Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

"blah blah blah the alcohol was contaminated blah blah blah"


"they didn't plot out all the points blah blah blah"


"they failed to state the source of the alcohol blah blah blah"



the game is over.

remedies can be distinguished from controls.

you will all have to admit that you were wrong.
 
Someone wake me up the day that Roy (or anyone else for that matter) actually manages to distinguish a remedy from the stock solvent. As opposed to distinguishing between two bottles of non-spectroscopic-grade ethanol.

:slp:

Rolfe..
 


no one will ever win that money; it's a fake prize. after the preliminary stage is passed randi sees that it is real and stalls. if forced to act he steps in and claims fraud then is allowed to force the researcher to alter his methods. methods will be altered in such a way to make it impossible to win.


the simple fact id that louis rey and now rustum roy have both found ways to differentiate a homeopathic remedy from a placebo.



http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=0dd37a60a935ce27e1ac6ccc41b2ef1c



Thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride
Purchase the full-text article



References and further reading may be available for this article. To view references and further reading you must purchase this article.

Louis ReyCorresponding Author Contact Information, E-mail The Corresponding Author

Chemin de Verdonnet 2, 1010, Lausanne, Switzerland

Received 10 December 2002.
Available online 28 February 2003.

Abstract

Ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride (10−30 gcm−3) have been irradiated by X- and γ-rays at 77 K, then progressively rewarmed to room temperature. During that phase, their thermoluminescence has been studied and it was found that, despite their dilution beyond the Avogadro number, the emitted light was specific of the original salts dissolved initially.
Article Outline

1. Introduction
2. Experimental
3. Results
References
 
"blah blah blah the alcohol was contaminated blah blah blah"


"they didn't plot out all the points blah blah blah"


"they failed to state the source of the alcohol blah blah blah"



the game is over.

remedies can be distinguished from controls.

you will all have to admit that you were wrong.


Only if you label one bottle 'Remedy' and one 'Control' before you start.
 
Anyone who wants to see the paper, send me your e-mail address and I'll send the PDF. The paper is giving me a headache. It is 22 pages long, and I have trouble figuring out if they are mis-stating things or if their English is not quite perfect.
Uggh...I don't believe I can torture myself like that.

I've read a couple of crap papers this week and need to actually read something useful to feel like I haven't waster my time.
 
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn3817

When Rey used the method on ice he saw two peaks of light, at temperatures of around 120 K and 170 K. Rey wanted to test the idea, suggested by other researchers, that the 170 K peak reflects the pattern of hydrogen bonds within the ice. In his experiments he used heavy water (which contains the heavy hydrogen isotope deuterium), because it has stronger hydrogen bonds than normal water.

Each dilution was made according to a strict protocol, and vigorously stirred at each stage, as homeopaths do. When Rey compared the ultra-dilute lithium and sodium chloride solutions with pure water that had been through the same process, the difference in their thermoluminescence peaks compared with pure water was still there (see graph).

"Much to our surprise, the thermoluminescence glows of the three systems were substantially different," he says. He believes the result proves that the networks of hydrogen bonds in the samples were different.
 
no one will ever win that money; it's a fake prize. after the preliminary stage is passed randi sees that it is real and stalls. if forced to act he steps in and claims fraud then is allowed to force the researcher to alter his methods. methods will be altered in such a way to make it impossible to win.
Please point to someone who's passed the preliminary stage.

If you can do that, then show where Randi denied them the next stage of testing.

Since the Million Dollar challenge is a legally binding contract doing so would have won those people the million anyway!
 
Please point to someone who's passed the preliminary stage.

If you can do that, then show where Randi denied them the next stage of testing.

Since the Million Dollar challenge is a legally binding contract doing so would have won those people the million anyway!
...he could probably sue you for libel. maybe maybe not? any lawyers here?
What a hypocrite.
 
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn3817

When Rey used the method on ice he saw two peaks of light, at temperatures of around 120 K and 170 K. Rey wanted to test the idea, suggested by other researchers, that the 170 K peak reflects the pattern of hydrogen bonds within the ice. In his experiments he used heavy water (which contains the heavy hydrogen isotope deuterium), because it has stronger hydrogen bonds than normal water.

Each dilution was made according to a strict protocol, and vigorously stirred at each stage, as homeopaths do. When Rey compared the ultra-dilute lithium and sodium chloride solutions with pure water that had been through the same process, the difference in their thermoluminescence peaks compared with pure water was still there (see graph).

"Much to our surprise, the thermoluminescence glows of the three systems were substantially different," he says. He believes the result proves that the networks of hydrogen bonds in the samples were different.

Published in 2003 and in the intervening 5 years no one has replicated this WORLD SHATTERING OVER THROW OF 20TH CENTURY PHYSICS??
Colour me mightily unimpressed.
:boggled:4
 
Last edited:
Published in 2003 and in the intervening 5 years no one has replicated this WORLD SHATTERING OVER THROW OF 20TH CENTURY PHYSICS??
Colour me mightily unimpressed.
:boggled:4

no one gives a damn. it was done, people looked at it and shrugged.

sort of like when that Dr Bridgman from Harvard found out that water has a memory of sorts. the whole thing where he freezes water at one pressure and notes that at a different pressure it remembers the structure it was previously frozen at.
 
no one gives a damn. it was done, people looked at it and shrugged.
You really think that a credible result that shows that conventional physics has got it all wrong will just be shrugged off? No young physicist eager to get a Nobel Prize for himself will investigate this phenomenon and try to formulate the new laws of physics?

:bs:
 
sort of like when that Dr Bridgman from Harvard found out that water has a memory of sorts. the whole thing where he freezes water at one pressure and notes that at a different pressure it remembers the structure it was previously frozen at.


Reference please (to Bridgman's work, not just somebody reporting it).
 
what's so funny? i read the Kerr, Morag et al letter now i want to see the response.

clue me in on the funny.

Not right now, thanks, at least not until you explain why a lack of blinding is not a sufficient problem with Rey's data.

It needs to be an actual explanation, though, not just another childish cut and paste of an abstract. You know, something that shows an understanding of the principles involved would do just fine.
 
"blah blah blah the alcohol was contaminated blah blah blah" "they didn't plot out all the points blah blah blah" "they failed to state the source of the alcohol blah blah blah" {snip}

remedies can be distinguished from controls.

you will all have to admit that you were wrong.
No, we do not. Tell us how "remedies can be distinguished from controls" as opposed to normal variations in the solvent used to prepare them. The authors surely do not know. Their response (to our note) did not address that problem. I await your analysis of their spectra.
 
{snip} "Much to our surprise, the thermoluminescence glows of the three systems were substantially different," he says. He believes the result proves that the networks of hydrogen bonds in the samples were different.
If you want, I can tell you about a lot of unexplained observations. Unexplained does not mean inexplicable, and does not support any notion (homeopathetic, or otherwise). I believe in the tooth-fairy based on more compelling data- when I was a kid and lost a tooth, I put it under my pillow at night and found a nickel in its place the next morning. That was a solid, repeatable result.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom