How many people are actually on the NWO payroll?

Why can't you be like Dave Rogers and actually just follow what is being discussed and comment?

Hey, who told you I was reasonable?

Actually, I think there's a lot to Mobyseven's point about publications. There really is no reason for any engineer, having read NIST's report, to take the time and trouble to write a paper saying, in effect, "I agree with NIST". If anyone did bother, there's no reason why any journal would want to publish it. There is therefore no formal mechanism for registering simple assent with NIST (as opposed to new results that agree generally with NIST, as in the case of Purdue University's continuing studies), whereas there is a well-defined formal mechanism for registering dissent. It's roughly equivalent to the well-known principle in customer services that positive comments have to be far more heavily weighted than negative comments, because people are motivated to complain about bad service but will rarely comment on good service because they're satisfied with the status quo.

We have a situation, therefore, where dissent with NIST is self-selected both by human nature and by publications policy, and yet that dissent is still rare and generally confined to details, rather than questioning the feasibility of collapse initiation altogether. Not proof, for sure, but it makes the case for widespread professional acceptance of NIST's broader conclusions extremely plausible.

Dave
 
Rule number one: If your audience can't understand what you're saying, it's likely not the fault of the audience.

I'm done with this. You're saying nothing, and saying it loudly.

Moby,

I don't think it's so complicated. At least one forum member clearly appreciated the point. I will happily concede that a certain clarity is needed to follow it. However, if you don't follow something, why not ask for clarification? What you and some other forum members do is simply start assuming what the point was and then argue with your own assumption. This isn't debate.

I am and have been a member of many discussion groups on the net for years. Based on this experience I would say that many people on this one are really reactive. It's like they don't even wait to try and appreciate what someone is trying to communicate, they just guess what it's about and come up with their own, usually highly formulaic, reaction. It's not so exciting really, guys.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Hey, who told you I was reasonable?

Well, what I like about you is you do appear to actually take the time to read something and get it clear before replying.

Dave said:
Actually, I think there's a lot to Mobyseven's point about publications. There really is no reason for any engineer, having read NIST's report, to take the time and trouble to write a paper saying, in effect, "I agree with NIST". If anyone did bother, there's no reason why any journal would want to publish it.

I agree with this point. As mentioned earlier, I think that if awareness of the CT position does rise then more engineers will come out to lend their opinion either way.

Dave said:
There is therefore no formal mechanism for registering simple assent with NIST (as opposed to new results that agree generally with NIST, as in the case of Purdue University's continuing studies), whereas there is a well-defined formal mechanism for registering dissent.

Yes, and like I said, I do sympathise. But you can't take liberties with statistical analysis because the system isn't fair. This, frankly, was all I was saying and I feel like its significance has been somewhat blown out of proportion with all this discussion.

Dave said:
It's roughly equivalent to the well-known principle in customer services that positive comments have to be far more heavily weighted than negative comments, because people are motivated to complain about bad service but will rarely comment on good service because they're satisfied with the status quo.

I would say that "roughly" is the operative word here. There are more variables. You need to demonstrate that people have actually read the report in depth, not go on vaguely substantiated supposition that they might have as some on this thread have tried to do.

My personal, unqualified opinion is that the NIST report is unlikely to be an open-and-shut case, with all the major issues clearly tied up neatly. If this were so then you would need to evaluate statistically to what degree real analysis of key areas had taken place. If it were not so, you could create a stronger case.

Like I say, I do sympathise. It isn't fair.

Dave said:
We have a situation, therefore, where dissent with NIST is self-selected both by human nature and by publications policy, and yet that dissent is still rare and generally confined to details, rather than questioning the feasibility of collapse initiation altogether. Not proof, for sure, but it makes the case for widespread professional acceptance of NIST's broader conclusions extremely plausible.

I guess it depends on to what degree you and other experts consider the case clearly closed by the NIST report. I could only find Prof Greening's comments. Are there others? I couldn't find much.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Dave said:
As far as I know, AE911T doesn't have a single real, living structural engineer (as opposed to practical-joker-originated fake or dead ones) among its numbers.

Well, I spent a merry hour trying to track down the email addresses of some of the 690+ professionals listed on the aetruth911 website. I would say that a majority of those I looked at did at least appear to exist. That's to say there were references to them resulting from a basic Google search, and that they did appear to have the professions accredited them on the ae site. I couldn't track down so many email addresses but that's a bit of a separate matter. A lot also did seem to be architects and engineers of a more "new-age" type, pretty much the type of guys one would expect to potentially take the CT position.

Hi again Dave,

Must admit that I'm interested in your comments about ae911truth.org. Do you stand by your statement that they don't have a "single real, living structural engineer," as far as you're aware?

Nick
 
Must admit that I'm interested in your comments about ae911truth.org. Do you stand by your statement that they don't have a "single real, living structural engineer," as far as you're aware?

I think the key word here is "as far as I'm aware", based only on the fact that last time I looked at their membership roll on the website I didn't see anyone claiming to be a structural engineer apart from obvious fakes. My awareness is not therefore necessarily relevant or up-to-date, as I may have missed some entries. In other words, don't take me as any kind of authoritative source.

Dave
 
As mentioned earlier, I think that if awareness of the CT position does rise then more engineers will come out to lend their opinion either way.

If the "demolitions" on 9/11 were as obvious as truthers say they are, I think a good number of engineers would be able to figure it out on their own without the aid of youtube.
 
If the "demolitions" on 9/11 were as obvious as truthers say they are, I think a good number of engineers would be able to figure it out on their own without the aid of youtube.

Well, I think that the unconcerned lay-man would assume the plane impacts caused the collapses, and the truther that would assume they were CDs. How the unconcerned lay-man reacts when he becomes aware of the truther's version is likely largely due to prior experience with authority, imo. What the engineers think is the bone of contention here.

I think another point that should be assessed here is the degree to which engineers are actually concerned with collapse dynamics as opposed to the initiation of the collapse. Aren't structural engineers less concerned with collapse dynamics, and more concerned with creating something that doesn't start to collapse in the first place?

No doubt I will be accused of over-complexity or pernickety-ness, but my gut instinct (!) is that there are significant things here not being examined by the JREF camp, when they consider that the absence of dissent is of considerable significance.

Nick
 
Last edited:
I think another point that should be assessed here is the degree to which engineers are actually concerned with collapse dynamics as opposed to the initiation of the collapse. Aren't structural engineers less concerned with collapse dynamics, and more concerned with creating something that doesn't start to collapse in the first place?

And to do that they need to know what causes a collapse and how a building behaves in a collapse.

No doubt I will be accused of over-complexity or pernickety-ness,
but my gut instinct (!) is that there are significant things here not being examined by the JREF camp, when they consider that the absence of discent is of considerable significance.

Nick

Would you care to give some examples of things that are not being examined, or do we just have to go with your gut?
 
I think another point that should be assessed here is the degree to which engineers are actually concerned with collapse dynamics as opposed to the initiation of the collapse. Aren't structural engineers less concerned with collapse dynamics, and more concerned with creating something that doesn't start to collapse in the first place?

That's wandering rather off the topic of this sub-discussion, given that the NIST report doesn't address the collapse dynamics, just the collapse initiation. In fact, what you've said is basically a justification of why NIST took that tack; once a building has started to collapse, the structure has already failed, so what you want is to prevent it getting to that point. By that argument, then, structural engineers looking at NIST are going to be checking that it addresses the concerns of importance to them, namely how the collapse began and how it could have been prevented.

As for the collapse dynamics themselves, simplified cases have been examined by several people and found to be broadly in agreement with the collapse times observed. The only papers I've seen that actually calculate significantly different collapse times are very seriously flawed; Kenneth Kuttler makes a number of unsupportable assumptions which I really ought to highlight some time, and Judy Wood's analysis doesn't touch on reality at any point whatsoever. This is rather more than a matter of professional consensus, it's a matter of unambiguous physical models that give good agreement with observation. For those of us who find the assumption of the objective reality of physical laws to be a useful tool in our everyday lives, this is a good enough proof for all practical purposes.

In other words, I don't really think we've missed anything important to do with the collapse times, if that's what you meant. Initiation is the key to this debate, which brings us straight back to the NIST report and its validity.

Dave
 
And to do that they need to know what causes a collapse and how a building behaves in a collapse.

But do they really study collapse dynamics, separate from causation? Because if I were a structural engineer looking casually at the WTC case I would not even consider another cause unless the pattern of the collapse really looked weird. I would not be making any kind of comparative case.

I'm asking how much collapse dynamics are actually studied by engineers. Aren't there a whole heap of complex variables that come into play at the point that the building starts to go down? Can you really separate factors originating from the building's structure and that of the collapse initiator. Sounds bloody complicated to me!

You see, if you claim that a whole lot of engineers are giving tacit acceptance to NIST by not contesting it, I guess you would need to demonstrate that collapse dynamics are extensively studied and that those that apply in the NIST scenario and the CD scenario are not reasonably similar. If it's just other factors that make the CD not viable then you have to show the engineers know this stuff too.

8den said:
Would you care to give some examples of things that are not being examined, or do we just have to go with your gut?

Well, I doubt many on this list would give that much creedence!

Nick
 
How the unconcerned lay-man reacts when he becomes aware of the truther's version is likely largely due to prior experience with authority, imo. What the engineers think is the bone of contention here.

Indeed. The engineers think you're out to lunch.

Aren't structural engineers less concerned with collapse dynamics, and more concerned with creating something that doesn't start to collapse in the first place?

Yes, because they're concerned with preventing collapses in the first place. What truthers fail to grasp is that when a 50,000 ton mass starts to fall there really isn't much point in analyzing it as it smashes through a building to see if it should have stopped somehow.

No doubt I will be accused of over-complexity or pernickety-ness, but my gut instinct (!) is that there are significant things here not being examined by the JREF camp, when they consider that the absence of dissent is of considerable significance.

Your Gut instinct vs. structural engineers. I wonder who wins that one....
 
That's wandering rather off the topic of this sub-discussion,

Well, if there is a case that engineers out there cannot be considered as tacitly accepting the NIST report, which I must admit I myself am not currently clear about, then I guess it could be considered as on topic.

I like to try and get clear about these things as, if the assertion does hold water, it's clearly a major thing. I'm just not clear about it yet. And I like clarity with things like this.

Nick

Dave said:
given that the NIST report doesn't address the collapse dynamics, just the collapse initiation. In fact, what you've said is basically a justification of why NIST took that tack; once a building has started to collapse, the structure has already failed, so what you want is to prevent it getting to that point. By that argument, then, structural engineers looking at NIST are going to be checking that it addresses the concerns of importance to them, namely how the collapse began and how it could have been prevented.

As for the collapse dynamics themselves, simplified cases have been examined by several people and found to be broadly in agreement with the collapse times observed. The only papers I've seen that actually calculate significantly different collapse times are very seriously flawed; Kenneth Kuttler makes a number of unsupportable assumptions which I really ought to highlight some time, and Judy Wood's analysis doesn't touch on reality at any point whatsoever. This is rather more than a matter of professional consensus, it's a matter of unambiguous physical models that give good agreement with observation. For those of us who find the assumption of the objective reality of physical laws to be a useful tool in our everyday lives, this is a good enough proof for all practical purposes.

In other words, I don't really think we've missed anything important to do with the collapse times, if that's what you meant. Initiation is the key to this debate, which brings us straight back to the NIST report and its validity.

Dave
 
Moby,

I don't think it's so complicated.

It's not, as far as I can tell. The reason it's not particularly complicated is that you're raising sort of a 'nothing' point. So structural engineers do/don't come out and state exactly what they think about the NIST report. Big frickin' deal, either way.

It isn't the engineers that matter - it's the engineering. It's the physics and the chemistry, the maths and the modelling - those are the things that matter. The engineers are the people who give us the answers to all those questions, certainly, but in the end it doesn't matter if the only person in the world who thinks that the NIST report is accurate is a three-legged structural engineer from Mexico - if his opinion most accurately reflects reality (and has the science to back it) then we'd best listen to what he has to say. Reality cares very little for pesky human opinions, understand. Reality just is.

At least one forum member clearly appreciated the point. I will happily concede that a certain clarity is needed to follow it. However, if you don't follow something, why not ask for clarification? What you and some other forum members do is simply start assuming what the point was and then argue with your own assumption. This isn't debate.

I did ask for clarification - that you were unable to explain your contention or reasoning in an understandable manner is not my fault. Hell, that's why I've come to the conclusion that you've nothing to say, and you're saying it loudly.

See, you've come in here all a-twitter, and you've attributed a position to us 'JREFers' (because we're a monolithic entity, bound by a single IP and destined to serve the hive-mind :rolleyes:) that we don't hold (or at least, most of us): That the absence of any dissent in the structural engineering community in regards to the NIST report is statistically significant.

As I said before: I couldn't give a wet slap if there was dissent in the structural engineering community, or indeed if there was total agreeance and a 'NIST ROX' barbeque every year. What is important is that the science and information within the NIST report is an accurate reflection of reality. Certainly, if all the structural engineers in the world turned around tomorrow and said, "You know what, that NIST report is full of faecal matter," it would raise my eyebrow a smidge - but the engineering community had better explain why the NIST report is full of said matter if they want me to take them seriously, or even set foot in a high-rise building again!

To summarise in a way that everyone can understand: Screw the lack of statistics and focus on the damn science.

I am and have been a member of many discussion groups on the net for years. Based on this experience I would say that many people on this one are really reactive. It's like they don't even wait to try and appreciate what someone is trying to communicate, they just guess what it's about and come up with their own, usually highly formulaic, reaction. It's not so exciting really, guys.

Bully for you. Am I supposed to be impressed or something - "Ooh, he's been a member of many discussion groups on the net for years!"

Who the hell hasn't?

If you don't want to be misunderstood, I suggest you learn to express yourself in plain English - Ed knows that no one around here is going to think good of you for obfuscating. As a general rule, if you can't express your basic contention in a single understandable sentence, you aren't expressing yourself clearly enough. Don't get annoyed because the members here aren't able to understand what you're saying, because quite honestly I've tried my best to understand your contention and your argument, and come up short every time - hell, I can't even figure out whether you believe in LIHOP, MIHOP, or reality!

Sometimes you just have to consider: Is it everybody else? Or might it be me?
 
Yes, because they're concerned with preventing collapses in the first place. What truthers fail to grasp is that when a 50,000 ton mass starts to fall there really isn't much point in analyzing it as it smashes through a building to see if it should have stopped somehow.

So you're upholding my proposal. The engineers can't be considered as giving tacit acceptance?

Nick
 
So you're upholding my proposal. The engineers can't be considered as giving tacit acceptance?

I think I see your "logic" here.

If engineers don't look closely at the collapse itself (judging there to be no need) then that means it was probably caused by bombs.

Have I got that right?
 
It's not, as far as I can tell. The reason it's not particularly complicated is that you're raising sort of a 'nothing' point. So structural engineers do/don't come out and state exactly what they think about the NIST report. Big frickin' deal, either way.

It isn't the engineers that matter - it's the engineering. It's the physics and the chemistry, the maths and the modelling - those are the things that matter. The engineers are the people who give us the answers to all those questions, certainly, but in the end it doesn't matter if the only person in the world who thinks that the NIST report is accurate is a three-legged structural engineer from Mexico - if his opinion most accurately reflects reality (and has the science to back it) then we'd best listen to what he has to say. Reality cares very little for pesky human opinions, understand. Reality just is.

So, you're also upholding the proposal. OK.

Moby said:
As I said before: I couldn't give a wet slap if there was dissent in the structural engineering community, or indeed if there was total agreeance and a 'NIST ROX' barbeque every year. What is important is that the science and information within the NIST report is an accurate reflection of reality. Certainly, if all the structural engineers in the world turned around tomorrow and said, "You know what, that NIST report is full of faecal matter," it would raise my eyebrow a smidge - but the engineering community had better explain why the NIST report is full of said matter if they want me to take them seriously, or even set foot in a high-rise building again!

To summarise in a way that everyone can understand: Screw the lack of statistics and focus on the damn science.

But we were debating statistics here.

Moby said:
- hell, I can't even figure out whether you believe in LIHOP, MIHOP, or reality!

Since you asked, and didn't see where I answered this previously, I personally believe that the plan and terrorist cell were created by the West, or NWO for want of a better name. I'm fine with the NIST report.

Nick
 
I think I see your "logic" here.

If engineers don't look closely at the collapse itself (judging there to be no need) then that means it was probably caused by bombs.

Have I got that right?

No. I was discussing the assertion (made by other forum members) that the wider body of engineers were giving tacit approval to the NIST report through not contesting it.

Nick
 
So you're upholding my proposal. The engineers can't be considered as giving tacit acceptance?

Hang on, I hear the creak of goalposts starting to walk here. You're suggesting that, because engineers are not familiar with modelling collapse dynamics, they are therefore not in a position to give assent or dissent to NIST's model of the collapse dynamics, right? That's a flawed premise, because NIST don't model the collapse dynamics, only the collapse initiation. Bringing collapse dynamics into a discussion of responses to the NIST report is what I referred to as drifting off-topic.

As for tacit acceptance, what are engineers failing to accept about the collapse dynamics? The fact that the buildings fell all the way to the ground is one of those points about 9-11 that every engineer in the world is certain to know, so if it were particularly suspicious we might expect large numbers of engineers to question it. The collapse time is far more obscure, but I'm happy from the results of my own analysis that the collapse times are reasonable, so I'm not concerned that the lack of dispute from the engineering community is hiding anything sinister. The fine detail of the collapses - for example, which columns were ejected in what directions, and suchlike - could best be described as unknowable, given the chaotic nature of the situation and hence the divergence of any sufficiently detailed physical model.

What else does that leave, except initiation? Which brings the debate back to the NIST report.

Dave
 
Hang on, I hear the creak of goalposts starting to walk here. You're suggesting that, because engineers are not familiar with modelling collapse dynamics, they are therefore not in a position to give assent or dissent to NIST's model of the collapse dynamics, right?

No. I'm saying that because they're not assessing collapse dynamics then the supposition that they're giving tacit approval needs still more examination.

Dave said:
That's a flawed premise, because NIST don't model the collapse dynamics, only the collapse initiation. Bringing collapse dynamics into a discussion of responses to the NIST report is what I referred to as drifting off-topic.

OK, thanks. I understand that bit now. My q is...if there's no significant difference between the collapse dynamics for progressive collapse and CD (or if engineers are not busy with assessing these things) then how can their lack of dissent be considered a rebuttal of the CD theory? They would have to be familiar with other factors that could discern the two.

Anyway, since I'm not contesting the NIST report, it does become increasingly an academic debate, and that's not so much my thing (honest!) It's not my intention to fuel the CD debate, since I don't really believe it.

Nick
 
if there's no significant difference between the collapse dynamics for progressive collapse and CD (or if engineers are not busy with assessing these things) then how can their lack of dissent be considered a rebuttal of the CD theory? They would have to be familiar with other factors that could discern the two.

Why do you assume that a collapse and a demolition are so hard to tell apart?

Demoltion charges make a series of deafening BANGS that are heard for miles. Progressive collapse doesn't. A demolition would have a series of flashes. Progressive collapse doesn't.

That alone tells most sane people that there was no demoltion which is why the engineering and demolition pros of the world are not up in arms.

What you're basically looking for is a bomb big enough to have been a factor in a building collapse yet small enough to have gone unnoticed by everyone but the twoofers.

No. I was discussing the assertion (made by other forum members) that the wider body of engineers were giving tacit approval to the NIST report through not contesting it.

If there were major glaring problems with the NIST report engineers would be pointing them out. This is not happening.

The reality of the situation is this: engineers are not ranting about demolitions because there is no evidence of any. If you think there is then show them that evidence and see what they say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom