Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Got citation information for the letter: Homeopathy 97/1, p44-45. As yet I'm not sure when it will actually appear, but it should be very shortly. I'll keep everyone posted.
 
DOI info for the letter: 10.1016/j.homp.2007.10.004

Also, DOI info for my response to Martin F Chaplin: 10.1016/j.homp.2007.10.002

These haven't actually appeared yet, but should be fairly soon.

I don't have info on any response from the authors of the original articles, but I'll post it as soon as I do.
 
Wow! I suspect I am not the only one to have a problem with their reply. It is pretty brazen to move seemlessly from a claim to be able to differentiate him remedies to saying they are pleased they have demonstrated a quality assurance tool that, amazingly, can distinguish clean ethanol from contaminated ethanol.

And, apparently, Roy is not a proponent of homeopathy.

Quite shameless.
 
Q: Why couldn't the changes have resulted from differences in composition (contamination)?

A: I don't know and don't care.

Linda
 
Of course I meant "hom" remedies not "him" remedies. Predictive text on the iPhone being too clever for its own good!
 
"Kerr et al's remarks concerning the probable contamination in the sample of the original solvent sent to us, although apparently not in any of the dilution materials..."

The implication being that it is more likely that all we know of medicine, chemistry and physics can be overturned than that the stock solution used in the remedies was from a different batch. Actually, I'm unnecessarily harsh. Since he's neutral on the issue of homeopathy, he probably gives an equal probability to both.

Linda
 
Although Rao was the corresponding author, I was pissadointed that Roy did not join in the response. He likes to make insulting remarks about other scientists. Either Rao did not show him our letter, or he realized that his incompetence was unarguable.
 
News? It's in the hands of the thesis committee! I'll let you all know when I know. But I hear it's been well received.
 
I thought that Rao et al. provided a non-answer. It's one thing to say that they provided homeopaths with 'potential quality control tools'. It's quite another to have actually demonstrated that. They really didn't show much of anything.
 
I thought that Rao et al. provided a non-answer. It's one thing to say that they provided homeopaths with 'potential quality control tools'. It's quite another to have actually demonstrated that.


I was kind of assuming he meant a quality control tool for assessing the quality of different batches of stock solvent.
 
Last edited:
Anyway, why would they need a quality control tool for the potentised remedies? They are supposed to produce such distinctive results that I'm sure the homoeopaths would notice if anything was amiss. ;)
 
I'm sorry, but I'm still gasping at the lameness of that reply. I suppose Darat would rap my knuckles if I posted it all here? Oh well.

First two paragraphs (at least half the reply) don't address the letter at all, just bang on again about pressures and structures. Total waste of paper.

Third paragraph appears first to concede that the "plain ethanol" was indeed contaminated ("probably"!), then to try to rescue something from that wreck. I think she actually means that they have made the great discovery that you can detect contamination in ethanol by UV spectroscopy!!! Wow! Whoda thunkit?!

Final paragraph, and this one I am going to quote as "fair use".

All the analytical data shown in the paper are the result of reproducible analyses, although we appreciate the suggestion of representing such data as an average with a standard deviation, we emphasize that our key identification by display of an envelope demonstrates that, there are indeed differences beyond the standard deviation range among individual homeopathic remedies, as used in practice.


Translation: OK, we could have presented SDs and done some statistics, but we didn't so shut up about it, we assert that the data are reproducible and differences are there. Honest. How can anyone say "there are indeed differences beyond the standard deviation range" with a straight face, while refusing to present the actual standard deviations? (And anyway, tell me about +/- 2 SDs, and I might start to listen!)

She seems to be implying that the "plain ethanol" was sent by Hahnemann Labs with the rest of the stuff. I'm not at all sure I believe her. It's a bit telling that fact isn't in the M&M, when all the extraneous rubbish about temperature sensors and unique identifying numbers is. And I don't really think it's all that likely Hahnemann Labs would have ethanol as filthy as that kicking about the shop, as it were. I still think Roy picked up a dusty old bottle from a store room, probably opened multiple times over the past ten years!

But, let's assume she's telling the truth. So, the "plain ethanol" sent by the manufacturer demonstrates marked absorbances which simply aren't in the prepared samples, and aren't characteristic of ethanol at all. What do you do? Jump to the conclusion that succussion alone removes massive amounts of absorbance from ethanol? Likely? Even there, that ignores the demonstrable fact that ethanol just doesn't have these absorbances - if we can find the Sigma catalogue, and so could Gavinimurthy when he started all this (OK, I see he got it from JJM), then so can she.

What does a true "inorganic materials scientist" do? Well, anything but order up some fresh ethanol in a variety of grades and run some spectra on these for comparison, obviously. I mean, no, you just accept any old rubbish and publish it, no matter how implausible, surely!

I think we done right in not attacking homoeopathy or her stupid theories at all, just demolishing the actual results. It removed a huge potential for come-back. I mean, for all she knew, we could all be raving woos! Frankly, she's toast. And I suspect she knows it.

Another little bonus - several veterinary homoeopaths of my acquaintance subscribe to that journal. They'll recognise my name. They are likely to be chewing the crockery about now.

:dl:

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Another little bonus - several veterinary homoeopaths of my acquaintance subscribe to that journal. They'll recognise my name. They are likely to be chewing the crockery about now.


Let's face it, "what have you had published in homeopathy" is going to be a great comeback to the perennial claims from homoeopaths that their critics know nothing about homoeopathy.
 
You know, I think I spent half the night marvelling at the lameness of the reply. I mean, she has barely addressed anything we said!

She apparently concedes that the "plain ethanol" was contaminated. However.
  • No mention of our (rather daring) assertion that one of the traces presented was an accidental duplication of a completely different trace.
  • No mention of our assertion that the same traces were presented on one graph as "typical" and on another as representing extreme high or low examples.
  • No confirmation (or denial) of what was meant by "envelope of differences", or how the traces presented in that figure were chosen.
  • And most of all, not a single syllable about what was arguably the most important point, that the subjective differences apparent between the three succussed preparations could be explained by each having been prepared using a different bottle of stock solvent.
All she seems to have said is, "well, here's my theory again in case you missed it" (no, we didn't comment on your theory, only on your results). Then, "we're not homoeopaths, we're only poor scientists, so all we did was order up what the manufacturer produces". As if that absolves her of all responsibility for addressing possible confounding factors in what the manufacturer might send! Then, "well, we didn't do any statistics at all, or present our data in such a way that it could be statistically analysed, but trust us, there really are differences!"

:jaw-dropp

Looking at how little grasp she seems to have of the criticisms, my suspicion is that she had little to do with either the experimental work or the writing up, and is now simply delegated to say something to provide a fig leaf over the emperor's nudity. I thought these results were really Roy's baby, but maybe he couldn't be trusted to say anything either coherent or polite? I also have a suspicion that Rao now realises they've been comprehensively exploded. I suspect the next tactic on the part of the homoeopathy establishment will be to keep referencing the paper, with never a mention of any debunking two issues later.

By the way, the letter following ours seems also to be a debunking job by a proper scientist on one of the other papers in that ghastly "memory of water" issue. I wonder if it was one of the Bad Science people?

Rolfe.
 
Let's face it, "what have you had published in homeopathy" is going to be a great comeback to the perennial claims from homoeopaths that their critics know nothing about homoeopathy.


Yeah, but do I list this one in my CV? Oh, the embarrassment!

I wish now I'd thought to put JJM's name first - this was really all down to him noticing the wrongness of the "plain ethanol" trace, and we ran with that. But, having written the letter, I automatically signed it.

Rolfe.
 
By the way, the letter following ours seems also to be a debunking job by a proper scientist on one of the other papers in that ghastly "memory of water" issue. I wonder if it was one of the Bad Science people?

You mean Adrian Gaylard? Yes, he is. I also notice that the letter by Philippe Leick (who has previously debunked Walach's ideas regarding WQT in the German magazine Skeptiker) gets no response.
 
Last edited:
Yes, the reply doesn't actually address any of the points raised. At all. I've just published to my blog on it, but I don't really make any different points to those already made here.

Following our letter, Adrian Gaylard has a go at the Vybiral and Voracek (apologies, no attempt to reproduce the diacritics...) and Milgrom papers. Neither really have much of a comeback. Gaylard posts at Bad Science, and has an excellent blog here.

I had a letter in responding to Martin Chaplin's review. At least Chaplin actually addressed some of the points I made, although I still don't agree with him.

I think the crowning glory of the issue, though, is Philippe Leick's demolition of the papers on quantum nonsense by Milgrom and Weingartner, with bonus shout-out to shpalman's blog.
 
Well let's hear it for the Web. Ten or 15 years ago it's very doubtful they'd have got responses at all, never mind like that. The Web drew our attention to the articles, early enough after publication to allow for a response. The Web allowed us to read the stuff, when we would probably not have bothered ordering it up from the library. But not only that, it allowed extensive discussion, with contributions from a variety of people who otherwise would never have met.

JJM, Wilsontown, Pipirr and myself have never met in person, and indeed inhabit three different countries (four if I have my SNP hat on!). Yet the Web has allowed up to collaborate and produce a publication on the subject.

Who says the woos have it all their own way?

Rolfe.

Edited to add: Your own letter comes over very well too, Wilsontown.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom