Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

vindication! {snip}
I don't think that word means what you think it means ...

If anybody actually understands what Meow is trying to say, perhaps they'd share it with us. {snip}
When I saw that, I wanted to respond- however, it is divorced from reality. Bell is certainly in no position to comment on anyone else's understanding of chemistry, if she did.
 
I think Meow just started to read the thread, and was responding to my first post in which I remarked that we'd already seen (and shredded, courtesy of you) Roy's UV spectroscopy results. This was before we got access to the published paper.

I posted the link to the pdf of the presentation in which these results were included. There was something else in that pdf by Bell, the usual wittering about "stuck in a Newtonian paradigm". I think that's what Meow means. I suppose she'd just accuse you of being "stuck on PhD level chemistry".

Every time I stop to contemplate that Rao et al. paper, I marvel at the depth of the incompetence on display. For that incompetence to come from people with a respectable scientific background is almost unbelievable.

Of course, that makes it exactly the sort of paper Meow likes to run around fly-posting about.

Rolfe.
 
Page 34 of that presentation includes: "the implausibility argument depends on assumptions from high school chemistry that the modern field of materials science has long since moved beyond". It's an attempt to presents a strawman argument against homoeopathy by ignoring the rather fundamental point that in properly controlled studies its effects are indistinguishable from placebo.
 
meow seems to be channelling the spirit of olaf/Xanta/gold- post a few of the homs' favourite bits of dodgy bench science then claim victory without engaging with any of the critical rebuttals.

It's a sadly familiar meme circulating in their population.

I also forgot to mention that the faux-naif use of all lower-case allied to a tediously smug sense of their own brilliance is a consistent feature of another subclass of hom that we have seen before.

Have the denizens of OtherHealth.com been tinkering in their basement to create some chimaeric form of uber-idiot for our enjoyment?
 
BSM, fix that link or just tell us what you mean.

Rolfe.


I wasn't intending it as a link, I was just referring to them as a body corporate that might wish to construct an idiot in their basement lab.

It was a loose reference to one of my favourite sporting insults;

"Phil Tufnell is a completely different character to Panesar but the crowds pounced when they realised he was unsure in the field. Within two weeks of his arrival in Australia, placards advertising the "Philip Tufnell Fielding Academy" were appearing at grounds and the jeering began. "Oi Tufnell can we borrow your brain," was a famous shout from the grass bank at the Adelaide Oval. "Why?" Tufnell innocently replied. "Because we're trying to build an idiot over here - that's why, you loser.""

I must also acknowledge that I've not been reading the forum very closely recently and missed the fact that allusions had already been made to meow's behaviour resembling hom/s we have previously known and loved.
 
I think Meow just started to read the thread, and was responding to my first post in which I remarked that we'd already seen (and shredded, courtesy of you) Roy's UV spectroscopy results. This was before we got access to the published paper.

I posted the link to the pdf of the presentation in which these results were included. There was something else in that pdf by Bell, the usual wittering about "stuck in a Newtonian paradigm". I think that's what Meow means. I suppose she'd just accuse you of being "stuck on PhD level chemistry".


Rolfe.

rustum roy and colleagues have close to 150 years experience how dare you call it a hatchet job and accuse him of incompetence. he could probably sue you for libel. maybe maybe not? any lawyers here?




http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=15594862

Titre du document / Document title
New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions
Auteur(s) / Author(s)
ELIA V. (1) ; NICCOLI M. (1) ;
Affiliation(s) du ou des auteurs / Author(s) Affiliation(s)
(1) Department of Chemistry, University ' Federico II'of Naples, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, via Cintia, 80126 Naples, ITALIE
Résumé / Abstract
The 'extremely diluted solutions' are anomalous solutions obtained through the iteration of two processes: a dilution 1:100 in mass and a succussion. The iteration is repeated until extreme dilutions are reached (less than 1.10-5 mol kg-1) to the point that we may call the resulting solution an extremely diluted solution, namely the composition of the solution is identical to that of the solvent used (e.g. twice distilled water). We conducted thermodynamic and transport measurements of the solutions and of the interaction of those solutions with acids or bases. The purpose of this study is to obtain information about the influence of successive dilutions and succussions on the water structure of the solutions under study. We measured the heats of mixing of acid or basic solutions with such 'extremely diluted solutions', their electrical conductivity and pH, comparing with the analogous heats of mixing, electrical conductivity and pH of the solvent. We found some relevant exothermic excess heats of mixing, higher electrical conductivity and pH than those of the untreated solvent. The measurements show a good correlation between independent physico-chemical parameters. Care was taken to take into account the effect of chemical impurities deriving from the glass containers. Here we thus show that successive dilutions and succussions can permanently alter the physico-chemical properties of the water solvent. The nature of the phenomena here described still remains unexplained, nevertheless some significant experimental results were obtained.
Revue / Journal Title
Journal of thermal analysis and calorimetry ISSN 1388-6150
Source / Source
2004, vol. 75, no3, pp. 815-836 [22 page(s) (article)] (32 ref.)
 
Last edited:
rustum roy and colleagues have close to 150 years experience how dare you call it a hatchet job and accuse him of incompetence.


Perhaps you could comment on the merits of the paper itself instead of using this appeal to authority.
 
http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=15594862

Titre du document / Document title
New physico-chemical properties of extremely diluted aqueous solutions
Auteur(s) / Author(s)
ELIA V. (1) ; NICCOLI M. (1) ;
Affiliation(s) du ou des auteurs / Author(s) Affiliation(s)
(1) Department of Chemistry, University ' Federico II'of Naples, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, via Cintia, 80126 Naples, ITALIE
Résumé / Abstract
The 'extremely diluted solutions' are anomalous solutions obtained through the iteration of two processes: a dilution 1:100 in mass and a succussion. The iteration is repeated until extreme dilutions are reached (less than 1.10-5 mol kg-1) to the point that we may call the resulting solution an extremely diluted solution, namely the composition of the solution is identical to that of the solvent used (e.g. twice distilled water). We conducted thermodynamic and transport measurements of the solutions and of the interaction of those solutions with acids or bases. The purpose of this study is to obtain information about the influence of successive dilutions and succussions on the water structure of the solutions under study. We measured the heats of mixing of acid or basic solutions with such 'extremely diluted solutions', their electrical conductivity and pH, comparing with the analogous heats of mixing, electrical conductivity and pH of the solvent. We found some relevant exothermic excess heats of mixing, higher electrical conductivity and pH than those of the untreated solvent. The measurements show a good correlation between independent physico-chemical parameters. Care was taken to take into account the effect of chemical impurities deriving from the glass containers. Here we thus show that successive dilutions and succussions can permanently alter the physico-chemical properties of the water solvent. The nature of the phenomena here described still remains unexplained, nevertheless some significant experimental results were obtained.
Revue / Journal Title
Journal of thermal analysis and calorimetry ISSN 1388-6150
Source / Source
2004, vol. 75, no3, pp. 815-836 [22 page(s) (article)] (32 ref.)

perhaps you can comment on this paper
 
Now, I wonder how many years of experience JJM, myself, Wilsontown and Pipirr have between us? Since JJM is a retired chemistry professor, we could probably rack up quite a bit.

That Rao et al. paper is the most spectacular display of incompetence in a "scientific" context that it has even been my privilege to witness. Given the extraordinary lameness of Rao's reply to our letter, I suspect she knows it.

It's always very difficult, when encountering blatant idiocy on this scale, to distinguish sincere incompetence from deliberate misrepresentation. In this case the incompetence is so enormous, coming from people with the sort of experience that should mean they knew better, that the temptation is to conclude deliberate misrepresentation. However, on the other hand, anyone intending to fudge results would surely make a better job of that, even.

So who knows. I'd go for incompetence associated with senility, myself.

Rolfe.
 
Since there is no details of this study, it is impossible to comment on this paper or its conclusions. Please furnish the methods of this study.
 
Hey, pussy-cat,
Go away a read all 450 posts first.

On second thoughts, no, forget about it.
It's not gonna make any difference.

regards,
BJ
 


Meow, would you care to comment on the absence of "p<anything at all" in the Rao paper (which is what this thread is actually about, I seem to remember)?

Rolfe.

PS. And what BillyJoe said. Come back when you've read the thread, and actually understand it.

See you in June.
 
Last edited:
You used to be able to get whole Homeopathy articles free online, but not now. I'm damned if I'm paying for that!
-Rolfe.

I was wondering. How's about JREF forumites getting a pool of money together so we could actually subscribe (once) to either serious publication sites or woo ones- then circulating the data between interested parties, (while wholly obeying all relevant legislation regarding intellectual property rights).
 
A character called Rao has shown up in the Grauniad. I thought it sounded more like another cat noise myself.
 
rustum roy and colleagues have close to 150 years experience how dare you call it a hatchet job and accuse him of incompetence.

By this argument, the sun really does go around the earth, as people spent far longer believing that than vice versa.

he could probably sue you for libel. maybe maybe not? any lawyers here?
I'm not a lawyer, but I highly highly doubt it. You'd have to demonstrate actual harm to begin with. And, well, if the courts start taking internet conversation seriously, they'll be having quite a few cases on their hands...
 
Since there is no details of this study, it is impossible to comment on this paper or its conclusions. Please furnish the methods of this study.
Anyone who wants to see the paper, send me your e-mail address and I'll send the PDF. The paper is giving me a headache. It is 22 pages long, and I have trouble figuring out if they are mis-stating things or if their English is not quite perfect.
 
May 16, 2007

by Prof. Rustom Roy and Iris Bell, MD, PhD

In May 2007, the NCH's first web cast featured groundbreaking results that may forever change the face of homeopathy.

Professor Rustom Roy, the Founding Director of the Materials Research Laboratory at Penn State and one of the world's leading experts on the structure of water, along with Professor Iris R. Bell, Director of Research Education for the Program of Integrative Medicine at the University of Arizona College of Medicine, presented their findings to an audience of prominent American scientists and medical researchers.

Roy's laboratory has found, using multiple testing methods, that not only do different remedy dilutions in excess of Avogadro's number carry unique characteristic signatures, but different potencies do as well!

These results will not only serve to prove to the scientific community that homeopathic medicines are not placebo medicine, but they also will provide a way for the homeopathic pharmacies to assure the nature and quality of their products.


Recorded: 5/16/2007, 2:30PM EST, (58:29)
Host: Peter Gold
Host company: Penn State University

The defining role of structure (including epitaxy)
in the plausibility of homeopathy, Manju Lata Rao, Rustum Roy, Iris R Bell,and Richard Hoover, Homeopathy (2007) 96, pp. 175–182.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom