Homeopathic Cough Medicine

I received my Skepdude Calendar yesterday. Which month are you? ;)

Linda
No idea yet, as I've not gotten my copy. And as I submitted a few poses from which Rebecca was free to choose her favorite, I don't even know what photo is in there. None of them were risque in the slightest, though. Sigh...
 
Without going back to her linked article, just as a general rule rule of thumb, anytime subjective assessments of probability made prior to data being collected are incorporated into an analysis, it's likely to be a Bayesian approach.

That's pretty much what I thought. I've checked out what she posted again, and I see how that's applicable.

Many thanks!
 
Darn it! What I meant to say was:

Why, the handsome one, of course.

Mr. January it is, then. ;)

Linda
(Disclaimer: (in case I ever go to a TAM) Of course all the men in the Skepdick Calendar are handsome.)
 
Mr. January it is, then. ;)
Now I need to get my calendar to be certain you're in lust with the right man.

(Disclaimer: (in case I ever go to a TAM) Of course all the men in the Skepdick Calendar are handsome.)
If we have been referred to as that in the past, I've missed it. It needs to become the required label for men of our, uh, stature.
 
If we have been referred to as that in the past, I've missed it. It needs to become the required label for men of our, uh, stature.

Skepdick?

I'm sure that's what Rebecca wanted to call it, but couldn't. :)

Linda
 
I received my Skepdude Calendar yesterday. Which month are you? ;)

I'm November :D

I think Mr. January is Alexander Hamilton without the tights. And a number of years ago from the looks of it ...
 
I'm still waiting for Beth to weigh in on your model's applicability to homeopathy studies.
I'm still waiting for you to weigh in with a trial that shows that a homoeopathic cough medicine is more effective than placebo.
 
I'm still waiting for you to weigh in with a trial that shows that a homoeopathic cough medicine is more effective than placebo.
I might be able to do that if you can inform me of any trial of a homeopathic cough medicine that has ever taken place.
 
You're right. :) I'm still waiting for Beth to weigh in on your model's applicability to homeopathy studies.


I thought I'd posted that yesterday, but it seems not. I probably hit the wrong button. I'll try to compose it again.

I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category. [As an aside, in interpreting results of a situation with "massive testing", simultaneous confidence intervals should be used which keep the probability of a false positive from rising above alpha. I'm not sure how commonly simulataneous C.I.'s are used, but the author of the paper makes no adjustment for that situation in his analysis.]

Since R respresents the ratio of "true relationships" to "no relationships", it can literally vary from 0 (no true relationships) to infinity (everything is related). Depending on your prior assessment of the ratio of true relationships to no relationships, the outcome can be just about anything. Unless you and Linda can agree upon a reasonable value for R, I don't think this analysis is useful to your discussion. On the other hand, discussing a reasonable value to set for R might be.
 
I thought I'd posted that yesterday, but it seems not. I probably hit the wrong button. I'll try to compose it again.

I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category. [As an aside, in interpreting results of a situation with "massive testing", simultaneous confidence intervals should be used which keep the probability of a false positive from rising above alpha. I'm not sure how commonly simulataneous C.I.'s are used, but the author of the paper makes no adjustment for that situation in his analysis.]

Since R respresents the ratio of "true relationships" to "no relationships", it can literally vary from 0 (no true relationships) to infinity (everything is related). Depending on your prior assessment of the ratio of true relationships to no relationships, the outcome can be just about anything. Unless you and Linda can agree upon a reasonable value for R, I don't think this analysis is useful to your discussion. On the other hand, discussing a reasonable value to set for R might be.

Pardon my ignorance, but what has this to do with showing any real evidence for the efficacy of homeopathic substances?

The person in the street needs something more concrete than your masturbatory statistics. If you can't provide that, then your input will be ignored, don'tcha know?

M.
 
Pardon my ignorance, but what has this to do with showing any real evidence for the efficacy of homeopathic substances?
None whatsoever. An request was made for an opinion regarding the applicability of the analysis Linda did regarding homeopathic studies. That was what I provided.

The person in the street needs something more concrete than your masturbatory statistics. If you can't provide that, then your input will be ignored, don'tcha know?

M.

You are, of course, free to ignore anything and everything you choose. As is everyone else. However, responding to a post is essentially the opposite of ignoring it. :)
 
I thought I'd posted that yesterday, but it seems not. I probably hit the wrong button. I'll try to compose it again.

I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category. [As an aside, in interpreting results of a situation with "massive testing", simultaneous confidence intervals should be used which keep the probability of a false positive from rising above alpha. I'm not sure how commonly simulataneous C.I.'s are used, but the author of the paper makes no adjustment for that situation in his analysis.]

Since R respresents the ratio of "true relationships" to "no relationships", it can literally vary from 0 (no true relationships) to infinity (everything is related). Depending on your prior assessment of the ratio of true relationships to no relationships, the outcome can be just about anything. Unless you and Linda can agree upon a reasonable value for R, I don't think this analysis is useful to your discussion. On the other hand, discussing a reasonable value to set for R might be.

Thanks, Beth. I think your key statements are: "I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as 'discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing' and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category."

As far as I know, all 81 positive studies cited in the 1991 British Medical Journal article were testing specific homeopathic medicines for specific outcomes. So how is a conditional probability analysis appropriate for any of those tests? But assuming it were, how is the 0.001 figure derived? Why not a figure of zero? (Then the medical establishment can simply dispense with those annoying homeopathy trials. ;)) To me, the relevant point is the one that (my dear friend and supporter ;)) Cuddles made: Homeopathic medicines "can be tested in the same way the JREF challenge tests things - the claim is tested with no regard to the proposed theory behind it, all that matters is that this particular remedy does something."

I also am interested in whether you agree with Linda's contention made in post #484 that, in the model she is using: "The negative studies don't matter; there don't even have to be any."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom