How many people are actually on the NWO payroll?

Hi Disbelief,

#86 contained extracts from various professional codes used by the industry, that shows that structural engineers theoretically should have created a fuss if they were concerned about the validity of the NIST report. It does not however address the underlying statistical issues, which were more addressed in the following posts, if I recall (#97). As soon as you try and get hard data from absence rather than presence you have to statistically figure in a lot more variables. This can be massively significant.

Like I wrote above, I do sympathise with the position of those engineers who have examined the NIST report and found it sound, and who understandably feel angry that Richard Gage and his crew are creating the impression they are able to. However, being pissed off doesn't alter statistical method.

Nick


Why is it about statistics then? What you are doing, is calling into question the ethics of structural engineers. If I were a structural engineer, I would be pissed that anonymous people on the internet were claimng that I would be silent about the tragic deaths of 3,000 people. If you are willing to speak up about your concerns, why would the people most capable of analyzing the collapse remain silent?

Like I said before, it also does not explain why engineers in Iran, China, etc are not proving the NIST explanation wrong. Would this not be the perfect opportunity for Ahmedinijad to prove to the world how evil the US is? He would not be playing to just a receptive anti-American audience in the Middle East, but he would have the attention of EVERYONE.
 
Why is it about statistics then? What you are doing, is calling into question the ethics of structural engineers. If I were a structural engineer, I would be pissed that anonymous people on the internet were claimng that I would be silent about the tragic deaths of 3,000 people. If you are willing to speak up about your concerns, why would the people most capable of analyzing the collapse remain silent?

You don't actually have to drag a bunch of emotions and supposition into it, Disbelief. There are actually other, straighter ways of communicating than through attempting to manipulate. For example, you could actually stick to the point. As stated, I have personally no issue with NIST report. What I am saying is that you cannot attribute to data, obtained in the way you are proposing, the degree of significance that you and others are trying to do.

There exists a professional code of conduct. Great. This is the basis for an assertation. You now need to demonstrate the degree to which this is, in practice, adhered to, and quote data on other related variables. It's a drag, to be frank. There are just too many variables. It's better to at least poll a few (statically significant number) engineers and ask them q's along the lines of those in #97. Then you can make your assertion.

Presenting a load of emotive and manipulative arguments does acutely little, in my eyes, to demonstrate that you are remotely interested in establishing the truth here.

Disbelief said:
Like I said before, it also does not explain why engineers in Iran, China, etc are not proving the NIST explanation wrong. Would this not be the perfect opportunity for Ahmedinijad to prove to the world how evil the US is? He would not be playing to just a receptive anti-American audience in the Middle East, but he would have the attention of EVERYONE.

What if this, what if that, what if the other. Listen to me. For a start, as far as I'm aware no one is "proving the NIST explanation wrong." They are contesting them and asking for an inquiry. I would stick with straw polling engineers than going on into "what if" land, if I were you. Though "what if" data could still be used if desperate.

Nick
 
Am I to take it from this that you do actually now appreciate this point? That you have actually learned something?
Nick, all you have presented is your inability to understand the report - which is not a major issue; I certainly don't understand, nor have I read, the whole thing - and your entrenched unwillingness to apply any knowledge of science that you might possess to evaluating claims of fact. That is a problem.

The "Truth Movement" bombards us with a constant stream of space beams, mini-nukes, cement-thermite composites, and buildings that fall faster than gravity, and yet you are unable to assess which side of the debate is likely to have a better grasp on the truth.

As I say, this is a problem, but I do not see this as my problem.

I have no issue with NIST report. This is not what the discussion was about. The only concern I could have relating to the NIST report might be that, if you and several other list members are representative of the quality of insight here, then I would struggle to give credibility to any case you presented.
You have yet to present any kind of salient point even tangentially related to the subject, instead preferring to engage in sophomoric philosophising and downright nonsensical psychoanalysis, and you have earned a certain amount of derision thereby.

Again, this is not my problem.
 
You don't actually have to drag a bunch of emotions and supposition into it, Disbelief. There are actually other, straighter ways of communicating than through attempting to manipulate. For example, you could actually stick to the point. As stated, I have personally no issue with NIST report. What I am saying is that you cannot attribute to data, obtained in the way you are proposing, the degree of significance that you and others are trying to do.

There exists a professional code of conduct. Great. This is the basis for an assertation. You now need to demonstrate the degree to which this is, in practice, adhered to, and quote data on other related variables. It's a drag, to be frank. There are just too many variables. It's better to at least poll a few (statically significant number) engineers and ask them q's along the lines of those in #97. Then you can make your assertion.

Presenting a load of emotive and manipulative arguments does acutely little, in my eyes, to demonstrate that you are remotely interested in establishing the truth here.
Aren't you the poster who makes decisions on "gut" feelings? So, you use no emotional inputs when doing this? Or do you only do this when it suits your beliefs?

Guess what, this is way different than practically any disaster. This was not something that you heard or read about, but something that you saw unfold on TV. I am not manipulating anything, but telling you reality.[/QUOTE]


Nick227 said:
What if this, what if that, what if the other. Listen to me. For a start, as far as I'm aware no one is "proving the NIST explanation wrong." They are contesting them and asking for an inquiry. I would stick with straw polling engineers than going on into "what if" land, if I were you. Though "what if" data could still be used if desperate.

Nick

Guess what, I am not going to do your work for you. You believe that the amsses are silent and that we can give no credence to their silence. You can do a straw poll to find out what they believe. There are a number of engineers here, just look at the expertise thread, so that could be a good place for you to start.
 
95.6% of the population are NWO. That's why only 4.6% believe the TWOof. (I'm trying to start calling them the TWO Troof World Order)
 
There exists a professional code of conduct. Great. This is the basis for an assertation. You now need to demonstrate the degree to which this is, in practice, adhered to, and quote data on other related variables.
No. No we don't. If you choose to differ with the report, you need to have a reason why.

It's a drag, to be frank. There are just too many variables. It's better to at least poll a few (statically significant number) engineers and ask them q's along the lines of those in #97. Then you can make your assertion.
How would this actually address anything?

Presenting a load of emotive and manipulative arguments does acutely little, in my eyes, to demonstrate that you are remotely interested in establishing the truth here.
Nick, you are the one suggesting that vast numbers of engineers and scientists around the world are complicit in the murder of 3,000 people. What sort of response do you expect?

What if this, what if that, what if the other. Listen to me. For a start, as far as I'm aware no one is "proving the NIST explanation wrong." They are contesting them and asking for an inquiry. I would stick with straw polling engineers than going on into "what if" land, if I were you. Though "what if" data could still be used if desperate.
Why straw poll anyone? What will that achieve? Certainly every engineer on the planet is aware by now of the collapse of the World Trade Center. That's a vast number of men and women of every imaginable political affiliation. Where is the competent analysis and refutation of the NIST report?

Even more fundamentally, it's been explained to you, at length, and in terms a layman can understand, why it is completely absurd to suggest that the WTC was destroyed by controlled demolition. You never even responded to this, instead preferring to suggest incompetence, malfeasance, or insanity on the part of every scientist and engineer involved (however peripherally) in the investigation, based solely on some strange snippet of pop psychology you gleaned from some Sunday tabloid or trashy potboiler. This does you little credit.
 
#86 contained extracts from various professional codes used by the industry, that shows that structural engineers theoretically should have created a fuss if they were concerned about the validity of the NIST report. It does not however address the underlying statistical issues, which were more addressed in the following posts, if I recall (#97). As soon as you try and get hard data from absence rather than presence you have to statistically figure in a lot more variables. This can be massively significant.

What we can, perhaps, infer from the absence of comment by professional structural engineers is that the overwhelming majority of the profession feels that there is nothing suspicious about the collapses per se. I think it's probably fair to say that every structural engineer in the world is aware, at the very least, of the collapses of the Twin Towers, and speaking as a member of a similarly geeky profession (physicist) I would expect very large numbers of structural engineers to take at least a passing interest in such high-profile events that directly concern their chosen profession (assuming that structural engineers choose to be such; I've not met any who desperately wanted to be something else but never had the education). Therefore, even without consideration of the NIST report, we can safely say that there are large numbers of structural engineers worldwide who see nothing strange in the collapse of two 110 storey skyscrapers that had been hit by airliners and set on fire.

If there was a significant minority who did see something suspicious about it, they would then be required by their code of ethics to investigate further, which would almost inevitably lead them to one of two positions. Either they would study the NIST report and accept its conclusions - at least to the extent of believing that collapse due to fire and impact damage is reasonable - or, with or without having studied the NIST report, they would gravitate towards the truth movement, and specifically AE911T. As far as I know, AE911T doesn't have a single real, living structural engineer (as opposed to practical-joker-originated fake or dead ones) among its numbers.

Absence of evidence is not necessarily evidence of absence, but in circumstances such as these the absence of evidence becomes increasingly difficult to explain away.

Dave
 
No. No we don't. If you choose to differ with the report, you need to have a reason why.

10 minutes debating with you, PM, and death loses its sting. I AM NOT DIFFERING WITH THE REPORT. We were discussing the degree to which many engineers not querying it could be considered statistically significant.

If you have any relevant insights into this subject that haven't already been gone into, I would be happy to hear them. Otherwise, please ****** off and annoy someone else with the haphazard outpourings of your convoluted mind.

Nick
 
What we can, perhaps, infer from the absence of comment by professional structural engineers is that the overwhelming majority of the profession feels that there is nothing suspicious about the collapses per se. I think it's probably fair to say that every structural engineer in the world is aware, at the very least, of the collapses of the Twin Towers, and speaking as a member of a similarly geeky profession (physicist) I would expect very large numbers of structural engineers to take at least a passing interest in such high-profile events that directly concern their chosen profession (assuming that structural engineers choose to be such; I've not met any who desperately wanted to be something else but never had the education). Therefore, even without consideration of the NIST report, we can safely say that there are large numbers of structural engineers worldwide who see nothing strange in the collapse of two 110 storey skyscrapers that had been hit by airliners and set on fire.

Hi Dave,

I would agree with this. However, for me, as previously debated, there are enough other potential factors here to prevent me from using this assertion as the basis of any hard-and-fast claim.

Dave said:
If there was a significant minority who did see something suspicious about it, they would then be required by their code of ethics to investigate further, which would almost inevitably lead them to one of two positions. Either they would study the NIST report and accept its conclusions - at least to the extent of believing that collapse due to fire and impact damage is reasonable - or, with or without having studied the NIST report, they would gravitate towards the truth movement, and specifically AE911T. As far as I know, AE911T doesn't have a single real, living structural engineer (as opposed to practical-joker-originated fake or dead ones) among its numbers.

Well, I spent a merry hour trying to track down the email addresses of some of the 690+ professionals listed on the aetruth911 website. I would say that a majority of those I looked at did at least appear to exist. That's to say there were references to them resulting from a basic Google search, and that they did appear to have the professions accredited them on the ae site. I couldn't track down so many email addresses but that's a bit of a separate matter. A lot also did seem to be architects and engineers of a more "new-age" type, pretty much the type of guys one would expect to potentially take the CT position.


Dave said:
Absence of evidence is not necessarily evidence of absence, but in circumstances such as these the absence of evidence becomes increasingly difficult to explain away.

Dave

As time goes by, and more and more people become aware of the CT position, this is unquestionably true.

Nick
 
Nick:

You have no problem with the report, yet you think it's suspicious that there aren't any structural engineers who have a problem with the report? Oy vey.

Sometimes the answer is in the grey area. This time, it's as obvious as it seems.
 
10 minutes debating with you, PM, and death loses its sting. I AM NOT DIFFERING WITH THE REPORT. We were discussing the degree to which many engineers not querying it could be considered statistically significant.

If you have any relevant insights into this subject that haven't already been gone into, I would be happy to hear them. Otherwise, please ****** off and annoy someone else with the haphazard outpourings of your convoluted mind.
What I am asking is what do you expect to gain from this, and how so you expect to accomplish it? You have already seen fit to ascribe insanity to the entire investigative team on the basis of, as it happens, nothing whatsoever. I'm not sure what this peculiar predilection for negative evidence is supposed to achieve. It's a funny way to approach a report with which you have no differences.
 
You are absolutely wrong.

...explosives, specifically thermate, ...



Thermate is an incendiary pyrotechnic composition, a thermite-like compound used for military applications. Thermate, whose primary component is thermite, also contains sulfur and sometimes barium nitrate, both of which increase its thermal effect, create flame in burning, and significantly reduce the ignition temperature. Various mixtures of these compounds can be called thermate, but, to avoid confusion with Thermate-TH3, one can refer to them as thermite variants or analogs. The composition by weight of Thermate-TH3 (in military use) is 68.7% thermite, 29.0% barium nitrate, 2.0% sulfur and 0.3% binder.




Before you go declaring others to be absolutely wrong, you really should fact-check your own assertions.
 
You have already seen fit to ascribe insanity to the entire investigative team on the basis of, as it happens, nothing whatsoever. I'm not sure what this peculiar predilection for negative evidence is supposed to achieve. It's a funny way to approach a report with which you have no differences.

I think you have me mixed up with someone else. I don't recall calling the NIST investigative team insane.

Nick
 
Nick:

You have no problem with the report, yet you think it's suspicious that there aren't any structural engineers who have a problem with the report? Oy vey.

No. What I was commenting on was the assertion that the absence of outcry from the structural engineering establishment was of a priori statistical relevance when considering whether the NIST report was valid. I said that it was potentially relevant but that data accrued by this means is inevitably flawed, and needing to be subject to further scrutiny prior to such assertions being made.

Frankly, it's hard to discuss this topic here because the majority of people thus far commenting on it seem incapable of grasping its essence. Their minds jump off all over the place onto subsidiary issues or attempts to drag an assortment of irrelevant nonsense in. I wonder who's next.

Nick
 
No. What I was commenting on was the assertion that the absence of outcry from the structural engineering establishment was of a priori statistical relevance when considering whether the NIST report was valid. I said that it was potentially relevant but that data accrued by this means is inevitably flawed, and needing to be subject to further scrutiny prior to such assertions being made.

Frankly, it's hard to discuss this topic here because the majority of people thus far commenting on it seem incapable of grasping its essence. Their minds jump off all over the place onto subsidiary issues or attempts to drag an assortment of irrelevant nonsense in. I wonder who's next.

Nick

Sorry, what? Try again in simple English, because to me it looks like you're saying that in order to judge the validity of the NIST report there would have to be a significant number of engineers publishing papers that support the NIST report...

...quite frankly, engineers have better things to do than publish papers that say, "Yes, this other paper was correct." Certainly in scientific research that may happen, but that is research. The NIST report is application and analysis - if there is nothing wrong with their analyses then there is no reason to publish an article saying so.
 
I think you have me mixed up with someone else. I don't recall calling the NIST investigative team insane.
You didn't use that term, no. However, when you were suggesting upthread that the investigators refused to admit the possibility of a controlled demolition due to a subconscious fear of the political implications, you were describing a (mild) form of paranoid psychosis.

If you look at the implications, you are suggesting that hundreds of scientists and engineers all went insane in exactly the same way. Folie a deux cent, or something. On the basis of nothing.
 
No. What I was commenting on was the assertion that the absence of outcry from the structural engineering establishment was of a priori statistical relevance when considering whether the NIST report was valid.
Which it is. But that should not make it anyone's primary means of assessing the report.

I said that it was potentially relevant but that data accrued by this means is inevitably flawed, and needing to be subject to further scrutiny prior to such assertions being made.
Which is essentially pointless.

Frankly, it's hard to discuss this topic here because the majority of people thus far commenting on it seem incapable of grasping its essence.
We understand it; we just regard the exercise as futile.

Their minds jump off all over the place onto subsidiary issues or attempts to drag an assortment of irrelevant nonsense in. I wonder who's next.
Nick, this "assortment of irrelevant nonsense" you are talking about is what scientists and engineers term empirical evidence. I thought you had some regard for that.

The underlying problem that you are encountering here is that the question you are asking is how do I judge this book by its cover? The answer you are receiving is you don't. You find this unsatisfying, but you aren't going the get a different answer just because you keep rephrasing the question.
 
Sorry, what? Try again in simple English, because to me it looks like you're saying that in order to judge the validity of the NIST report there would have to be a significant number of engineers publishing papers that support the NIST report...

...quite frankly, engineers have better things to do than publish papers that say, "Yes, this other paper was correct." Certainly in scientific research that may happen, but that is research. The NIST report is application and analysis - if there is nothing wrong with their analyses then there is no reason to publish an article saying so.

Listen carefully, I'm not going to explain it again....READ......THE......THREAD

Making haphazard assumptions as to what was being discussed and then proceeding to challenge your own dim-witted cogitations doesn't really achieve so much.

Nick
 
Listen carefully, I'm not going to explain it again....READ......THE......THREAD

Making haphazard assumptions as to what was being discussed and then proceeding to challenge your own dim-witted cogitations doesn't really achieve so much.

Nick

Put the coffee down... Step away from the keyboard... Breathe... And ask yourself, "WWJFD?" (What Would Jacob Frank Do?")

I'm just funning, of course. But you are the first person I've ever met who brought up 17th century Jewish messianic movements from Poland in casual conversation. I don't want to lose that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom