How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
See Mhaze's post #3897. 50 BTC/day limit at Coinbase.

Someone upthread actually compiled the withdrawal limits and expected wait times for withdrawals at various exchanges; the wait times were typically in weeks and withdrawal limits were usually in the $20-50K range. I'll see if I can find the post.
To clarify, 50BTC immediate, same day deposit or credit at Coinbase for consumer account fully verified.

Merchant accounts are different and may be expected to be higher.
 
Out of the entire list at spendbitcoins.com/places/, the very first link I went to (myonlyvice.com :boxedin:) says

We accept all major Credit and Debit Cards including American Express, PayPal and hope to include Bitcoin to this list soon.
 
Transaction delays have nothing to do with the definition of "ponzi scheme". That is just a word you pulled out of your backside simply because you disapprove of bitcoin.

As babycondor pointed out, the way the exchanges are presently being run is pretty much the textbook definition of a Ponzi scheme.

I don't "disapprove" of Bitcoin; I think the tech behind it is useful, and will no doubt eventually be coopted by one or more of the big banks. Bitcoin as presently constituted, though, is nothing more than an extremely speculative investment; it has practically no value as "currency", nor will it until the volatility issues abate. All the handwaving in the world and anecdotes about Starbucks cards and pizzas will not make it otherwise.
 
As babycondor pointed out, the way the exchanges are presently being run is pretty much the textbook definition of a Ponzi scheme. ...

You are welcome to go look up the textbook definition, and post here on this forum the various definitional points one by one which define Ponzi and how you are wrong on each of them. Just blurting out the words and the attribution does not support your claim, and neither is your claim supported by the fact that one other individual agrees with you.
 
No, that is not even close to the words in posts I have made, or the actual reality of operations in exchanges. Not in the least. It's called 'making things up'.

Here is what you wrote:


....
Suppose there was a surge of activity, and exchanges take money in but wait a week or two before delivering coin. That's cash in their hands from the new buyers to pay off the new sellers. That's the exact reverse of a 'liquidity problem'.
....

That's the exact definition of a Ponzi.
 
Roller Coaster ride anyone?
No, I think I'll discuss from the point of view of Technical Analysis (satirical).

The Amplitude of the Ascending Tops is Huge, so Andrew's Pitchfork is having it's expected effect on the Ascending Triangles, offset in part by the Bearish Abandoned Baby. The Blowoff after the Blow off Top is clear and we expect a Breakaway Gap soon. The Bullish Homing Pigeon came home to roost. There was a nice Coppock Curve, followed by Corrective Waves and the Climax.

Man, that Hindenburg Omen after the Island Reversal was something to see. Expect to see Momentum Investors come in and the McClennan Oscillator effect, with price gains caused by the Polarized Fractal Efficiency curves. Some will Sell into Strength, ignoring the SHooting Stars on the Signal Line.
 
Here is what you wrote:
Originally Posted by mhaze
....
Suppose there was a surge of activity, and exchanges take money in but wait a week or two before delivering coin. That's cash in their hands from the new buyers to pay off the new sellers. That's the exact reverse of a 'liquidity problem'.

....

That's the exact definition of a Ponzi.

A liquidity problem, which is not a Ponzi scheme at all, is ...

cash in hand from new buyers paying off old sellers...

Your comment does not even rise to the level of "wrong".
 
A liquidity problem, which is not a Ponzi scheme at all, is ...

cash in hand from new buyers paying off old sellers...

Your comment does not even rise to the level of "wrong".

Relates more to a pump and dump which is what goes on regularly with bitcoin. The problem here is that the pump was too effective and normal liquidity isn't going to occur above $150 and probably not until a return below $50 or so.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponzi_scheme

This is exactly what the Bitcoin exchanges are doing. It also has the unintended consequence of tying the hands of the Bitwhales; they can't get their money out all at once, so they're taking it as they can.

Just ot of idle curiosity, mhaze, what do you suppose would happen if one of your putative Silicon Valley venture capitalists opened a Bitcoin exchange with, say, $20 million in capital? What makes you think there wouldn't be $20 million of immediate liquidation?
 
You are welcome to go look up the textbook definition, and post here on this forum the various definitional points one by one which define Ponzi and how you are wrong on each of them. Just blurting out the words and the attribution does not support your claim, and neither is your claim supported by the fact that one other individual agrees with you.

Google "Bitcoin ponzi" and you will discover how many others agree.
 
Google "Bitcoin ponzi" and you will discover how many others agree.
All that proves is that there are a lot of ignorant people around. Bitcoin itself is not a ponzi scheme.

Whether incompetence, fraud or banking difficulties make the exchanges unresponsive or slow is a matter of speculation. However, the principle on which they are supposed to run is similar to any stock exchange and has no ponzi aspect to it.
 
Banks and stock exchanges are regulated, bitcoin exchanges are not That's the difference. Pump and dump and Ponzi schemes are flourishing in such an environment.
 
Last edited:
Banks and stock exchanges are regulated, bitcoin exchanges are not That's the difference. Pump and dump and Ponzi schemes are flourishing in such an environment.
Ah! So it's lack of government regulation and not fraud that defines a pump and dump or ponzi scheme.

That's an interesting dictionary you have. :rolleyes:
 
Strange, at the moment MtGox is the only one over $1000/coin all the other exchanges on bitcoin wisdom are about $100 below that.
Possibly because you might see real money using one of the other exchanges.

That's hilarious. Interesting how the comments show how utterly stupid the bitbugs are.

Overstock.com had $1.1 billion in revenue last year. Let's do a thought experiment.

Suppose their revenue is flat this year, but they do 0.1% of their sales in BTC. That's $1.1 million. Do all of the exchanges, combined, have $1.1 million in liquidity to pay Overstock off? They're gonna want their money... and not in BTC.
Maybe, but how will it effect others trying to cash out?

The commenter on Wildy's link who referred to it as "libertarian funbux" really hasn't got it too terribly wrong; but then libs are often goldbugs too, so it's very similar.
I prefer "Dunning-Krugerrands".

Banks and stock exchanges are regulated, bitcoin exchanges are not That's the difference. Pump and dump and Ponzi schemes are flourishing in such an environment.
And outright scams like Project: Black Flag.
 
As I posted above, it would exacerbate the liquidity crunch dramatically; possibly to the point where the entire edifice simply couldn't function because Overstock had drained off all the available cash.

And *snerk* at "Dunning-Krugerrands".
I suspect that the liquidity of the exchanges is the only thing keeping the scam going, it's in the crash phase but moving in slow motion.
 
As I posted above, it would exacerbate the liquidity crunch dramatically; possibly to the point where the entire edifice simply couldn't function because Overstock had drained off all the available cash.

And *snerk* at "Dunning-Krugerrands".

Got it! Market expansion and growth is SCARY AND BAD!

ROFL.....Yes, seriously disruptive technology is SCARY!

By the way, I do like your term "liquidity crunch". Like liquidity is tiny crunchy morsels. Maybe like popcorn. Bitcoin at the movies, downing his biggie cup of like crunchy liquidity morsels, sprinkled and flavored with end game fiat. Spectacle on the big screen of little humans trying to cope with his little bitcoins spreading in every direction.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REvmhBO99I4
 
Google "Bitcoin ponzi" and you will discover how many others agree.

Ah! So it's lack of government regulation and not fraud that defines a pump and dump or ponzi scheme.

That's an interesting dictionary you have. :rolleyes:

Especially since there has been a criminal indictment for a Ponzi scheme using bitcoins. Apparently the cops don't need or care about your government regulation.

And the Ponzi scheme using bitcoins, which of course Google reports (unlike JREF posts, which Google has stopped reporting) is not of bitcoin or bitcoin exchanges being a Ponzi scheme, but of a Ponzi scheme using bitcoins.

Thus your logical fallacy, the argument from popular opinion, fails to meet the standard for a logical fallacy.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom