Moby,
I don't think it's so complicated.
It's not, as far as I can tell. The reason it's not particularly complicated is that you're raising sort of a 'nothing' point. So structural engineers do/don't come out and state exactly what they think about the NIST report. Big frickin' deal, either way.
It isn't the engineers that matter - it's the engineering. It's the physics and the chemistry, the maths and the modelling - those are the things that matter. The engineers are the people who give us the answers to all those questions, certainly, but in the end it doesn't matter if the only person in the world who thinks that the NIST report is accurate is a three-legged structural engineer from Mexico - if his opinion most accurately reflects reality (and has the science to back it) then we'd best listen to what he has to say. Reality cares very little for pesky human opinions, understand. Reality just
is.
At least one forum member clearly appreciated the point. I will happily concede that a certain clarity is needed to follow it. However, if you don't follow something, why not ask for clarification? What you and some other forum members do is simply start assuming what the point was and then argue with your own assumption. This isn't debate.
I did ask for clarification - that you were unable to explain your contention or reasoning in an understandable manner is not my fault. Hell, that's why I've come to the conclusion that you've nothing to say, and you're saying it loudly.
See, you've come in here all a-twitter, and you've attributed a position to us 'JREFers' (because we're a monolithic entity, bound by a single IP and destined to serve the hive-mind

) that we don't hold (or at least, most of us): That the absence of any dissent in the structural engineering community in regards to the NIST report is statistically significant.
As I said before: I couldn't give a wet slap if there was dissent in the structural engineering community, or indeed if there was total agreeance and a 'NIST ROX' barbeque every year. What is important is that the science and information within the NIST report is an accurate reflection of reality. Certainly, if all the structural engineers in the world turned around tomorrow and said, "You know what, that NIST report is full of faecal matter," it would raise my eyebrow a smidge - but the engineering community had better explain
why the NIST report is full of said matter if they want me to take them seriously, or even set foot in a high-rise building again!
To summarise in a way that everyone can understand: Screw the lack of statistics and focus on the damn science.
I am and have been a member of many discussion groups on the net for years. Based on this experience I would say that many people on this one are really reactive. It's like they don't even wait to try and appreciate what someone is trying to communicate, they just guess what it's about and come up with their own, usually highly formulaic, reaction. It's not so exciting really, guys.
Bully for you. Am I supposed to be impressed or something - "Ooh, he's been a member of many discussion groups on the net for years!"
Who the hell hasn't?
If you don't want to be misunderstood, I suggest you learn to express yourself in plain English - Ed knows that no one around here is going to think good of you for obfuscating. As a general rule, if you can't express your basic contention in a single understandable sentence, you aren't expressing yourself clearly enough. Don't get annoyed because the members here aren't able to understand what you're saying, because quite honestly I've tried my best to understand your contention and your argument, and come up short every time - hell, I can't even figure out whether you believe in LIHOP, MIHOP, or reality!
Sometimes you just have to consider: Is it everybody else? Or might it be me?