Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Yeah, they're touchy feely experiential sort of people, rather than scientifically rational and analytical.
 
Here’s the latest from Lynne McTaggart on the Water Intention Experiment:

As you remember, our experiment isn’t conclusive – largely because we’re only looking at one parameter to see if it has changes.

This is a little like looking at an elephant from one side. If you look from the front, you will mainly see a trunk. Look from bottom, and you only see a giant mass hovering over you like a dark grey cloud.

-snip-

… new equipment…a revolution in characterizing water…Professor Roy…van der Waals bonds…subtle energies…Man’s Search for Meaning…trangulate our perception…

-snip-

For the first time we’ll be able to see the whole elephant.


More…
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178:BlogPost:101204
 
Lordy, that is hilarious.

As you remember, our experiment isn’t conclusive – largely because we’re only looking at one parameter to see if it has changes.

This is a little like looking at an elephant from one side. If you look from the front, you will mainly see a trunk. Look from bottom, and you only see a giant mass hovering over you like a dark grey cloud.

Rainen’s new equipment consists of three separate devices that examine, respectively, the light scattering, the thermal expansion and any infrared changes in a sample of water. Once these measurements are taken, they are sent into a computer, and from this handful of data points, the computer can determine some 1000 parameters of the sample.

“This equipment represents a revolution in characterizing water,” says Roy.

Some 1,000 parameters? Given the proven statistical nous of the team, I'm sure they'll remember to apply an appropriate correction for multiple comparisons.

And given that these 1,000 parameters are apparently derived from 'a handful' of measurements, they can hardly be independent parameters.

Still, this is an excellent way of improving the chances of a false positive result.
 
Somebody thinks that the water knew about the experiment and decided that it didn't want to change because it was an experiment :jaw-dropp

Poor little water moly-cuddles, somebody better start an anti-watersection league to protect them from the nasty scientists.
 
Last edited:
You used to be able to get whole Homeopathy articles free online, but not now. I'm damned if I'm paying for that!

But looking at the abstract, I think we've seen his data already.




Four slides in the middle of this.

The UV spectroscopy is just wrong. The spectrum he presents for ethanol just is not the UV spectrum of ethanol, period. He then seems to be saying that the potentised remedies are less absorbent than the solvent. I could see no data supporting his contention that he could tell different potencies or different remedies apart.

If in fact what he says is true (that ethanol has significant UV absorbance at 320nm which is eliminated when the ethanol is used as the solvent for the production of a potentised remedy), anyone with a spectrophotometer capable of reading at that wavelength would be able to see this easily for themselves. And be queueing up to apply for the million bucks. I could do it myself (I suspect - modern analysers are so specialised compared to the simple spectrophotometers we used to use that I'd have to think about how....). The problem is that it all falls apart when you simply observe that ethanol does not in fact have significant UV absorbance at 320nm.

I couldn't understand the Raman spectra he presented in that slide show, but they all seemed noisy, and the scales were inconsistent. Given that he has messed up an ordinary UV spectrometry reading of ethanol quite as comprehensively as he has, I have little confidence in anything he presents in a more complex field.

Rolfe.

vindication!

you people really should be quaking in your boots by now. randi aint sweating too much cuz afterall everyone knows it's a fake prize. never in a million years is anyone ever going to claim it.

what will happen is he will have to dump ultra dilute solutions from the eligibility list in about 5 years as the evidence multiplies.

hey rolfe,

iris bell MD PhD thinks you're still stuck on high school chemistry! (page 34) she's correcto!


check out page 32--Key Conclusions



meow meow
 
Assuming this portion is true

(and it probably is not, but for argument sake, let us assume, temporarily, that it is)

You still have a problem of the body, itself, not only determining the difference, but determining what to do with the stuff once it does. I doubt that even if UV-VIS spectroscopy was sensitive enough to distinguish the difference, that our own body chemistry would also be able to do so.
(These are water molecules, we are talking about, after all.)

If homeopathy claims it is efficacious, it must pass proper medical trials, period.

well it certainly seems that HUMAN BASOPHILS receive the frequency as proved over and over and over by the basophil studies.


http://www.vetpath.co.uk/jref/histamine.pdf



http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15105967

1: Inflamm Res. 2004 May;53(5):181-8. Epub 2004 Apr 21.Click here to read Links
Histamine dilutions modulate basophil activation.
Belon P, Cumps J, Ennis M, Mannaioni PF, Roberfroid M, Sainte-Laudy J, Wiegant FA.

Boiron, 20 rue de la Libération, 69110 Sainte-Foy-Les-Lyon, France.

BACKGROUND: In order to demonstrate that high dilutions of histamine are able to inhibit basophil activation in a reproducible fashion, several techniques were used in different research laboratories. OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to investigate the action of histamine dilutions on basophil activation. METHODS: Basophil activation was assessed by alcian blue staining, measurement of histamine release and CD63 expression. Study 1 used a blinded multi-centre approach in 4 centres. Study 2, related to the confirmation of the multi-centre study by flow cytometry, was performed independently in 3 laboratories. Study 3 examined the histamine release (one laboratory) and the activity of H(2) receptor antagonists and structural analogues (two laboratories). RESULTS: High dilutions of histamine (10(-30)-10(-38) M) influence the activation of human basophils measured by alcian blue staining. The degree of inhibition depends on the initial level of anti-IgE induced stimulation, with the greatest inhibitory effects seen at lower levels of stimulation. This multicentre study was confirmed in the three laboratories by using flow cytometry and in one laboratory by histamine release. Inhibition of CD63 expression by histamine high dilutions was reversed by cimetidine (effect observed in two laboratories) and not by ranitidine (one laboratory). Histidine tested in parallel with histamine showed no activity on this model. CONCLUSIONS: In 3 different types of experiment, it has been shown that high dilutions of histamine may indeed exert an effect on basophil activity. This activity observed by staining basophils with alcian blue was confirmed by flow cytometry. Inhibition by histamine was reversed by anti-H2 and was not observed with histidine these results being in favour of the specificity of this effect We are however unable to explain our findings and are reporting them to encourage others to investigate this phenomenon.



p< .0001



meow meow
 
Last edited:
vindication!

you people really should be quaking in your boots by now. randi aint sweating too much cuz afterall everyone knows it's a fake prize. never in a million years is anyone ever going to claim it.

what will happen is he will have to dump ultra dilute solutions from the eligibility list in about 5 years as the evidence multiplies.

hey rolfe,

iris bell MD PhD thinks you're still stuck on high school chemistry! (page 34) she's correcto!


check out page 32--Key Conclusions



meow meow

Meow, you must know more than Rolfe's allegedly high school chemistry. Please explain in detail where her criticisms of Roy are wrong.
 
Oh noes! Randi will have to withdraw the ability to tell one batch of solvent from another from the list of eligible paranormal abilities.
 
Last edited:
Oh noes! Randi will have to withdraw the ability to tell one batch of solvent from another from the list of eligible paranormal abilities.
It's ok, it's ok, apparently he hasn't given the million dollars away yet. Phew.

Yuri
 
Homeopathetic hasn't worked since it was invented in 1796.
That's a loooong testing regime
 
If anybody actually understands what Meow is trying to say, perhaps they'd share it with us.

Actually, the two posts she's quoted are nos 11 and 19 from the first page of this thread. I don't think she'd read any further.

I think she might be in for a bit of a surprise as she reads on.

Here's the clue-bat, in case you missed it
.

Rolfe.
 
If anybody actually understands what Meow is trying to say, perhaps they'd share it with us.

Actually, the two posts she's quoted are nos 11 and 19 from the first page of this thread. I don't think she'd read any further.

I think she might be in for a bit of a surprise as she reads on.

Here's the clue-bat, in case you missed it
.

Rolfe.

Good thing I checked the URL. I thought you meant this clue bat:

:deadhorse
 
Oh, just for Meow....

Scene: A couple of back rooms in a corner of a university department. There are a few superannuated items of equipment on the benches, in varying stages of dilapidation. There are some squeeezy bottles lying around, and the streaked illegible writing on the sides indicates they contain some sort of extremely polar solvent. [Something Geni likes to smell in the mornings.]

Rao/Roy: OK guys, we're going to measure some actual homoeopathic remedies in our spiffy spectrophotometer. TeaBoy, order us up a couple of remedies from a real homoeopathic manufacturer, will you.

[A few days later]

Rao/Roy: Well, here they are, let's open the box. All nicely labelled with unique identification numbers so we know which is which, good. And here's the temperature sensor in the box too.

TeaBoy: What's that for?

Rao/Roy: Nothing at all, but mentioning it in the paper will sound scientific.

[long pause]

Rao/Roy: Ethanol? 95% ethanol? These remedies aren't water, then?

TeaBoy: You didn't say anything about water or ethanol. You just asked me to order some remedies from a homoeopathic manufacturer, and that's what I did.

Rao/Roy: Oh cr*p. Well, lets just run them through the old machine and see what they look like anyway. TeaBoy, we're off to the pub, will you just run these samples through for us?

TeaBoy: Sure, boss. Er, where do I turn it on...?

[A few days later]

Roy: Well, this is very exciting, look, the traces aren't identical.

TeaBoy: Well, I did each one a few times, and you're right, no two traces are identical.

Roy: Never mind. If we choose this trace for the 30C and this trace for the 6C and so on, that clearly illustrates the real differences between them.

TeaBoy: But this other trace from the 30C is almost identical to the one you've got there for the 6C....

Roy: Never mind that, we want the ones that are "representative". But we can say you did each one ten times if you like, that will impress the scrutineers.

Rao: I wonder if ordinary ethanol that hasn't been succussed by trained experts would look any different? Have we got any of that?

Roy produces a dusty, three-quarters empty Winchester from the back of a store cupboard. It has the word "Ethanol" on its torn, yellowing label, in faded handwritten letters.

Roy: Oh yes, here's some. TeaBoy, could you just run that one for us later this afternoon?

[Next day.]

Roy: Oh look, isn't this marvellous, look at the huge difference between this trace and all the others. Let's get to the word processor, we have to write this up.

Rao: But the paper is about the memory of water, and these samples were all 95% ethanol.

Roy: So? We've got results that show homoeopathy works, don't quibble about small details.


Rolfe.
 
meow seems to be channelling the spirit of olaf/Xanta/gold- post a few of the homs' favourite bits of dodgy bench science then claim victory without engaging with any of the critical rebuttals.

It's a sadly familiar meme circulating in their population.
 
Yes, it's quite uncanny the resemblance between these posts and the SOP of Xanta's various clones.

Must be a psychic connection I suppose.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom