Nick said:It's not so much that it doesn't tell us about the world, rather that the objective mindset proceeds from unexamined assumptions.
Really? And what might those be?
There is the presumption of a finite observer.
Nick
Nick said:It's not so much that it doesn't tell us about the world, rather that the objective mindset proceeds from unexamined assumptions.
Really? And what might those be?
This is utter nonsense. You were better off with generalities.
Well, of course it isn't demonstrably provably. It's a definition.Well, without trying to get too existential and OT, I would submit that that is an assertion. It is not demonstrably provable.
Bingo.The only reason who can say? If you are your thoughts then who is it that is saying you exist? Your thoughts?
Correct. Irrelevant, but correct.The thoughts are real, the notion of "I" is a construct. It is not demonstrably provable.
And the mind does have the capacity to divert one's attention away from the anxiety. Whole groups of people can decide en masse to not examine something because it is simply too scary, and a great deal easier to decide to look the other way. I'm not saying this has happened in the case of 9/11. But it can happen. It's entirely feasible.
No.Are you saying that the notion that one's entire knowledge of world political structure might be incorrect would not induce anxiety?
We often find belief in conspiracy theories associated with extreme anxiety. I won't even dispute that conspiracy theories are sometimes the cause of anxiety in otherwise normal people.I submit that CTs have the capability to induce extreme anxiety.
Right.We evaluate them objectively, that's all you can do.
In whom? The theory that the World Trade Center was destroyed in a controlled demolition in 2001 causes no more anxiety in a competent investigator than the theory that Washington DC was destroyed by Martians in 1951, or any other poorly-crafted fiction. It didn't happen, therefore no anxiety.But they do have the capacity to induce anxiety.
This, of course, didn't happen. The investigation did happen.And the mind does have the capacity to divert one's attention away from the anxiety. Whole groups of people can decide en masse to not examine something because it is simply too scary, and a great deal easier to decide to look the other way.
Then why are you making all this fuss?I'm not saying this has happened in the case of 9/11.
In some other event, which wasn't videotaped, which didn't have thousands of eyewitnesses, which wasn't the focus of worldwide attention, which wasn't the subject of exhaustive investigations, yes, in completely different circumstances, someone might miss something.But it can happen. It's entirely feasible.
Read up one what controlled demolition actually entails.Personally, I think that the CTists position over the 9/11 CD theory looks pretty weak but I'm still trying to evaluate this stuff. I'm undecided. I'm trying to explain why I do not simply accept the NIST report.
I beat you easily by getting the privilege to spike their Kool-Aid!I negotiated the terms a little bit, since Ameros aren't really in wide use yet....So, I get free Cadbury eggs year round.
A controlled demolition would leave explosives residue, would show a different pattern of collapse on the videos, would leave physical evidence of the explosive charges, wiring, and detonators, would leave evidence of the thousands of charges being put in place in buildings occupied 24 hours a day. None of this evidence exists.
Therefore, objectively, the controlled demolition theory is false.
You are absolutely wrong.
There is a mountain of physical evidence which includes chemical signatures of explosives, specifically thermate, at the World Trade Center complex.
Architect Richard Gage uses this evidence, elucidated in part by BYU physicist Steven Jones, to show in his talk "How the Towers Fell" that it is beyond any doubt that controlled demolitions were used to destroy the World Trade Center here: http: //video.google. com/videoplay?docid=3118021782753292874
There is a mountain of physical evidence which includes chemical signatures of explosives, specifically thermate, at the World Trade Center complex.
I watched the first ten minutes of this two hour video. Could you please tell me at what point the lies and distortions stop and the mountain of physical evidence begins, so that I can skip ahead to the good bit?You are absolutely wrong.
There is a mountain of physical evidence which includes chemical signatures of explosives, specifically thermate, at the World Trade Center complex.
Architect Richard Gage uses this evidence, elucidated in part by BYU physicist Steven Jones, to show in his talk "How the Towers Fell" that it is beyond any doubt that controlled demolitions were used to destroy the World Trade Center here: http: //video.google. com/videoplay?docid=3118021782753292874
There is a mountain of physical evidence which includes chemical signatures of explosives, specifically thermate, at the World Trade Center complex.
I can only say that if this is the state of the logic of the CT rejectors, you guys need help! Really.
......OK, so loads of, uh, professors and, uh, engineers haven't written stuff agreeing with the CT position, so....uh....it must be wrong! Yeah!
There is a mountain of physical evidence which includes chemical signatures of explosives, specifically thermate, at the World Trade Center complex.
It doesn't quite work that way. You see 'loads of' professors and engineers haven't even heard of the 'truthers' fantasy claims about 9-11. However, they will have heard of, and studied, the NIST report into the collapse of the wtc towers.
You kinda touched on the crux of the 'truther' problem with your post, but you got it arse about face. It's not agreement with the 'truther' position which should be tacitly assumed from professionals silence on the issue, but rather it is tacit approval of the official position.
If it was contrary to established and accepted thinking then there would be an avalanche of papers disputing it's findings simply because the implications would have bearing on the work of professionals in the relevant fields.
Understand?
Fine then.We did go through the perspective you're forwarding later in this thread, I believe. I pointed out at the time that not hearing dissent, and assuming that all structural engineers have thoroughly examined the NIST report, isn't anywhere near as good as having a positive confirmation that they agree with it. Something several list members seemed to have active trouble taking in, which to me demonstrates just how much, in reality, they understand about empiric method.
What do you want? Another Project Steve?I appreciate that the situation is frustrating for those who are qualified, have studied the report, and are certain that it is valid, but this does not excuse taking liberties with statistics. I'm sure you appreciate this.
Alternately, if you can empirically substantiate your claims above I will be happy to listen.
I think it's the closing credits.I watched the first ten minutes of this two hour video. Could you please tell me at what point the lies and distortions stop and the mountain of physical evidence begins, so that I can skip ahead to the good bit?
Thanks.
We did go through the perspective you're forwarding later in this thread, I believe. I pointed out at the time that not hearing dissent, and assuming that all structural engineers have thoroughly examined the NIST report, isn't anywhere near as good as having a positive confirmation that they agree with it. Something several list members seemed to have active trouble taking in, which to me demonstrates just how much, in reality, they understand about empiric method.
I appreciate that the situation is frustrating for those who are qualified, have studied the report, and are certain that it is valid, but this does not excuse taking liberties with statistics. I'm sure you appreciate this.
Nick
Didn't post #86 address this? There are rules for PEs, which you acknowledged, but now you appear to be blowing it off. It also does not explain why structural engineers the world over (specifically, in the Middle East and China) are not stepping up and criticizing NIST.
Fine then.
PixyMisa said:Do you actually have a point of disagreement with the NIST report?