I thought I'd posted that yesterday, but it seems not. I probably hit the wrong button. I'll try to compose it again.
I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category. [As an aside, in interpreting results of a situation with "massive testing", simultaneous confidence intervals should be used which keep the probability of a false positive from rising above alpha. I'm not sure how commonly simulataneous C.I.'s are used, but the author of the paper makes no adjustment for that situation in his analysis.]
Since R respresents the ratio of "true relationships" to "no relationships", it can literally vary from 0 (no true relationships) to infinity (everything is related). Depending on your prior assessment of the ratio of true relationships to no relationships, the outcome can be just about anything. Unless you and Linda can agree upon a reasonable value for R, I don't think this analysis is useful to your discussion. On the other hand, discussing a reasonable value to set for R might be.