How many people are actually on the NWO payroll?

This highlights one of the points I was going to make. I'm sure that when Nick mentioned "consequences", he was referring to things like the War on Terror, and all that.

But of course, to the engineers involved, that doesn't matter. When asked to determine why the buildings collapsed, they only care about the mechanics of the question. The implications to Government policy are simply not relevant.

If their investigation turned up some sort of malfeasance - be it engineering or construction fraud, or somebody lacing the building with explosives - then they would report that, and let the chips fall where they may.

Any building falling down in such circumstances is a very serious affair. There may be structural implications, and design considerations, I'm sure, though I guess, depending on the established cause, these would or would not be so significant. I'm sure you appreciate I'm not at all qualified to comment specifically on this. I don't know to what degree engineers take scenarios like 911 into account when designing.

As to your assertion that "implications to Government policy are simply not relevant," in theory this would certainly be so. The objectivity of no analyst should waver on the grounds of the implications raised by his or her researches. But, we are all human. The implications of the CD possibility are immense and I wouldn't consider it remotely unreasonable to find that people experience difficulty objectively assessing this particular incident on these grounds.

The brain is multi-layered and only parts of our decision-making processes do we have conscious control over. Check out especially the role of the limbic brain, on the borders of conscious awareness, in assessing information. Check out the notion of "emotional hijacking." The subconscious perspective is always relevant when dealing with cases where belief systems are at stake.

Have you, for example, lived in the shoes of someone who believes that the US government is merely a front for a worldwide malevolent organisation. Have you gone there emotionally?

Nick
 
The implications of the CD possibility are immense and I wouldn't consider it remotely unreasonable to find that people experience difficulty objectively assessing this particular incident on these grounds.
I don't think you've ever met an engineer.

Many engineers wouldn't even think of the implications, and most of the rest wouldn't care. If the evidence pointed to a controlled demolition, they'd put that straight into the report. It wouldn't raise the slightest difficulty for objective assessment.

If there were any evidence.

There isn't.

Have you, for example, lived in the shoes of someone who believes that the US government is merely a front for a worldwide malevolent organisation. Have you gone there emotionally?
Have you ever put yourself in the shoes of someone who, by instinct, by training, and by profession, reports exactly what the physical evidence shows and nothing else?
 
Have you, for example, lived in the shoes of someone who believes that the US government is merely a front for a worldwide malevolent organisation. Have you gone there emotionally?
Yes, when I was eight. In fact, when the babysitter was over, we would watch "Get Smart" reruns and I would pretend to be a malevolent organization. It was a very indirect and immature way of expressing my admiration for her boobs.

Your point?
 
The implications of the CD possibility are immense and I wouldn't consider it remotely unreasonable to find that people experience difficulty objectively assessing this particular incident on these grounds.

[...]

Have you, for example, lived in the shoes of someone who believes that the US government is merely a front for a worldwide malevolent organisation. Have you gone there emotionally?

I suggest you take a look at some of the posts by Dr. Frank Greening, aka Apollo20, on this forum. Here is a man who would very happily accept the implications of the CD theory, who is inclined by nature and by experience within the Canadian nuclear energy industry to believe in all sorts of coverups and conspiracies, who regularly scoffs and sneers at what he sees as pro-government and pro-consensus attitudes on JREF, and who has investigated, and is investigating, the events of 9-11 through his own mathematical modelling. His results are frequently cited by debunkers as very clear evidence that no explosives were necessary for the total collapse of WTC1 and 2 in exactly the manner described, once collapse had initiated. The supposition that the Twin Towers should not have collapsed as they did is perhaps the central myth of the 9-11 conspiracists, and that myth has been exposed as unfounded by someone who is actually, outside his own field, virtually a conspiracy theorist himself.

One of the strongest arguments against the WTC CD's, in my mind, is that even Frank Greening can't find any evidence that supports them.

Dave
 
I suggest you take a look at some of the posts by Dr. Frank Greening, aka Apollo20, on this forum. Here is a man who would very happily accept the implications of the CD theory, who is inclined by nature and by experience within the Canadian nuclear energy industry to believe in all sorts of coverups and conspiracies, who regularly scoffs and sneers at what he sees as pro-government and pro-consensus attitudes on JREF, and who has investigated, and is investigating, the events of 9-11 through his own mathematical modelling. His results are frequently cited by debunkers as very clear evidence that no explosives were necessary for the total collapse of WTC1 and 2 in exactly the manner described, once collapse had initiated. The supposition that the Twin Towers should not have collapsed as they did is perhaps the central myth of the 9-11 conspiracists, and that myth has been exposed as unfounded by someone who is actually, outside his own field, virtually a conspiracy theorist himself.

One of the strongest arguments against the WTC CD's, in my mind, is that even Frank Greening can't find any evidence that supports them.

Dave

Dave,

I sincerely consider that I have an open mind about the WTC collapses. I am not trying to raise a case here against the NIST report, or for the CD theory. I am just pointing out that:

1) Statistically, it is better to get data from events, rather than the absence of events (with regard to the lack of dissent from engineers being a positive assertion of their agreement with the OT)

2) Objectivity can waver when the emotional stakes are high, and it's good to acknowledge this.

Nick
 
Yes, when I was eight. In fact, when the babysitter was over, we would watch "Get Smart" reruns and I would pretend to be a malevolent organization. It was a very indirect and immature way of expressing my admiration for her boobs.

Your point?

My point is that it may be possible for Horatius, or other readers, to validate what I am saying for themselves.

There is, in my experience, a considerable emotional impact that can result from having one's belief systems about our world shaken by CTs. And the mind does have defences to resist this happening. The need to return to a state of cognitive resonance can overwhelm the desire to be fully objective.

If you have not, at least for a period, been shaken by the possibility that much of your existing beliefs about yourself and the world may be actually invalid, then you could surmise from this that perhaps your objectivity could waver. If you've been shaken, if you've gone there emotionally, you also know.

Nick
 
I don't think you've ever met an engineer.

Many engineers wouldn't even think of the implications, and most of the rest wouldn't care.

I'm not saying they would think of the implications. I'm saying that there are other processes at work on the borders of awareness that can influence decision making.

PixyMisa said:
If the evidence pointed to a controlled demolition, they'd put that straight into the report. It wouldn't raise the slightest difficulty for objective assessment.
[/quote}

I put it to you that such a statement itself is unlikely to be objective. You yourself appear to be demonstrating the validity of what I am saying. That is unless you can 100% corroborate it.


PixyMisa said:
Have you ever put yourself in the shoes of someone who, by instinct, by training, and by profession, reports exactly what the physical evidence shows and nothing else?

Well, I worked for a few years at the Police Forensic Science labs in London when I left school. It gave me an insight into the world of science and I still have a few social contacts from this time, but I certainly wouldn't claim science as my profession. Though this isn't really what I was writing about. I was just offering the opportunity to examine on a personal level what we were discussing.

Nick
 
Dave,

I sincerely consider that I have an open mind about the WTC collapses. I am not trying to raise a case here against the NIST report, or for the CD theory. I am just pointing out that:

1) Statistically, it is better to get data from events, rather than the absence of events (with regard to the lack of dissent from engineers being a positive assertion of their agreement with the OT)

2) Objectivity can waver when the emotional stakes are high, and it's good to acknowledge this.

Nick

I'm not particularly trying to convince you either way about the conspiracy theories. I'm just pointing out that there are scientists out there who have made the exact emotional journey that you're talking about, and still found no evidence.

Dave
 
I'm not particularly trying to convince you either way about the conspiracy theories. I'm just pointing out that there are scientists out there who have made the exact emotional journey that you're talking about, and still found no evidence.

Dave

Hi Dave,

That's a very good point, for sure. You mentioned one, are there more then? I'd like to check them out. I've had a preliminary look at the NIST report and the Gage ideas but I lack sufficient knowledge of engineering to make meaningful assessments.

Nick
 
Hi Dave,

That's a very good point, for sure. You mentioned one, are there more then? I'd like to check them out. I've had a preliminary look at the NIST report and the Gage ideas but I lack sufficient knowledge of engineering to make meaningful assessments.

Nick

It's very hard to tell what a particular person believed at the time they started an investigation into 9-11. That's not in general how scientific publications work. We really only know about Frank Greening's attitude from his posts here. Consider him an existence theorem.

There are certainly people who have entertained the idea of something nefarious about 9-11 but found no evidence to support the idea - I'm one of them - and some examples of former dedicated truthers who've changed their minds. Most tellingly, though, I know of no instance of anyone who's studied the evidence in detail, rejected the conspiracy theories, then on seeing further evidence come to accept them. This doesn't necessarily mean there aren't any, but can you imagine how the truth movement would publicise their conversion of a former debunker? It would be hard to miss, so I suspect it hasn't happened.

If it were purely an emotional bias, nobody would change their mind either way, and if both sides had a strong case then people might sway either way; yet neither of those seems to be the case.

Dave
 
It's very hard to tell what a particular person believed at the time they started an investigation into 9-11. That's not in general how scientific publications work. We really only know about Frank Greening's attitude from his posts here.

Hi Dave,

I was asking about more examples as you wrote scientists, the plural, earlier. Hopefully you weren't trying to reinforce your position in such a way! Not that I, and many others, haven't been guilty of such acts in the past.

Dave said:
There are certainly people who have entertained the idea of something nefarious about 9-11 but found no evidence to support the idea - I'm one of them - and some examples of former dedicated truthers who've changed their minds. Most tellingly, though, I know of no instance of anyone who's studied the evidence in detail, rejected the conspiracy theories, then on seeing further evidence come to accept them. This doesn't necessarily mean there aren't any, but can you imagine how the truth movement would publicise their conversion of a former debunker? It would be hard to miss, so I suspect it hasn't happened.

I think you have what sounds like maybe an excellent point. I'd like to just check through it briefly though. We have:

Group 1 - believes in CT; researches 911 more; rejects CT (some exist)

Group 2 - debunks CT; researches more; believes in CT (probably none exist)

For me, I'm not sure here, it seems a little loaded. Would you say there are an equal number of debunkers out there as CTists? I would have thought that the former would probably outnumber the latter considerably. It depends for me also what you call a debunker. There are also, for me, people out there who at first glance rejected CT, then on closer examination, did convert. I've seen plenty. Seems to me a debunker is, timewise, further down the line than a CTist, as debunkers need CTists to exist. They come along after the CTist.

Anyway, I'm not clear.

Dave said:
If it were purely an emotional bias, nobody would change their mind either way, and if both sides had a strong case then people might sway either way; yet neither of those seems to be the case.

Dave

But it's not purely a subconscious (emotional) drama. There's inevitably a big objective element. There's a struggle going on between any latent subconscious drive which sees this as an opportunity to come up into awareness, and the desire of the higher mind for objectivity.

Nick
 
I was asking about more examples as you wrote scientists, the plural, earlier. Hopefully you weren't trying to reinforce your position in such a way! Not that I, and many others, haven't been guilty of such acts in the past.

Sorry, should have clarified - I'm a scientist too, and I seriously considered the conspiracy scenario. I didn't feel I needed to study 9-11 in anywhere near as much detail as Frank Greening, partly because he'd already covered that ground and I came in much later, partly because the evidence available so obviously pointed the same way. That's two, justifying the plural. I can't say for certain whether there are others, but I don't believe in my own uniqueness all that strongly. It might be argued that all debunkers have to at least consider CTs seriously at some point; if one rejects CTs out of hand, why study the evidence, and without a study of the evidence how can one assess it critically?

I think you have what sounds like maybe an excellent point. I'd like to just check through it briefly though. We have:

Group 1 - believes in CT; researches 911 more; rejects CT (some exist)

Group 2 - debunks CT; researches more; believes in CT (probably none exist)

For me, I'm not sure here, it seems a little loaded. Would you say there are an equal number of debunkers out there as CTists? I would have thought that the former would probably outnumber the latter considerably. It depends for me also what you call a debunker. There are also, for me, people out there who at first glance rejected CT, then on closer examination, did convert. I've seen plenty. Seems to me a debunker is, timewise, further down the line than a CTist, as debunkers need CTists to exist. They come along after the CTist.

To clarify, I wouldn't classify someone as a debunker who has heard about the CT and rejected it out of hand. I would only include people who have in some way engaged in the CT debate on the debunking side. I don't have any idea over the relative numbers of CTists and debunkers, and I can't offhand think of a good reason why there should be more of either at any particular point in the evolution of a CT debate. I agree that you can't have a debunker without a CT to debunk; however, there is clearly a two-way debate going on, and amongst the people already active in that debate, the conversions seem to be universally one way.

Dave
 
I'm not saying they would think of the implications. I'm saying that there are other processes at work on the borders of awareness that can influence decision making.
Engineering isn't fluffy stuff like sociology. It's physics and chemistry. No-one gives a good goddam about what's on the borders of awareness. It either is, or it isn't.

Is there any evidence of a controlled demolition? No, there is no evidence whatsoever. What's more, such a process would be quite impossible to carry out without tens of thousands of people noticing the preparations.

I put it to you that such a statement itself is unlikely to be objective. You yourself appear to be demonstrating the validity of what I am saying. That is unless you can 100% corroborate it.
I put it to you that you are projecting your own subjectivity onto others who actually get the job done.

Well, I worked for a few years at the Police Forensic Science labs in London when I left school. It gave me an insight into the world of science and I still have a few social contacts from this time, but I certainly wouldn't claim science as my profession. Though this isn't really what I was writing about. I was just offering the opportunity to examine on a personal level what we were discussing.
Well, just between me and you, you're talking complete bollocks.
 
Engineering isn't fluffy stuff like sociology. It's physics and chemistry. No-one gives a good goddam about what's on the borders of awareness. It either is, or it isn't.

Is there any evidence of a controlled demolition? No, there is no evidence whatsoever. What's more, such a process would be quite impossible to carry out without tens of thousands of people noticing the preparations.

I put it to you that you are projecting your own subjectivity onto others who actually get the job done.


Well, just between me and you, you're talking complete bollocks.

Dude,

You're actively terrified of alternative explanations. I'd swear on it.

Nick
 
you know I would love to believe that we have been visited by an alien race (though they can keep the anal probes...lol), but until there is evidence of this, which there is not, I do not for a moment believe we have...

So what I am saying, is even things that I WANT to believe, I require evidence for, so you can imagine I am quite set that the proof must be solid and bountiful before I will believe things I do not particularly wish to believe (that our own govts plot to kill us so we may go to war).

For 9/11 and all the truth CTs that have come from it, i have seen NO EVIDENCE they are right.

TAM:)
 
So what I am saying, is even things that I WANT to believe, I require evidence for, so you can imagine I am quite set that the proof must be solid and bountiful before I will believe things I do not particularly wish to believe (that our own govts plot to kill us so we may go to war).

TAM:)

You know, to understand why CTists do the stuff they do, my opinion is you have to appreciate some real baseline stuff about the nature of our existence. No one knows ****. You were a little baby and you had no sense of what was yours or what was not. At some point there's all these people pointing at you and saying stuff and it's like - Oh, I get it, this body is me and this funny noise they're saying is my name. It's a game, basically, and we all play along, because we're social animals. But you can't prove anything. You have no way of knowing if all the thoughts currently passing through your head are yours, or if they even belong to anybody. You have no way of knowing if the monitor is outside of you, inside of you, or wherever. Really, there's no way to prove any of this stuff. Most of us accept unquestioningly a socially learned reality.

Now, if you start to rip all these preconceptions apart a bit, what do you realise? You realise that actually nobody knows ****. All the belief systems we build up over time are finally constructed on unexamined preconceptions. This is where most of the CTists are. Someone or something has affected them and they can no longer play the consensual reality game so well. Once you rip apart the belief system a bit you can believe any kind of crazy nonsense that's floating about in your subconscious. Issues with authority? Suddenly it's like Wow, conspiracy theories are true, true, true and I need to tell the world! They just go there.

Nick
 
You know, to understand why CTists do the stuff they do, my opinion is you have to appreciate some real baseline stuff about the nature of our existence. No one knows ****.

...

Now, if you start to rip all these preconceptions apart a bit, what do you realise? You realise that actually nobody knows ****.
That does explain the twooder mindset. "I don't know ****, therefore nobody else really does either so any retarded take on reality can be valid." :p
 
You know, to understand why CTists do the stuff they do, my opinion is you have to appreciate some real baseline stuff about the nature of our existence. No one knows ****. You were a little baby and you had no sense of what was yours or what was not. At some point there's all these people pointing at you and saying stuff and it's like - Oh, I get it, this body is me and this funny noise they're saying is my name. It's a game, basically, and we all play along, because we're social animals. But you can't prove anything. You have no way of knowing if all the thoughts currently passing through your head are yours, or if they even belong to anybody. You have no way of knowing if the monitor is outside of you, inside of you, or wherever. Really, there's no way to prove any of this stuff. Most of us accept unquestioningly a socially learned reality.

Now, if you start to rip all these preconceptions apart a bit, what do you realise? You realise that actually nobody knows ****. All the belief systems we build up over time are finally constructed on unexamined preconceptions. This is where most of the CTists are. Someone or something has affected them and they can no longer play the consensual reality game so well. Once you rip apart the belief system a bit you can believe any kind of crazy nonsense that's floating about in your subconscious. Issues with authority? Suddenly it's like Wow, conspiracy theories are true, true, true and I need to tell the world! They just go there.

Nick

What do you think of science? Doesn't it tell us a little about the world?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom