How many people are actually on the NWO payroll?

Nick,

Please open your mind on this subject. You are being led astray on this by people who really don't understand the physics or engineering issues involved.

And that is understandable as we have done such a horrific job of science education here.

But the people who really know this stuff know that there is nothing suspicious about the WTC tower collapses that requires any sort of bomb or thermite to explain.

Please read the NIST report; It was written with summaries of key points because politicians were expected to understand its conclusions and change building codes as a result. You won't have a hard time understanding the important points, I promise.

-Ben

Hi Ben,

Thanks. I have every intention of reading the report and thank you to everyone who's forwarded me links. I do personally consider that I have an open mind about 9/11. I don't feel a big personal investment in either position, having spent a lot of time in both camps. I am concerned that the truth be revealed and that cases be heard.

It does concern me rather that the NIST report was apparently not a comparative study, but rather proceeded from the assumption that the planes' impact caused the collapse. Of course, it's totally natural that it should take this position. But if other structural engineers are calling into question this apparent primary assumption of the report, then I think a comparative study could be in order.

Nick
 
Since I would appreciate some additional Bucks from the NWO,
what is their official contact info?

Sheesh. Some people... the fact that we serve the interests of Jewish Bankers doesn't mean we're made of money, OK? If you needed the extra money, you'd have it, but since you don't, you don't. Are we clear on this, or do you want some Men in Light Fuchsia to come and explain it in detail?
 
I don't recall Trutherians being told they have to come up with absolute proof. (Or anyone else.) They have been told that they need to come up with some reasonable evidence, which they have not done. I would argue that they need to come up with a coherent narrative, or no one will ever listen to them; but that is an issue of mine and no doubt others disagree as to the need of a narrative.

I would say that they need to demonstrate reasonable doubt, and, as a general rule, ideally they should be qualified to make any statements made. Otherwise, as you say, anyone could derail professional investigations with all sorts of nonsense.
[/quote]

SDC said:
Gage, Jones, et al., are the ones who challenge the so-called "Official Theory," which in fact is more than that -- it is accepted by a general consensus of professionals in the relevant fields. Let them disprove it with evidence and with clear narratives. They have not done this. They do not seem even to have tried in a serious way.

Can I just check something out here? Are you saying that because many professionals have not contested the NIST report they therefore can be considered as having accepted it?

SDC said:
Yes, some people dispute the report. Dr Greening has some specific issues, for example, but no qualified person, including him, has come out in favor of the planned demolition theory. (Gage and his group are hardly qualified.)

If the issues could be said to raise significant doubt, especially if they come from someone with professional credentials, then I would have thought that they need to be checked into.

Are you saying that Gage is not qualified to make an assessment?

SDC said:
I have tried to respond in sequence to your comments. Fundamentally, I think you are saying "why not listen to these other fellows?" My response is that they have already been weighed in the balance, and been found wanting.

I just need to see for myself that this is the case. Some of your comments do concern me a bit.

Nick
 
Oh god! Not the MiLFs! Anything but that!
Speak for yourself.
pervert.gif
 
Can I just check something out here? Are you saying that because many professionals have not contested the NIST report they therefore can be considered as having accepted it?

Nick

From http://www.nspe.org/ethics/eh1-code.asp Section II. Rules of Practice, item 1 f :

Engineers having knowledge of any alleged violation of this Code shall report thereon to appropriate professional bodies and, when relevant, also to public authorities, and cooperate with the proper authorities in furnishing such information or assistance as may be required.



Section III. Professional Obligations, item 2 a :

Engineers are encouraged to participate in civic affairs; career guidance for youths; and work for the advancement of the safety, health, and well-being of their community.



From http://www.peo.on.ca/Ethics/code_of_ethics.html

Section 77 2(ii):


endeavour at all times to enhance the public regard for the practitioner's profession by extending the public knowledge thereof and discouraging untrue, unfair or exaggerated statements with respect to professional engineering,


Section 77 8:

8.A practitioner shall maintain the honour and integrity of the practitioner's profession and without fear or favour expose before the proper tribunals unprofessional, dishonest or unethical conduct by any other practitioner.


So yes, if an engineer was aware of the NIST report, and believed there to be serious flaws in it, they are expected to expose those flaws to the proper authorities. For any engineer who has read the report, and not done this, it can be reasonably assumed that said engineer supports the validity of the NIST report.

And it's a safe bet that a large majority of the structural engineers in the world have read some or all of the NIST report, dealing as it does with one of the most dramatic, and most documented, engineering events of all time.
 
From http://www.nspe.org/ethics/eh1-code.asp Section II. Rules of Practice, item 1 f :

Section III. Professional Obligations, item 2 a :

From http://www.peo.on.ca/Ethics/code_of_ethics.html

Section 77 2(ii):

Section 77 8:

So yes, if an engineer was aware of the NIST report, and believed there to be serious flaws in it, they are expected to expose those flaws to the proper authorities. For any engineer who has read the report, and not done this, it can be reasonably assumed that said engineer supports the validity of the NIST report.

And it's a safe bet that a large majority of the structural engineers in the world have read some or all of the NIST report, dealing as it does with one of the most dramatic, and most documented, engineering events of all time.

Seems you've done your homework. Thanks for giving me this information. For me, it's still better to have a positive demonstration of assent than the absence of a negative. A lot better. There are too many variables otherwise.

Nick
 
Seems you've done your homework. Thanks for giving me this information. For me, it's still better to have a positive demonstration of assent than the absence of a negative. A lot better. There are too many variables otherwise.

Nick

There are several reputable scientific journals that support the official version. There are exactly zero reputable scientific journals supporting the conspiracy theories. ae911 is not a reputable organisation.
 
Seems you've done your homework. Thanks for giving me this information. For me, it's still better to have a positive demonstration of assent than the absence of a negative. A lot better. There are too many variables otherwise.

Nick



Would you hold the same standard for every other engineering disaster that occurs? We've had several bridge collapses in the last year or so. How many engineers have come out to positively support the notion that those collapses weren't "inside jobs"?

Take a look at Wikipedia, and search on "building collapse". Do you expect all the engineers in the world to make public pronouncements that they agree with the findings into the causes of these collapses? If not, why is 9/11 different?
 
I think your right. If the movement was more popular more professionals would speak out. The movements problem is their theories are mostly outrageous and are laughed aside because of this. I'm a builder and every time we hear the subject it's considered a joke.
I have had email conversations with Gage. He told me that I was the only one that questioned the 6.7 second collapse of WTC7 (4 months ago). When I asked him about the east penthouse he said it wasn't part of the collapse. How exactly should a building professional reacted to that type of comment? Now do you see why they are ignored.

Eggsaxtlee!
We pay no more attention to these guys than Congress would to some fellow from Podunk, Idaho who claims allover the Internet to be the hereditary King of the Americas
 
Since I would appreciate some additional Bucks from the NWO, what is their official contact info?

Don't worry, they'll contact you. They may even knock, but more likely, it'll be a rude awakening, complete with a light in your eyes, a hand on your mouth, a knife at your throat, and a harsh warning to say nothing to anyone.
 
http://usinfo.state.gov/media/misinformation.html

The Top September 11 Conspiracy Theories

Numerous unfounded conspiracy theories about the September 11 attacks continue to circulate, especially on the Internet. Some of the most prevalent myths are:

1) The World Trade Center (WTC) twin towers were destroyed by controlled demolitions.

This is how the collapses may have appeared to non-experts, but demolition experts point out many differences:

Demolition professionals always blow the bottom floors of a structure first, but the WTC tower collapses began at the upper levels, where the planes hit the buildings.
Non-experts claim that debris seen blowing out of windows was evidence of explosive charges, but experts identify this as air and light office contents (paper, pulverized concrete, etc.) being forced out of windows as floors collapsed on each other.
Demolition firms had very sensitive seismographs operating at other sites in Manhattan on September 11. None recorded any explosions during the tower collapses.
Clean-up crews found none of the telltale signs of controlled demolitions that would have existed if explosive charges had been used.
Cutting away walls, insulation, plumbing, and electrical conduits to place numerous charges on the towers’ structural columns in advance would not have gone unnoticed.


For more information, see ImplosionWorld’s article on the WTC collapses and Popular Mechanics, parts 4 and 5.

LOL
 
For more information, see ImplosionWorld’s article on the WTC collapses and Popular Mechanics, parts 4 and 5.

LOL
It certainly makes sense for Popular Mechanics to be in on it. After all, the New World Order was founded on the principle of confusing people about hemis. :rolleyes:
 
Would you hold the same standard for every other engineering disaster that occurs? We've had several bridge collapses in the last year or so. How many engineers have come out to positively support the notion that those collapses weren't "inside jobs"?

Take a look at Wikipedia, and search on "building collapse". Do you expect all the engineers in the world to make public pronouncements that they agree with the findings into the causes of these collapses? If not, why is 9/11 different?

Horatius,

Just to make it clear, I'm not trying to make a major point here. I'm looking forward to the checking out the links I've been given and trying to formulate my own opinions about 911. I'm open minded about what caused the Towers to fall down.

What I'm saying is that, in terms of gathering meaningful evidence, it is better to have a response than the absence of a response. There are fewer variables to assess.

There are several ways you could specifically dispute this, if you are a structural engineer or you have close contact with some. How many project failure reports get run past you annually? To what degree do you examine these? How many have you had a concern about, a concern not addressed in the report? What degree of concern would cause you to write a statement? Etc, etc.

Of course, it would probably be a lot easier to just run a poll, or get an agency to run one, sampling structural engineers and asking them a simple series of questions about the specific example of the NIST report. I doubt it would cost so much and I think would get some reasonable quality evidence plus spread word of any concerns you have from the CT movement.

Regarding why 911 is different from other building failures....do you really need to ask that question? The consequences are greater, a lot greater, on both an exterior and interior level.

Nick
 
Regarding why 911 is different from other building failures....do you really need to ask that question? The consequences are greater, a lot greater, on both an exterior and interior level.

Nick

I would disagree. How often are buildings hit by planes? Would the consequences not have been greater if a building collapsed only because of fire? This would then bring in adequacy of fire protection, sprinkler systems, etc.
 
Regarding why 911 is different from other building failures....do you really need to ask that question? The consequences are greater, a lot greater, on both an exterior and interior level.

Nick

I would disagree. How often are buildings hit by planes? Would the consequences not have been greater if a building collapsed only because of fire? This would then bring in adequacy of fire protection, sprinkler systems, etc.



This highlights one of the points I was going to make. I'm sure that when Nick mentioned "consequences", he was referring to things like the War on Terror, and all that.

But of course, to the engineers involved, that doesn't matter. When asked to determine why the buildings collapsed, they only care about the mechanics of the question. The implications to Government policy are simply not relevant.

If their investigation turned up some sort of malfeasance - be it engineering or construction fraud, or somebody lacing the building with explosives - then they would report that, and let the chips fall where they may.
 
<snip>Now, the government has produced a report, and there are structural engineers who are contesting it.

Snipping out most of your post and leaving aside all of the references to the legal system that you got wrong, please tell me - who are these "structural engineers" to whom you refer? Name names, please.

<snip>But if there are professionals who are disputing the report then surely their concerns have to be considered? They do not have to unequivocably prove that the towers were brought down by demolition, they simply need to demonstrate significant doubt in the NIST report.

Who are these "professionals" that you refer to? Again, name names, please. And what "significant doubt" do you think they have demonstrated?

Please put your cards on the table so that your concerns can be dealt with directly rather than vaguely or circumspectly. After all, that's what you're here for, right?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom