Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Is it my imagination, or is Penn State increasingly plagued by woo these days?

Did Randi's recent visit there have no effect at all??
 
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178:BlogPost:92122


“Science is in the strange position of acknowledging that a naturally occurring inorganic liquid is essential for the maintenance of all organic life.


:nope:

[although] water has been closely associated with the psyche, intuition and healing...this link has been ignored by modern medical research


;)


and

“It may well be that these blessings, given with true loving intentions, actually change the structure – hence the properties – of water. That is the basis of our experiment.


:jaw-dropp


And what do they intend to do?

“Structured waters have been produced using various forms of energy, such as light, sound, heat, pressure and radiation.“In our proposed experiment, we aim to examine whether we can structure water with intention alone. So if we’re successful, we will have performed an extraordinary feat. We will have created ‘holy healings waters’ simply by the power of the thought alone.


:D:D:D
 
Last edited:
Oh good lord, that is pure comedy gold.

Rustum Roy said:
In our proposed experiment, we aim to examine whether we can structure water with intention alone. We’ll be monitoring any change against control using analytical tools such as spectroscopy.

So we can expect another round of drivel, then.
 
It will be interesting if he actually uses water this time round though.

Remember, all the spectroscopy results in the paper we were discussing were obtained from 95% ethanol. Ethanol, I think I'm right in saying, is much much more prone to picking up contamination accidentally than water, at least the sort of contamination that might have a major influence on the absorption in the wavelengths he's looking at. It was the presence of such contamination in the samples that seemed to be the source of the different UV spectra.

Well, that and simple sloppy technique. And I suppose it's possible that different water samples might have the relatively small differences shown between the succussed preparations in the earlier study (especially when combined with said sloppy technique). However, I have difficulty believing that water might get so contaminated as to do anything similar to what was shown in the "plain ethanol" trace.

Bottom line, if all he's going to do is present single spectra from each of his samples, and these spectra differ slightly, then he can hand-wave to his heart's content over these tiny differences. Repeatability, precision, standard deviations and statistically significant differences seem to be completely foreign concepts to these guys.

I doubt it he's going to attract a lot of scientific respect if he serves all this up with comments about "blessings", "loving intentions" and "holy healing waters" though.

I repeat my totally speculative theory about how come all the verbiage about "the memory of water" in the Homeopathy paper was followed by a set of results obtained from samples of 95% ethanol.

Scene: A couple of back rooms in a corner of a university department. There are a few superannuated items of equipment on the benches, in varying stages of dilapidation. There are some squeeezy bottles lying around, and the streaked illegible writing on the sides indicates they contain some sort of extremely polar solvent. [Something Geni likes to smell in the mornings.]

Rao/Roy: OK guys, we're going to measure some actual homoeopathic remedies in our spiffy spectrophotometer. TeaBoy, order us up a couple of remedies from a real homoeopathic manufacturer, will you.

[A few days later]

Rao/Roy: Well, here they are, let's open the box. All nicely labelled with unique identification numbers so we know which is which, good. And here's the temperature sensor in the box too.

TeaBoy: What's that for?

Rao/Roy: Nothing at all, but mentioning it in the paper will sound scientific.

[long pause]

Rao/Roy: Ethanol? 95% ethanol? These remedies aren't water, then?

TeaBoy: You didn't say anything about water or ethanol. You just asked me to order some remedies from a homoeopathic manufacturer, and that's what I did.

Rao/Roy: Oh cr*p. Well, lets just run them through the old machine and see what they look like anyway. TeaBoy, we're off to the pub, will you just run these samples through for us?

TeaBoy: Sure, boss. Er, where do I turn it on...?

[A few days later]

Roy: Well, this is very exciting, look, the traces aren't identical.

TeaBoy: Well, I did each one a few times, and you're right, no two traces are identical.

Roy: Never mind. If we choose this trace for the 30C and this trace for the 6C and so on, that clearly illustrates the real differences between them.

TeaBoy: But this other trace from the 30C is almost identical to the one you've got there for the 6C....

Roy: Never mind that, we want the ones that are "representative". But we can say you did each one ten times if you like, that will impress the scrutineers.

Rao: I wonder if ordinary ethanol that hasn't been succussed by trained experts would look any different? Have we got any of that?

Roy produces a dusty, three-quarters empty Winchester from the back of a store cupboard. It has the word "Ethanol" on its torn, yellowing label, in faded handwritten letters.

Roy: Oh yes, here's some. TeaBoy, could you just run that one for us later this afternoon?

[Next day.]

Roy: Oh look, isn't this marvellous, look at the huge difference between this trace and all the others. Let's get to the word processor, we have to write this up.

Rao: But the paper is about the memory of water, and these samples were all 95% ethanol.

Roy: So? We've got results that show homoeopathy works, don't quibble about small details.

I was looking for a character to point out that the huge difference between the "plain ethanol" and all the succussed samples might suggest that the effect was entirely mechanical, due to the shaking, and nothing to do with the mother tinctures. However, I couldn't imagine anyone in this little group actually having even that amount of smarts. I was also thinking of including someone asking how come the homoeopathic preparation methods were actually capable of removing absorbance from the carrier solvent, but again, I couldn't imagine anyone there having the gumption to question that aspect either.

Expect more of the same. Nevertheless, I'll be interested to see what happens when they look at some actual water.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
[...snip...]

Scene: A couple of back rooms in a corner of a university department. There are a few superannuated items of equipment on the benches, in varying stages of dilapidation. There are some squeeezy bottles lying around, and the streaked illegible writing on the sides indicates they contain some sort of extremely polar solvent. [Something Geni likes to smell in the mornings.]

[...snip...]

That's very good Rolfe. It would have made a good Muppets show, with Dr._Bunsen_HoneydewWP in the role of Roy, and Beaker_(Muppet)WP as the TeaBoy.
 
What The Bleep

"It may well be that these blessings, given with true loving intentions, actually change the structure – hence the properties – of water. That is the basis of our experiment."

Sounds like Roy has fallen for the "what the bleep" / Dr. Emoto scam. I wonder if he'll reference Ramtha in his paper? Shame to see someone who was a pretty good scientist fall for this bunk.
 
It will be interesting if he actually uses water this time round though.

Remember, all the spectroscopy results in the paper we were discussing were obtained from 95% ethanol. Ethanol, I think I'm right in saying, is much much more prone to picking up contamination accidentally than water, at least the sort of contamination that might have a major influence on the absorption in the wavelengths he's looking at. It was the presence of such contamination in the samples that seemed to be the source of the different UV spectra.

Well, that and simple sloppy technique. And I suppose it's possible that different water samples might have the relatively small differences shown between the succussed preparations in the earlier study (especially when combined with said sloppy technique). However, I have difficulty believing that water might get so contaminated as to do anything similar to what was shown in the "plain ethanol" trace.

Bottom line, if all he's going to do is present single spectra from each of his samples, and these spectra differ slightly, then he can hand-wave to his heart's content over these tiny differences. Repeatability, precision, standard deviations and statistically significant differences seem to be completely foreign concepts to these guys.

{snip}
Yes. It seems they have learned that too many of us know UV-Vis spectroscopy; so they will concentrate on Raman spectroscopy henceforth. Raman is a method that few of us understand well-enough to critique. It is also very sensitive (so minor contaminants in water may show up) and noisy (so random variations appear among spectra, and they can be claimed as features).
 
I've only just come across this thread, not sure how I missed it when it started, but I want to thank all concerned for the input to the thread, which I found to be quite fascinating and a startling example of how actually checking the facts can expose all kinds of problems with published studies.

I particularly liked the back and forth with the authors of the paper, which I have summarised in my head as:

Rao, Roy et. al. : Look ... you can tell the difference betwen homeopathic stuff and water ethanol! We rule!
JJM, Rolfe et. al. : Really? Are you sure? Looks dodgy, where the hell is your data? Where did you get your control samples? What on earth did you test?
Rao, Roy et. al. : La, la, la, can't hear you....we rule!
 
{snip} And this new post gives an explanation of how the experiment will be run:
http://theintentionexperiment.ning.com/profiles/blog/show?id=848178%3ABlogPost%3A94693

Can somebody help us out? If that is a picture of a Raman spectrometer, I'll eat my hat. In their article in "Homeopathy" the authors proudly assured us the Raman sample is enclosed in a device that does not admit incidental light; which should go without saying.

It is a nice photo of a brand-new-out-of-the box, never-been-used beaker; I bet they have cases of them in their "lab."
 
Last edited:
I saw a Raman experiment once ages ago: I remember it was a big cabinet with a stage in it, onto which a tiny beaker was placed. You shine a big laser into the sample and measure any light coming out which is of a wavelength just a little bit longer than the original light (while taking care to avoid saturating your detector with the laser light which has been Rayleigh scattered without a change in wavelength).

I'm not sure what that "probe" is. There would need to be a monochromator to resolve wavelengths.

Let's all concentrate on giving Roy a prolapse.
 
Last edited:
Incidentally, there have been a couple more responses to the criticisms of the Memory of Water special - this time to Philippe Leick, from Milgrom and Walach.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/14754916

I don't have access to the full text for these, but from the previews it seem that Milgrom, having used quantum mechanics to show that DBPC trials don't apply to homoeopathy, is complaining about positive DBPC trials of homoeopathy being ignored, while Walach is just saying it's "not about truth, nor about data, but about beliefs and world views", and therefore can't be settled by anything other than "a large cultural shift".
 
Some representative quotes...

Milgrom:
I have adopted implicitly a post-modern stance. This acknowledges
there is no such thing as an objective reality
that has only to be unveiled, and exists whether we observe
it or not, and irrespective of the method in which it is
approached. Leick et al. explicitly adopt what is, in my
view, an outdated positivist model of reality and science.
This is a reasonable approximation for most of what we
do and sufficient for structures like washing machines or
airplanes. However, it is neither correct nor sufficient for
more intricate problems, such as the therapeutic process.
and
This is indeed ironic, since the founder of Leick’s
employer, Robert Bosch, was a staunch supporter of
homeopathy!

Walach:
No doubt Dr Leick and his colleagues will see it differently.
They view likes of Milgrom, Walach, and others as
charlatans, a danger to enlightenment, progress and rationality.
I argue that they are quite wrong, and this is where
the world views start clashing. Hence we need to elaborate
on those, and not debate at a seemingly factual and data
driven level.
and
But
our position is similar to Bacon’s about the world being
round: we have a good theoretical structure, and some empirical
evidence to back it, although decisive proof is missing.
In a couple of 100 years we might have such data. The
question is, whether we have that much time. The traditional
world view is failing. Medical treatment of chronic
problems is unsatisfactory, social systems are decaying,
world politics and distribution of wealth, catastrophic. I
am not sure that more of the same would help. But something
quite different, a world view that allows for non-local
connectivity might.
Idiots.
 
Replies to Leick

Thing: many thanks for the quotes.

I'd be very happy if anybody could send me the papers, as I don't have access to the journal.

Meanwhile, the quotes suggest there are plenty of word games ("Treating Leick with like" is nice and does show that Milgrom, who has proven on numerous occasions that spelling is not his strong point, can pronounce german names!) and clever rhetorical devices... But are there any substantial arguments? OK; they are not needed when a post-modern stance is adopted.

Also, I'd like to point out that I don't think that either Milgrom or Walach are charlatans. I just think that they're "Not even Wrong", at least when it comes to (Weak) Quantum Theory and Homeopathy. Hence the debate.
 
I really must start reading this journal regularly. The same issue includes a debate item entitled"British media attacks on homeopathy: Are they justified?" by George Vithoulkas (who lives in Greece). He rails, quite rightly, against people who do provings by way of dreams or imagination, or claim that homeopathy can cure AIDS, or that water can encode music. He rightly points out that these claims make homeopaths look stupid. Unfortunately he thinks that back-to-basics Hahnemann-based homeopathy isn't stupid. About 30% of the text is in italics.
 
I really must start reading this journal regularly. The same issue includes a debate item entitled"British media attacks on homeopathy: Are they justified?" by George Vithoulkas (who lives in Greece). He rails, quite rightly, against people who do provings by way of dreams or imagination, or claim that homeopathy can cure AIDS, or that water can encode music. He rightly points out that these claims make homeopaths look stupid. Unfortunately he thinks that back-to-basics Hahnemann-based homeopathy isn't stupid. About 30% of the text is in italics.

This is a vital point. Whenever I get the chance faced with one of these pseudorationalist homeopaths trying to distance themselves from the real loons, I ask, "How can you tell?", i.e. how do you 'know' they are loonies but you're all right?.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom