Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Excellent post, Rolfe.

We're never told why we need to know about the type of glass...

Maybe something to do with this? (blog)

"...it is likely that Conte's original results are attributable to experimental artifact originating in the glassware used for the manufacture of the NMR tubes."
 
Last edited:
That is exactly what happens with pharmaceutically based medical journals as well. Ask the doctors who eventually went on to expose Fenoterol as the load of bunk it is. They faced a protracted onslaught for years, in which this and other tactics were used against them.

Again, its very interesting how the protracted squabble over feneterol lasted so long, and pretty much dragged out until Fenoterol was just about out of its patent. :covereyes

Just a shame it killed so many people in the process:

amazon.com /Adverse-Reactions-Fenoterol-Neil-Pearce/dp/1869403746 ~ broken link in order for it to take....

The same tactic is still used to this day. So Rolfe, all I can say is that either you do what Neil Pearce and others do, accept that the stack is loaded against you, and keep on submitting short excrutiatingly painful letters until such time as the point is won, or... leave it alone.

But you can't honestly squeal that its a homeopathy conspiracy, when the master of obfuscation is the medical profession.

In that, the homeopathy people learned from the master teachers.


I think you'll find that this discussion is not about deficiencies in conventional medicine. Nobody here is claiming that conventional medicine is perfect, or that there have not been some extremely regrettable episodes.

However, we see a constant habit among homoeopathy proponents of diverting every attempt to discuss the deficiencies of homoeopathic practice ito an attack on conventional medicine.

Shouting "but you've done it too" is not an answer. Two blacks do not make a white.

If you want to discuss Fenoterol, and whatever happened in relation to that preparation, you're entirely at liberty to start a thread about it. However, I'm afraid that whatever did or did not happen in relation to that drug does not in any way excuse Rao and others' abysmal failures in basic science, which is what we're actually talking about.

And thank you, I have no intention of stopping pointing out deficiencies in homoeopathic pubications as I encounter them. Remarking that the "right of reply" gives the original author the last word is merely that - a remark.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Or perhaps the acquaintance doesn't exist, and Procida just copied the info from the e-mail below, without checking whether it was true. Or are you the author of this e-mail too Procida ?

http://dcscience.net/hpathy-com.pdf


Neat sting, Prof.

Could it be that Procida isn't entirely honest?

Of course we all know that Dr. B isn't the most accurate cove in the world, and actually I'd check the facts even if he told me it was daylight, at noon.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't get onto whatever that site it. it diverted me to a main page?

The acquaintance does exist. She happens to be a journalist.

My use of "homeopathy" extends to the following experiments, all anecdotal.

<snip tedious unverifiable and uncontrolled anecdotes>


Procida, it may have escaped your notice, but this thread is about a certain paper published in a journal, and its manifest deficiencies in basic science. In fact, the clinical efficacy or otherwise of homoeopathy isn't even part of the discussion.

What you have posted is an enormous derail. It may well be interesting, and people here may well be pleased to discuss it with you. But if you want to talk about it, why not start another thread on that matter - to go with the one I'm sure you're about to start about Fenoterol.

Here, it simply looks as if you are trying to counter criticisms of a detailed spectroscopic analysis with "never mind that, I think it works" (after having already tried "but conventional medicine has scandals too you know") - which is another tried and tested diversionary tactic we encounter so often among those desperate to defend homoeopathic practice and publications from specific criticisms.

Rolfe.
 
There are some here on this board who do know me, and they will tell you, that I'm telling the truth. I don't haunt that many board, and homeopathy is one area that I'm too remotely interested in to go to boards about. But given that I had a bout of insomnia last night, I decided to read the thread here about it, to see what I could learn.

rolfe, you have twisted my words about fenoterol to mean something I wasn't intending.

My point to you was that there was no point in complaining about the tactic, since its one used by both sides.

Your tone appeared to feel that fairness was the domain of science only.
 
thanks rolfe.

From your explanation I'd vote for incompetence first.

To me, whether homeopathy works, or is a placebo, is still up for grabs.


I posted my explanation at 6.31. It was long and detailed.

At 6.33 you yourself posted a very long post.

At 6.36 you posted a reply to another post by DeeTee.

At 6.40 you posted the above.

Tell me, did you actually read what I made quite some effort to explain to you? If you did, could you expand on why you think that experienced academics, professors even, managed to be so appallingly incompetent, and not realise that their experiment was very very badly designed?

Rolfe.
 
rolfe, why would I be interested in starting the one on Fenoterol?

I know the doctors concerned so would have no interest in debating the merits of the case. It's been opened, and shut, and the book is really the last word on the topic. And its very "old" now....

you interpret my personal comments as a derail.

they are not. I got the feeling that people would probe with the usual personal attacks, so I simply being straight up with you here, and stating that that's my only experience with it, and is the basis of my thinking. i've nothing more to add on a personal basis, and do consider I asked you honest questions, even if you don't.
 
rolfe:
Tell me, did you actually read what I made quite some effort to explain to you? If you did, could you expand on why you think that experienced academics, professors even, managed to be so appallingly incompetent, and not realise that their experiment was very very badly designed?

Rolfe.
I've spent four hours reading all your detailed explanations on all 7 pages of this thread.

I realised from the start that the experiment design was shonk. The bit I don't understand, and that's my fault as I'm no chemist, is what the spikes would represent in different lots of vodka, and whether that would explain the differences in the batches.
 
Last edited:
There are some here on this board who do know me, and they will tell you, that I'm telling the truth. I don't haunt that many board, and homeopathy is one area that I'm too remotely interested in to go to boards about. But given that I had a bout of insomnia last night, I decided to read the thread here about it, to see what I could learn.

rolfe, you have twisted my words about fenoterol to mean something I wasn't intending.

My point to you was that there was no point in complaining about the tactic, since its one used by both sides.

Your tone appeared to feel that fairness was the domain of science only.


Procida, if you read my post again, you will note that I reported an identical instance of the "unfairness" of the last-word right-of-reply in a mainstream journal. Why you think that a rant about a drug that you claim "killed so many people" was in any way a reply to that. I can't fathom. It didn't even relate to journal publications or the right of reply.

Please go on discussing the Rao et al. paper here. If you want to discuss Fenoterol or your own personal homoeopathic anecdotes, please open new threads about these.

Rolfe.
 
The reason for my comment about the value of homeopathy being up for grabs has nothing to do with the experiment per se. It has everything to do with the inexplicable nature of my limited experience with homeopathy. And prayer for that matter.
 
rolfe:
I've spent four hours reading all your detailed explanations on all 7 pages of this thread.

I realised from the start that the experiment design was shonk. The bit I don't understand, and that's my fault as I'm no chemist, is what the spikes would represent in different lots of vodka, and whether that would explain the differences in the batches.


Well if you've read it all so carefully, you'll have read that the vodka suggestion was a bit of a red herring. Nobody has concluded that any vodka was used in the Rao paper.

I suggested vodka, because a homoeopath of my acquaintance says he uses vodka to make the dilutions. Pipirr (or someone) posted a graph of the UV absorbance of different vodkas. Looking closely, you can see that the ones with the big spikes are the ones with added flavouring - which is what the traces are demonstrating. The pure unadulterated vodka in fact looks very like pure spectroscopic grade ethanol.

However, we didn't pursue that avenue, because JJM pointed out that the much more reasonable explanation was that the manufacturer was using pharmaceutical grade ethanol, which of course has rather more in the way of contaminants than the spectroscopic UV solvent grade, and would not be expected to be absolutely identical between bottles.

Rolfe.
 
Procida, if you read my post again, you will note that I reported an identical instance of the "unfairness" of the last-word right-of-reply in a mainstream journal. Why you think that a rant about a drug that you claim "killed so many people" was in any way a reply to that. I can't fathom. It didn't even relate to journal publications or the right of reply.
I'm sorry... I must have missed that bit since I was more concentrating on your analysis of science.

Please go on discussing the Rao et al. paper here. If you want to discuss Fenoterol or your own personal homoeopathic anecdotes, please open new threads about these.

Rolfe.
personal explanations were only a way of contextualising comments. I can't see the point in starting a thread about them.

But I would like to understand more about what it is in the vodka or ethanol than can influence results as I think that's the most important thing about the whole study, and I'm hoping they will reply to your letter about that.
 
The reason for my comment about the value of homeopathy being up for grabs has nothing to do with the experiment per se. It has everything to do with the inexplicable nature of my limited experience with homeopathy. And prayer for that matter.


Well, as I said, that might be interesting to discuss. But this thread is not about the value of homoeopathy. It is about the Rao et al. paper.

Please keep discussions about the therapeutic value of the stuff out of it. It's a derail.

Rolfe.
 
But I would like to understand more about what it is in the vodka or ethanol than can influence results as I think that's the most important thing about the whole study, and I'm hoping they will reply to your letter about that.


For the third time, leave the vodka. We don't think there was vodka involved.

Here is spectroscopic grade ethanol. This is prepared with minimum contamination as being suitable as a solvent for UV spectroscopy, with low enough levels of contaminants so that their absorbance will not mess up your experiments.

Here is pharmaceutical grade ethanol. This is still reasonably pure, but if you look at the minimum absorbances you will see that in the mid-UV range these are greater than for the spectroscopic grade. You would not want to use that as a solvent for UV spectroscopic work (although it would be significantly cheaper), because there is enough contaminant absorbance to cause interference in your results.

While it is not exact (and we don't know that it was Sigma the alcohol in the paper was obtained from anyway), the absorbances of all three succussed preparations are close enough to this to make it likely that this sort of alcohol was used. And as the stuff is not made for spectroscopic use, the manufacturers will not guarantee that all batches will be identical in that respect.

The fact is that ethanol is very prone to picking up contamination, and even if I'd specified spectroscopic grade was to be used for the preparations in this experiment, I'd still also have insisted that every drop of material came originally from the same stock bottle. It's the only way to ensure that different contaminant profiles don't give you a false result.

This is elementary. But these experienced senior professors, with a track record of scientific publication, were too incompetent to realise this? Really? They got these very surprising results (particularly the strikingly different "plain ethanol" one), and it didn't even enter their pretty little heads that the bottles might not be identical? Really?

Rolfe.
 
Okay... re the vodka... thanks.
If I may ... (I hope I don't cross-post with Rolfe).

Potable alcohol, whether vodka or pharmaceutical grade, is a natural product. Natural products vary from time-to-time and place to place; a little or a lot (think of wine). That would involve slight impurities, which may absorb more light than the pure alcohol chemical.

The main difference between vodka and pharmaceutical alcohol is the vodka has more water in it (which does not absorb light and, thus, does not alter the spectrum).
 
Procida's 4-hour visit seems to be over, for now anyway.

She was very quick to state her belief that Rao and friends were simply incompetent. However, given the track record of these people, the prior publications, the academic experience and so on, this degree of incompetence simply beggars belief.

If it had just been the aparent differences between the three remedies (or rather, succussed preparations), I could perhaps have excused it. Imagine - order 3 potencies of each of three "remedies", and run them through the spectrophotometer. Gosh, look, Nat Mur is different from Nux Vom, and both are different from succussed ethanol! Eureka!

Now at this point I'd expect rigorous science to kick in, and try to prove conclusively that they'd definitely found a difference. Because really, I think there is one there and they're not imagining it. So, normal people do ten runs of each preparation, then do statistics on the results to demonstrate significance.

They say they did the ten runs (OK, not real replicates, just within-batch rather then between batch, but we'll let that pass for now). Did they do the statistics? No idea. If they had, I think I can guess what they'd have found. No significant differences between the different potencies of each individual remedy, but significant differences between the Nux vom, the Nat Mur and the succussed ethanol, at any potency.

Now if they'd got such results, I'd have thought they'd have been pretty excited. OK, disappointing in one way because of the lack of difference between potencies, but absolute Eureka stuff as regards the differences between the remedies. But that's not what is presented. Instead we get only selected results, no statistics, and some vague hand-waving about "differences" (unspecified) between all the preparatios, potencies as well as remedies.

Now why is that? Is it that they did the statistics and were so disappointed by the lack of significance between the potencies that they decided to suppress these findings, discard 80% of the data, and just hand-wave and pretend there were differences everywhere? Or did they not even think of doing the statistics, and really imagined that al they had to do was present some pretty pictures and say, "look at the differences!"?

I don't even get it at this level. To pass up on the opportunity of presenting proper statistically-verified evidence of actual differences between remedies, in order to present vague and wooly suggestions of differences, seems extremely peculiar. But not as mad as what comes next.

So far, simply handling the material supplied by the manufacturer, it's conceivabnle nobody thought about the uniformity of provenance of the ethanol. I could just about imagine someone publishing a Eureka paper with these results, in good faith. (Until some bright spark actually thought about why these differences might be real, other than aome effect of potentisation, that is!)

But it's the "plain ethanol" that's the complete dead giveaway. I'd love to know when in the course of the work they decided to analyse that. But when they got the result, and they must have known it hadn't come from the manufacturer with the rest, didn't they even stop for a second to wonder at the huge difference between that and the "succusseed ethanol"? And surely it would have occurred to anyone that given the difference provenance of the material, maybe there were actual chemical differences?

At that stage, don't you start checking all the bottles of "ethanol" you can find, to see if they're all like that? Don't you ask the homoeopathic manufacturer to send you a sample of their unsuccussed solvent, and check that? Surely, you realise you're looking at a chemical difference!

Then of course, maybe it occurs to you that it might be possible that the differences you've spotted in the supplied remedies might have a similar explanaiton? No?

What is very very odd is the lack of rigorous investigation of any sort at all. Just throw together a few almost random results, type, Oooh, look at the differences, and submit it? Given that there are actual differences there (between the remedies), why not characterise them, and demonstrate that they're real? Avoiding doing that almost makes it look as if they're avoiding what the same exercise would also demonstrate, that the differences between the potencies are not real.

If you're going to do that, as I said, why not just make something up? That way, you can at least make sure it's plausible!

Sorry, I'm just having real trouble getting any sort of handle on the mental processes involved here. Something as shoddy as this would get a fail grade as an undergraduate project, and then you'd have to go and have a bit of a word with the student's supervisor, to find out why no guidance had been given about how to improve the study. To find it submitted for publication by people with postgraduate qualifications and academic posts and publication records just defies comprehension.

Unless it is as simple as throw something together that isn't actually lies so we can't be exposed as frauds, insuch a way that the debunking will be tedious and largely impenetrable to laymen and journalists, and there we have a "refereed publication" that can be cited in perpetuity by proponents, without the tedious necessity of actually demonstrating anything at all.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom