Homoeopaths say the darndest things

I especially liked how all negative effects appearing after moving from a medical treatment to a homeopathic one are attributed to the "toxicity of allopathic medicine", yet all positive effects are attributed to the homeopathic treatment working. It's a crying shame most laymen don't understand how important falsifiability is.
I've formed the view that homeopathy is not really a "medical system". It is a religion. If you call it "The Holy Church of St Homeopath", these peoples' responses to medical crises make a lot more sense. Just like the rabid religionites who see visions of Mary in every stain they encounter, they are, literally, praying to their own saint to help them recover instead of seeking real medical aid.
 
Geni called homoeopathy "a system of excuses masquerading as medicine", and I think there's a lot of truth to that. They've got it all worked out so that any possible outcome can be explained in terms of the remedy working and "allopathy" being bad.

Rolfe.
 
Geni called homoeopathy "a system of excuses masquerading as medicine", and I think there's a lot of truth to that. They've got it all worked out so that any possible outcome can be explained in terms of the remedy working and "allopathy" being bad.

Rolfe.
Irrational rationalisation.
 
87443.strip.gif


From the Dilbert.com homepage (that does allow embedding images).
 
I've formed the view that homeopathy is not really a "medical system". It is a religion. If you call it "The Holy Church of St Homeopath", these peoples' responses to medical crises make a lot more sense. Just like the rabid religionites who see visions of Mary in every stain they encounter, they are, literally, praying to their own saint to help them recover instead of seeking real medical aid.

Thats certainly one approach that has been taken:

http://www.angelfire.com/mb2/quinine/cult.html
 
Thats certainly one approach that has been taken:

http://www.angelfire.com/mb2/quinine/cult.html
Hmmm, not so much a cult, although it meets that criteria. I'm seeing a religion requiring faith, i.e. requires belief without the necessity for providing evidence.

Homeopathy as a religion can indeed become cultish - in some cases such as for Milgrom it is indeed a cult. There are some homeopaths who will indeed deny evidence squarely in the face if it conflicts with their preset belief. However not all homeopaths and believers in homeopathy are follows of it as a cult.

For them it is like turning up the church every Sunday even though you no longer REALLY hold with the professed tenets of the faith. Instead, it is merely habitual and comfortable like putting on your favourite pair of old shoes. Or because they have simply not thought about it in depth and are happy to coast along without thinking.
 
Wrong-sized pillules stop homeopathic remedies working!

It appears homeopathic remedies will not work unless the sugar pillules they are given on are the "correct" size.

No, really! Don't laugh! You heard it here first!

Albert the Loon again said:
The ongoing problem with the Q-potencies is one with our pharmacies failing to make the correctly sized micro-globules to replicate Hahnemann’s directions and experience. They’re supposed to be a certain size, but our pharmacies just fudge it by using standard-sized globules. No, that doesn’t get it because one globule (rather than a drop, as in centesimal and decimal potencies) is used in the manufacture of each subsequent, higher potency. It therefore has to be a particular size. From the translator’s note in the Kunzli et al. translation of the sixth-edition ORGANON (1982), the only one worth quoting:

Jost_Kunzli said:
Hahnemann speaks of a grain. The standard Troy grain of the time corresponds to exactly 0.064798918 grams in our metric system. But according to the second edition of the German PHARMACOPOEIA, 1950, Hahnemann used the Nuremberg measure: one grain was 0.062 grams in our system. If Hahnemann had lived today[,] it is almost certain that he would have indicated 0.05 grams as a practical quantity easy to work with.

The existing globules don’t weigh that, either, though. We scream, but they still don’t fix it. I’m going to pelt them with rotten eggs and tomatoes unless they get to it pretty quick, for this has been known for more than a century. Barf!
http://www.otherhealth.com/homeopathy-discussion/11137-worsening-wrong-dose.html#post85430
 
Last edited:
It appears homeopathic remedies will not work unless the sugar pillules they are given on are the "correct" size.

No, really! Don't laugh! You heard it here first!


http://www.otherhealth.com/homeopathy-discussion/11137-worsening-wrong-dose.html#post85430
So....it's not that there's no active ingredient, it's that the sugar pill is the wrong size? It's a whole 2 milligrams (or 12 mg?) off? Huh.


[OT] When I was diagnosed with diabetes, I asked my doc if he thought that I should treat it with homeopathy. After he shot me a quizzical look, I retorted "What? You don't think treating diabetes with sugar pills is a good idea?" :D[/OT]

Now I know that it's ok to treat diabetes with sugar pills, so long as the pills are of the right size...
 
Yep! And I'm going off to weigh all my pillules individually right now, and will be rejecting all of them which are the "wrong" size.










Wait... There's none left now! :confused:




Oh, I get it! They have been homeopathically diluted! ;)
 
Last edited:
Yep! And I'm going off to weigh all my pillules individually right now, and will be rejecting all of them which are the "wrong" size.










Wait... There's none left now! :confused:




Oh, I get it! They have been homeopathically diluted! ;)
So, does that make them more effective then?
 
They are a blue-coloured bottle at the homeopath's pharmacy. But you MUST get the right sized ones! No bigger, no smaller, or it won't work.
 
Last edited:
Anyone remember Dr. MAS? Big mouth, small intellect, no integrity? Well, here he goes on about how he got banned at JREF long, long, LONG ago (you may not remember him, children!) for allowing multiple users of his account then denying it. This is his version of it only recently, and no, he has not forgotten or forgiven. However he managed to shoot himself in both feet with this one short post. :D

Yes, I got life long experience from JREF and I am so happy to expose you on all networks and at all forums. When that incident was happened. I called meeting of all my colleagues who are registered as Dr. MAS on different forums and we decided to expose your EVIDENCE LOVING TACTICS on all ground. I have got a good plea to expose when I need it. Just like here. Ban was imposed on me by saying that the account was in used by duplicate person because so many mails were sent on randi forum...... Look at the stupids. And look at nonsense who support this decision including Ph.D degree holders.
http://nch.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=1867&view=findpost&p=22827
 
There's a comment from MAS in the "Remedy pillules the wrong size" thread over there:
It is ok, if the doctor feels the he has in his clinic is in tiny pillule form but that potency strength required more materialistic dose, he can make a choice of 5 or 6 pillules of the same size or will seek a single pillule of large size.


Whenever skeptics stage a mass overdose, we are told that the amount of the remedy taken doesn't matter, and any number of pillules taken at around the same time counts as a single dose. So why would a homoeopath need to prescribe several pillules, or a larger pillule?
 
There's a comment from MAS in the "Remedy pillules the wrong size" thread over there:


Whenever skeptics stage a mass overdose, we are told that the amount of the remedy taken doesn't matter, and any number of pillules taken at around the same time counts as a single dose. So why would a homoeopath need to prescribe several pillules, or a larger pillule?
I haven't pursued that angle with them...yet. Although it was one of the obvious fallacies for which I was laying the foundations for exposing from the outset.

You may also note that MAS has been vehement in insisting that homeopathic remedies are indeed dose-dependent (and OK, I admit I have been tagging him along a bit on that score! ;)). That's going to be yet another trapdoor he will drop himself through fairly soon.

Shhh! Don't tell him! :D
 
Nancy Malik, tips of the day. And if they make any sense to you, do please explain!
Tip of the day-8

Tyler said that the Cina child cannot be punished because it goes into a convulsion. [Homeopaths classify people by their remedy type, btw]

Tip of the day-9

When it comes to health, there is no margin for error.. [Really? This from homeopaths!]

Tip of the day-10

You don't have to be a wreck.You don't have to be sick.One's aim in life should be to die in good health. Just like a candle that burns out [Myself, I'd much rather LIVE in good health. But each to their own!]
http://nch.ipbfree.com/index.php?showtopic=1933&view=findpost&p=23084
 
Nancy Malik, tips of the day. And if they make any sense to you, do please explain!
Tip of the day-9

When it comes to health, there is no margin for error..


I refer you back to the one quoted in the O/P:
I do not know what the situation is, but if she saw a competent homeopath then the only reason homeopathy did not work is because the remedy chosen was not the correct remedy for her.
 
Nancy has no clue, actually. She just goes Google-mining but never ever reads the references she finds. Or even easier - she collects references that other nut-cases have Googled already - steals them off websites. She has a whole raft of this crap which she posts with furious abandon. Usually to gloriously humorous results.

In fact, some of her found stuff flatly contradicts the headlines outright, including homeopaths saying so. It's often like this:

HEADLINE: HOMEOPATHY CURES AIDS?
Report: Patient tried homeopath for 5 years to cure AIDS but is not better now. No, it's not possible, says leading homeopath. Seek real medical help instead.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom