How homeopathy does work? - 4 Years of DHMS course.

[Nucular]

Everyone in Britain over the age of 25 looks like that. It's from lack of sunlight. If you take them to Spain, expose them to sunlight and dip them in the warm ocean, they plump right back up and look just like Spice Girls/Boys.

Untrue. While the theory is sound, unfortunately this idea has not been borne out by experimental evidence.

 

[Perpetual Notion]

Untrue. While the theory is sound, unfortunately this idea has not been borne out by experimental evidence.

Well he is plump. And have you seen Ginger Spice lately?

 

[MRC_Hans]

It's not that they look old, it's the interiour "decoration" of that place . Unfortunately, it is not atypical. I wonder when the British will catch up with the rest of the universe and invent white (or at least light) paint.

Hans

 

[H'ethetheth]

It's not that they look old, it's the interiour "decoration" of that place ...

Are you saying that they don't actually look old, but the wall paint makes us think they do?
This could mean one of two things:

- White wall paint would make them actually look old and confirm our suspicion that they do.
- White wall paint would not change how they look, but make us change our mind about how old they look.

 

[MRC_Hans]

Are you saying that they don't actually look old, but the wall paint makes us think they do?
This could mean one of two things:

- White wall paint would make them actually look old and confirm our suspicion that they do.
- White wall paint would not change how they look, but make us change our mind about how old they look.

I'm just saying that the room looks worse than the occupants.

Hans

 

[H'ethetheth]

Ah! Pity.

 

[Dr. MAS]

It's more serious than that, I suspect. I'm discovering painfully that MAS and the others from NCH have yet to pass GO on basic chemistry.

If anybody proves that "BSM equation is equally applicable on all homeopathic potencies in the same way as BSM has applied on Nat Sulph", then WHCC will offer him/her a blank check.

 

[MRC_Hans]

If anybody proves that "BSM equation is equally applicable on all homeopathic potencies in the same way as BSM has applied on Nat Sulph", then WHCC will offer him/her a blank check.

Seriously, MAS, could we get past all this prize nonsense?

You started this thread by promising to explain how homeoathy works. So far, you have made ONE post that that could be said to at least start to do just that.

How about you continue?

And if you claim that some rmedies have different chemistry, go ahead and explain how.

But stop demanding that we prove you wrong at every step of the way.

Hans

 

[Dr. MAS]

I will continue to explain how homeopathy does work.

I was responding on the few posts which were booked in my abscence.

OK i will not responde on those which are irrelevent.

 

[Dr. MAS]

A quick question, Qureshi. Is that your face you are using as your avatar?

Qureshi: You are so young. You look too old in this avatar. Which software you use? And where are your moustache and whiskers.

 

[MRC_Hans]

I will continue to explain how homeopathy does work.

Good, we eagerly await your next lesson .

I was responding on the few posts which were booked in my abscence.

OK i will not responde on those which are irrelevent.

Might I suggest we skip the endless bickering part. If you address the questions directly pertaining to your first lesson, most of which are given in the first page of this thread, I think most here will be reasonably happy.

Hans

 

[Mouthfire]

If anybody proves that "BSM equation is equally applicable on all homeopathic potencies in the same way as BSM has applied on Nat Sulph", then WHCC will offer him/her a blank check.

It's becoming readily apparent that you truly don't understand the equation.

How about this? Instead of just stating "I reject that equation", why don't you explain what the derivation means AND THEN explain why it does not apply to homeopathy.

I'm not going to hold my breath, because it's becoming very obvious that these diversionary tactics and wafering on this and that, are a smoke screen to hide the fact that you don't understand the topic.

It's very sad that a self-purported doctor has never studied elementary chemistry....



Edited for grammar

 

[Jocce]

If anybody proves that "BSM equation is equally applicable on all homeopathic potencies in the same way as BSM has applied on Nat Sulph", then WHCC will offer him/her a blank check.

Not only is it applicable on all homeopathic remedies, it's applicable on everything from solutions of chemicals to piles of colored balls.

MAS, If you can't see that, then just leave and let the grownups continue the discussion. One sad thing is that you don't even understand how big a fool you're making out of yourself. But, the sadest thing is that there's an even worse bunch of people standing on the sideline applauding your high potency postings.

Amazing...

 

[Rolfe]

Errr, uhmmm, Rolfe? You might want to get some new blood into that society of yours, they all look kinda old

/runs and hides

I only noticed when I was copying the pictures, how I'd managed to home in on the geriatric contingent! The thing is, most of them are very senior scientists, with minds like the proverbial steel traps, so you tend not to notice the age when you're talking to them. There were some younger people there too, just not in range of the camera (well, I think one is visible just on the edge of one frame). And I took the bloody photos, from behind the camera, so stop casting nasturtiums!

But you have a point. It's become something of a senior partners' club, and getting the up-and-coming contingent on board is something that needs to be addressed.

It's not that they look old, it's the interiour "decoration" of that place . Unfortunately, it is not atypical. I wonder when the British will catch up with the rest of the universe and invent white (or at least light) paint.

Well, it's quite a big room. Which means that the flash on the camera didn't really do it justice. Some types of screen seem to show it up better then others (it wasn't bad on my notebook's LCD screen). It's actually the "Picture Room" at the Athenaeum Club in Pall Mall, London, and it's nicer than it appears in the photos.

Rolfe.

 

[geni]

If anybody proves that "BSM equation is equally applicable on all homeopathic potencies in the same way as BSM has applied on Nat Sulph", then WHCC will offer him/her a blank check.

The general case? Not a problem:

for C remedies

F=I/n¹⁰⁰

For X remedies

F=I/n¹⁰

Where F is the final number it items per liter, I is the initail number of items and n is the potency. The highest posible value for I is about 6.02214*10²⁵ (athough the higest value I can think of would be 3.31218*10²⁵ for water). It is trivial to show that for large enough values of n F<1

 

[Rolfe]

Anybody care to estimate the chance that Mas will actually understand that?

Rolfe.

 

[geni]

Anybody care to estimate the chance that Mas will actually understand that?

Rolfe.

It's only very basic chemistry.

 

[Rolfe]

It's only very basic chemistry.

Well, yes....

And your point is...?

Rolfe.

 

[geni]

Well, yes....

And your point is...?

Rolfe.

If he doesn't understand this what do we tell him to go and study?

 

[Rolfe]

For God sake, try to study basic chemistry first.

Ka-BOOM!!

Rolfe.