How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Doesn't matter. For bitcoins to have value, it must be possible to reliably convert them to real world currencies. That means exchanges, and exchanges can be found and shut down.

Not necessarily, though. Bitcoins have value as soon as I can buy stuff with them. It is highly unlikely for this to be so without a means to convert bitcoins to other currencies, but not necessarily impossible.

And if bitcoins are not legal tender, not a real currency, then the exchanges aren't illegal on grounds of exchanging one kind of money for another, are they?
 
What would be the law's position on these things being stolen? Let's say that someone does steal 500 Bitcoins, and for some reason the transaction/s can't be rolled back, but it can be proved who did it. Would this legally be theft, or... I don't know?
 
And if bitcoins are not legal tender, not a real currency, then the exchanges aren't illegal on grounds of exchanging one kind of money for another, are they?

Exchanges are regulated because they would need to take deposits, keep funds, keep accounts, transfer funds, etc. All of these activities can only be performed by authorised institutions, so if the exchanges are not registered at the moment, they are running an illegal financial operation.
 
What would be the law's position on these things being stolen? Let's say that someone does steal 500 Bitcoins, and for some reason the transaction/s can't be rolled back, but it can be proved who did it. Would this legally be theft, or... I don't know?

It really depends on what Bitcoin is from a legal perspective. This is an open question at the moment, but I don't think it's useful to think of theft. If someone hacks your account and "steals" your Bitcoins, it would be covered under hacking laws that forbid an unauthorised person to enter your account and make any modification. This applies to everything, from email to World of Warcraft, so you might be better off pursuing it that way.

If Bitcoins are illegal, then there would be no theft.
 
Not necessarily, though. Bitcoins have value as soon as I can buy stuff with them. It is highly unlikely for this to be so without a means to convert bitcoins to other currencies, but not necessarily impossible.

While it might be theoretically possible, I don't think it's possible in practice. A business has expenses which must be paid in dollars (or whatever the real-world currency of their country of operation is): wages, sales tax, insurance premiums, utilities, interests on loans, postage, custom duties and so on. Without a way to convert bitcoins to dollars, they won't be able to cover their expenses.

Now, granted, they could do a mix economy, selling in both dollars and bitcoins, using their dollar sales to cover "hard currency expenses" and using their bitcoins sales to buy services and goods available in bitcoins. The trouble is, it's not going to be worth it, because you can't use a surplus of bitcoins for anything. You can't pay it out in wages, you can't invest it in another company, you can't use it to pay dividends; in short you can't use it to make more dollars (or even to make more bitcoins). Your business is still dollar-driven: it's your income in dollar that determines how well your business is doing and whether you will swim or sink.

Basically, every single sale you do in bitcoins carries with it a massive opportunity cost. Where the income from a sale in dollars can be used for anything you want or need, an income of bitcoins can only be used for buying whatever goods and services a) you require and b) are available for sale in bitcoins.

Now, while it's true that it's sometimes worth taking an opportunity cost in order to expand into a new market, that's not the case in this situation. Your business is dollar-driven, so you can't expand without an increase in dollar income. An increase in bitcoins income is just going to make you accrue bitcoins in excess of what you can use.

And if bitcoins are not legal tender, not a real currency, then the exchanges aren't illegal on grounds of exchanging one kind of money for another, are they?

They may not be illegal today, but if bitcoins ever grows to the point where it shows up on the political radar, it would be a simple matter for a government to amend the legislature to make them illegal.
 
While it might be theoretically possible, I don't think it's possible in practice. A business has expenses which must be paid in dollars (or whatever the real-world currency of their country of operation is): wages, sales tax, insurance premiums, utilities, interests on loans, postage, custom duties and so on. Without a way to convert bitcoins to dollars, they won't be able to cover their expenses.

Now, granted, they could do a mix economy, selling in both dollars and bitcoins, using their dollar sales to cover "hard currency expenses" and using their bitcoins sales to buy services and goods available in bitcoins. The trouble is, it's not going to be worth it, because you can't use a surplus of bitcoins for anything. You can't pay it out in wages, you can't invest it in another company, you can't use it to pay dividends; in short you can't use it to make more dollars (or even to make more bitcoins). Your business is still dollar-driven: it's your income in dollar that determines how well your business is doing and whether you will swim or sink.

Basically, every single sale you do in bitcoins carries with it a massive opportunity cost. Where the income from a sale in dollars can be used for anything you want or need, an income of bitcoins can only be used for buying whatever goods and services a) you require and b) are available for sale in bitcoins.

Now, while it's true that it's sometimes worth taking an opportunity cost in order to expand into a new market, that's not the case in this situation. Your business is dollar-driven, so you can't expand without an increase in dollar income. An increase in bitcoins income is just going to make you accrue bitcoins in excess of what you can use.

I was going to explain a counter example but then realized it wouldn't work for more than a small part of the bitcoin-economy. Yes, one would need a whole economy running on bitcoins if no exchanges for dollars should ever be needed. (FWIW, I thought a business might need enough of one resource to always be able to spend all available bitcoins on it whilst sales would never exceed the demand for the resource. But that would be rather rare and the problem of what to do with the bitcoins would then lie with the provider of the ressource.)

They may not be illegal today, but if bitcoins ever grows to the point where it shows up on the political radar, it would be a simple matter for a government to amend the legislature to make them illegal.

Possibly. I was really just doubting the claims that they were already illegal and specifically that using bitcoins would amount to counterfeiting.
 
Possibly. I was really just doubting the claims that they were already illegal and specifically that using bitcoins would amount to counterfeiting.

Yes, I think those claims are wrong. I was arguing against the view that bitcoins are somehow bulletproof against government control or regulation. It seems obvious to me that even if the government can't affect the transfer of bitcoins between holders, they don't need to: they just need to be able to shut down the "interfaces" between bitcoins and normal currencies and bitcoins will end up effectively valueless.
 
Amir Taaki said:
The supply of bitcoins is 21 million. The supply of money is infinite. A bitcoin can currently be divided to 8 decimal places.

I do not think he knows what "infinite" means.
 
I first discovered these Monday and was fascinated by just about every video I watched and article I read. I have a Bitcoin wallet now with an astonishing 1 and a half cents in it and will probably be giving it a try with some disposable income in the near future.

I'm also fascinated by the way these fairly quickly surpassed the U.S. dollar in value and what we'll be able to learn about a currency that operates under sheer supply and demand forces without "helpful" oversights and regulations. The $500,000 "theft" on one of the exchange sites caused a pseudo-crash that lasted mere minutes before the currency rebounded on its own.

In many ways I would think this a libertarian wet-dream. And a great way to test some free-market theories that have been debated endlessly with a shortage of objective, modern examples.

On top of all that, it's also evidence that the internet's free trade possibilities will eventually destroy any government's ability to stop its citizens from participating in voluntary private transactions. Bitcoin seems to "fund" a lot of black market activity, including drugs and online poker, but obviously this new spike in "evil" crimes against the self has had no apparent negative effect on society. We shall see if one emerges, since many people love to claim that these sorts of things must be controlled by well-meaning overseers of people's personal freedoms...but of course, regardless, it appears that the nanny-wand is being forcefully removed from big-government and big-government voter's hands...and individual freedom is going to take over whether they like it or not. We can only stand back and observe the results. I wouldn't have it any other way.
 
Yes, I think those claims are wrong. I was arguing against the view that bitcoins are somehow bulletproof against government control or regulation. It seems obvious to me that even if the government can't affect the transfer of bitcoins between holders, they don't need to: they just need to be able to shut down the "interfaces" between bitcoins and normal currencies and bitcoins will end up effectively valueless.

As has already been mentioned, assuming that governments still exist, (pokes head out of door, fails to notice anything unusually on fire,) the bitcoin, even if used extensively and securely for transactions, will fail the instant that a major economic power decides not to honor them. You want to secure land? Well, the US decides that loans secured by bitcoin don't meet the requirements to be protected by all the government assurances and protections that make "your land" definable in the first place. Bitcoins immediately lose value.
Of course, Libertarians deny that "their land" is in any way protected by any sort of governmental authority, it is merely bounded by awesomeness.
 
@ EGarrett,
You say, "the nanny-wand is being forcefully removed from . . . big-government voter's (sic) hands...and individual freedom is going to take over whether they like it or not." (emphasis mine)
So, to be clear about this, you are against democracy or republicanism, prefering powerful individuals to be able to control society as they see fit, with no checks on their power?
 
I first discovered these Monday and was fascinated by just about every video I watched and article I read. I have a Bitcoin wallet now with an astonishing 1 and a half cents in it and will probably be giving it a try with some disposable income in the near future.

I'm also fascinated by the way these fairly quickly surpassed the U.S. dollar in value and what we'll be able to learn about a currency that operates under sheer supply and demand forces without "helpful" oversights and regulations. The $500,000 "theft" on one of the exchange sites caused a pseudo-crash that lasted mere minutes before the currency rebounded on its own.

In many ways I would think this a libertarian wet-dream. And a great way to test some free-market theories that have been debated endlessly with a shortage of objective, modern examples.

On top of all that, it's also evidence that the internet's free trade possibilities will eventually destroy any government's ability to stop its citizens from participating in voluntary private transactions. Bitcoin seems to "fund" a lot of black market activity, including drugs and online poker, but obviously this new spike in "evil" crimes against the self has had no apparent negative effect on society. We shall see if one emerges, since many people love to claim that these sorts of things must be controlled by well-meaning overseers of people's personal freedoms...but of course, regardless, it appears that the nanny-wand is being forcefully removed from big-government and big-government voter's hands...and individual freedom is going to take over whether they like it or not. We can only stand back and observe the results. I wouldn't have it any other way.

I'm not sure how trading in bitcoins instead of cash can prevent the government from prohibiting things.
 
@ EGarrett,
You say, "the nanny-wand is being forcefully removed from . . . big-government voter's (sic) hands...and individual freedom is going to take over whether they like it or not." (emphasis mine)
So, to be clear about this, you are against democracy or republicanism, prefering powerful individuals to be able to control society as they see fit, with no checks on their power?
No, I'm not prefering (sic) that. Just like civil rights, I don't think basic human personal freedoms should be up to a vote. What you do in your OWN home, without harming anyone else, is your own business and not up to public scrutiny or the will of someone else in a voting booth.

Political parties (both democrat and republican) LOVE to try to use the hand of government to reach into your pocket or your underwear and grab at your money or your sexual organs and try to take them over...trying to force you to give your income away to others, or force you to only fall in love with certain groups of people, and so on. No matter which major US party gets power, they WILL be trying to take away certain private freedoms...it was and is a sort-of Catch-22, inescapable situation. But what we're seeing here is a major sign that the internet, almost like some kind of electronic-messiah, is going to come in and neuter this sort-of behavior by the government and the voters, permanently.

I think this is why michaelsuede and so many others are basically creaming their pants over this little viral currency program. I didn't realize that there even COULD be a way out. But Ian Malcolm was right. Life finds a way. Life, liberty, intelligence, and good (the way I see it) is finding a way...despite all the old-fashioned and obstinate bureaucrats, third-world regimes, entrenched government institutions, naive and ignorant voters convinced by charismatic speeches, riot police forces, doomsday military weapons...and trillions of unearned dollars backing all of it. It can (and probably WILL) be overpowered by people's urge to be free. What a millennium.
 
I'm not sure how trading in bitcoins instead of cash can prevent the government from prohibiting things.
I want to buy something the government doesn't like. You want to sell something the government doesn't like. I anonymously send you bitcoins. You send me a non-descript package. How does the government stop this?
 
Last edited:
I anonymously send you bitcoins. You send me a non-descript package.

If you're anonymous, how do I send you a package? If you're not anonymous to me, why not just use cash? Cash doesn't leave a transaction path.
 
I tell you my address. The bitcoin transaction can be anonymous, that doesn't mean you have no way of knowing me.

Yes, but in that case you'd be better off just using cash. So what's the point of bitcoins again?
 
By the way, one of the noteworthy things about Bitcoin transactions, and you see this on the Bitcoin scam threads, is that it's nigh impossible to prove the purpose of a transaction and whether or not it was voluntary. Even the people who start the threads to claim that they were stolen from can't actually prove that that's what happened. If one of the people actually involved in the transaction, who knows you and doesn't like you, can't prove that you did something wrong, imagine how astonishingly difficult it is for someone outside the transaction who don't know either of you. Think of Silk Road, they are an organized, public institution that blatantly trading in illegal drugs, not even attempting to conceal it, using bitcoin transactions.

Yes, but in that case you'd be better off just using cash. So what's the point of bitcoins again?
I mean tell you over the internet or phone. There's tons of ways to make my information accessible without it being associated with any kind of transaction or even realistically knowable. You can share your information publicly, with your business partner being of many who has access to it, you can have encrypted Skype conversations, you can even have a BS chat over some random instant messenger about the weather or your birthday party plans in which innocuous-seeming info is mentioned.

One of the noteworthy things about Bitcoin transactions, and you see this on the Bitcoin scam threads, is that it's nigh impossible to prove the purpose of a transaction and whether or not it was voluntary. Even the people who start the threads to claim that they were stolen from can't actually prove that that's what happened. If one of the people actually involved in the transaction, who knows you and doesn't like you, can't prove that you did something wrong, imagine how astonishingly difficult it is for someone outside the transaction who doesn't know either of you. Think of Silk Road, they are an organized, public business that's blatantly trading in illegal drugs, not even attempting to conceal it, using bitcoin transactions.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom