How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems clear to me that the payment transfer is not the most vulnerable part of the transaction--it is getting the contraband from point A to point B that exposes one most to law enforcement interdiction. Bitcoin offers no protection in that realm.
 
If the package is non-descript, and done on a small-scale, it would be like a teardrop in the rain. Hidden in such a tidal wave of other packages and mailings, 99.999% of which are boring and legal, and which the government can't exactly go tearing through.

And I see that in my attempt to clarify my previous post, I apparently copy/pasted a paragraph instead of cut/pasting it, making it appear twice. Lovely.
 
And yet busts are still made all the time, that changing from cash to bitcoin wouldn't prevent. I'm not disagreeing that it might present a new challenge, but it's hardly a game-changer.

DEA: Oh no, they're using bitcoins. We might as well fold up shop, folks. See you on the unemployment line.
 
Last edited:
If the package is non-descript, and done on a small-scale, it would be like a teardrop in the rain. Hidden in such a tidal wave of other packages and mailings, 99.999% of which are boring and legal, and which the government can't exactly go tearing through.

In other words, transactions using bitcoins can stay safe from government oversight and control in the exact same way that transactions using money can stay safe from the government. So where is the added benefit?
 
Last edited:
Maybe EGarrett hasn't noticed, but it was the US government that forced civil rights onto the southerners in the 60's.
 
And yet busts are still made all the time, that changing from cash to bitcoin wouldn't prevent. I'm not disagreeing that it might present a new challenge, but it's hardly a game-changer.

DEA: Oh no, they're using bitcoins. We might as well fold up shop, folks. See you on the unemployment line.
What type of busts are you referring to when you say "busts are made all the time?" You have to be much more specific.

In other words, transactions using bitcoins can stay safe from government oversight and control in the exact same way that transactions using money can stay safe from the government. So where is the added benefit?
No, because distance transactions using instant and convenient payment require financial institutions with public records, which the government squeezes to try and control what you can and can't buy. I've had first-hand experience with this as an online poker player.

Maybe EGarrett hasn't noticed, but it was the US government that forced civil rights onto the southerners in the 60's.
...by repealing laws passed by state governments. That's a bit like telling me I shouldn't worry about a dog ******* on the carpet because every now and then they eat their own feces.

(I apologize if that's too strong an analogy, but when it came to me I had to say it)
 
What type of busts are you referring to when you say "busts are made all the time?" You have to be much more specific.

Any arrests made by investigating other than the payment in an illegal transaction.

No, because distance transactions using instant and convenient payment require financial institutions with public records, which the government squeezes to try and control what you can and can't buy. I've had first-hand experience with this as an online poker player.

If we're talking about physical packages, as you did, it is just as easy to send a package of cash as it is to send a package of goods.

In the case of online gambling it may represent a significant obstacle, but I can't think of many other industries that the government watchdogs, that could run with impunity just by switching to bitcoins for transactions.

Bear in mind I don't deny the effect in some cases--I only disagree with where you seemed to say that it represents an overwhelming change in the government's ability to regulate our activities.
 
Any arrests made by investigating other than the payment in an illegal transaction.
I can't tell if you're talking about drug-dealers working in cash, people doing illegal transactions online with payment processors, people buying in hookers in Vegas or what...nor do I know exactly what methods you're referring to. I'm saying that Bitcoin makes it much, much more difficult for the government to control online free-market purchases and exchanges of money...so if you're going to say that the government does bust people, I need you to be more specific so I can see exactly which methods you're referring to that you feel will still work.

If we're talking about physical packages, as you did, it is just as easy to send a package of cash as it is to send a package of goods.
Not instantly and conveniently.

In the case of online gambling it may represent a significant obstacle, but I can't think of many other industries that the government watchdogs, that could run with impunity just by switching to bitcoins for transactions.
Silk Road is the most prominent and timely example. Imagine what would happen if you tried to charge an order of cocaine on your credit card?

Bear in mind I don't deny the effect in some cases--I only disagree with where you seemed to say that it represents an overwhelming change in the government's ability to regulate our activities.
Well, the online gambling industry is a multi-billion dollar business, and I think it's safe to say that the drug trade is a multi-billion dollar business as well. So, just for starters, we immediately have several multi-billion-dollar industries that will skyrocket (whether we like it or not) if Bitcoins become largely accepted. I would consider that a major change.

Secondly, and this is probably far more important...Bitcoin could potentially shutdown the income tax. If they can't tell which string of characters corresponds to which person, business, or purpose (and it appears that you can change your personal string of characters at will)...it would be the same as if everyone involved suddenly started doing business in person, in cash. The government can no longer know how much money you made, and for what.

The entire notion of double-taxation (tax your income, then tax your spending) would fall apart...government revenues would be crippled. It would be a massive shrink of the government, by dramatic, abrupt starvation instead of the decades of polite requests that have resulted only in a slower-rate of fattening. I'm sure you see the incredible potential implications of that.
 
Last edited:
As has already been mentioned, assuming that governments still exist [...] the bitcoin, even if used extensively and securely for transactions, will fail the instant that a major economic power decides not to honor them.


I think you're unintentionally implying that major economic powers already honor Bitcoin; they don't. So, to be more accurate, the only way Bitcoin can succeed is if major economic powers decide to honor them.

And not even "major" economic powers, either. Bitcoin isn't going to get very far if your landlord refuses to accept them for your monthly rent, your local car dealership refuses to accept them as a down payment on a vehicle, or your local grocery store refuses to accept them as payment for the food you take from their shelves.
 
It seems clear to me that the payment transfer is not the most vulnerable part of the transaction--it is getting the contraband from point A to point B that exposes one most to law enforcement interdiction. Bitcoin offers no protection in that realm.
Not necessarily. It depends on how the law is worded. If the law draws a distinction between mere distribution and distribution for profit (selling) then the use of bitcoins might make it harder to prove the selling aspect. (OTOH I am aware that in many jurisdictions, mere possession of more than a minimum amount automatically makes you a dealer).

I think you're unintentionally implying that major economic powers already honor Bitcoin; they don't. So, to be more accurate, the only way Bitcoin can succeed is if major economic powers decide to honor them.
All you need are money merchants who are willing to trade in bitcoins and bitcoin becomes currency.
 
All you need are money merchants who are willing to trade in bitcoins and bitcoin becomes currency.

Willing and legally able to trade in bitcoins. It would be simple enough to legislate against such use, and then what would bitcoins be worth? A drug-dealer isn't going to sell you drugs for bitcoins if the only thing he can use bitcoins for is buying drugs from other drug dealers. At some point, bitcoins would have to connect into the economy proper -- and that interface would be simple enough to shut down.
 
Not instantly and conveniently.

Yes, bitcoins are slightly more convenient (for the buyer -- it's less convenient for the seller) for buying stuff online than cash is. But that's all -- it doesn't bring anything new to the table. (Well, except a paper trail which gives the police a little more to work with than cash does.)
 
Nobody uses Bitcoin as a currency except a handful of criminal enterprises, small-time webdesign firms, and hippie beadwork merchants. Why is that? If it's such a great currency, why isn't it being used as a currency by many online businesses?

Bitcoin doesn't work as a currency. It doesn't do a good job at any of the proper functions of a currency. It's far too unstable and volatile to be practical for business. There's no protection or legal recourse against fraud and theft. The exchanges are untrustworthy and unreliable. The runaway deflation (read: overvaluation) punishes spending, so it strongly hinders trade. Despite its overvaluation, there's no consumer confidence in it. Worst of all, Bitcoin is hardly accepted anywhere for all those reasons.

The only way to even obtain Bitcoin these days is to receive an online payment in it, do the "mining" thing (the creators' pyramid scheme setup, which is prohibitive to private citizens by this point), or deal with the unreliable, insecure and untrustworthy exchanges.

Of those 3 options, accepting Bitcoins as payment for goods or services is the only reasonable option; but why would anyone accept payment in Bitcoin, when they can't even spend it anywhere. You still have to use the shady, unprofessional and unreliable Bitcoin exchanges to cash it in for your local currency.

Though it admittedly employs some impressive math and crypto, Bitcoin is just pathetically badly conceived as a currency. Where it really shines, though, is as a platform for Ponzi games and other scams.
 
Last edited:
... People choose to be members of their society on an ongoing basis by continuing to live in and receive the benefits of that society. ...

The choice is pretty limited. There is not a place on earth where I can go instead and live under no state's jurisdiction. So one's choice is (in mst cases) either the country they were (involuntary) born to, or some other state with rules and benefits and drawbacks. But can I pick any state, can I pick the best among them? No, because many states just won't let me choose to live there. Often, a 3 months tourist visa is the most I can get. Even if I get a long term visa or residence permit, almost everywhere I am subjected to discriminations that neither my home country nor the citizens of the chosen country suffer. Some of these are state-imposed (restrictions on my right to work, for example), imposed by the population (plain old xenophobia), or arise as practical matters (such as language barriers). The choice is thus heavily geared and biased towards the state I originate from.
 
...
You mentioned enforcing its acceptance as legal tender. If I own a business and decide I only want to accept bitcoins and refuse to accept dollars, are you saying the government has the ability to force me to accept dollars?

I don't know about the legal situation in the USA, but I understand that at least in Germany, this is so: Any business is, in principle, required to accept the official currency of the land (the Euro as we speak) in cash. There are probably exceptions that arise from practical considerations: For example, many gas stations do not accept 500 Euro bills; I don't know if that is because of the risk of forgeries, or because they don't guarantee to have enough change in the drawer. Also, I guess bills exceeding certain cash sums ("millions") may be excempted.
 
I don't know about the legal situation in the USA, but I understand that at least in Germany, this is so: Any business is, in principle, required to accept the official currency of the land (the Euro as we speak) in cash.
Here's a short US Treasury FAQ for US policy on currency as legal tender. Businesses in the US can determine what they will accept in exchange for goods and services and thus aren't required to accept US currency. This is at least true at the time of an exchange being made, so for example if I want to buy a candy bar, the merchant can ask that I pay with a dozen plastic buttons while refusing to accept a US dollar in exchange. It gets more complicated if one is attempting to resolve a debt, but the presumption would be that debts should be measured in US dollars unless otherwise specified in a legal contract.
There are probably exceptions that arise from practical considerations: For example, many gas stations do not accept 500 Euro bills; I don't know if that is because of the risk of forgeries, or because they don't guarantee to have enough change in the drawer. Also, I guess bills exceeding certain cash sums ("millions") may be excempted.
Under US Federal Law, businesses can refuse to accept particular denominations of US currency in exchange for goods and services based on practical considerations such as not wishing to keep large amounts of money on hand in order to provide change for large bills (convenience stores, gas stations, and such) or not wishing to handle large numbers of coins for a high-dollar transaction (20,000 pennies is extremely inconvenient payment to accept in a $200 transaction).
 
Yes, bitcoins are slightly more convenient (for the buyer -- it's less convenient for the seller) for buying stuff online than cash is. But that's all -- it doesn't bring anything new to the table. (Well, except a paper trail which gives the police a little more to work with than cash does.)
That's like saying youtube is slightly more convenient for spreading videos than mailing VHS tapes is. The notion of instant, world-wide, fee-free connection and distribution is not minor.
 
By the way, one of the noteworthy things about Bitcoin transactions, and you see this on the Bitcoin scam threads, is that it's nigh impossible to prove the purpose of a transaction and whether or not it was voluntary. Even the people who start the threads to claim that they were stolen from can't actually prove that that's what happened. If one of the people actually involved in the transaction, who knows you and doesn't like you, can't prove that you did something wrong, imagine how astonishingly difficult it is for someone outside the transaction who don't know either of you. Think of Silk Road, they are an organized, public institution that blatantly trading in illegal drugs, not even attempting to conceal it, using bitcoin transactions.

I mean tell you over the internet or phone. There's tons of ways to make my information accessible without it being associated with any kind of transaction or even realistically knowable. You can share your information publicly, with your business partner being of many who has access to it, you can have encrypted Skype conversations, you can even have a BS chat over some random instant messenger about the weather or your birthday party plans in which innocuous-seeming info is mentioned.

The scam threads are precisely the reason why nobody other than nerd circles, cybercriminals and rabid libertarians is using BTC. It is simply too risky for anyone else, too many scams, too many lost wallets due to hacking, weak exchanges. There are too many security issues.
 
That's like saying youtube is slightly more convenient for spreading videos than mailing VHS tapes is. The notion of instant, world-wide, fee-free connection and distribution is not minor.

Fee-free? The constant risk of loss through hacking is a substantial fee, I´d say, and one which is completely unpredictable, in contrast to regular fees.
 
The scam threads are precisely the reason why nobody other than nerd circles, cybercriminals and rabid libertarians is using BTC. It is simply too risky for anyone else, too many scams, too many lost wallets due to hacking, weak exchanges. There are too many security issues.
All you're saying is that it's desirable for someone to develop convenient security software or security sites to accompany the Bitcoin client. That's inevitable...and is probably so easy to implement that I wouldn't even be surprised if they're free and open-sourced.

Fee-free? The constant risk of loss through hacking is a substantial fee, I´d say, and one which is completely unpredictable, in contrast to regular fees.
That's not a fee. Fees and risks are two different things (for example, cliff diving is highly risky, but costs no money). The lack of fees in using Bitcoin is one of the major points in its favor, and is separate from the risk of theft (if the risk of theft were nearly eliminated, the lack of fees would still be a positive). Let's not change word definitions and mix categories because the conversation will become messy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom