I'm sorry, but I'm still gasping at the lameness of that reply. I suppose Darat would rap my knuckles if I posted it all here? Oh well.
First two paragraphs (at least half the reply) don't address the letter at all, just bang on again about pressures and structures. Total waste of paper.
Third paragraph appears first to concede that the "plain ethanol" was indeed contaminated ("probably"!), then to try to rescue something from that wreck. I think she actually means that they have made the great discovery that you can detect contamination in ethanol by UV spectroscopy!!! Wow! Whoda thunkit?!
Final paragraph, and this one I am going to quote as "fair use".
All the analytical data shown in the paper are the result of reproducible analyses, although we appreciate the suggestion of representing such data as an average with a standard deviation, we emphasize that our key identification by display of an envelope demonstrates that, there are indeed differences beyond the standard deviation range among individual homeopathic remedies, as used in practice.
Translation: OK, we could have presented SDs and done some statistics, but we didn't so shut up about it, we
assert that the data are reproducible and differences are there. Honest. How can anyone say "there are indeed differences beyond the standard deviation range" with a straight face, while refusing to present the actual standard deviations? (And anyway, tell me about +/-
2 SDs, and I might
start to listen!)
She seems to be implying that the "plain ethanol" was sent by Hahnemann Labs with the rest of the stuff. I'm not at all sure I believe her. It's a bit telling that fact isn't in the M&M, when all the extraneous rubbish about temperature sensors and unique identifying numbers is. And I don't really think it's all that likely Hahnemann Labs would have ethanol as filthy as that kicking about the shop, as it were. I still think Roy picked up a dusty old bottle from a store room, probably opened multiple times over the past ten years!
But, let's assume she's telling the truth. So, the "plain ethanol" sent by the manufacturer demonstrates marked absorbances which simply aren't in the prepared samples, and aren't characteristic of ethanol at all. What do you do? Jump to the conclusion that succussion alone removes massive amounts of absorbance from ethanol? Likely? Even there, that ignores the demonstrable fact that ethanol just doesn't have these absorbances - if we can find the Sigma catalogue, and
so could Gavinimurthy when he started all this (OK, I see he got it from JJM), then so can she.
What does a true "inorganic materials scientist" do? Well, anything but order up some fresh ethanol in a variety of grades and run some spectra on these for comparison, obviously. I mean, no, you just accept any old rubbish and publish it, no matter how implausible, surely!
I think we done right in not attacking homoeopathy or her stupid theories at all, just demolishing the actual results. It removed a huge potential for come-back. I mean, for all she knew, we could all be raving woos! Frankly, she's toast. And I suspect she knows it.
Another little bonus - several veterinary homoeopaths of my acquaintance subscribe to that journal. They'll recognise my name. They are likely to be chewing the crockery about now.
Rolfe.