Homeopathic Cough Medicine

It is also funny to note that to homoeopaths it is a sign of healing if the sickness gets worse. This is called aggravation, and is normal in homoeopathy. It is a win/win situation: If the patient gets better, homoeopathy works, and if the sickness gets aggravated, it also shows that homoeopathy works!
Not necessarily a win/win situation for the patient, though. Here's a news story I noticed yesterday.
Walker's varied experience has helped her see the benefits of a broad range of natural remedies for a wide variety of ailments. She has treated chronic diseases (hepatitis, fibromyalgia, and chronic fatigue syndrome) since 1990, when she learned a German homeopathic "nosode" treatment (made from a disease or pathological product) developed by Dr. Reinhold Voll. She later applied Dr. Voll's method to treat Lyme disease when she lived in Sag Harbor, New York, across from Lyme, Connecticut.

"There aren't very many good treatments of Lyme disease," Walker says.

"In general, if you're healthy and you get bit by a Lyme tick and you go to the doctor and take antibiotics, you're fine. But if you're sick, run down or under tremendous stress, and you get bit by a Lyme tick and take antibiotics, [the antibiotics] push it deeper into your body.

"The homeopathics boost your immune system and push [the disease] out, so when you initially take the remedies, you look like you're worse and you feel like you're getting worse because your symptoms come out, but then they clear."
Great. If Lyme disease is treated promptly with antibiotics, the prognosis is generally good, but delaying treatment can lead to chronic and disabling disease. Here we have a homoeopath recommending that patients avoid antibiotics because they will "push it deeper" and wait for the symptoms to "come out".
 
If Lyme disease is treated promptly with antibiotics, the prognosis is generally good, but delaying treatment can lead to chronic and disabling disease. Here we have a homoeopath recommending that patients avoid antibiotics because they will "push it deeper" and wait for the symptoms to "come out".
Surely this is a great big juicy negligence law suit looking for somewhere to happen?
 
Re: post #603 -- another brilliant bit of writing by fls. Thanks so much for that.

The notion of "like curing like" really appealed to me. It might be a good idea for clients of homeopaths to pay for the consultation with Monopoly money (it has the memory of the real thing).

Just an irrelevant thought :)

M.
 
I agree on the kudos to fls.

My only shame is that I am not the one who nominated you twice out of this thread. You deserve at least that many.

Some of the clearest writing in a very long time.
 
Scientific methods and standards are not arbitrary. They represent the hard-won recognition that chance and cognitive bias (aka wishful thinking) conspire against us to give the illusion of pattern where none exists. We don't hold research to these standards in order to get into some Old Boys' Club. We hold it to these standards because we have discovered that if we don't, we are likely to be wrong. We have demonstrated over and over and over again, that if we aren't meticulously careful, we end up concluding stuff that just isn't true. So now, instead of kicking ourselves for wasting years/decades/centuries on backing the wrong horse, we actually try to do it right the first time. We hold conventional medicine to the standards presented in that model because we are tired of being wrong, not so we can exclude homeopathy and the rest of the sCAM from the game.

Thank you Linda. This paragraph of yours is going 'in my file'. It excellently makes a point that is often difficult to make succinctly.

Bravo.
 
Thanks, guys.

Of course, using Murphy's Law, having several posts nominated means that none will make it into the finals. <g>

Linda
 
Well, I don't want to join Moochie in all the back-slapping and all that (because you might just fall off your bar stool :mad:) but, I have to admit, I did learn a thing or two in this thread.

BillyJoe
 
So, Moochie.

Have you decided upon a cough remedy for your wife yet? :D

She's not still waiting for an answer is she? :eek:
 
Originally Posted by JJM
Rodney, what is your professional opinion of the Logan technique in chiropractic? Are you embarrassed by it?

Rodney:
Never heard of it. Does it have anything to do with homeopathy?
You will note I mentioned chiro, not homeo. I thought you went to the chiro "school" Logan founded.

Nonetheless, there is a connection. The Logan technique employs perianal massage that is as therapeutically unfounded as homeopathy. It may be "confused" with sexual assault. Most of your fellow chiros have heard of it.
 
Sorry, I just don't know enough about homeopathy to state with certainty one way or the other. I'm only saying that from my limited perspective, they have a rationale - albeit not a particularly rational rationale - thus, it isn't arbitrary.

I think I see where the confusion is here:

Yes, they have a rationale, but it is a completely unfounded and unsupported rationale. They have a hypothesis, but they have no evidence or theoritical framework to base it on.

To use an analogy - I may believe that an invisible pink unicorn will cure any illness I have if I leave a saucer of milk out for him nightly. But I have no evidence or theory to base this on.

By the way, your contributions to this thread are greatly appreciated. This kind of productive discussion is how things should work.
 
Originally Posted by JJM [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/helloworld/buttons/viewpost.gif[/qimg]
Rodney:You will note I mentioned chiro, not homeo. I thought you went to the chiro "school" Logan founded.
You thought wrong.

Nonetheless, there is a connection. The Logan technique employs perianal massage that is as therapeutically unfounded as homeopathy. It may be "confused" with sexual assault.
Fascinating, I'm sure. :rolleyes:

Most of your fellow chiros have heard of it.
Evidently your keen mind has led you to another unwarranted conclusion.
 
I think I see where the confusion is here:

Yes, they have a rationale, but it is a completely unfounded and unsupported rationale. They have a hypothesis, but they have no evidence or theoritical framework to base it on.

To use an analogy - I may believe that an invisible pink unicorn will cure any illness I have if I leave a saucer of milk out for him nightly. But I have no evidence or theory to base this on.

By the way, your contributions to this thread are greatly appreciated. This kind of productive discussion is how things should work.
I concur.
 
Dodging to the left,
Dodging to the right!
Let's see where Rodney
Dodges to tonight!
 
Rodney believes that Homoeopathy has been neither proven nor disproven and that it could work by some unknown mechanism. It seems to me that he is not actually promoting it. However, because it has not been disproven, he does think it is therefore okay to sell it and to use it.

Is that about it, Rodney?
 
I think I see where the confusion is here:

Yes, they have a rationale, but it is a completely unfounded and unsupported rationale. They have a hypothesis, but they have no evidence or theoritical framework to base it on.

To use an analogy - I may believe that an invisible pink unicorn will cure any illness I have if I leave a saucer of milk out for him nightly. But I have no evidence or theory to base this on.

Hmm. You may be right. I wouldn't call the decision to leave a saucer of milk out arbitrary. After all, they wouldn't be leaving a saucer of rocks out for the IPU :)

By the way, your contributions to this thread are greatly appreciated. This kind of productive discussion is how things should work.

Thank you. <blush> Such compliments are very much appreciated.
 
So, Moochie.

Have you decided upon a cough remedy for your wife yet? :D

She's not still waiting for an answer is she? :eek:

She saw her GP, was put on antibiotics and an inhalant, and has regained her usual good health.

She is still opposed to quack remedies.

M.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom