Homoeopaths say the darndest things

So the monkeys finally managed to put those typewriters to use. Did he actual provide the "absolute proof"?


One of the examples was to do with Polo mints:
To give just one example of this (I have a far, far better example of ABSOLUTE PROOF of Survival, later on, here): our dad sadly did what’s wrongly termed ‘die’ in May 1982, aged just 49. LATER that year (I was 23 at the time of his ‘death’), I began to regularly consume Polo mints. Ie, whilst our dad had been on Earth, I’d never consumed Polos. It is NOWHERE documented, on Earth, that I’ve been consuming them for the past 37 and a half years. Well, in a reading with a Spiritualist Church medium (N.B., they, Spiritualist Church mediums, worldwide, are not allowed to work in their Churches unless/until they are able to 100% PROVE that they are genuinely relaying information from the very real Spirit world) that I, his eldest child, “was always consuming Polo mints”. And NO, the medium in question DID NOT see a packet of Polos on my person; for the reading took place over the phone. The ONLY way that my dad in Spirit could have known that is for him (ie, the REAL him; ie, the immortal consciousness that was my dad, in this lifetime) to have SURVIVED the death of his physical body ‘coat’; and then to have seen, from his vantage-point in the Spirit dimension, that I had, later on in the year in which he ‘died’, started to consume Polo mints.
 
From a reply to a post on Edzard Ernst’s blog:


:boggled:

So not only does dilution increase strength, and water remember more complex molecules, and opposites cancel out, but all this acts on the spiritual, not the physical, but it still heals the "not real us" via the spiritual, AND standard proof doesn't work on it?

That is one colossal house of cards, there.
 
So not only does dilution increase strength, and water remember more complex molecules, and opposites cancel out, but all this acts on the spiritual, not the physical, but it still heals the "not real us" via the spiritual, AND standard proof doesn't work on it?


And it still works fine even if the patient experiences “the immensely illusory event that’s wholly incorrectly termed ‘death’.”
 
"I am not aware of any alternative medicine comedians. Perhaps they use homeopathic comedy. The original joke is repeatedly diluted down in many other neutral and unfunny words until the paragraph only retains the memory of the joke, which can then be read out. Although, according to the law of similars, such a homeopathic joke should be used to cure enjoyment and stop people laughing.

It works! Homeopathy is proven!"

:D

"Some ‘facts’ are merely CLAIMED to be facts. To give just two examples, the following:
1) It is a merely CLAIMED ‘fact’ that vaccines are ‘safe and effective’.
Whereas the ACTUAL fact is that they, vaccines, are immensely dangerous, in most cases not effective, and that they have been proven to be a medical fraud/hoax/scam.
2) It is a merely CLAIMED ‘fact’, by ‘orthodox’ Science and ‘orthodox’ Medicine, that ‘death’ is the end of existence.
Whereas the ACTUAL, 100% DEFINITELY PROVEN fact is that NO, ‘death’ is most definitely NOT the end of existence, for there exists a veritable wealth, a cornucopia, in fact, of multi-faceted evidences which PROVE that we all survive (in our immortal spirit body form…) that immensely illusory, hugely misinterpreted, event.
There are any number of other examples of merely CLAIMED ‘facts’, and then the ACTUAL facts, which are the exact opposite of the merely CLAIMED ‘fact’, regarding whatever subjects one cares to mention."

Oh my..
 
Last edited:
Oh my...Quoting Susan Humphries and Ty Bollinger favourably...Mis-quoting Kubler-Ross (but many people do that, just not in this way).

Assign to Big Round Rubbish Receptacle.
 
From a reply to a post on Edzard Ernst’s blog:
Homeopathy works due to the fact that it works on the ACTUAL us; for, even though I bet that 99.9% of the people who post on this sceptics’ site will not be aware of the PROVEN truth of the following statement (and I WILL have absolute proof for you, later on in this lengthy post. A couple of examples of personal proof; as have many millions of other spiritually-enlightened people, worldwide), the physical body is NOT the REAL us. The real us is our eternal, immortal SOUL/SPIRIT BODY form; that is the thing which literally ANIMATES our physical body ‘coat’ whilst we live each [of many…] lifetime. For yes, some years ago, Dr Suzanne Humphries discovered the veritable wealth of multi-faceted evidences which PROVE that we all in very real truth SURVIVE (in our eternal, immortal soul/SPIRIT body form) the immensely illusory event that’s wholly incorrectly termed ‘death’.

:boggled:
That very much needs to get combined with FMOTL "strawman" etc definitions!
 
From a reply to a post on Edzard Ernst’s blog:


:boggled:
Looked up Dr Suzanne Humphries and the first page has Why Dr Suzanne Humphries, an anti-vaccine activist, is lying to you about measles!

Christine Thompson's "Part 1." comment is a spate of lies about vaccines being "immensely dangerous" and " a proven medical fraud/hoax/scam". A small lie of being "immensely scholarly by nature" when reading mostly crank books as in her book list is not scholarly. Scholarly would be reading the science about vaccines or even high school biology textbooks.

Christine Thompson's "Part 2." comment starts with that Dr Suzanne Humphries has an inaccurate or lying (or Thompson is lying) book.
Vaccines did not 'eradicate' diseases (plural). Vaccines eradicated smallpox. The historical data shows that vaccines are effective against whooping cough, diphtheria, measles, etc.
Advances in medicine and public heath did not eradiate diseases. It is irrelevant that they were also effective.
Then "Why homeopathy does work." and Thompson's nonsense about the spirit/soul. Homeopathy does not to claim to be actual witchcraft working by spells on the spirit or soul :p! Homeopathy claims to be medical science.

Christine Thompson's "Part 3." comment is nonsense about "proven to be genuine" mediums, clairvoyants, and clairaudients and personal anecdotes about Thompson being fooled by them. She continuously eats Polo mints, goes to a a medium and the medium has her voices comment on the mints. Anyone with a nose would detect mints on her.

Christine Thompson's "Part 4." has an irrelevant list of books with "proven truth" nonsense about spirits, souls, etc. Christine Thompson lies that Andrew Wakefield was not doing "fraudulent research" when that was what Brian Deer showed Wakefield did and part of why he was struck off the United Kingdom medical register. Christine Thompson lies that Wakefield's research was replicated. No link between the MMR vaccine and autism has ever been found.
More spiritualism nonsense.

In short, Ex-doctor Andrew Wakefield: “Better to die as a free man than live as a slave” (and get vaccinated against Covid-19) has Wakefield lying about Covid-19. Christine Thompson comments with hero worship of Wakefield, lies about vaccines, and spiritualism nonsense about homeopathy.
 
One of the examples was to do with Polo mints:
Well, in a reading with a Spiritualist Church medium (N.B., they, Spiritualist Church mediums, worldwide, are not allowed to work in their Churches unless/until they are able to 100% PROVE that they are genuinely relaying information from the very real Spirit world)

I love this bit.
I think we're dealing with definitions of '100%' and 'prove' that may not be found in a dictionary.
How does this work? Is there some kind of interview? An examination? A demonstration?
How is it possible to fail such a process? "Dear Madame Bloviatsky, thank you for your interest in the position of Genuine 100% Proven Spiritualist Medium. We regret to inform you that your portentous claptrap failed to meet our rigorous standards of vagueness, inconsistency and the co-option of the legends and culture of indigenous cultures".
I'm thinking here of the mediums Scorpion quoted as saying there were civilisations on both Mars and Venus. Apparently that medium was able to pass the entrance (pun intended! In trance? Never mind.) exam.
Does anyone have any info about this process?
 
I think people are underestimating how much information a good cold reader can get out of a willing mark. Especially if, as is usually the case with marks who actually look for someone to scam them, said mark is more than willing to ignore failed pokes for information and only count the positives.
 
I think people are underestimating how much information a good cold reader can get out of a willing mark. Especially if, as is usually the case with marks who actually look for someone to scam them, said mark is more than willing to ignore failed pokes for information and only count the positives.

One of the very best cold reader "mentalists' and debunker is Derren_BrownWP

The number of people who have been convinced that he is the genuine THING is legion. Just listen to what they say. HE MUST BE REAL!

Here is a fairly typical documentary he's made in which he investigates Joe Power, a man who claims to be able to talk to the dead.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=duxQA9TcDcA
(pick up the cold reading analysis at the 23 minute mark)

More at his website: http://derrenbrown.co.uk/
 
Last edited:
I think people are underestimating how much information a good cold reader can get out of a willing mark. Especially if, as is usually the case with marks who actually look for someone to scam them, said mark is more than willing to ignore failed pokes for information and only count the positives.

Indeed. Or most skilled interviewers...

I was a mental health nurse for 30-odd years and I could get information out of folk that they didn't think they were going to tell me or join the dots of what they'd told me to reach correct conclusions.
 
I think people are underestimating how much information a good cold reader can get out of a willing mark. Especially if, as is usually the case with marks who actually look for someone to scam them, said mark is more than willing to ignore failed pokes for information and only count the positives.

For sure, but you also need to consider the beliefs and motivations of the churches that employ these people.
They will undoubtedly be aware of what hot and cold reading are. The question would be whether they are in on the scam, and use mediums in the full knowledge that it's fake, or if they actually genuinely believe in mediumship as a link to the spirit world?
That's where this supposed test comes into it. How could you distinguish between a skilled cold reader and a real medium, if you thought that there really were real ones?
Even Scorpion, who is a true believer, has admitted to being fooled. If you know it's a con, it's not a problem, but if you are sincere, then it kind of undermines a major chunk of your belief system.
 
Well, I've never seen one in a church setting, or for that matter have no experience with specifically mediums, so I'm not sure what the difference is there. But it seems to me like if you know someone is doing cold-reading, you know that any information they get is coming from you. It's pretty trivial to feed them false information and see if then their spirits or crystal ball or tarot cards or telepathy powers then tell them exactly that falsehood.
 
Well, there’s the cartoon of a medium saying, “come on, there must be somebody here who knew someone whose name begins with a J!”
 
Well, I've never seen one in a church setting, or for that matter have no experience with specifically mediums, so I'm not sure what the difference is there. But it seems to me like if you know someone is doing cold-reading, you know that any information they get is coming from you. It's pretty trivial to feed them false information and see if then their spirits or crystal ball or tarot cards or telepathy powers then tell them exactly that falsehood.

If the churches were doing that, you'd think they would publish those results, to expose the charlatans (as they see it) and prevent anyone else from falling victim.
Christian charity and all that, you know. I'm not aware of this actually happening- the debunking and the outing of fraudsters seems to be an exclusively skeptic thing- Randi et al. Anyone know of any church-based debunkers?
 
If the churches were doing that, you'd think they would publish those results, to expose the charlatans (as they see it) and prevent anyone else from falling victim.
Christian charity and all that, you know. I'm not aware of this actually happening- the debunking and the outing of fraudsters seems to be an exclusively skeptic thing- Randi et al. Anyone know of any church-based debunkers?

I'm not sure it counts as church based debunking but I found this:

https://www.cmf.org.uk/resources/publications/content/?context=article&id=548

"Many Christians in the UK today are concerned that homoeopathy may involve the occult. Hahnemann was a freemason and a hypnotist, but was reportedly a well-educated and empathetic practitioner.

However, the answer to the question of whether homoeopathy involves the occult is not immediately evident. It depends on where the 'immaterial and vital' force is thought to originate from. This will follow to some extent, but not necessarily wholly, from the therapist's world-view.

There is certainly evidence from continental Europe of a link between homoeopathy and the occult, where it has been alleged that homoeopathic practitioners carry out research during seances and use occult practices such as the pendulum.[10] This is probably less common in Britain, but anecdotal reports are of concern. Christian homoeopathic practitioners should obviously not use these practices."

It seems there is some pushback from religion against homeopathy, how widespread that is /shrug.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom