Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

The tiny URL thing? You just go to the TinyURL website:

http://tinyurl.com/

and enter the URL for a website you wish to link to. It then generates a unique small URL which takes you first to their website, and then onto the original.
 
Thanks for the replies guys.

My understanding is that:

(A) Vaccines claim to prevent diseases whereas homeopathy claims to cure diseases. DIFFERENCE in principle.

(B) And, that they both claim to trigger the body's own immune system to accomplish their targets. Vaccines achieve this demonstrably and effectively over and over again in proper RCT's and in field work, whereas homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level, over and over again. SIMILARITY in principle.

Is this correct enough, and would you add any basic differences or similarities?

AFAIK, the reason why homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level is because there are no active ingredients in the actual pill that they prescribe, and that the whole idea is wrong. The question is:

With respect to what the modern science now knows, what would it take for the homeopathic principle to work?

(1) Hahnemann's basic idea for curing diseases would have to be correct.

(2) The water they use would have to have a "memory" that would only "remember" the ingredient that the homeopath (or whoever it is) mixed in the water, or would somehow have to make this ingredient the most active part of the dilution.

(3) Our current tools for detecting the "memory trace" would have to be insufficient.

(4) Our current knowledge of how the diseases work would have to be wrong.

Is this fair, and would you add anything else? And could someone clarify to me how accurately current knowledge can analyse these points?
 
Some homoeopaths make a claim for homoeoprophlaxis, which is the prevention of disease through homoeopathic vaccination. There have been homoeopathic vaccines for malaria and haemophilus influenza type B, for example.
 
With respect to what the modern science now knows, what would it take for the homeopathic principle to work?

(1) Hahnemann's basic idea for curing diseases would have to be correct.

(2) The water they use would have to have a "memory" that would only "remember" the ingredient that the homeopath (or whoever it is) mixed in the water, or would somehow have to make this ingredient the most active part of the dilution.

(3) Our current tools for detecting the "memory trace" would have to be insufficient.

(4) Our current knowledge of how the diseases work would have to be wrong.

Is this fair, and would you add anything else? And could someone clarify to me how accurately current knowledge can analyse these points?

Please be aware that homoeopathy is not just based on the memory of water. Many remedies are based on alcohol, and most remedies are given in the form of pills on which the solution has been sprayed and left to dry. These are the different carriers of the complex information that needs to be conveyed to the body.

Even if water, alcohol and sugar pills are actually able to contain the necessary information, there is also a need for a mechanism for the body to be able to receive the information and transform it to instructions to the immune system. This is a huge problem for homoeopathy which is in no way addressed if they ever succeed in proving water can contain information.

It is also necessary for a mechanism to exist to impart the information to the water through serial solutions, succusions, triturations, titillations, or whatever they call it. It is by no means easy to show that these will be able to store the necessary information in the carrier.

Homoeopathy would gain much credibility if homoeopaths had any method, any at all, to distinguish two glasses of pills from each other if the labels had fallen of. they use chemical analysis, animal tests, proving, dowsing, or whatever method, to distinguish the remedies. It is not just a question of healing, it is a question of confidence in the method. How can you have confidence in the importance of having a wide variety of remedies if there is no way at all to distinguish them from each other.

And if you are talking to homoeopaths, you should never forget to ask them if airport x-ray scanners damage the remedies, and how they know!
 
Thanks for the replies guys.

My understanding is that:

(A) Vaccines claim to prevent diseases whereas homeopathy claims to cure diseases. DIFFERENCE in principle.

(B) And, that they both claim to trigger the body's own immune system to accomplish their targets. Vaccines achieve this demonstrably and effectively over and over again in proper RCT's and in field work, whereas homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level, over and over again. SIMILARITY in principle.

Rolfe and Hans (and some others here) are knowledgeable about the standard claims made by homeopaths. However, in my more limited experience, homeopaths make various contradictory and inconsistent claims about the role of the immune system in this process, depending on whatever will serve the needs of the moment. I'm not sure that striking down this point makes any real difference, as the immune system idea seems to have been co-opted in order to give the appearance of plausibility, but something else would do (in the homeopath's mind) just as well if that fails.

Is this correct enough, and would you add any basic differences or similarities?

It really all depends upon who you are debating with. The problem is that to start the debate, you have to determine which particular set of ideas that individual holds and debate on those points. Even then, if you pin them down, they are likely to simply switch to something else when you have them cornered.

AFAIK, the reason why homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level is because there are no active ingredients in the actual pill that they prescribe, and that the whole idea is wrong.

The 'no active ingredients' is the more obviously silly part of the idea. However, their method of choosing ingredients to not have in the actual pill is (I think) the more problematic idea.

The question is:

With respect to what the modern science now knows, what would it take for the homeopathic principle to work?

(1) Hahnemann's basic idea for curing diseases would have to be correct.

(2) The water they use would have to have a "memory" that would only "remember" the ingredient that the homeopath (or whoever it is) mixed in the water, or would somehow have to make this ingredient the most active part of the dilution.

(3) Our current tools for detecting the "memory trace" would have to be insufficient.

(4) Our current knowledge of how the diseases work would have to be wrong.

Is this fair, and would you add anything else? And could someone clarify to me how accurately current knowledge can analyse these points?

Numbers 1 and 4 are the same thing. Hahnemann's idea for curing disease is contradicted by pretty much everything we know about how diseases work. Which means that homeopaths have the task of explaining how hundreds of thousands of randomized, controlled trials are able to show a difference if Hahnemann's ideas are right.

Number 3 is unfounded by the claims that they make. While our laboratory tools may be insufficient (which may be a reasonable claim to make), if you consider the human body a tool, the memory trace would be detectable through fairly crude methods when they make claims related to provings and healings.

Number 2 isn't necessary. The (non)content of the actual remedies (and issues about memory in various substances) is irrelevant to the principle of homeopathy. That is, if homeopathy was demonstrated to have an effect, that would serve as evidence that something strange was going on with the carrier substances and/or the dilution process and that would open up a whole new field of exploration. But the discovery that water and other carrier substances have a memory provides no evidence in favour of whether homeopathy works. It provides no support for the idea that like cures like, and it provides no support for an effect on the human body. It simply makes a relatively irrelevant component of the principles appear less superficially silly.

I am probably biased in this assessment because I come at it from a clinical perspective. However, the original claims for homeopathy were made on a clinical basis. The memory of water stuff only came after subsequent discoveries in chemistry revealed that none of the original ingredient was likely to be present in the remedy. As far as I know, the original idea was that the ingredients were present, but diluted to small amounts (and 'activated' by succussion).

Linda
 
Hm, I imagine that if they had found something, they would have ignored all the points they make about the sensitivity of the experiment and so forth, and declared that 'intention' definitely works.
 
Number 2 isn't necessary. The (non)content of the actual remedies (and issues about memory in various substances) is irrelevant to the principle of homeopathy. That is, if homeopathy was demonstrated to have an effect, that would serve as evidence that something strange was going on with the carrier substances and/or the dilution process and that would open up a whole new field of exploration. But the discovery that water and other carrier substances have a memory provides no evidence in favour of whether homeopathy works. It provides no support for the idea that like cures like, and it provides no support for an effect on the human body. It simply makes a relatively irrelevant component of the principles appear less superficially silly.

Actually, I find number 2 the most compelling argument against homeopathy. A homeopath sets out to make a solution of some ingredient by adding one thing and massively diluting it. The result is in fact a "homeopathic solution" (whatever the correct word is) of lots of things they didn't intend to add, and one thing they did intend to add. The homeopathic claim is thus that what they did intentionally is significant while what they did unintentionally is not. I think this is perhaps the most extraordinary claim associated with homeopathy.

The caveat being that I spend practically no time thinking about homeopathy.
 
The results are now in and are inconclusive:
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178%3ABlogPost%3A100388

Apparently the protocol is to be refined and the experiment is to be repeated in two month’s time.

How about a little intention experiment of our own?
All JREFers should, at a time to be arranged, send "intention" thoughts that the brains of the intention experiment members should explode.

ETA: Hang on.... scrap that. There would be no way of telling whether the experiment worked or not.


PS - some other quotes from experiment members:
Intriguing the thunderstorm that happened not too long after the experiement......I wouldn't be surprised if all the focus of so many's people's energy in the area didn't produce changes that coudl have precipated the thunderstorm...and just as I typed that sentence it began to rain in an otherwise clear sky...and now its stopped...a one minute rain shower.,,,,,,the arrival of many great spiritual figures, such as Amma, in an area usually brings on rain or lightening within a few hours,,,,perhaps this is no different
If intention works out of time, then we should structure an experiment that affects a moment in the "past". There would be no reason to anticipate a coming moment. However, I suspect that we would not all reach the past at the same moment.
I wondered if remote healing could be done the same way. I went out to the old scotch pine in our front yard after dark, grounded with Earth, linked with Spirit and “sent” healing energy to all who requested it. The “shortcuts” worked.
Then, late one evening, a request comes from a severely injured young man training for the Olympic trials. I’m so tired, I can’t even drag myself outside to the pine tree. Instead, I just simply stand beside the kitchen phone, evoke Unconditional Love and project a wellness intent toward the injured fellow. I sigh, and promise myself to do a more formal healing in the morning.
I hadn't appreciated just how surreal these dudes are.
From the blurb about their conference last year:
It's not too often you can say that a conference changes lives - but that's just what happened to the delegates who came to "the Intention Experiment conference last March.
After hearing the theory from leading scientists and researchers, including Lynne McTaggart, author of The Intention Experiment, the delegates participated in the world's largest mind-over-matter experiment in history.
They intended for a leaf, in a laboratory in Arizona, to 'glow and glow'. In fact, it glowed so much that scientists could easily see the results on special imaging equipment. And now the experiment is being published in a prestigious science journal.
So it needed special imaging equipment before the glow could be detected? You mean it wasn't readily obvious to the naked eye??? And where is this research published then?
 
Last edited:
"If intention works out of time, then we should structure an experiment that affects a moment in the "past". There would be no reason to anticipate a coming moment. However, I suspect that we would not all reach the past at the same moment."

So they can't even pick cherries?

ETA: Sorry, that should be: So they can't even pick the same cherries?
 
Last edited:
Actually, I find number 2 the most compelling argument against homeopathy. A homeopath sets out to make a solution of some ingredient by adding one thing and massively diluting it. The result is in fact a "homeopathic solution" (whatever the correct word is) of lots of things they didn't intend to add, and one thing they did intend to add. The homeopathic claim is thus that what they did intentionally is significant while what they did unintentionally is not. I think this is perhaps the most extraordinary claim associated with homeopathy.

I realize that this is the silliest sounding part of homeopathy. However, if we could show that an ultradilute homeopathic remedy did have a substantial, consistent, objective clinical effect on a particular disease, we would be forced to look at the issue of ultradilution in greater detail. That is, it would serve as evidence of something interesting going on (even if it's only to discover previously unrecognized sources of contamination).

That same result would provide no evidence whatsoever that the idea of 'like cures like' is a valid idea, though. 'Like cures like', as the homeopaths use it, has been so thoroughly disproven that no amount of evidence can overcome it. That is, even if there was consistent evidence that specific homeopathic remedies worked, it still wouldn't confirm that the way the remedies are chosen is valid.

Linda
 
Last edited:
...snip...

That same result would provide no evidence whatsoever that the idea of 'like cures like' is a valid idea, though. 'Like cures like', as the homeopaths use it, has been so thoroughly disproven that no amount of evidence can overcome it.

...snip...

Typical closed minded pseudosceptic....... ;)

Seriously I do find it perplexing that more homoeopaths do not understand why this is such a problem for what they claim they do.
 
I think it's more to do with with the fact that they do not actually understand what they are claiming to do. I know that sounds patronizing but it's based on my reading on here over the years in which, time and time again, I've seen homoeopaths show that they do to have the foggiest idea of why they do what they do. In other words they've taken homoeopathy on faith.
 
PS - some other quotes from experiment members:
Intriguing the thunderstorm that happened not too long after the experiement......I wouldn't be surprised if all the focus of so many's people's energy in the area didn't produce changes that coudl have precipated the thunderstorm...and just as I typed that sentence it began to rain in an otherwise clear sky...and now its stopped...a one minute rain shower.,,,,,,the arrival of many great spiritual figures, such as Amma, in an area usually brings on rain or lightening within a few hours,,,,perhaps this is no different


Well, we've already had storms as a side-effect of homoeopathy:

Then something quite unexpected happened. Two weeks after the sheep were given the first dose of Angustura, an unusually violent storm swept over Northern California. It devastated the subject ranch which is located on the tallest hills within sight of the ocean at Tomales Bay, approximately 45 miles north of San Francisco. The winds were clocked at 100+ mph. The roof was blown off the barn, as were the barn doors. It blew a 2,500-gallon steel water tank through the air one-and-a-half miles until it crashed into a distant neighbor's building. Most trees, fences, and gates were destroyed by the high winds.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom