Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

So, I have just got back from our library, and I have in my hot little hand a copy of "The Physics of High Pressure", by PW Bridgman, pub 1958.

Its 445 pages, and looks like it might, ironically enough, be rather dry. If people have some links to what actually has been claimed for this work I will do my best to tease out what actually was said.
 
So, I have just got back from our library, and I have in my hot little hand a copy of "The Physics of High Pressure", by PW Bridgman, pub 1958.

Its 445 pages, and looks like it might, ironically enough, be rather dry. If people have some links to what actually has been claimed for this work I will do my best to tease out what actually was said.

You're a better man than I am Criticalist. ;)
 
So, I have just got back from our library, and I have in my hot little hand a copy of "The Physics of High Pressure", by PW Bridgman, pub 1958.

Its 445 pages, and looks like it might, ironically enough, be rather dry. If people have some links to what actually has been claimed for this work I will do my best to tease out what actually was said.


The claims are quoted and linked to in this post, but note that it doesn't explicitly state that they are in the book.
 
Last edited:
So, I’ve been taking a look through Bridgman’s book, and I think I have found the section which is the source of Dana’s excitement.

To give you a flavour of the book it is 445 pages long, published in 1958. It is an extremely detailed account of over 25 years of experiments by the author in which he examines the effects of extremely high pressures on the physical properties of a number of substances, both liquid and solid. There are thirteen chapters, ranging from a historical introduction, and review of the equipment he uses, and then onto subjects such as “The compressibility of solids”, “Effects of pressure on thermo-properties” and the like. I believe the part we are interested in is in Chapter 8, “Polymorphic Transition under Pressure”.

A few caveats here. I am neither a physicist nor a mathematician, and Bridgman not unreasonably expects a certain degree of expertise from his reader that I do not possess. Not being entirely insane, I have not read the whole book, but have skimmed the bits that seemed relevant, and think I have found the appropriate reference, but can’t swear I haven’t missed others.

The section deals with polymorphic transitions under pressure, which I think relate to the creation of phase diagrams; (from wikipedia)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase_diagram

and he provides many phase diagrams for lots of different materials. He then (page 243) describes the anomalous behaviour of water ice, a description that takes about half a page, and that’s it.

Having read the description, I have to be honest I don’t really understand it. Bridgman notes some unusual physical properties, suggests they may be worth further investigation, but certainly isn’t jumping up and down shouting “A memory!!! Its got a memory!!!”.

Now, I have scanned the relevant pages. I’m not sure of the forum rules, but if its allowed, and possible, can these be uploaded? Alternatively, I can email the pdf to those who are interested if they pm me, and finally I can simply type out the relevant section as a last resort if there is enough interest.
 
As this would only be a small excerpt from a long book, reproduced for the purpose of critical discussion, it would certainly be legitimate under actual copyright law, and it might even be allowable under the (much stricter) forum rules.

IMHO.

Rolfe.
 
How long does it last?
How much information?
What is the saturation of information?

Well going by homeopaths claims of what remedies work the answers must be at least:

How long does it last? Decades
How much information? 4000 odd remedies so at least 12 bits. On the other hand remedy machine tables seem to have up to 5 digets so 17 bits. Incerdentaly this page may be illegal under UK law (zee rounderabout cancer cure claim):

http://homepage.ntlworld.com/homeopathy_advice/Resources/remedyrates/remedyrates_t.html

What is the saturation of information? very very high. For example some homeopaths think that even if too remedies are made from the same substance but from a different mother tincture they may behave differently.
 
The pdf of the scanned pages is too large to upload as an attachement, so I am posting a transcript of what I believe the relevent passage to be. If anyone would like a copy of the actual pdf, please send me a PM.

The passage relates to experiments subjecting water to extreme temperatures and pressures, and plotting the resultant phase diagram. Peforming this experiment aparently resutls in difefrent forms of ice, (I'm not entirely sure how they are distinguished, I think it is by diffrent slopes on the phase diagram) which are referred to in the text as forms I-VI.

Transcript:

“The conditions under which the different modifications of ice appear are somewhat capricious, and often inconvenient manipulation is necessary to arrive in the part of the phase diagram desired. The behaviour is particularly striking in the neighbourhood of the V-VI triple point, say between 0 and -10 degrees and between 5000 and 6000 kg./cm3 . With the ordinary form of the apparatus, water in a steel piezometer with pressure transmitted to it by mercury, it is very difficult to produce the modification V. For example, if liquid water at -10 degrees is compressed across the melting curve, the liquid will persist in the sub-cooled condition for an indefinite time, without freezing to V, the stable form. But if the compression is carried further, to the unstable prolongation of the liquid VI line, freezing to the form VI will take place almost at once on crossing the line, in spite of the fact that VI is unstable with respect to V. Now in order to make V appear, VI may be cooled 30 or 40 degrees, when it will spontaneously change to V, the stable form. If pressure is now released back to 5000, say and the temperature raised to the melting line of V, melting takes place at once, and so the co ordinates of the melting line may be found. Suppose now after the melting is completed the liquid water be kept in the neighbourhood of the melting line fro several days and then the pressure increased again across the melting line at -10 degrees; it will be found that the instant the melting line of V is crossed the liquid freezes to V. This suggests that there has persisted in the liquid phase some sort of structure, not detected by ordinary large-scale experiments favourable to the formation of V. It is now known, of course, from X-ray analysis that structures are possible in the liquid; this experiment suggests a specificity in these structures that might well be the subject of further study.”

