I maintain that there is no "NWO."
Wait, isn't the NWO more of a right-wing, neo-con sort of group? Wouldn't that make them against unions?Can someone give me contact details of the NWO union.
Nick227 said:If I was a structural engineer and I saw the Richard Gage thing and felt it was bs, I would get up and say so. I mean it.
I am a structural engineer and Richard Gage is full of crap.
Your giving them way to much credit as to their popularity. The average person doesn't even know this fringe conspiracy group even exists.
There is hard evidence that an office fire can weaken steel.
Personally, I don't think it's obvious the towers were demolished. I think it looks suspicious. But, the point is, you can't really take the absence of outcry in the structural engineering business as meaningful evidence that the CT position is wrong, or that the NWO are paying them all off. Especially when there are some structural engineers who are concerned about the OT, and seemingly not yet so many standing up to say they uphold it.
If you want to ridicule something, why not just say it's ridiculous? Concocting some highly pseudo-scientific proposal to try and do so, to me, just makes you look ridiculous.
You don't have hard evidence that the towers were not demolished. You don't have hard evidence that the towers fell down as a result of being struck by planes. Neither is there hard evidence that they were demolished. Nor that they didn't come down as a result of the plane impacts. None that I've seen, anyway. There's the OT. There's the CT contention. There are rebuttals and alternative proposals. The position is unclear. It's in play. It's cool.
Garb, why debate something like this? Why not just go and ask the guy?
If I was a structural engineer and I saw the Richard Gage thing and felt it was bs, I would get up and say so. I mean it.
Nick
Who exactly? And like I said, why should someone voice their support?
Garb said:Should they support every single position on every single structural failure in the world?
Garb said:Burden of proof is on YOU to find evidence the towers WERE demolished.
Garb said:Why is that my job?
I think your right. If the movement was more popular more professionals would speak out. The movements problem is their theories are mostly outrageous and are laughed aside because of this. I'm a builder and every time we hear the subject it's considered a joke.Exactly.
If and when it does become more known, more people will come out and take a position
Nick
Because, as a rule, people care about this stuff. "Should" doesn't come into it.
I think when the credibility of the US Government itself is at stake it will incline people to be more concerned.
I'm not repudiating the statement of the OT, neither the CT. I don't know the truth. BTW, could you quote me the principles involved behind your statement that the burden of proof is on me. Burden of proof is a legal term. I wasn't aware we were in court.
Garb, are you the kind of guy who sits in the corner at clubs and wonders if the girl over there is attracted to him; who spends all the time trying to figure it out. (I used to be!). Because this is precisely the position you are taking here. You want to debate something when you can just go and ask the guy. Why debate what his understandings or motivations might be, when you can ask him yourself? Are you actually even interested in TRUTH - whatever it looks like?
Nick
Are you going to ask my question or only quote that one part?
Garb said:But why doesn't it? What do you think an expert's opinion would be on this subject if they don't voice their support either way? You think that they would believe the CT and do nothing?
Garb said:So in debate class you were actually settling legal terms? When you are in a debate, you have the burden to prove a positive statement.
Garb said:If you believe the government was behind the attacks one way or another, then you prove it. There have been studies that have proved the towers were brought down by planes and fires. They had the burden, so they proved it.
I think your right. If the movement was more popular more professionals would speak out. The movements problem is their theories are mostly outrageous and are laughed aside because of this. I'm a builder and every time we hear the subject it's considered a joke.
I have had email conversations with Gage. He told me that I was the only one that questioned the 6.7 second collapse of WTC7 (4 months ago). When I asked him about the east penthouse he said it wasn't part of the collapse. How exactly should a building professional reacted to that type of comment? Now do you see why they are ignored.
Nick, I'm going to just digress from this pointless discussion we are having, and ask you a question, which you haven't answered since the beginning of this thread.
What makes you not satisfied with the NIST evaluation of the Twin Towers collapse?
Then why your assertion that there is no proof that the towers collapsed by planes?I haven't read it.
Nick
Then why your assertion that there is no proof that the towers collapsed by planes?
Because a lot of people don't believe it. I'm not a structural engineer. I don't have the ability to intelligently assess the report. I just go on the fact that there is considerable dispute as to its accuracy. One of the aspects of "proven cases" is that not many people dispute them.
Nick
Do you disagree with its proof because actual experts disagree or just because the truth movement as a whole does?Because a lot of people don't believe it. I'm not a structural engineer. I don't have the ability to intelligently assess the report. I just go on the fact that there is considerable dispute as to its accuracy. One of the aspects of "proven cases" is that not many people dispute them.
Nick