A friend of mine is a biologist. I allways tell him he's wrong.
Maybe football isn't his forte?
A friend of mine is a biologist. I allways tell him he's wrong.
Maybe football isn't his forte?
THEY want me to believe the dirty foriegners' lies that soccer can be called football.There's no such thing as footbal. They want you to believe there is.
THEY want me to believe the dirty foriegners' lies that soccer can be called football.![]()
How can it be football with no forward pass? Answer me that, huh?THEY want me to believe the dirty foriegners' lies that soccer can be called football.![]()
Exactly. And every player out there is moving around. What are they doing it with? THEIR FEET!!How can it be football with no forward pass? Answer me that, huh?
Not even slightly.Dude,
You're actively terrified of alternative explanations. I'd swear on it.
Sorry, that's just you.You know, to understand why CTists do the stuff they do, my opinion is you have to appreciate some real baseline stuff about the nature of our existence. No one knows ****.
Reality is not a social construct. Reality doesn't give a damn. The fact that there's no deductive proof that leads you out of solipsism and into (say) materialism is of no consequence, because if you act on the assumption that reality is shaped by your beliefs and desires, you will die.But you can't prove anything. You have no way of knowing if all the thoughts currently passing through your head are yours, or if they even belong to anybody. You have no way of knowing if the monitor is outside of you, inside of you, or wherever. Really, there's no way to prove any of this stuff. Most of us accept unquestioningly a socially learned reality.
Paranoid schizophrenia is treatable now. All the same, I have no particular wish to experience it.Once you rip apart the belief system a bit you can believe any kind of crazy nonsense that's floating about in your subconscious. Issues with authority? Suddenly it's like Wow, conspiracy theories are true, true, true and I need to tell the world! They just go there.
I'm perfectly prepared for my world to be rocked. Just spare me the sophomoric philosophy and show me the evidence. I couldn't be less interested in unsupported speculation and appeals to emotion.If you have not, at least for a period, been shaken by the possibility that much of your existing beliefs about yourself and the world may be actually invalid, then you could surmise from this that perhaps your objectivity could waver. If you've been shaken, if you've gone there emotionally, you also know.
Reality is not a social construct. Reality doesn't give a damn. The fact that there's no deductive proof that leads you out of solipsism and into (say) materialism is of no consequence, because if you act on the assumption that reality is shaped by your beliefs and desires, you will die.
This can be true... but not nearly often enough.That's not necessarily true. People have historically shown to consistently build their beliefs around survival. So, in essense, it could be said that belief is more an effect of reality.![]()
I can agree with that.Mostly, though, I wanted to chime in to say that belief is more a search for 'why' while science tends to be a search for 'how'. Not necessarily incompatible, though obviously there are problems when one attempts to apply one to the other as if they always fit perfectly.
Maybe so. But when he suggests that the reason competent, working scientists and engineers reject all the drivel of the truthers is that they are afraid of the implications, he deserves everything he gets.Don't be too hard on Nick. I have a personal and scholarly respect for him from our discussion in another thread, and even though there are plenty of things we disagree over, he's never been belligerent and has always taken a fairly socratic approach with me. Just wanted to note that he's good people.![]()
What do you think of science? Doesn't it tell us a little about the world?
I'm perfectly prepared for my world to be rocked. Just spare me the sophomoric philosophy and show me the evidence. I couldn't be less interested in unsupported speculation and appeals to emotion.
Maybe so. But when he suggests that the reason competent, working scientists and engineers reject all the drivel of the truthers is that they are afraid of the implications, he deserves everything he gets.
This is utter nonsense. You were better off with generalities.What I said was that the decision-making facilities in the individual can be hijacked by processes of which they are not consciously aware. There is a mid-brain, beneath the rational mind, that constantly monitors the environment for threats. It has the power to divert throught processes away from certain anxiety-inducing pathways, without the individual being consciously aware this is happening.
This is, again, utter nonsense, and offensive as well.You denied that this could happen with engineers. In my experience, denial of this nature is invariably a fear reaction, which is why I called you on it.
I haven't been abusive. You'll know when I get abusive. I use footnotes.As to GreNME's comments, I am fine that you are as "hard" as you like on these or other ideas of mine, but I would prefer it if you were not abusive.
You don't have the slightest idea what you are talking about.Aside of anything else, it's invariably another fear reaction, mediated by the mid-brain.
It's not a question of possession, it's a question if identity. I am my thoughts. The only reason I can say that I exist is that my thoughts exist.Well, seeing as you asked, you can demonstrate it for yourself. Can you prove that the thoughts passing through your head right now are yours? Can you prove that the head is yours? The head exists, the thoughts exist, and but can you scientifically demonstrate that they have possession?
Really? And what might those be?It's not so much that it doesn't tell us about the world, rather that the objective mindset proceeds from unexamined assumptions.
We already know how CTs arise. We don't necessarily know why a specific CTist might believe a specific CT, but we can see that some of them have specific agendas, some of them are dishonest, some of them are seeking attention, and all of them are incompetent to evaluate the evidence.If you appreciate this you can understand why CTs arise, and how people who previously appeared normal and objective can become suddenly attracted to beliefs that are seemingly quite mad.
It's not a question of possession, it's a question if identity. I am my thoughts.
PixyMisa said:The only reason I can say that I exist is that my thoughts exist.