Disbelief
Illuminator
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2007
- Messages
- 3,619
Hi Disbelief,
#86 contained extracts from various professional codes used by the industry, that shows that structural engineers theoretically should have created a fuss if they were concerned about the validity of the NIST report. It does not however address the underlying statistical issues, which were more addressed in the following posts, if I recall (#97). As soon as you try and get hard data from absence rather than presence you have to statistically figure in a lot more variables. This can be massively significant.
Like I wrote above, I do sympathise with the position of those engineers who have examined the NIST report and found it sound, and who understandably feel angry that Richard Gage and his crew are creating the impression they are able to. However, being pissed off doesn't alter statistical method.
Nick
Why is it about statistics then? What you are doing, is calling into question the ethics of structural engineers. If I were a structural engineer, I would be pissed that anonymous people on the internet were claimng that I would be silent about the tragic deaths of 3,000 people. If you are willing to speak up about your concerns, why would the people most capable of analyzing the collapse remain silent?
Like I said before, it also does not explain why engineers in Iran, China, etc are not proving the NIST explanation wrong. Would this not be the perfect opportunity for Ahmedinijad to prove to the world how evil the US is? He would not be playing to just a receptive anti-American audience in the Middle East, but he would have the attention of EVERYONE.