Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Interestingly, I got an e-mail from Homeopathy on our response to the Rao et al. paper. They wanted me to send them figures 1 to 3 that were missing from the original manuscript. I was a little puzzled by this, as there were no figures in the manuscript. Then I realised that they had taken references to the original figures in Rao et al. as being references to figures in our response. I was able to clear up this confusion, but it does make me wonder. Has the response been accepted for publication without anyone seeing the figures they thought were supposed to be included? There are alternative explanations, of course, but given what we've seen it perhaps wouldn't be surprising.
 
Possibly, the person doing the typesetting saw references to figures but didn't read the text properly.
 
Interestingly, I got an e-mail from Homeopathy on our response to the Rao et al. paper. They wanted me to send them figures 1 to 3 that were missing from the original manuscript. I was a little puzzled by this, as there were no figures in the manuscript. Then I realised that they had taken references to the original figures in Rao et al. as being references to figures in our response. I was able to clear up this confusion, but it does make me wonder. Has the response been accepted for publication without anyone seeing the figures they thought were supposed to be included? There are alternative explanations, of course, but given what we've seen it perhaps wouldn't be surprising.


Shpalman is probably right. I once wrote a noddy-type book on basic biochemistry interpretation for clinicians. I had a basic format of giving an approximate reference range for each analyte, a short description of the analyte's role in metabolism, then reasons for a decreased concentration, and for an increased concentration.

I gave the approximate reference range for bilirubin as (I think) 0-3 mcmol/l.

I got a letter from the editor asking me where the paragraph on reasons for a decrease in concentration had got to.

Rolfe.
 
Shpalman is probably right. I once wrote a noddy-type book on basic biochemistry interpretation for clinicians. I had a basic format of giving an approximate reference range for each analyte, a short description of the analyte's role in metabolism, then reasons for a decreased concentration, and for an increased concentration.

I gave the approximate reference range for bilirubin as (I think) 0-3 mcmol/l.

I got a letter from the editor asking me where the paragraph on reasons for a decrease in concentration had got to.

Rolfe.
:confused:
I don't follow (....long day...)

Your range is wrong, no? So the editor was actually right, yes?

ETA - I see now.
In humans the range is 3-17.
But there are no pathological conditions associated with levels below this range afaik.
 
Last edited:
Deetee:

Rolfe works in veterinary medicine, so the range may well be right for the species she was discussing.

With that in mind, and the normal range starting at zero, how in the world could you have an abnormal decrease in concentration?

:D

At least, that's my understanding of the post :)
 
Last edited:
Procida's 4-hour visit seems to be over, for now anyway.

She was very quick to state her belief that Rao and friends were simply incompetent.

I do have a real life outside my working life.

If I prefer to read, and think, there is nothing wrong with that.

I very much appreciate your posts when you stick to science.

But not everyone is going to want to have an average of 7.5 posts a day, or to reply to either inuendo or epithet, even if they have to do that at least once, just to make the point.
 
Last edited:
Deetee:

Rolfe works in veterinary medicine, so the range may well be right for the species she was discussing.

With that in mind, and the normal range starting at zero, how in the world could you have an abnormal decrease in concentration?

:D

At least, that's my understanding of the post :)
Yes - I got that eventually, but my brain was on holiday yesterday. I added in the comment about the human range for info, not to suggest Rolfe had got the vet range wrong.
 
Last edited:
:confused:
I don't follow (....long day...)

Your range is wrong, no? So the editor was actually right, yes?

ETA - I see now.
In humans the range is 3-17.
But there are no pathological conditions associated with levels below this range afaik.


Yes. That human reference range owes rather a lot to the old gravimetric units, and to the conversion factor - the old unit was mg/100ml, and the conversion factor to get to mmol/l (OK, I tried this time but hell's bells, Darat, if "µ" or "μ" would just work, life would be so much easier, I really, really want the html back!) well, anyway, it's 17.1. You will find that upper reference limit quoted as 17.1mmol/l in quite a lot of publications, although the precision of the assay actually doesn't allow a significant figure after the decimal point.

I really don't know about man, but that's way too high for dogs and cats, although a lot of old publications still quote the 17.1 regardless. I know I'm getting distinctly suspicious summat ain't right from 4mmol/l upwards, and from about 5 I start to see a subtle jaundice evident in the plasma.

The idea of having a lower reference limit for this analyte is daft. As you say, there's no such thing as a pathologically low concentration. I get 0 or 1 as the most common actual results in normal dogs and cats. I can only assume that this is not the case in man, and presumably the lower limit of 3 was obtained from an actual population survey. I just can't figure out why that's so, given that the upper limit is quite clearly a translation of an old upper limit ot 1mg/100ml. I would have assumed the old-unit range would have been given as 0-1mg/100ml, but the "3" seems to assume an old-unit range of 0.2-1mg/100ml, which is a tad unlikely. To be honest, you can barely read at that level of precision, and down there you're into minor artefacts of haemolysis more than actual presence of bilirubin.

[Of course, once you change species again all bets are off. In the horse the reference range goes up to about 50mmol/l, though pony breeds usually seem to be lower which may have more to do with diet than anything else. Any increase in this is overwhelmingly likely just to be an effect of fasting, as all horses get fasting hyperbilirubinaemia (similar to Gilbert's syndrome in man). Sheep and cattle are somewhere in between, maybe closer to the human range, but since cattle have naturally yellow plasma in any case due not to bilirubin but to beta-carotene, it gets even more complicated.]

</biochemistry geek stuff>

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Interestingly, I got an e-mail from Homeopathy on our response to the Rao et al. paper. They wanted me to send them figures 1 to 3 that were missing from the original manuscript. I was a little puzzled by this, as there were no figures in the manuscript. Then I realised that they had taken references to the original figures in Rao et al. as being references to figures in our response. I was able to clear up this confusion, but it does make me wonder. Has the response been accepted for publication without anyone seeing the figures they thought were supposed to be included? There are alternative explanations, of course, but given what we've seen it perhaps wouldn't be surprising.


Back to the actual letter.

I caught on to a slight error in terminology in the letter last night while wathcing University Challenge. The question was, what do you call the science of comparing the intensity of a light source with a light source of known intensity? I didn't catch on at all, and when the answer came back from Paxman as "photometry", I just said, shoot me now!

Of course, photometry is what this is all about, it's just that doing it at different wavelengths makes it spectrophotometry. That's the term I always use, and it's the correct one. I just got sucked into using the word "spectroscopy" because of the Sigma description of the ethanol as "spectroscopic grade" and I think Rao et al. may also use the word in the paper. But spectroscopy is a lot more about actual absorption and emission bands I think. Maybe at a pinch you could call this spectroscopy, but really the correct term is spectrophotometry.

So, in the last paragraph of the letter, the sentence reading

It is clear that the data presented are wholly inadequate to support the authors’ assertion that UV spectroscopy can differentiate between the two remedies, and between different potencies of the remedies.


Should really read ".... assertion that UV spectrophotometry can differentiate...." And there's another instance where arguably the usage should be the sam.

This is industrial-strength nitpicking, and I really don't think we're going to ask the editor to correct it.

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe,

I think there is also a difference between British and American terminology. A while back, a colleague tried to teach me the difference between -ometry and -oscopy; but few people, here, care. I think this is an application of the Law of Conservation of Syllables (-photometry vs. -oscopy). The original article uses -oscopy.

I also had a nit to pick (I once raised body lice, that is a fact, so I am good at it). The letter refers to the absorbance peak at 330nm. However, someone went to the trouble of providing us with a nice graphic showing it at 324nm. (Go to the page that lists all the threads, and this thread is marked with a paperclip. Click on that to see the graphic.) I am not sure it is worth changing.
 
Last edited:
Yes, Geni did the demonstration that the peak was (as far as he could tell) at 324nm, but he was using the figure from the powerpoint slide show that is on the web, not the printed figure from the paper. My impression was that the peak seems slightly further to the right in the printed figure. Also, 324nm cannot be substantiated from the data presented in the paper, it's far too precise - and it sounds absolutely obsessive! Given the eyeball appearance of the printed graph, I thought that "about 330nm" actually described it best, and better than "about 325nm" - in that version, it does look a bit closer to 350 than to 300. Also, it does sweetly corroborate your remark about acetone.

Rolfe.
 
I'm told that proofs of the letter should be available on or about December 3rd. I'll send them around to all involved. I don't think that there would be any problem asking for some such minor corrections at the proof stage, if required. They only get upset if you want to change quite a lot of stuff.

Incidentally, Rolfe, you seem to have a fancy animated graphic on your posts suggesting it's your birthday. If so, many happy returns.
 
Why, thank you sir. Currently tryng not to be entirely buried under dead farm animals, but seem to have managed to swap a dead Friesian cow for a pile of small animal biochemistry results, so it's not all bad.

Rolfe.
 
Just in case folks hadn't seen this, there's an interesting account of a debate with Rustum Roy at this here blog...

It's going to be very, very interesting to see what his response to the letter can possibly be.
 
Yeah, I read that earlier.

I pointed out, as many others have, that this study is worthless because he did not demonstrate that the different preparations (which were just obtained from a homeopathic company) had no chemical differences - to which he had no effective answer.


I was quite in awe of his masterly summary of the entire letter in one pithy statement.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom