Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Rolfe:

Yes, definitely agree with those points. In fairness, I think Homeopathy deserves some kudos for allowing Ben Goldacre to journal club the original special issue, thus giving far wider access to the articles than would otherwise be the case. And also for publishing critical letters.

Another thing on Rao's 'response', while I think on. Rao says that s/he and her co-authors are "neither champions nor detractors of homeopathy". How does that square with Rustum Roy showing up at the Grauniad to argue in favour of homeopathy?
 
Last edited:
Well fair play to Peter Fisher opening up access to the articles in the original Memory of Water issue and for publishing the letters, even if he basically ignores everything, feels legitimized by the ability to debate (not the ability to be right: he thinks the homeopaths have shown that they can "at least hold their own") and states the following:

Water, prepared by the homeopathic method of successive dilution and succussion, exhibits anomalous properties which can be detected by a range of chemical and physical methods.

Trace amounts of contaminants including silica and dissolved gases are important in determining those properties.

These properties exhibit surprising temporal evolution.

The findings suggest organisation at a mesoscopic scale. No author disputes that, on the microscopic scale, water structure is extremely short lived.

So far there is no satisfactory or uniting theoretical explanation of these observations.

"Unfortunately the debate does little to help, in the short term, the difficult situation in which homeopathy finds itself..."

Well, good. Because it isn't a debate, it's us telling you lot that you're wrong.

(Note: written before I saw wilsontown's post)
 
Last edited:
Hm, as shpalman says, Fisher states that "supporters of homeopathy can debate with opponents of a high scientific level, with strongly held sceptical views, and at least hold their own."

What's interesting is that a lot of the authors of the 'memory of water' papers insist that they are not supporters of homeopathy. Chaplin says so, and so does Rao. They seem to think that publishing in a journal called 'Homeopathy' is irrelevant.

And if you think Rao et al., Milgrom and Weingartner have 'held their own' in the debate, you're dreaming.
 
Last edited:
In fairness, I think Homeopathy deserves some kudos for allowing Ben Goldacre to journal club the original special issue, thus giving far wider access to the articles than would otherwise be the case. And also for publishing critical letters.


And, of course, Dana deserves some of the credit for attracting everyone's attention to the Rao et al. paper.
 
Let's face it, "what have you had published in homeopathy" is going to be a great comeback to the perennial claims from homoeopaths that their critics know nothing about homoeopathy.


Ha! I think I'll try and use that one.
 
JJM was musing about a reply to Rao's reply. I don't think there's any point in sending one, however if we/he/I did, there are a few points I'd like to include.

How does she reconcile her oft-repeated assertion that she is not a proponent of homoeopathy with the language used in the paper, and in particular the use of some fairly esoteric homoeopathic terminology (such as "polychrest"), and an attack on a false representation of the position of "skeptics" on the subject - the latter a very common feature of the committed homoeopathic proponent?

As she seems to accept that the "plain ethanol" sample was grossly contaminated compared to the succussed samples, is she absolutely, completely and utterly positive that it came from Hahnemann Laboratories with the rest of the stuff? (And if so, why didn't she say so in the M&M?) (And a supplementary - did she not consider acquiring some other samples of 95% ethanol and analysing them for comparison?)

Talking of the M&M section, what was the point of the temperature sensor in the package? What was the point of the "unique identifying numbers" on each sample? Was the analysis blinded?

Are we right about a Nat mur 30C trace having been omitted from fig. 2a and a Nux vom 30C one substituted in error? If this is so, does she have any comment to make?

Are her "envelopes of differences" indeed simply presentations of alleged "extreme" high and low traces from each preparation? If so, has she any comment on the degree of precision demonstrated by these results?

Assuming this is indeed the case, why do some of the traces presented as part of the "envelopes of differences" (that is, extreme or outlier traces) in fig. 2, reappear as "representative" traces in fig 1? How can a trace be both the edge of the envelope and "representative?"

Given that she claims to have run each preparation ten times, would she care to present these results as means and standard deviations (10nm increments would do), and show us by means of t-tests where the significant differences she claims to have discovered actually lie?

We have pointed out that the simple and most probable explanation for the apparent differences in the spectra of the three different succussed preparations is small differences in the impurities in the different bottles of ethanol used to manufacture each remedy. Her response to this seems to be simply that these are the remedies "as used in practice". In what way does she think her results have advanced our understanding of these preparations, given that we already knew that different batches of 95% ethanol were likely to have different impurities, and so different UV spectra?

And finally, the biggie.

Given that all her theorising (and indeed the section of the reply letter where she reiterates that theory!) concerns the structure of water, why did she choose to do all her experimental work on 95% ethanol? While the nature of the solvent may matter little to the homoeopath, does it also not matter to the "inorganic materials scientist"? How do findings derived from 95% ethanol illuminate a theory about water?

Oooh. Should we?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure that a further letter would achieve anything. The letter is out there in the public domain now, the authors have failed to refute it, and it might be best to leave it at that.

If there was to be a further letter, I think it would probably suffice to summarise our original letter, and point out that none of the concerns have been addressed.

The thing is that we would just end up re-iterating points that we've already made, and I'm just not sure it's worth the bother.
 
Last edited:
Mind you, I did muse on my blog that Homeopathy ought to withdraw the paper, and Le Canard Noir suggested I could write to Peter Fisher and request that the paper be withdrawn.
 
I think JJM was talking more about a private email to Rao herself asking some questions, rather than anything for publication. It's gone as far as it needs to, in print. Contacting her privately would rather be rubbing her nose in it, but it could be interesting to see how she responds. I mean, she's an inorganic materials scientist, not a homoeopath, so she should welcome scrutiny of her work. No?

I think hell will freeze over before Peter Fisher will withdraw that or any other paper. We have seen Rao's position. These mere scientists just ordered material from a homoeopathic manufacturer. This is studying the stuff "as used in practice". So the results are clearly valuable and relevant. (We just don't want to think too hard about the probable reasons for the differences shown.) Oh, and by demonstrating that UV spectroscopy can be used to identify contamination in samples of 95% ethanol, we have given the homoeopathic community a valuable quality control tool!

I'd put a modest bet on Peter Fisher declaring that this means the paper is all good stuff, and there is no question of withdrawing it.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, I've misunderstood what you were suggesting.

A personal e-mail might be worth a go. Personally, I would like to know exactly what an envelope of differences is supposed to be.

I'm sure you're correct that the paper will not be withdrawn.
 
Yes, I was thinking more in line with "rubbing her nose in it." I might have offered to drive out there and show them how to use their spectrometer (Rolfe- that's, properly, a spectrophotometre). I, too, would like to know what the "envelope of differences" means; but I am not itching for it.

I hate to say it; but I don't think the paper is a candidate for withdrawal. They have conceded the error in the claim for "pure" ethanol. Their other raw data has not been impeached (although, conclusions about it have been). I was taught that "conclusions are for the amusement of the authors" and always subject to re-interpretation; so they do not require withdrawal.

It seems their only, clear infraction was labeling spectral extrema "representative." Looking at the spectra, I suspect that a proper comparison would show (smaller) differences they could still claim support their case. If someone could prove otherwise, that would be grounds for withdrawal.

Homeopaths will always point to the Rao article, I hope our letter will save other scientists' time rebutting it.
 
Weak Replies

...Adrian Gaylard has a go at the Vybiral and Voracek ...and Milgrom papers. Neither really have much of a comeback. ...I think the crowning glory of the issue, though, is Philippe Leick's demolition of the papers on quantum nonsense by Milgrom and Weingartner, with bonus shout-out to shpalman's blog.

I think that the sceptical letters all came over well. I'll blog on the reponses to mine later this week when I've got some time. I agree with wilsontown that the comeback's aren't very strong. Vybiral and Voracek do seem to be a little thin skinned; and don't engage with the substance of the criticism. Milgrom plays around with definitions to shape a riposte; but it's a bit of a mess.

The Rao reply is just stunning in it's failure to engage with the criticism. I really enjoyed Philippe Leick's contribution.

Generally the replies seem to follow the politician's format: don't answer the question asked; talk about something else instead.
 
I've been musing about the water/ethanol thing.

Roy and his mates' theories are all about water. All their other publications are about water or aqueous solutions. All the theorising in the introduction to the present offering is about water. In Rao's reply, where she recaps this theory, she again refers to water, not ethanol. Dammit, the publication is even in an issue of Homeopathy explicitly dedicated to "Memory of Water" speculation. Just occasionally the words "other solvents" make an appearance, but it looks as if they've been added as an afterthought when someone has remembered that the actual results were obtained from ethanol, not water.

So, why carry out your experimental work on 95% ethanol, when you're specifically and explicitly testing a theory about water? The nature of the solvent may well be irrelevant to homoeopaths (nothing would surprise me there), but surely not to "inorganic materials scientists".

I have a few thoughts.

While I suspect Roy et al of being far stronger proponents of homoeopathy than they admit, they're not practitioners, and I suspect they may not have studied the subject in enormous detail. You don't have to interact with homoeopaths for very long before you start to become familiar with jargon such as "polychrest" (though it's an odd term for an unbiassed scientist to use, especially with no effort to define it). However, the question of the nature of the solvent isn't one that seems to come up very often.

It's the same here. How often do we hear people saying, "oh, it's just water", or "the only thing homoeopathy will cure is a thirst" (or "dehydration"). My usual response is to point out that the remedies are most commonly taken as dry sugar pills. But even that begs the question of whether they were prepared using aqueous or alcohol solutions.

I haven't studied the Organon as carefully as MRC_Hans, but my impression is that Hahnemann's original work was done using alcohol. In his 1842 essay, O. W. Holmes was quite clear that he was talking about lakes and oceans of alcohol, not water. I don't know when the switch to water (or its introduction as an alternative) occurred, but I believe it was related to the spread of homoeopathy in the US and the resistance to taking anything alcoholic encountered in groups of people who were strictly teetotal. The infamous King Bio case, where the NCAHF sued King Bio homoeopathic manufacturers for misleading advertising, on the grouds that their own product information stated clearly that their products were nothing but pure water, seems to have arisen because King Bio were making that claim to attract the custom of those opposed to alcohol. (I can't seem to get into that web site at the moment.)

However, the tradition of alcohol-based remedies seems always to have persisted. A veterinary homoeopath acquaintance of mine recommended vodka as a suitable solvent. And, as we see, Hahnemann Laboratories as patronised by Rao and Roy, uses "alcohol" as its solvent.

Now this is just my speculation, but I wonder if Roy actually had no idea that some manufacturers used alcohol. I wonder if he simply ordered (or asked a minion to order) this stuff from a homoeopathic pharmacy, and this is what he got. I know that the alcohol thing is prominent on their web site, but if a minion was doing the ordering, it might not have been picked up on.

That might even be why the "plain ethanol" was so different - if you're expecting to get aqueous remedies, then it's perhaps not unreasonable (at least by their standards) to assume that you can simply use any old distilled water as a control. Then you realise it's not water, and go scraping around for something labelled "95% ethanol"?

Why not simply throw the stuff away, and reorder from some outfit like King Bio? Well, they went to all this trouble, why not have a look at the stuff anyway? And hey, there are some differences!

Correct me if I'm wrong here, but ethanol picks up impurities a lot more easily than water does. The UV absorbances of different bottles of pharmaceutical grade ethanol are far more likely to be appreciably different than different bottles of distilled water. So wasn't this just a lucky break for them!

I suspect that if you did the same thing as Roy did, but ordered from King Bio instead of Hahnemann Laboratories, and used some bench distilled water as the "plain water", you'd be far less likely to see anything that could be described as differences by the UV method. (I even wonder if they tried it and found nothing!)

It's a very curious tale, but it does highlight the insanity of this entire "memory of water" debate. If Hahnemann's original work was done using alcohol, then surely it should be the memory of ethanol we're investigating? I mean, that was the medium in which the efect was first observed! The apparent fact that water seems to retain the same properties should be more of an addendum than anything else. (And that's before we even get started on the question of how the encoded memory is transferred to the sugar pill, or how it is preserved when the solvent evaporates, or how it it transferred to the body!)

I wonder if we need to do a bit more digging into exactly which solvent has been used at different times in history, and in connection with which claims.

Rolfe.
 
But what makes up the remaining 5% with the 95% ethanol?
 
Last edited:
But what makes up the remaining 5% with the 95% ethanol?

Water, probably, because that's about the limit of distillation. Unless it's denatured (so that you don't have to pay tax on it) in which case there's about 1% methyl ethyl ketone. (That's what Roth sell anyway.)
 
So maybe they can still claim that it is memory of water which is the valid mode of action.....
 
But what makes up the remaining 5% with the 95% ethanol?

Water, probably, because that's about the limit of distillation. Unless it's denatured (so that you don't have to pay tax on it) in which case there's about 1% methyl ethyl ketone. (That's what Roth sell anyway.)
Yes, 95% alcohol/5% water is as it comes from distillation of a water-based stock (fermentation, if it is to be potable).

However, there are many formulas for denatured alcohol; they are often designated SDA (specially denatured alcohol). SDA 23A has 10% acetone. Others have an extremely bitter alkaloid added. One chooses an SDA on the basis of the chemical compatibility of the denaturant with the rest of the formula.
 
I’ve been in touch with Dr. Rustum Roye, professor of materials science at Penn State University and Manju Roe, his senior scientist, both of whom will be carrying out our Water Intention Experiment on April 26.

Well done on misspelling both Roy and Rao's names in the first paragraph!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom