Thanks for the replies guys.
My understanding is that:
(A) Vaccines claim to prevent diseases whereas homeopathy claims to cure diseases. DIFFERENCE in principle.
(B) And, that they both claim to trigger the body's own immune system to accomplish their targets. Vaccines achieve this demonstrably and effectively over and over again in proper RCT's and in field work, whereas homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level, over and over again. SIMILARITY in principle.
Rolfe and Hans (and some others here) are knowledgeable about the standard claims made by homeopaths. However, in my more limited experience, homeopaths make various contradictory and inconsistent claims about the role of the immune system in this process, depending on whatever will serve the needs of the moment. I'm not sure that striking down this point makes any real difference, as the immune system idea seems to have been co-opted in order to give the appearance of plausibility, but something else would do (in the homeopath's mind) just as well if that fails.
Is this correct enough, and would you add any basic differences or similarities?
It really all depends upon who you are debating with. The problem is that to start the debate, you have to determine which particular set of ideas that individual holds and debate on those points. Even then, if you pin them down, they are likely to simply switch to something else when you have them cornered.
AFAIK, the reason why homeopathy is stuck at the placebo level is because there are no active ingredients in the actual pill that they prescribe, and that the whole idea is wrong.
The 'no active ingredients' is the more obviously silly part of the idea. However, their method of choosing ingredients to not have in the actual pill is (I think) the more problematic idea.
The question is:
With respect to what the modern science now knows, what would it take for the homeopathic principle to work?
(1) Hahnemann's basic idea for curing diseases would have to be correct.
(2) The water they use would have to have a "memory" that would only "remember" the ingredient that the homeopath (or whoever it is) mixed in the water, or would somehow have to make this ingredient the most active part of the dilution.
(3) Our current tools for detecting the "memory trace" would have to be insufficient.
(4) Our current knowledge of how the diseases work would have to be wrong.
Is this fair, and would you add anything else? And could someone clarify to me how accurately current knowledge can analyse these points?
Numbers 1 and 4 are the same thing. Hahnemann's idea for curing disease is contradicted by pretty much everything we know about how diseases work. Which means that homeopaths have the task of explaining how hundreds of thousands of randomized, controlled trials are able to show a difference if Hahnemann's ideas are right.
Number 3 is unfounded by the claims that they make. While our laboratory tools may be insufficient (which may be a reasonable claim to make), if you consider the human body a tool, the memory trace would be detectable through fairly crude methods when they make claims related to provings and healings.
Number 2 isn't necessary. The (non)content of the actual remedies (and issues about memory in various substances) is irrelevant to the principle of homeopathy. That is, if homeopathy was demonstrated to have an effect, that would serve as evidence that something strange was going on with the carrier substances and/or the dilution process and that would open up a whole new field of exploration. But the discovery that water and other carrier substances have a memory provides no evidence in favour of whether homeopathy works. It provides no support for the idea that like cures like, and it provides no support for an effect on the human body. It simply makes a relatively irrelevant component of the principles appear less superficially silly.
I am probably biased in this assessment because I come at it from a clinical perspective. However, the original claims for homeopathy were made on a clinical basis. The memory of water stuff only came after subsequent discoveries in chemistry revealed that none of the original ingredient was likely to be present in the remedy. As far as I know, the original idea was that the ingredients were present, but diluted to small amounts (and 'activated' by succussion).
Linda