How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

A common one is about the way airplanes fly. The most commonly seen explanation is that air streams are traversing different distances in the same time and that one must therefore be traveling faster and have lower pressure because of the Bernoulli effect.

Something like this may contribute somewhat, but it certainly isn't the predominant mechanism by which airplanes maintain lift. A more important factor is that the airfoil creates a low density region as it displaces air with its foremost part and this lowered density (not the Bernoulli Effect) is responsible for the lowered pressure above the wing.

This is, of course, combined with the upward component of drag force on the lower part of the wing, which is generally tilted upward. There's a lot more to it as well, but the most commonly seen explanation is wrong.


When I was in high school I had a teacher who insisted that the force of lift comes from low pressure areas above the wing "pulling" the wing up rather than a high pressure area pushing it up. I countered that that's not really true and that low pressure doesn't "pull" anything, but that it was just no longer pushing equally against the high pressure. The teacher refused to reverse positions and another student told about how he saw someone "from NASA" say the same thing on a documentary. Everyone sort of nodded about how that should end the matter, so I just sat there a bit taken aback.
 
How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

.....that masturbation causes blindness.

I know this is a critical thinking forum, but please don't ask me for evidence ;)
 
Cool page about how planes fly - http://www.allstar.fiu.edu/AERO/airflylvl3.htm

Back to topic:

A few things that come to mind ...

Acne is a result of bad diet.

Don't go swimming for an hour after you eat. You will get a cramp and drown.

Wetlands are a bad thing, and should be drained and have houses built on them.
 
Last edited:
I think most people believe, purely due to its name, that a killer whale (orca) is a whale.

~~ Paul

It is. Dolphins, and the related orcas, are whales. The most common useage refers to the suborder Odontoceti, the toothed whales, which includes killer whales, pilot whales and melon-headed whales. Sperm whales are also toothed whales, but diverged further back and are not usually grouped with the others, although they are more closely related than either group is to baleen whales.
 
Yeah, but it's a lever in the way a tire iron is a lever, not the way a crowbar is a lever. I get hung up on semantics.

I think you mean 'lug wrench', not 'tire iron'. You would know the difference if you had ever dismounted a tire from a rim- by hand. A tire iron IS used like a crow bar. A lug wrench or a screwdriver is used to transmit rotational force- like a gear tooth. Or a lever....
 
I think you mean 'lug wrench', not 'tire iron'. You would know the difference if you had ever dismounted a tire from a rim- by hand. A tire iron IS used like a crow bar. A lug wrench or a screwdriver is used to transmit rotational force- like a gear tooth. Or a lever....

Ah, yes, yes, I meant a lug wrench. I should have just said wrench, full stop. Sigh. I always manage to show off what an idiot I am when I post here. Heheh.
 
Wetlands are a bad thing, and should be drained and have houses built on them.
Wetlands are DEFINITELY a bad thing in the World of Warcraft.

Young, bright-eyed level 7 Night Elves who want to play with their human/dwarf/gnome buddies in Ironforge or Stormwind have to cross the Wetlands to do it ... and usually get eatern by the level 22 crocolisks that wander too close to the road. :eek:
 
I protest. I put in a link and then skeptigirl puts in the same link only one day later. What is going on here? Can someone please explain it?
I skim over posts too fast, that's all. Sorry. It really is hard to read 5 pages of posts.
 
.....that masturbation causes blindness.

I know this is a critical thinking forum, but please don't ask me for evidence ;)
I don't know about the blindness thing but until at least the 1950s masturbation was listed in medical texts as abnormal and unhealthy.
 
Radio waves (and for that matter light) are always described as if it's some sort of wave that goes up and down in space as it travels. While it does have a "length" the amplitude is not spacial in the same sense. It's a variance of electromagnetic potential. So when you draw a sinewave as a representation of a radio wave or light it doesn't literally "look" like that. The wave is a graph with the verticle axis representing the electrical and magnetic potential and...

I've just confused everyone, haven't I? No, I don't mean people here are stupid. It's just kinda hard to put into words.
 
:rolleyes:

I don't get bogged down in such silly arguments. To a marine biologist they are all cetaceans. Dr. Galapagos says a dolphin is a whale is a cetacean.
Cetacea branch off into two main groups according to the current classification on the Tree of Life Web site.

Baleen Whales are in the group of Mysticeti. They include humpbacks, blue whales, minkes, gray whales, and right whales.

Odontoceti contain dolphins, sperm whales, belugas, narhwals, orcas, pilot whales and porpoises.
 
Sitting too close to the TV will expose you to excessive radiation. (7th grade science teacher)


Yes, I remember being told that when I was growing up. It's something that doesn't seem to be true today. But is this something which was always false, or something which was true once but has since become false?

Televisions have come a long way since their early days. They used to be a conglomeration of tubes which snapped and crackled -- and sometimes popped. My understanding (which may well be wrong -- this is something I know fairly little about) is that television sets, and particularly color television, emitted much more radiation back in the 50s and 60s than they do now. If that is so, it may have been a sensible precaution to tell children not to sit right up close to the tv, but to sit at least a few feet back.

If so, there may be an interesting sub-category to explore: things we were taught as true which were true once but aren't anymore.
 
Yes, I remember being told that when I was growing up. It's something that doesn't seem to be true today. But is this something which was always false, or something which was true once but has since become false?

Televisions have come a long way since their early days. They used to be a conglomeration of tubes which snapped and crackled -- and sometimes popped. My understanding (which may well be wrong -- this is something I know fairly little about) is that television sets, and particularly color television, emitted much more radiation back in the 50s and 60s than they do now. If that is so, it may have been a sensible precaution to tell children not to sit right up close to the tv, but to sit at least a few feet back.

If so, there may be an interesting sub-category to explore: things we were taught as true which were true once but aren't anymore.
Was true, isn't true any more.
Wikipedia has some info on it.
I wouldn't vouch for the dates and the other numbers, but in general Wikipedia has it right.
 
I was told that the Coriolis effect causes water to go down the plughole in opposite directions depending on whether you are in the northern or southern hemisphere.
 
Yes, I remember being told that when I was growing up. It's something that doesn't seem to be true today. But is this something which was always false, or something which was true once but has since become false?

Televisions have come a long way since their early days. They used to be a conglomeration of tubes which snapped and crackled -- and sometimes popped. My understanding (which may well be wrong -- this is something I know fairly little about) is that television sets, and particularly color television, emitted much more radiation back in the 50s and 60s than they do now. If that is so, it may have been a sensible precaution to tell children not to sit right up close to the tv, but to sit at least a few feet back.

If so, there may be an interesting sub-category to explore: things we were taught as true which were true once but aren't anymore.

Was true, isn't true any more.
Wikipedia has some info on it.
I wouldn't vouch for the dates and the other numbers, but in general Wikipedia has it right.


I have to admit, I didn't think even the old tubes would have given off that much in the way of x-rays. I would have expected them to be shielded from the leaded glass or the internals. Anyhow, I found this site that gives that amount of radiation--quite high actually. 50 mR/hr is much more than I would have expected. The 8 R/hr is just scary to me since my grandmother had one of those sets and I used to sit fairly close to it. As a nuke, I should have looked deeper. Thanks MortFurd and Nova

http://www.hps.org/publicinformation/ate/q498.html

glenn

Now, the idea that microwaves heat food from the inside is definitely bogus.
 
Now, the idea that microwaves heat food from the inside is definitely bogus.

I frequently see the explanation for microwaves include the idea that the microwaves make the molecules move around faster, and they rub up against other molecules, which creates friction that generates heat to cook the food.

Utter garbage!! The microwaves make the water molecules move (rotate) faster. Since the molecules are moving faster, they have a higher average kinetic energy and are therefore at a higher temperature. No friction involved.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom