we would prefer to see it's valuation increase as a result of increased utilization and transaction volume. Ease the worthless fiat currencies out gradually, without any panics or crises or human suffering. Give the banksters time to find honest jobs.

Cheers!
 
Last edited:
Can anyone show the biggest cash outs from mtgox lately? Would be interesting.
 
Can anyone show the biggest cash outs from mtgox lately? Would be interesting.

Only if knowing more facts about the cash outs would assist in the stereotyping and demonization of bitcoin.

And that demonization, that's the point!

:)
 
Only if knowing more facts about the cash outs would assist in the stereotyping and demonization of bitcoin.

And that demonization, that's the point!

:)

Funny, I'd think that if people were getting their money out of Mt. Gox you'd be the first to wave it in our faces.

I think it's an entirely reasonable question; what are the current processing times and withdrawal limits at Mt. Gox? I suspect that your response above is an indication that a factual answer would not be helpful to your cause.

ETA: Here's some interesting reading from the Bitcoin forum:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.2720
 
Last edited:
Only if knowing more facts about the cash outs would assist in the stereotyping and demonization of bitcoin.

And that demonization, that's the point!

:)

Facts hurt your case? That would be a red flag right there..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom