Do you disagree with its proof because actual experts disagree or just because the truth movement as a whole does?
I have not read it but others here have (with much better expertise than either of us) who do believe the report did what it should have and did it well.Because different experts disagree. Seeing as you have read, I assume, the NIST report, could you tell me to what degree it ascribes absolute veracity to its findings?
Nick
Nick,
Please open your mind on this subject. You are being led astray on this by people who really don't understand the physics or engineering issues involved.
And that is understandable as we have done such a horrific job of science education here.
But the people who really know this stuff know that there is nothing suspicious about the WTC tower collapses that requires any sort of bomb or thermite to explain.
Please read the NIST report; It was written with summaries of key points because politicians were expected to understand its conclusions and change building codes as a result. You won't have a hard time understanding the important points, I promise.
-Ben
I'm not repudiating the statement of the OT, neither the CT. I don't know the truth. BTW, could you quote me the principles involved behind your statement that the burden of proof is on me. Burden of proof is a legal term. I wasn't aware we were in court.
Because a lot of people don't believe it. I'm not a structural engineer. I don't have the ability to intelligently assess the report. I just go on the fact that there is considerable dispute as to its accuracy. One of the aspects of "proven cases" is that not many people dispute them.
Nick
While everyone else is shocked that there are still people who believe 9/11 was an inside job, I find myself more stunned that the OP actually got into college. (Or so he claims, maybe that's the real conspiracy theory).
so you mean the thousand amero a week stipend ive been getting is worthless sicne there wont be a NAU?I'm going to go with a realistic number of 0 people on the NWO payroll because the NWO only exists in our imagination and the paranoia of some others.
so you mean the thousand amero a week stipend ive been getting is worthless sicne there wont be a NAU?
![]()
While everyone else is shocked that there are still people who believe 9/11 was an inside job, I find myself more stunned that the OP actually got into college. (Or so he claims, maybe that's the real conspiracy theory).
And that is exactly how the CT profiteers want you to react. Anyone can create "dispute" simply by shouting, "I doubt it!". The question needs to be, is the dispute a legitimate dispute or not? You have to look at who is creating the dispute, and whether or not they have the skills and knowledge to be able to raise legitimate concerns, and whether or not they have some other motive for creating dispute.
This is an incredibly common tactic amongst the woo promoters out there - they'll make up bogus issues just to manufacture a controversy, because they know a certain percentage of the population will fall for it. That's the percentage they make their money from.
Try not to fall for it, okay?
That may be the case but I would like to raise this issue a little. You see, I have seen on this list on several occasions CT opposers apparently state that if one wishes to dispute the OT one must absolutely prove another case. As I understand it, this is not necessary.
If there was a legal case, where the verdict had already been delivered, and I wanted it re-opened, I would not have to prove an alternate verdict. I would simply have to demonstrate a reasonable doubt as to the soundness of the existing verdict. There could be new evidence or there could be reason to doubt the quality of the existing evidence.
This is the procedure, as I understand it, for a criminal case, in our adversarial legal system. The NIST report does not fall within this harshly scrutinised arena, yet I have seen several people on this list assert that a far higher degree of evidence is needed to even challenge it.
The NIST report, as I understand it, is more like an inquest. The primary responsibility of the government, and its offices, is to ascertain the truth, that it can better protect the public in future. This is its primary duty, not to put its weight behind one version of events, but to seek the truth and protect the people. It is not the State vs Richard Gage, or Alex Jones, or whoever.
Now, the government has produced a report, and there are structural engineers who are contesting it. As far as I can see, it is not a comparative report. It proceeds, not unreasonably, from the assumption that the impact of the planes brought down the towers. But if there are professionals who are disputing the report then surely their concerns have to be considered? They do not have to unequivocably prove that the towers were brought down by demolition, they simply need to demonstrate significant doubt in the NIST report.
What do you think?
Nick
Nick,
Please open your mind on this subject. You are being led astray on this by people who really don't understand the physics or engineering issues involved.
And that is understandable as we have done such a horrific job of science education here.
But the people who really know this stuff know that there is nothing suspicious about the WTC tower collapses that requires any sort of bomb or thermite to explain.
Please read the NIST report; It was written with summaries of key points because politicians were expected to understand its conclusions and change building codes as a result. You won't have a hard time understanding the important points, I promise.
-Ben