I have had to read through this several times to understand what seems to have happened; the upshot seems to be that the water behaves in a different manner in the second iteration of the procedure. I'd be intersted in more knowledgeable comments.
 
It's not clear, but it seems to suggest that pressure was maintained at 5000 kg/cm3 for several days, then raised again across the melting line.

As in this part:

If pressure is now released back to 5000, say and the temperature raised to the melting line of V, melting takes place at once, and so the co ordinates of the melting line may be found. Suppose now after the melting is completed the liquid water be kept in the neighbourhood of the melting line fro several days and then the pressure increased again across the melting line at -10 degrees; it will be found that the instant the melting line of V is crossed the liquid freezes to V.

I don't have anything especially insightful to add, not being a high altitude physiotherapist (or whatever Dullman thought Bridgman was). But water maintaining some sort of property while under high pressure is an extremely different scenario to room temperature water being banged about on a bible and remembering past lives.
 
So the argument is something like, "At high pressure water can do some really weird stuff that I can't understand, therefore Homeopathy works." Got it. :rolleyes:
 
So the argument is something like, "At high pressure water can do some really weird stuff that I can't understand, therefore Homeopathy works." Got it. :rolleyes:

Hmm. So, when astronomers finally start finding Earth-size planets, there may be one with both water and a very dense atmosphere. And on that one Homeopathy may work. :boggled:
 
Homeopathy test

A simple test would be to give someone say 10 bottles of homeopathic remedies, without labels, and all they have to do is correctly identify the substance.
 
Hmm. So, when astronomers finally start finding Earth-size planets, there may be one with both water and a very dense atmosphere. And on that one Homeopathy may work. :boggled:
Ah, except that the 'Law of Similars' is a form sympathetic magic.

Let's not forget that homeopathy consists of multiple independent irrationalities; it's magic inside woo, wrapped in fallacies, inside mysticism, wrapped in peudoscience.
 
A simple test would be to give someone say 10 bottles of homeopathic remedies, without labels, and all they have to do is correctly identify the substance.

1. Water
2. Water
3. Water
4. Water
5. Water
6. Water
7. Water
8. Water
9. Water
10. Water

What did I win?
 
A simple test would be to give someone say 10 bottles of homeopathic remedies, without labels, and all they have to do is correctly identify the substance.

IIRC, the Million Dollar Challenge can be won by anyone who can distinguish a homeopathic tincture from water (or alcohol, or whatever the solvent in the tincture is) by any means whatsoever.
 
Ah, except that the 'Law of Similars' is a form sympathetic magic.

Let's not forget that homeopathy consists of multiple independent irrationalities; it's magic inside woo, wrapped in fallacies, inside mysticism, wrapped in peudoscience.

Eh? I'll try again. If there is a Universe in the infinite number of Universes in our Multiverse, there may be (just may be) one in which magic inside woo, wrapped in fallacies, inside mysticism, wrapped in peudoscience actually work and in that one Homeoquakery is real. I think it's the same one in which elephants defecate gold. But I may be wrong. :o
 
IIRC, the Million Dollar Challenge can be won by anyone who can distinguish a homeopathic tincture from water (or alcohol, or whatever the solvent in the tincture is) by any means whatsoever.


There's also the Quackometer's challenge:
THE HOMEOPATHY CHALLENGE

With minimum cost, homeopaths could do a simple test that would start to shut me up about the implausibility of homeopathy.

It is now

325 weeks​

without anyone taking the test.
 
A simple test would be to give someone say 10 bottles of homeopathic remedies, without labels, and all they have to do is correctly identify the substance.


There's a slight technical problem with that:

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200607/ldselect/ldsctech/166/7022105.htm

Q538 Lord Broers: I have a simple, technical question about homeopathy and drugs. Is it possible to distinguish between homeopathic drugs after they have been diluted? Is there any means of distinguishing one from the other?

Ms Chatfield: Only by the label.
 
Last edited:

Thia is something I have always thought.

If you went into a place where such homeopathic stuff is sold and asked them, "How can you show me that what you are selling is really what it is?" what could they say?

"Um....I can't. See, look at the label!"

"But how do you know the label is correct?"

So those selling homeopathic stuff can't actually promise that they are even selling you homeopathic stuff!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom