Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

In addition, the basic principles of homoepathy don't include the idea of disease causing pathogens (or the specific diseases caused by them for that matter) so even if homoeopathic remedies produced antibodies their action in preventing disease wouldn't be compatible with the principles on which homoeopathy is claimed to work.

Instead, homoeopaths say stuff like "they make it so your energy doesn’t have a malaria-shaped hole in it so the malarial mosquitos won’t come along and fill that in." to quote David Colquhoun, "this last bit of advice means nothing whatsoever. It is sheer gobblydegook."

By the way, when I was looking for that I found this: Help! I have a malaria shaped hole in my Qi!

:D
 
Last edited:
Thank you all for the welcomes and replies!

I don't know too much about the issue, but my long-standing understanding of homeopathy is that it works, at best, as a placebo. And I consider it very unlikely that there will ever be evidence that shows anything else. But, I'd like to know more about it.

I've recently seen a lot about the placebo effect and homeopaths claiming that their observations show that their treatment may work through this mechanism.

The placebo effect has several mechanisms which are understood to different extents.

The sort of diseases that homeopaths specialise in are usually self correcting. The aspect of the placebo effect which occurs here is simply that the patient gets better. This is not particularly amazing, hundreds of millions of years of evolution have produced mechanisms to repair damaged tissue and to destroy infecting bacteria and viruses. The claim that some interaction of homeopath, homeopathic preparation and patient leads to a cure above no treatment at all has less evidence than homeopathy works. And the evidence that homeopathy works is so small as to be invisible.
 
Vaccines are preventative: the immune system is primed to combat the virus if it should ever invade the body. There is no purpose in using a vaccine if you are already infected, because the virus itself will be stimulated the body to a response, although too late (OK, I think there are cases where the vaccine does a better job then the live virus, but that is an exception). Homoeopathy is not preventative: it aims at curing diseases directly. If you are vaccinated, you are really immune to that particular disease for a certain time. If you only use homoeopathy, you will get the same disease again and again (because you are not being treated at all)

We know everything about how vaccines work, but nobody knows how homoeopathy is supposed to work. The theories of homoeopaths have no relation to reality, and no homoeopath has ever been able to show any element of their theories to be based on reality.

There are actually active ingredients in vaccines. Not even homoeopaths can show that there are any active ingredients in their remedies when they are above 12C. In fact, no homoeopath has ever been able to show that they can tell two of their remedies apart, because they are all technically identical to nothing at all.
 
Thank you all for the welcomes and replies!

I don't know too much about the issue, but my long-standing understanding of homeopathy is that it works, at best, as a placebo. And I consider it very unlikely that there will ever be evidence that shows anything else. But, I'd like to know more about it.

I work in a place where I meet homeopaths, naturopaths, ayurvedics, acupuncturists, reiki healers, etc. (and their customers) almost daily. I enjoy talking with them and sharing all the different viewpoints about these subjects. I'm comfortable sharing my skepticism with them, because it doesn't really require anything technical to point out many problems in their ideas and practises, only fairly common sense. But when the discussion turns technical, I don't want to speak over my head, even if I realise that that's pretty much all that they are doing.

I understand what you mean and they rely on that; the use of technical language means that they are not forced to explore or justify their ideas. Because they are speaking over their head, they do not realize that what they are saying does not make sense (they probably assume it does make sense having learned it from someone they think was not speaking over their own head), and they recognize that most others will lack confidence in their own technical expertise and shut up. It's a good debate-stopping technique.

Few things I'd like to understand better in homeopathy (DIM :)) and it's relation to EBM (of which my knowledge is minimal as well).

1) Hahnemann's claim was that 'like cures like', right? Now, to a significant part of the population, this seems quite imaginable because all they know is that vaccines are doing "the same thing" and are helping people. Could someone clarify to me, in simple but real terms, how the homeopathic principle differs from the vaccines?

Homeopathic remedies are 'like' the conditions they 'cure' in the same way that armadillos are like alligators because they both start with the letter 'a'.

The 'like' when it comes to vaccines refers to the identification of a causative agent and a response directed to that specific causative agent. When homeopaths use the word 'like', they are referring not to a causative agent, but to subjective perceptions (loosely corresponding to symptoms) and personality characteristics, and a response directed (using that term very loosely) at those perceptions. To fill in the blanks, when it comes to vaccines, "like cures like" means "a dose of the same agent leads to a physical response that can cure a second dose of the same agent", but when it comes to vaccines it means "a dose* of an agent that led** to a similar subjective perception when taken by a person 200 years ago changes that subjective perception".

Linda

*As you point out, no 'dose' need actually be present.
**'led' used loosely, since whether or not the subjective perceptions recorded in the provings done by Hahnemann (and others) were caused by the substances ingested or merely due to the power of suggestion is questionable.
 
Thank you all for the welcomes and replies!

I don't know too much about the issue, but my long-standing understanding of homeopathy is that it works, at best, as a placebo. And I consider it very unlikely that there will ever be evidence that shows anything else. But, I'd like to know more about it.

I work in a place where I meet homeopaths, naturopaths, ayurvedics, acupuncturists, reiki healers, etc. (and their customers) almost daily. {snip}
The best InterNet source for those topics is www.quackwatch.org I would suggest some books; but I am not sure of their availability to you. A couple have been published, recently, in England; but I am waiting for them here. If you can get a copy of "A Consumer's Guide to 'Alternative Medicine'" by Kurt Butler (Prometheus, 1992) I recommend you to do so.
 
...feedback from those who took part in yesterday's ‘Water Intention Experiment’ can found here:
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/forum/topic/show?id=848178:Topic:96821

Apparently Rustum Roy's team will have the results available next week.


The first feedback from the experiment has just been published. The scientists involved claim that they've "seen results they’ve never seen before with their equipment"...
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178:BlogPost:97963
 
The first feedback from the experiment has just been published. The scientists involved claim that they've "seen results they’ve never seen before with their equipment"...
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178:BlogPost:97963
I love it!

Many scientists have seen "results we've never seen before." It would be great if those were a discoveries; however, it usually means there is something wrong with the equipment or the experimental controls. Considering these characters' history, it is probably both.
 
The first feedback from the experiment has just been published. The scientists involved claim that they've "seen results they’ve never seen before with their equipment"...
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178:BlogPost:97963

... long-wave far-infrared light waves... infrared energy at the levels detected by the Raman spectrometer is not something that can, according to our understanding of transverse EM waves, be sent long distance.

Here's what I understand about Raman:

When you see a peak in a Raman spectrum at, say, 1160cm^-1, it doesn't mean that the sample is emitting light at that wavenumber. It means that the outgoing laser beam has its wavenumber shifted by 1160cm^-1 compared to the incoming one. The shift is relatively small: red light has a wavelength of about 650 nm, which corresponds to a wavenumber of about 15400cm^-1, so a Raman shift of 1160cm^-1 would mean that the outgoing light had a wavelength of 700 nm. So the peak at 1160cm^-1 doesn't mean that their detector is really detecting light at 8628nm: it's detecting light which is about 50nm longer (depending on the laser they are using) than the laser it's expecting.

(A peak at about 9 microns, by the way, corresponds to a black-body temperature of about 60 degrees C. What are they talking about, that it "can't be sent long distances?")
 
The laser light is absorbed by the water molecules, depending on how they are energetically configured or arranged, and then reradiated at a different wavelength.

This quote is from the web page describing the "intention experiment" (see links in previous posts). Whoever wrote this text doesn't understand the difference between ordinary fluorescence (absorption and subsequent reemission of photons) and Raman scattering (instantaneous scattering with wavelength shift of the scattered photon).

Also, they write about "typical Raman spectra when the laser is turned off". But Raman scattering can only occur when the laser is turned on. There's something here that needs to be explained... it would be nice to see details of the experimental setup somewhere.
 
Rustum Roy may have dropped a bomb, but Lionel Milgrom seems to have dropped something else...again.

http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/acm.2007.0674

Published on 1st April, but I don't suppose he'd see that as a joke.

I'd be fascinated to know who J. Comp. Alt. Med. got to referee the paper. Probably a couple of homeopaths whose previous greatest mathematical feat has been working out the difference between the cost of a sugar pill and what it can be sold for when labelled with the phrase "Homeopathic Remedy".
 
Looking at the famed Rao et al. paper in Homeopathy, they state that for Raman spectra, "stray light is eliminated by turning off all the room lights whenever data are being collected". Unless they're working in a darkroom, that surely won't be good enough, and how would they see what they're doing?

The more you look at it, the stupider it gets.
 
Looking at the famed Rao et al. paper in Homeopathy, they state that for Raman spectra, "stray light is eliminated by turning off all the room lights whenever data are being collected". Unless they're working in a darkroom, that surely won't be good enough, and how would they see what they're doing?

The more you look at it, the stupider it gets.
I guess that's another lesson for me- to never "assume" things. When I read they turned off the room lights, I thought they were being quaintly over-cautious! It should, perhaps, have served notice that their spectrometer is only cobbled-together.
 
Last edited:
I've just realised where these muppets are getting their ideas from;

Compare

http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/pdfplus/10.1089/acm.2008.0064

"And now, as a summation of his previous work, the present opus derives
a picture of a stellated octahedron known as a stella octangula.

Milgrom rightly mentions the stella octangula’s connection to mystical Judaism, but uncharacteristically leaves it to the reader to deduce the full significance of this fact, which is certainly worthy of comment."

with

http://www.clivebanks.co.uk/THHGTTG/THHGTTGradio6.htm

"The Haggunennons of Azizatus Three have the most impatient chromosomes of any life-forms in the galaxy. Where as most races are content to evolve slowly and carefully over thousands of generations - discarding a prehensile toe here, nervously hazarding another nostril there, the Haggunennons would do for Charles Darwin what a squadron of Arcturan Stunt-Apples would have done for Sir Isaac Newton. Their genetic structure, based on the quadruple-striated octo-helix, is so chronically unstable, that far from passing their basic shape onto their children, they will quite frequently evolve several times over lunch. "

The numpties aren't writing about medicine's interface with physics, they're just producing poor imitations of Douglas Adams' material. His estate should sue.
 
It won't link either!

Oh, well, insert "05on-bv||$#!+-and-m!^dfv<k!^g.html" after the "2008"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom