Homoeopaths say the darndest things

She has a whole raft of this crap which she posts with furious abandon.


Makes a change from the other homoeopathic approach, I suppose, which is to pick up a particular recent piece of (usually) in vitro research which involves dilute substances and reports some sort of anomalous effect, and claim that it proves homoeopathy works (check out the "Best Answer - Chosen by Asker" and the asker's response to it, along with all the other answers that they don't approve of). Then, when they think everyone will have forgotten about the last "proof" and its subsequent demolition, they find another one. Last year, for example, it was the Montagnier paper, this year it appears to be the Frenkel et al breast cancer cell-line paper.
 
Last edited:
Nancy doesn't even read her own references, that's the point. It's like she can't help shooting herself in the foot continually. She has long run out of feet to shoot, and is so far up her own legs she is now aiming at her own head. Suicide by Google??!
 
Wow, people still listen to homeopaths? I hear in about 11 states, one can be an licensed "ND" (Naturopathic doctor), I hear it's a very similar line of bs.
 
Wow, people still listen to homeopaths? I hear in about 11 states, one can be an licensed "ND" (Naturopathic doctor), I hear it's a very similar line of bs.
They are nothing alike.

Homeopathy is an 18th century religion based solely on ritualistically shaking a few drops of water to make it gain magic curative powers. It is related to mesmerism and witch-doctoring - they have the same amount of science involved. Look up "magical thinking".

Naturopathy is a nebulous notion has a basis in something real, at least. It is misguided, simplistic and somewhat unscientific, but it does not seem to involve so much religious magic ritual like homeopathy.

This thread is to record the amusing output of homeopaths who think they have been blessed with this wondrous scientific knowledge. Do you have any contributions?
 
Naturopaths use a large range of things- from vitamins and other real medicine to homeopathy.
 
Naturopaths use a large range of things- from vitamins and other real medicine to homeopathy.
They also never seem able to agree completely between any two of them what "naturopathy" is.

But we are derailing...prepare for the mod hammer to fall! :jaw-dropp
 
From facebook:
This guy has it all wrong 30C means diluted one in one hundred thirty times. not 100 to the 30th power. He needs to get his facts straight before anyone can understand what he is saying.
 
From Nancy Malik on the Guardian's "comment is free" (my emphasis):
@PonchOd: how homeopathy works

Memory of water (1988) (Dr. Jacques Benveniste, IgNobel Laureate in Chemistry)
Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE (1988)


:dl:
 
Last edited:
From Nancy Malik on the Guardian's "comment is free" (my emphasis):


:dl:

I know, it should have said double Ig Nobel laureate...







Actually, I think they've mutated somewhat, and an Ig Nobel very often is something to be proud of now (though I obviously don't include Benveniste in that). The original intent of the prizes was to note research "that cannot, or should not, be reproduced"; now it is "first make people laugh, and then make them think".
 
Last edited:
Here's one posted on the talk page for the Wikipedia article on homoeopathy:
George1935 said:
It might be completely be due to nonspecific effects -----this does not mean ONLY placebo, .
The placebo effect is more complex than is often acknowledged (see, for instance, specific studies where specific sorts of the placebo effect can be eliminated by specifically blocking certain neurotransmitters). However, George1935 doesn't seem to be aware of how "non-specific effects" is, essentially, the exact definition of a placebo. These effects may stem from a variety of causes (from things as seemingly trivial as a return to the mean all the way to varying levels of actual psychogenic analgesia[1] --note that, even with placebo based analgesic effects, you might still have an underlying treated condition remain unaffected[2]).

To be fair to George1935, not all placebos are equally strong since different placebos using different presentations can produce different levels of perceived improvement (for example, talking vs. talking empathetically vs. red pills vs. blue pills vs. pills of different sizes vs. interventions of differing durations vs. elaborate rituals vs. injections vs. placebo surgery, etc.). It is therefore of great importance that in placebo controlled studies the placebo condition strictly resembles the investigated treatment intervention condition with the exception of the element of the treatment protocol which is alleged to be involved in producing an improvement even when it is not known how differences in presentation could produce differences in perceived effectiveness (because anything can be a confounder --remember that, above all, we create studies because we are ignorant about the issue being investigated and thus, as much as reasonably possible, we should not assume that we know ahead of time which variables are confounding and which are not).

It is important to note, however, that this does not make these differences in placebo effectiveness specific effects because these effects would be maintained across a treatment group which was using a presentation as similar as possible to the placebo. For instance, although in trials intending to test the effectiveness of acupuncture, placebo interventions in the forms of talking, massage or pills (for example) would be expected to have different perceived treatment effects, none of this points to specific effects of the placebo condition because the proper control for an acupuncture intervention may be something which exactly reproduces the feeling of having a needle inserted without actually having a needle being inserted (since one way an acupuncture intervention would be alleged to work is by the act of having a needle inserted having a physiological effect of some sort, which would allegedly confer a benefit that would be secondary to --and presumably distinct from-- the actual trauma being inflicted by the insertion of needles).

This presents a problem because many interventions exist which are either extremely difficult or impossible to blind[3]. Thus, it is important in study design that, as much as possible, novel placebo interventions be properly validated. For instance, a study on acupuncture intending to use a given novel "mock acupuncture" intervention as a placebo might have to be preceded by a separate study to determine that when study subjects try to guess whether they have been treated by the novel mock acupuncture intervention or by "real" acupuncture they cannot guess the correct answer with greater accuracy than if their guesses were produced by chance alone (this, should be done under double blinded conditions). Alternatively, the data analysis, which would validate the use of the placebo, would be likely to included in the design of the study itself (in practice, though, I would guess that, whether formally or informally carried out, preliminary validation studies would be an integral part of the process of developing a novel placebo intervention so you would more properly do both preliminary validations and in-study validations). The issue of proper controls in acupuncture studies is further complicated by the fact that one may hypothesize that alleged treatment effects may either be produced by specific effects resulting from inserting needles at well defined, specific points (as determined by maps of meridians and their associated acupuncture points --which produces yet another layer of complexity because more than one such map exists) or by non-specific effects resulting from the insertion of needles anywhere in the body. For the former hypothesis, a proper control would involve insertion of acupuncture needles at random locations whereas for the latter hypothesis, a proper control would involve using an intervention which feels like a needle has been inserted without actually doing so.




1· A psychogenic analgesic effect which, as the case may be, may or may not have a discernible nurophysiological correlate (for example, as may be seen by means fMRI).
2· In fact, I would argue that this is, by far, the scenario most likely to be seen in studies.
3· Ironically, alternative medicine advocates often make the claim that some interventions are extremely difficult or impossible to test scientifically most strenuously for interventions for which blinding procedures are actually trivial. The most notable example of this is homeopathy (since the trivially obvious placebo intervention for magically treated distilled water is untreated distilled water).
 
Last edited:
Here’s a well-known proponent of homeopathy talking about three trials by the same lead researcher:
Ernie…each of those three trials used DIFFERENT prescribing homeopaths! That is independent replication.
 
Last edited:
Here’s a well-known proponent of homeopathy talking about three trials by the same lead researcher:

An interesting site, though much of what I read was cringe-worthy. That people pay these creeps is hard to stomach.
 
The title of the blog article needs to be in the thread: Children respond particularly well to homeopathy. TIME TO ABANDON THIS DANGEROUS MYTH!

Homeopaths have a fantasy that conventional drugs somehow stop their sugar solutions from working as well that think they do in adults. A more rational reason would be that children are more susceptible to the placebo effect than adults. The article concludes that homeopathy is being abandoned and the remedies are placebos.
Homeopathic remedies, however, are not being used in Hanauer’s Paediatric Hospital because, after 200 years of research, it has become clear that the basis of homeopathy is not in accordance with the modern concepts of the natural sciences.
Let’s be clear what exactly the last paragraph means:
  1. This institution has bee open to homeopathy for a very long time.
  2. They treated children homeopathically.
  3. They conducted research in homeopathy.
  4. They taught homeopathy to medical students.
  5. Eventually, they could no longer ignore what was before their eyes.
  6. They stopped using homeopathy.
  7. And they discontinued their course of homeopathy.
Why?

Because highly diluted homeopathic remedies are pure placebos – and that is true for children, adults and even animals.
 
From a reply to a post on Edzard Ernst’s blog:
Homeopathy works due to the fact that it works on the ACTUAL us; for, even though I bet that 99.9% of the people who post on this sceptics’ site will not be aware of the PROVEN truth of the following statement (and I WILL have absolute proof for you, later on in this lengthy post. A couple of examples of personal proof; as have many millions of other spiritually-enlightened people, worldwide), the physical body is NOT the REAL us. The real us is our eternal, immortal SOUL/SPIRIT BODY form; that is the thing which literally ANIMATES our physical body ‘coat’ whilst we live each [of many…] lifetime. For yes, some years ago, Dr Suzanne Humphries discovered the veritable wealth of multi-faceted evidences which PROVE that we all in very real truth SURVIVE (in our eternal, immortal soul/SPIRIT body form) the immensely illusory event that’s wholly incorrectly termed ‘death’.


:boggled:
 
So the monkeys finally managed to put those typewriters to use. Did he actual provide the "absolute proof"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom