Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

This is a vital point. Whenever I get the chance faced with one of these pseudorationalist homeopaths trying to distance themselves from the real loons, I ask, "How can you tell?", i.e. how do you 'know' they are loonies but you're all right?.


In the case of the editor of that particular journal, an appropriate question is "how do you know it doesn't prevent malaria?"

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/newsnight/5178122.stm

The hospital's Director Peter Fisher told Newsnight "I'm very angry about it because people are going to get malaria - there is absolutely no reason to think that homeopathy works to prevent malaria and you won't find that in any textbook or journal of homeopathy so people will get malaria, people may even die of malaria if they follow this advice."
 
Holy ****! Milgrom is citing Rao et al to support his statement that "recent work from the materials sciences indicates that it may indeed be possible to distinguish ultra-diluted and potentised homeopathic remedies from pure water by physical methods".
 
Hi all, it's my first post here, didn't want to start a new thread, I hope this is fine. English is not my native language, so please excuse any obvious grammar mistakes.

I was talking about homeopathy with my friend the other day and this is roughly where we are:

We believe that there's been no signs of positive results in scientific homeopathy studies. And, we'd like to know more about how the studies have taken into consideration the "possible" "bad energies" or whatever the homeopaths claim to be the reasons for the tests failing one after another.

Any kind of help is much appreciated. And sorry, this must be common knowledge around here, but it's a pretty big mountain of scattered info to climb and we'd like to make progress.
 
Last edited:
Here is the evidence that homoeopathy works:

Oh, I'm sorry, you don't see anything?
 
Hello Kuko 4000, and welcome to the JREF forums. :)

...we'd like to know more about how the studies have taken into consideration the "possible" "bad energies" or whatever the homeopaths claim to be the reasons for the tests failing one after another.

Any kind of help is much appreciated. And sorry, this must be common knowledge around here, but it's a pretty big mountain of scattered info to climb and we'd like to make progress.


Just take it from the Director of the (troubled) London Homoeopathic Hospital, and Homoeopathic Physician to Her Majesty, Queen Elizabeth II, that homeopathy is a placebo:
"Over these years we have come to believe that conventional RCTs are unlikely to capture the possible benefits of homeopathy...It seems more important to define if homeopathists can genuinely control patients' symptoms and less relevant to have concerns about whether this is due to a 'genuine' effect or to influencing the placebo response."

http://rheumatology.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/40/9/1052


BTW, feedback from those who took part in yesterday's ‘Water Intention Experiment’ can found here:
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/forum/topic/show?id=848178:Topic:96821

Apparently Rustum Roy's team will have the results available next week.
 
Last edited:
We believe that there's been no signs of positive results in scientific homeopathy studies. And, we'd like to know more about how the studies have taken into consideration the "possible" "bad energies" or whatever the homeopaths claim to be the reasons for the tests failing one after another.
The problem with "bad energies" is that because the homeopaths won't say what this means, they can't be controlled for in the experiment.

If they meant light, for example, we could run two experiments in parallel, one in a lighted room, and one in total darkness. If they meant radiation, we could run one experiment in a shielded room, and the other in a normal lab. If they meant noise, we could run one in a soundproofed lab. And so on.

But they won't say, because then they wouldn't have an easy answer for the perennial failure of homeopathy in any properly controlled experiment.

Oh, and welcome! :)
 
Last edited:
Hi all, it's my first post here, didn't want to start a new thread, I hope this is fine. English is not my native language, so please excuse any obvious grammar mistakes.
Welcome.

I was talking about homeopathy with my friend the other day and this is roughly where we are:

We believe that there's been no signs of positive results in scientific homeopathy studies.


That's not quite the case. There are some studies giving positive results, but they tend to be small or of poor quality. It has been found that larger better quality studies (i.e. ones that reduce the likelyhood of an apparent positive being due to chance or a result of flaws in the experimental procedure) are less likely to give positive results. If you look at the threads on this forum in which studies have been presented as showing that homoeopathy works, you'll find that It always tends to be the same handful of studies. When all the evidence is looked at it appears that homoeopathy is no more effective than placebo.

And, we'd like to know more about how the studies have taken into consideration the "possible" "bad energies" or whatever the homeopaths claim to be the reasons for the tests failing one after another.


They haven't really done this. What we see is assertions that double blind RCTs are not suitable for testing homoeopathy, and fantastic rationalisations of this (mis)using quantum mechanics. No alternative methods of rigorously assessing homoeopathy are ever suggested.

Instead, we see homoeopaths running unblinded trials such as the 2005 Spence et al study, in which patients treated at a homoeopathic hospital were asked if they felt better a few months later. Because there is no control group this can't tell us anything about whether homoeopathy actually works. This doesn't prevent homoeopaths claiming that it does, of course.
 
I suspect Kuko 4000 is not referring to "bad" energies like radiation, but bad "energies"- the bad vibes that the homs sometimes claim screw up SCAM experiments if nasty sceptics try to do them with proper objectivity.
 
I suspect Kuko 4000 is not referring to "bad" energies like radiation, but bad "energies"- the bad vibes that the homs sometimes claim screw up SCAM experiments if nasty sceptics try to do them with proper objectivity.
Yep. But if you ask the homeopaths what "energies" means, you don't get very far.
 
That's not quite the case. There are some studies giving positive results, but they tend to be small or of poor quality. It has been found that larger better quality studies (i.e. ones that reduce the likelyhood of an apparent positive being due to chance or a result of flaws in the experimental procedure) are less likely to give positive results. If you look at the threads on this forum in which studies have been presented as showing that homoeopathy works, you'll find that It always tends to be the same handful of studies. When all the evidence is looked at it appears that homoeopathy is no more effective than placebo.

I'm not sure that that's even true. I've accepted the word of others that the poor quality trials are positive, because they should be (poor quality has the effect of increasing the probability of returning a 'positive' result). I've mostly focussed on the results of the better trials and discovered that while many of them are reported as 'positive', they are actually negative when judged using the usual standards. However, I've not come across this body of positive but low-quality trials that homeopaths and others make passing reference to. I'm beginning to think that this is a fiction. They make these claims and then present long lists of studies, but if you actually look up the references on those lists (as I did in the Lupercalia thread), the majority of them would be considered negative. I used to assume that all these 'positive' studies were out there and I had simply missed them (I wasn't looking very hard, after all, since quality tells you whether the results are likely to be valid and so even positive results in a low-quality study don't need to be taken seriously). But the more I look in to this and fail to discover these positive studies, the more I suspect that they don't even exist - that homeopaths are calling a bunch of crappy negative studies 'positive' and getting away with it because no one with the know-how bothers to get past 'crappy'.

Linda
 
Maybe I should have said "apparently giving positive results".

If that is acceptable to you, I think it would help to bring attention to what are misleading (I'll be generous in my characterization ;)) claims.

Linda
 
The study that opened this thread is a case in point. The data presented simply cannot be used to conclude that homeopathic remedies can be distinguished on the basis of structure since the authors made no effort to exclude other differences in the preparations, and they did not provide the information that would allow anyone to confirm that their measurements were actually different (mean, S.D., or confidence intervals). Yet this is presented as a 'positive' paper.

Linda
 
There are also the various clinical studies that after the event choose, from a variety of other measurements, an individual measurement that showed a significant difference - effectively drawing a target around where the dart happened to hit.
 
Last edited:
Thank you all for the welcomes and replies!

I don't know too much about the issue, but my long-standing understanding of homeopathy is that it works, at best, as a placebo. And I consider it very unlikely that there will ever be evidence that shows anything else. But, I'd like to know more about it.

I work in a place where I meet homeopaths, naturopaths, ayurvedics, acupuncturists, reiki healers, etc. (and their customers) almost daily. I enjoy talking with them and sharing all the different viewpoints about these subjects. I'm comfortable sharing my skepticism with them, because it doesn't really require anything technical to point out many problems in their ideas and practises, only fairly common sense. But when the discussion turns technical, I don't want to speak over my head, even if I realise that that's pretty much all that they are doing.

Few things I'd like to understand better in homeopathy (DIM :)) and it's relation to EBM (of which my knowledge is minimal as well).

1) Hahnemann's claim was that 'like cures like', right? Now, to a significant part of the population, this seems quite imaginable because all they know is that vaccines are doing "the same thing" and are helping people. Could someone clarify to me, in simple but real terms, how the homeopathic principle differs from the vaccines?

At this point, nevermind that there is no observable 'like' at all in the diluted homeopathic medicine (because this just gives them room for claiming that "our" "meters" are not good enough yet), I just want to be able to explain to the people around me, in simple and real terms, how the homeopathic principle differs from the use of vaccines.

I'd like to do this one point at a time, in order to keep it easy for me to digest. More questions coming up if you have the time to answer!
 
Last edited:
1) Hahnemann's claim was that 'like cures like', right? Now, to a significant part of the population, this seems quite imaginable because all they know is that vaccines are doing "the same thing" and are helping people. Could someone clarify to me, in simple but real terms, how the homeopathic principle differs from the vaccines.

At this point, nevermind that there is no observable 'like' at all in the diluted homeopathic medicine (because this just gives them room for claiming that "our" "meters" are not good enough yet), I just want to be able to explain to the people around me, in simple and real terms, how the homeopathic principle differs from the use of vaccines.


Vaccines work by stimulating an immune response - the immune system produces antibodies against whatever the vaccine is for. Homoeopathic remedies do nothing of the sort.

ETA: I think those last three words may be redundant.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom