Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

This very morning I was told that the letter has been accepted for publication in Homeopathy. It won't actually appear until the January issue, but they have actually accepted it.

Cool, eh? Wonder what the response of the authors will be?
One reason for a delay in publication may be that they have offered the authors right of reply. If my own experience is anything to go by, the authors will use this to dismiss your own queries out of hand and rubbish the relevance and aplicability of your points, and generally attempt to make your premise look as silly as possible. And they know you haven't the opportunity to rebut their response to your letter - you can't say back: "Hey, hang on! That's nonsense!"
 
One reason for a delay in publication may be that they have offered the authors right of reply. {snip}
Your point is good; but, most of what we wrote is unarguable. For example, anyone can look up the spectrum of pure alcohol and see Roy's "pure" alcohol is nothing of the sort. At the same time, they will see that his homeopathic alcohol looks like ordinary, potable alcohol.

It will be interesting to see their reply, even if they do "rubbish" what we wrote.
 
This is where of course I start to get cold feet, and wonder how I could possibly have screwed up the argument to leave the homoeos an out. They always find something to bluster about, exactly as DeeTee pointed out.

The problem is that by allowing the author right of reply, the author invariably gets the last word. A couple of years ago some of us wrote to the Veterinary Record about a strangely pro-homoeopathy paper, and tried very hard to keep under the journal's 400-word limit for letters. (In fact we split ourselves into two groups and wrote two different letters, just to begin to cover the points we wanted to make.) The author's right of reply gave her another rant which was longer than our letters combined, and actually getting close to the length of the original paper. I thought this was grossly inequitable. Mainly, she kept rehashing her thesis that "there was something interesting going on", but there's no doubt she had the last word.

I fear that the present authors may be less scholarly than that lady, and will now introduce some more spurious and demonstrably wrong assertions we will have no opportunity to refute.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Ernst has a letter in Homeopathy 96 (4) (which is the current issue at time of writing) which says, regarding Robertson et al., that if you plot their data on a graph it's obvious that the homeopathy is not doing anything. Their response is basically, "yes it is".

I once had a comment published, and I never saw the authors' response but I saw the low opinion that the referee had of it.
 
Ernst has a letter in Homeopathy 96 (4) (which is the current issue at time of writing) which says, regarding Robertson et al., that if you plot their data on a graph it's obvious that the homeopathy is not doing anything. Their response is basically, "yes it is".


well, as a non-subscriber, I can't see most of that (and a couple of the links seem to be broken) but I notice that we seem to have another invocation of some sort of "entanglement": Walach: Response: potential nonlocal mechanisms make placebo controls in pathogenetic trials difficult.
 
Homeopaths have had 200 years to produce data showing their craft works. The best anybody, regardless of its personnal opinion, regardless of what they had at stake, have been able to produce are tests that yield, sometimes, a slightly ambiguous result - which mysteriously disappear in any replication of the experiment.

Pick any other theory that has failed to be supported by any data for 200 years. Why aren't you pushing for more time and money be spent on delving further into them?

How long must homeopathy fail to produce results before you throw in the towel and say "it doesn't work"?

Well it would be nice if so-called logical thinkers could work out what its to be. I mean, either homeopathy is a load of nothing or its not. So, if its a load of nothing, then why is it that it's not possible to buy Arsenic-alb, Nux-vom, and Opium in 30C or 200C in some countries, supposedly because they are toxic?
 
I don't think there are any logical thinkers who would ban it because of its toxicity. If any country has banned the remedies for this reason, they are certainly not thinking logically...

Which countries are these by the way?

Edit, perhaps it is because the quality control is negligible which could result in some pills actually having some of the substance in them?
 
Last edited:
The problem is that by allowing the author right of reply, the author invariably gets the last word. A couple of years ago some of us wrote to the Veterinary Record about a strangely pro-homoeopathy paper, and tried very hard to keep under the journal's 400-word limit for letters. (In fact we split ourselves into two groups and wrote two different letters, just to begin to cover the points we wanted to make.) The author's right of reply gave her another rant which was longer than our letters combined, and actually getting close to the length of the original paper. I thought this was grossly inequitable.

That is exactly what happens with pharmaceutically based medical journals as well. Ask the doctors who eventually went on to expose Fenoterol as the load of bunk it is. They faced a protracted onslaught for years, in which this and other tactics were used against them.

Again, its very interesting how the protracted squabble over feneterol lasted so long, and pretty much dragged out until Fenoterol was just about out of its patent. :covereyes

Just a shame it killed so many people in the process:

amazon.com /Adverse-Reactions-Fenoterol-Neil-Pearce/dp/1869403746 ~ broken link in order for it to take....

The same tactic is still used to this day. So Rolfe, all I can say is that either you do what Neil Pearce and others do, accept that the stack is loaded against you, and keep on submitting short excrutiatingly painful letters until such time as the point is won, or... leave it alone.

But you can't honestly squeal that its a homeopathy conspiracy, when the master of obfuscation is the medical profession.

In that, the homeopathy people learned from the master teachers.
 
Last edited:
well, as a non-subscriber, I can't see most of that

I plotted a graph of their results here.

(and a couple of the links seem to be broken)

I'm not sure if they are slow with registering their DOIs or what.

but I notice that we seem to have another invocation of some sort of "entanglement": Walach: Response: potential nonlocal mechanisms make placebo controls in pathogenetic trials difficult.

It says, for example:

Walach said:
It is a well-known lore of homeopathic proving that those in control groups, relatives, or even the pet dog may develop proving symptoms although they have not taken the remedy. This lore, although anecdotal and not scientific evidence at all, is valuable since it suggests that placebo controls might not be adequate.

That sort of thing. Citations to Milgrom, of course.
 
I don't think there are any logical thinkers who would ban it because of its toxicity. If any country has banned the remedies for this reason, they are certainly not thinking logically...

Which countries are these by the way?

Edit, perhaps it is because the quality control is negligible which could result in some pills actually having some of the substance in them?

An acquaintance of mine went to buy homeopathic arsenicum in Toronto and was informed that it wasn't available because it was toxic.

editted to add, ... since conventional wisdom (or is that an oxymoron) dictates that there would be absolutely nothing there after the 12th potency, then a 300 would be unlikely to be anything except nothing.
 
Last edited:
An acquaintance of mine went to buy homeopathic arsenicum in Toronto and was informed that it wasn't available because it was toxic.

editted to add, ... since conventional wisdom (or is that an oxymoron) dictates that there would be absolutely nothing there after the 12th potency, then a 300 would be unlikely to be anything except nothing.

Well I seem to be able to find it easily for sale on Canadian based websites. Anyone here from Canada that can tell us whether this is true?

If the dilutions are done properly, it is extreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeemely improbable that you would find a single molecule in the remedy. Maybe the problem (if there is one) is that they don't allow the homeopaths that make the remedy access to a toxic substance in the initial tincture. We haven't really established that you can't buy it in Canada yet though.
 
An acquaintance of mine went to buy homeopathic arsenicum in Toronto and was informed that it wasn't available because it was toxic.

editted to add, ... since conventional wisdom (or is that an oxymoron) dictates that there would be absolutely nothing there after the 12th potency, then a 300 would be unlikely to be anything except nothing.

According to this,
EPA has set the arsenic standard for drinking water at .010 parts per million (10 parts per billion) to protect consumers served by public water systems from the effects of long-term, chronic exposure to arsenic.

0.010 ppm is equivalent to 4C, so that's your natural background level of arsenic in safe drinking water.
 
Rolfe, I'm new to this, but would appreciate, (if it doesn't equate to a tome and a bother) an explanation of this.

Also, the succussed stuff does vary itself. The Nat Mur traces are generally low-absorbance, and almost identical between the three potencies, while the Nux Vom absorbs rather more than the succussed ethanol, especially around 250nm, and there is more variability between the potencies.
are you saying that the difference is a "difference" in contaminations of the base ethanol?

So what I'm thinking is, first, as we concluded, the unsuccussed ethanol has a completely different provenance. However, we also have no guarantee that everything coming from Hahnemann laboratories all originated in the same stock bottle. So second, I think we're looking at slightly different sources of ethanol for each of the three hand-succussed preparations - no mother tincture, Nat Mur and Nux Vom respectively.

I've checked the web page Roy quotes in his M&M section, and there's no mention of the source or grade of the "alcohol". But I know what many homoeopaths say they use and recommend. Could we possibly be looking at slight differences in the UV spectrum of different bottles of vodka?
if every bottle of vodka differs in the UV spectrum, what do the differences represent?

dilutions of differing "contaminants"?
 
An acquaintance of mine went to buy homeopathic arsenicum in Toronto and was informed that it wasn't available because it was toxic.
Methinks your friend was actually talking about ayurvedic medicine, which in Canada was shown a few years ago to have toxic levels of heavy metals.

Fascinatingly, as reported here, the manufacturer of the ayurvedic remedies in India claimed
Metals form an integral part of many Ayurvedic medicines as they (metals) have therapeutic properties and that Ayurveda has well established detoxification procedures to remove toxicity from these metals and make them safe for human use
So that's OK then.
Tell your friend not to worry - they are safe.
 
Last edited:
[derail]
One of the threads is titled "In winter I feel like niddle pinching"
What is niddle pinching, and why do people get the urge to do it in cold weather?
[/derail]
ETA - the thread titles actually are a bit reminiscent of the spam in my inbox - all about penises and premature ejaculation cures.
 
Last edited:
Rolfe, I'm new to this, but would appreciate, (if it doesn't equate to a tome and a bother) an explanation of this.

are you saying that the difference is a "difference" in contaminations of the base ethanol?

if every bottle of vodka differs in the UV spectrum, what do the differences represent?

dilutions of differing "contaminants"?


You really need to see the published paper, including the graphs.

First, Rao and her friends declare that they were sent two samples of homoeopathic remedies from the manufacturer - 30C natricum muriatum (salt to the rest of us) and 30C Nux vomica. Then they immediately present results from six different samples - the 6C, 12C and 30C potencies of these two remedies. Next, they state that they have analysed no less than ten preparations of each sample. Later, they also introduce three preparations of "succussed ethanol" without saying anything about where they got it, also a single sample of "plain ethanol", again without saying where they got it.

So, how many preparations did the manufacturer actually send? The authors say two, then present results for six, then imply that they were sent ten separate samples of each of these, then add another three and then another one. Altogether that would be 64 different samples. I don't think that is the case however.

I think the manufacturer sent nine different preparations to the authors - one each of Nat Mur, Nux Vom and "succussed ethanol" (that is obviously, though not stated, a preparation made like the others but with no mother tincture added at the start, and since we're told that this process was done by a "trained expert" for the actual remedies, it is reasonable to assume that the manufacturer also provided these preparations), each at 6C, 12C and 30C. Any duplicate runs of these I believe were simply repeat analyses of the same bulk sample, and not separate preparations taken through from the mother tincture independently (as they ought to have been).

I also believe that the three different potencies of each remedy were simply split off from the process at the appropriate stage, rather than being prepared independently from the mother tincture as they probably ought to have been.

Where did the "plain ethanol" come from? The trace from that sample is quite startlingly different from all the others, leading to the conclusion that it almost certainly did not come from the same source. It was probably a bottle already in the authors' laboratory, with the label "ethanol" on it, but of uncertain provenance. JJM can explain how the shape of the trace suggests that it may be a preparation with added contaminants to make it undrinkable - in relation to the alcohol licensing laws. This is what would most probably be found in a scientific laboratory, not under lock and key, but of course a homoeopathic manufacturer preparing remedies to be taken by mouth would not use it.

It is quite ridiculous that we're having to guess all this. Any competent scientific author would include this information clearly and unambiguously in the Materials and Methods section. However, this paper instead tells us totally irrelevant facts about the nature of the glass bottles used, and the way in which they were sent.

A Food and Drug Administration-regulated homeopathic pharmacy (Hahnemann Laboratories, San Rafel, CA) prepared samples of two different test solutions in 16 ounce (450g), clear glass bottles [Type I borosilicate glass] previously annealed at temperatures between 600–700 1C for 15 minutes. ..... Each bottle was coded with an unique number, the bottles were shipped together by overnight courier in the same box, with temperature sensor.


We're never told why we need to know about the type of glass, or why the temperature sensor was there, or the reason for the "unique number" (there is no mention of blinding the analysis). But we're told all this. While not being told what we really need and want to know, see above. This is a very bad start.

Then, the results.

Although the authors declare that

Nearly 200 runs were made to calibrate every step in the experimental configurations and procedures used for the different instruments. In the dual beam UV–VIS, the many experimental options are all tested separately to ensure that any differences within the data obtained on our samples are well above the instrument noise measured in the calibration run data. The data are obtained largely at different times scales by different individuals gave consistent results.


absolutely no data to this effect are presented. In addition, although a figure caption declares that ten separate samples of each of the six remedy preparations were analysed, that same graph presents only two sets of results for each remedy, with no statistics to show whether there are in fact any significant differences between the different preparations.

In all, although all these replications and so on are mentioned, only 15 sets of results in total are presented for 10 different preparations - one set only for the four ethanol samples, and two of all but one of the six remedy samples (one appears to have been missed in error). Not enough data to be able to guess with any certainty whether there are differences between the preparations, and of course no statistics at all are included.

Nevertheless, just by eyeballing the results, some conclusions can be drawn. First, as mentioned above, that the "plain ethanol" has a totally different provenance from the rest of the material, and almost certainly did not come from the homoeopathic manufacturer. Second, that the three different potencies of Nat Mur are absolutely identical. Third, that while the three different potencies of Nux Vom and "succussed ethanol" show more variation, the lines are close together and cross in places, and appear to come from the same population (i.e. to be replicates of the same solution).

The one guess one can make (although this is not supported by any figures or statistics presented by the authors) is that while the Nat Mur, the Nux Vom and the "succussed ethanol" are all quite like each other, and certainly very very different from the "plain ethanol", they do not seem to be identical and appear to represent three different (though similar) preparations.

So, what is the likely explanation for all this?

It all lies in thinking about the provenance of the various samples, exactly what is not told to us in the Materials and Methods section.

The "plain ethanol" may not in fact be ethanol at all, as its results are vastly different from the published UV absorbance of either spectroscopic grade ethanol (the most pure preparation you can buy), or pharmaceutical grade ethanol (also quite pure, and suitable for ingestion, although due to slightly higher levels of contaminants, not suitable for spectroscopic analysis). However, if it is ethanol, the appearance suggests that it is adulterated ethanol, possibly including acetone, probably a laboratory sample of non-potable ethanol made to be undrinkable for tax reasons.

The nine sample which I believe actually came from the homoeopathic manufacturer are not spectroscopic grade ethanol either - they have too much UV absorbance for that. However, they might be pharmaceutical grade ethanol, such as would probably be bought for homoeopathic remedy preparation. This stuff is intended to be pure enough to drink, but it is not guaranteed to be suitable for use as a solvent for UV spectroscopy. Thus, we would not be desperately surprised by small difference in UV absorption between different bottles of the stuff.

And that is exactly what it looks like. As if the Nat Mur, the Nux Vom and the "succussed ethanol" were each prepared using different bottles of pharmaceutical grade ethanol. Each remedy is the same, as if the different potencies were simply taken out of the run at the appropriate times, but the different remedies are slightly different as if they had been prepared using different bottles to start with - possibly they were prepared at different times.

And that's it.

If you wanted to produce valid results from this experiment, you'd have to source all ten different preparations from the same stock bottle of ethanol. Because of differences in purity between different bottles, this is an absolute basic essential. And one which the authors make no mention of considering ,and which their results strongly suggest was not considered.

Then you'd have to do some duplicate analyses. Ten of each preparation would do, certainly, but each one would have to be prepared separately from the mother tincture stage, otherwise you're just reanalysing the same thing, which is not really a measure of anything but your technique. And you'd actually have to present all ten sets of data, not choose the two you feel like presenting - not individually of course, but as means and standard deviations, with t-test results to show whethere there were indeed any significant differences between any of the preparations.

The way it was actually done and presented shows absolutely nothing at all except shoddy and ill-considered experimental design. These points I make are so elementary, would be so well understood even by a postgrad student, that I leave it to you to decide whether we're looking at simple incompetence from these learned professors, or something more.

In this, I make no predictions about what the results might be if the experiment were to be done properly, and I make no comment on homoeopathy as such. However. I merely point out that what the paper essentially says is that you can distinguish between homoeopathic remedies and the stock solvent (and, according to the discussion, between different remedies and different potencies of the same remedy) simply by measuring the UV absorbance of the solution at 330nm. This is so elementary that any undergrad lab with a grating spectrophotometer could do it. Even a clinical photometer capable of doing ordinary routine blood tests could probably do it.

I seriously doubt that this is in fact the case.

By the way, the vodka thing was agreed to be a red herring. Different bottles of vodka do have different spectra due to different additives. Pure vodka looks very like spectroscopic grade ethanol however, as it happens. Nevertheless, the probable explanation is that the manufacturer used different bottles of pharmaceutical grade ethanol, which would in all probability have slightly different levels of different contaminants.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Or perhaps the acquaintance doesn't exist, and Procida just copied the info from the post below, without checking whether it was true. Or are you the author of this post too Procida?

http://abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/126789/

I couldn't get onto whatever that site it. it diverted me to a main page?

The acquaintance does exist. She happens to be a journalist.

My use of "homeopathy" extends to the following experiments, all anecdotal.

first experiment = 28 years ago.

subject= person who had had bad accident.

result = in hospital with severe cuts bruising all over body.

experiment = using arnica cream on one side of the body, avoiding the cuts, and solely massage on the other.

complaint from patient = that I should have just used oil and massages the other since arnica cream was hocus pocus.

Answer to complaint = didn't want to be accused of not massaging both sides, and if arnica hocus pocus then there would be no result apart from my aching arms from massage.

Result = not complete. Most of the surface bruising on the arnica treated side (apart from that surrounding cuts which the jar said to keep arnica away from, don't ask me why...) disappeared very much more quickly than that on the other with the exception of very deep extensive buttock haematomas. I guess there is only so far anything can absorb from the skin?

most impressive part of experiment = one particular bruise on torso, which had to be "divided" down middle. the arnica side of the bruise disappeared with about 3/4 " disappearance extending into the rest of the haemotoma which had no arnica applied. The rest of the bruise remained.

My presumption = that the arnica cream was primarily a cream which had the actual herb in it, and if arnica does in fact remove bruising, then at least that worked.

next experiment was a two fold one. Nearly 27 years ago.

After the birth of first child, nothing the doctor or nurse suggested would unblock his tear ducts. In desperation, I tried homepathic eye-bright on the basis that I had nothing to lose apart from money.

Strangely, it worked. When the doctor's nurse saw the result, she expressed interest, as she bred dogs. (don't ask me what breed, as I don't remember) Her breeding kennel was about to be shut down, as they had had blocked tear ducts which the vet had not been able to fix, and after 18 months it was considered a major strike against them.

I gave her the left overs, on the basis that she had nothing to lose and I had nothing to gain by keeping it.

she used it, and even more strangely it worked. She, like me, rarely uses homeopathy, but she says its the only thing that works on the tear ducts in her dogs.

don't ask me why. I'm not being sarcastic in my tone, by the way.

next three, again, oldest son. At the age of three months he got eczema, which got progressively worse until he had patches from his forehead to his knees. At 7 months, I was offered steroidal cream for it. A woman who had given birth at the same time as I had, had also had a baby with eczema, but found that the eczema only disappeared when the cream was used, but came back when it was discontinued. I didn't want to play yo-yo, so on the basis that homeopathy, as a placebo, was pretty cheap, I went to a homeopath (who I've never been back to since). the doctor said I was nuts and all a homeopath would do was kill my child. :eye-poppi which wasn't the greatest tack to take for something I was only ascribing placebo value for. The homeopath gave me a remedy, but said that the problem was me, and I was to take it, and it would go through the breastmilk.

To me, the explanation was totally ridiculous, and it still is today. But I did as told, and within three days, the most recent eczema had softened and started to disappear and progressively, over a month it went. The last bits to go, were the first bits to come.

A few weeks later, I noticed that verucae I had had in profusion for years, had all gone but just shrugged. Five years later, when they came back, I took another dose of it, on the basis I had nothing to lose, and they all went again.

In terms of oldest son, whenever he gets eczema patches (about once every 6 years or so) he takes one dose, and they go.

even now, every time I get a wart or verrucae, I take it, and they go away. Which beats both the burning and the frozen stuff as well as the creams the doctor used to prescribe or use.

next experiment birth of second son. I was haemorrhaging, and the doctor used homeopathic secale, and the bleeding took 30 seconds to stop. I bawled him out on the basis that he should have used the oxytocin as it would have been quicker. He said that in his experience the injection took a lot longer. I told him that he was a fruit loop and the bleeding probably just stopped on its own.

I mean, who knows? You can't cut a mother in half, and see whether leaving it alone stops quicker than something that I didn't believe in, and was pretty annoyed about at the time. But that was done "to" me, not something I asked for.

Next experiment. 24 years ago... the same thing happened to the second child with regard to eczema, but I didn't bother going to the homeopath, since, as the theory goes, the problem was "me". Same remedy, same result.

so that was a pretty good and safe placebo.

5th Experiment. 25 years ago..Husband, chronic intractible hayfever.

Nothing had worked. On the basis of the arnica experiment he decided to try homeopathy on the basis that he had nothing to lose.

he took homeopathic allium cepa, and also vitamin C which probably messed the experiment.

His hayfever cleared up within a week, but it might have had more to do with the vitamin c than the homeopathy, since we only used the allium cepa the first month, and since then he's just used vitamin C. He now only gets hayfever if he decides to bury himself in a privet tree for a whole day. Used to be that he only had to see one from 100 yards, and his eyes and nose would start.

apart from bruises, that's about the extent of my use of homeopathy, simply because I've had no other occasion to try either homeopathy or anything else for that matter yet.

So its either all a matter of good luck, or placebo, or it worked.

I've no idea what the answer is. I can't explain what or why. But I'm not prepared to write it totally off. By the same token, I hardly ever use it. Probably because the basic way we live is sound enough.

My view of the discussion on this thread is that its very interesting, and I'd like to understand the flaws in the article better.

I'm not prepared to write homeopathy off, but then, I also believe in the power of prayer, which wouldn't fall into the sceptic orbit either. If prayer is a placebo too, then its worked relatively well in the times of need when i've used it. so I'm not going to write that off, on the basis that its not reproducable or scientifically quantifiable either.

But I'm open to thinking about both.
 
Last edited:
Deetee, I don't know what Ayurvedic medicine is, and she's never mentioned that either. She did mention that the potency she asked for was 200 C.

Does ayurvedic medicine use homeopathy?
 
thanks rolfe.

From your explanation
The way it was actually done and presented shows absolutely nothing at all except shoddy and ill-considered experimental design. These points I make are so elementary, woud be so well understood even by a postgrad student, that I leave it to you to decide whether we're looking at simple incompetence from these learned professors, or something more.
I'd vote for incompetence first.

To me, whether homeopathy works, or is a placebo, is still up for grabs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom